Further Reading: Superman's Musical Moment in It's a Bird... It's a Plane...

Kim Newman on an obscure slice of the Man of Steel...

by | September 7, 2008 | Comments

Further Reading by Kim Newman

This week, as Warner Brothers prepare to mount yet another reboot, Kim Newman looks at a rarely-seen screen incarnation of the Man of Steel and his fight for truth, justice and the American way.

The 1975 TV special It’s a Bird It’s a Plane It’s Superman is so seldom-seen it tends to get written off by people who only judge from ropey clips in documentaries which bulk out DVD box sets of the Superman movies. The show has problems, but also a lot going for it — mostly providing a visual record of the 1966 Broadway musical take on the DC Comics characters.

With Batman on TV in the much-derided (but also much-loved) Adam West comedy series, the stage Superman was mounted in the spirit of camp, with colourful cardboard sets and much genial fun poked at the squarest of all superheroes. With a witty book by David Newman and Robert Benton (who would go on to rewrite Mario Puzo‘s Superman movie script, carrying over several major elements from the musical) and superb songs by composer Charles Strouse (Bye Bye Birdie, Annie) and lyricist Lee Adams, It’s a Bird It’s a Plane It’s Superman ran for 123 performances; it tends to get listed in reference books as a flop, though many Stephen Sondheim shows managed shorter initial runs.

It's a Bird, It's a Plane, It's Superman

The musical was a key step in the evolution of Superman from the kid-friendly comic book, radio, movie serial and TV franchise he was from the 1930s through to the 1960s into the modern American myth figure reinvented by the Richard Donner/Christopher Reeve film in 1979 and recently reworked all over again by TV shows like Lois and Clark and Smallville and the Bryan Singer-directed Superman Returns.

In 1975, this shot-on-video version was mounted for late-night television — and no one much saw it. Romeo Muller adapted the play: Strouse and Adams contributed a new song (a hymn to rapacious American criminal capitalism) to accommodate Muller’s biggest change — dropping the Chinese acrobats who were Superman’s sparring partners on Broadway and replacing them with a horde of old-fashioned, slouch-hatted gangsters (including Harvey Lembeck, of Sgt Bilko fame) who resemble the interchangeable hoods from the 1950s Superman TV show (the big boss is Malachi Throne, who played False Face opposite Adam West’s Batman).

It's a Bird, It's a Plane, It's Superman

Performances are broad (broader even than the stage versions, to judge from the show’s soundtrack album) and the sets are stylised cardboard cut-outs — which is admittedly cheap, but also matches the look of comic books (a BBC-TV version of the Jane strip used cartoon backgrounds to similar effect). 1975-ish disco arrangements mangle some of the songs, Superman’s introductory number (‘Doing Good’) is sadly dropped (I miss the line ‘It’s a satisfying feeling when you hang up your cape/knowing you’ve averted murder, larceny and rape’ — though I suspect that’s also why the song got cut), only the two women in the cast (Lesley Warren and Loretta Swit) have really good voices, and the choreography looks as if it’s been done in an afternoon. But, y’know, it’s got a good heart.

Though it’s a spoof, modish twists foreshadow the way the superhero would be treated in more complicated dramas. Realising that Superman’s bones are unbreakable, the villains set out to break his spirit and turn the world against him (a theme DC Comics have been hammering away at for decades, which Newman and Benton seem to have invented), and a psychoanalyst comes on to diagnose the Last Son of Krypton’s survivor guilt and contempt for lesser mortals. There are also a couple of adult winks — when it’s suggested that Clark might be Superman, a villain snaps ‘I always thought he flew, but not like that’ (‘he flies’ is archaic slang for being gay).

Further Reading by Kim Newman

Clark Kent/Superman (a bland, blow-dried David Wilson) isn’t top-billed (any more than Reeve was in Superman the Movie): on Broadway, smoothie Jack Cassidy played the Daily Planet’s smug, lecherous, self-centered Walter Winchell-like columnist Max Mencken; here, we get Mel Brooks regular Kenneth Mars, who can’t underplay anything, hasn’t the charisma to carry the whole show and lacks the pipes to do justice to some of the show’s best numbers (especially the hit ‘For the Man Who has Everything’). David Wayne weasels more entertainingly as the number two villain, Dr Abner Sedgwick. Driven mad by his persistent failure to win the Nobel Prize (which inspires a very funny song), Sedgwick teams up with Max and the Metropolis criminal contingent to undo Superman. It seems odd now that Sedgwick isn’t Lex Luthor, but Superman’s comic book nemesis wasn’t featured in the 1950s George Reeves show and so didn’t become essential to the Superman mythos until Gene Hackman was cast.

It's a Bird, It's a Plane, It's Superman

Lois Lane is played as a bipolar ditz who fails to remember Clark even when she’s briefly in love with him (her signature line is ‘Oh Clark, I didn’t notice you there’). Lesley Warren is smart, sexy and fun — it’s not surprising that she was a strong contender for the role when Donner was casting, but (like Stockard Channing) she lost out to Margot Kidder. Lois is balanced by Sydney (Swit), Max’s cast-off who vamps Kent (‘You’ve Got Possibilities’) — though the staging muffs the clever joke that she tries to seduce him by unbuttoning his shirt, which means he has to keep fighting her off rather than let her see the big red S underneath — and belts out a showstopper about Max’s great love (‘Oooh, Do You Love You’).

Sydney predates the introduction of the similar Cat Grant character in the comics (and the first season of Lois and Clark), but is also the first of a line of dumb-smart semivillain gals with a secret yen for the nice guy in tights who played in the movies by Valerie Perrine, Pamela Stephenson and Parker Posey. Perry White (Allen Ludden) does a running joke of dashing out of his office with old news (Lincoln Steffens’ telegram from Moscow) and firing the Jimmy Olsen-look copyboy (Danny Goldman). When Superman considers jumping off Metropolis’s Warren G. Harding bridge because he feels he is ‘a freak’, a couple of hippies called Joe (Michael Lembeck) and Jerry (Stuart Getz) — representing Superman’s creators Siegel and Shuster — talk him out of it because, in their terms, being a freak is a good thing.

It's a Bird, It's a Plane, It's Superman

A few optical effects are sub-children’s television show (and Batman-style ‘pow’, ‘bam’, etc. overlays are overused), but that’s perhaps the point. Much business (Lois asking Superman to try out his x-ray vision on her underwear, for instance) used in the 1979 Superman originates here, as does the joke Bryan Singer picked up on that Superman preserves his secret identity because no one notices Clark Kent (even a computer forgets him). Laugh-In’s Garry Owens does serial-style cliffhanger announcements, some of which are quite funny (‘Will Superman make it or not? See Chapter Three: Superman Makes It!’).

Director Jack Regas later worked on Electra Woman and Dyna Girl, exactly the sort of children’s show this parodies. It’s a shame the special didn’t run to stronger performers as Superman as Max, but the material is charming enough to shine through the orangey-purpley 1975 videotape haze.

Tag Cloud

Dark Horse Comics rt labs critics edition Creative Arts Emmys Legendary scorecard Kids & Family blockbuster dogs james bond zombie movie 99% ITV ABC Signature Food Network technology diversity streaming Set visit Funimation TCA comedies romantic comedy ABC Family Lucasfilm feel good marvel comics revenge Marvel Studios Turner supernatural PlayStation TCA Awards romance 71st Emmy Awards rotten movies we love Turner Classic Movies New York Comic Con TBS monster movies Amazon Captain marvel GoT National Geographic thriller political drama PBS know your critic art house Sundance TV Marathons Marvel Oscars Comics on TV Vudu all-time book adaptation 2016 indiana jones comics SundanceTV streaming movies MCU Lifetime Christmas movies Warner Bros. 2021 Bravo hidden camera emmy awards Premiere Dates jurassic park Hollywood Foreign Press Association police drama ABC Logo talk show toronto TruTV Cosplay Hallmark Christmas movies witnail golden globes Travel Channel Amazon Studios Nickelodeon king arthur Nominations book Peacock game of thrones halloween tv spider-man breaking bad Hear Us Out Song of Ice and Fire women comic book movie Biopics medical drama TCA 2017 war Masterpiece Prime Video cancelled television stand-up comedy Esquire screenings what to watch Sci-Fi dark Arrowverse science fiction APB based on movie green book Chernobyl nature movies Red Carpet venice Heroines Rom-Com kong Sundance Now HFPA Acorn TV Trailer joker crime drama Sundance VH1 Comedy international cancelled TV shows See It Skip It superman franchise Holidays Paramount Emmys travel Discovery Channel twilight Sony Pictures Animation adventure dramedy Avengers Adult Swim TV Land E! golden globe awards Television Academy animated The Academy sports A&E Apple TV Plus crime stop motion documentary video The CW Anna Paquin hist superhero japanese 1990s italian cars Epix Netflix psychological thriller mission: impossible BBC America discovery Comic-Con@Home 2021 leaderboard Columbia Pictures GIFs Family VOD cooking YouTube TIFF justice league Tags: Comedy young adult IFC Pride Month natural history Fall TV ghosts Brie Larson USA kids cults a nightmare on elm street Fantasy japan child's play sag awards indie Star Trek dragons Character Guide remakes Paramount Network gangster Ghostbusters The Purge comiccon television Interview GLAAD saw CMT children's TV versus LGBTQ laika Valentine's Day 2019 Film binge Podcast biography comic book movies spanish language Comic Book action-comedy football Thanksgiving FX on Hulu Spring TV aliens black latino PaleyFest nbcuniversal Television Critics Association Fox Searchlight FXX spain adaptation Walt Disney Pictures game show YA Disney Plus E3 robots Broadway space Winter TV Best and Worst ID DC Universe critic resources halloween The Walt Disney Company Ovation 2018 Music Rock Reality Competition reboot werewolf 90s cancelled TV series Holiday Mary Poppins Returns Endgame mockumentary biopic target deadpool WGN Photos facebook documentaries HBO Max casting directors rotten doctor who prank 2017 FOX spinoff archives teaser 2015 Infographic historical drama hispanic blockbusters dceu Syfy mcc Pet Sematary vs. Neflix FX heist movie nfl rt labs BBC One psycho best Tokyo Olympics batman new zealand Fox News stoner Disney Channel cartoon TV renewals Hallmark BBC dreamworks critics Grammys hispanic heritage month Image Comics Teen NBA harry potter 21st Century Fox BET sopranos Toys crime thriller TV vampires LGBT posters Apple TV+ OWN Elton John Election SXSW wonder woman dexter anthology Pacific Islander toy story President asian-american 79th Golden Globes Awards boxing YouTube Red NYCC dc chucky Hulu fresh marvel cinematic universe sitcom Crunchyroll canceled TV shows basketball Film Festival Amazon Prime CBS scary 72 Emmy Awards Lionsgate anime video on demand USA Network Trivia HBO The Witch First Reviews YouTube Premium worst IFC Films TCM legend Christmas Wes Anderson 45 ratings politics new star wars movies Mudbound Pixar festivals Crackle royal family concert debate A24 Spectrum Originals Reality DirecTV Superheroe name the review Paramount Plus AMC Plus Tarantino Pop Instagram Live elevated horror cops 007 sequel First Look Shudder IMDb TV miniseries AMC criterion Binge Guide universal monsters sequels popular Ellie Kemper Nat Geo Exclusive Video reviews boxoffice El Rey trophy fast and furious Star Wars Britbox Starz free movies composers Musicals Showtime Mary Tyler Moore ViacomCBS TCA Winter 2020 Quiz spy thriller adenture jamie lee curtis high school Cannes quibi Mindy Kaling Writers Guild of America Netflix Christmas movies Black History Month satire true crime RT21 TLC Countdown DGA festival french Apple richard e. Grant Disney streaming service The Walking Dead RT History TNT Trophy Talk 73rd Emmy Awards south america period drama Mary poppins Marvel Television renewed TV shows Academy Awards Fargo Country Alien 2020 Disney+ Disney Plus Horror Opinion Universal telelvision Rocketman 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Martial Arts hollywood screen actors guild VICE Awards Tour award winner Winners kaiju cinemax Pirates films DC Comics Year in Review disaster X-Men Amazon Prime Video trailers zombies king kong ESPN OneApp 20th Century Fox Musical transformers Spike classics social media The Arrangement slasher mob canceled HBO Go serial killer crossover theme song blaxploitation Drama rom-coms Emmy Nominations rt archives docuseries Summer BET Awards black comedy Tumblr History CBS All Access Calendar San Diego Comic-Con Lifetime godzilla TV One news finale 24 frames cancelled strong female leads lord of the rings Watching Series worst movies live event Freeform CNN BAFTA live action Schedule Tomatazos Chilling Adventures of Sabrina series tv talk new york 93rd Oscars independent comic books Shondaland Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt scene in color singing competition Comedy Central Sneak Peek unscripted SDCC spanish Disney Action Tubi aapi genre MSNBC Baby Yoda WarnerMedia pirates of the caribbean NBC Western australia zero dark thirty Mystery spider-verse scary movies Black Mirror MTV Awards foreign Women's History Month razzies christmas movies comic DC streaming service suspense slashers Video Games TV movies obituary CW Seed Polls and Games parents Rocky Box Office Pop TV Certified Fresh olympics 4/20 Cartoon Network Stephen King Super Bowl Extras die hard docudrama cats mutant American Society of Cinematographers Superheroes Universal Pictures Classic Film