Further Reading: Seasonal Slaying - The 12 Horrors of Christmas

Kim Newman chooses 12 Yuletide nightmares.

by | December 25, 2008 | Comments

Thanks to Charles Dickens and A Christmas Carol, the Yuletide season has long been associated with ghost stories — often with hard-won uplift at the end, like Scrooge being reformed by pestering spectres or Jimmy Stewart terrified into affirming that It’s a Wonderful Life after all. In the 1970s, the BBC threw a chill into Morecambe and Wise-dominated holiday schedules with their annual Ghost Story for Christmas series, mostly adapted from stories M.R. James had originally written to be read aloud as a seasonal treat. Somehow, the combination of the long nights, the cold weather and forced proximity to your family is as conducive to bone-freezing horror as joy to the world and all-round merriment.

So, for those who still think Christmas fans should be buried at the crossroads with a sprig of holly through their hearts, here are my recommendations for a full holiday of horrors…

On the first day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
Tales From the Crypt (1972)

Joan Collins bludgeons her husband to death under the Christmas tree and tries to get rid of the body, all the while besieged in her hideous suburban home by an escaped homicidal maniac dressed as Santa Claus. In the end, her innocent little daughter lets Santa in and he throttles Joanie. Heh heh heh. The classic first episode of Freddie Francis’s adaptation of stories from the gleefully nasty 1950s horror comic.

On the second day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
Hansel and Gretel (2006)

Three Korean psychic kids establish an eternal Christmas with sweets and cake for every meal in a house in the middle of magic woods. Only loosely connected to the fairytale, it features a Korean Santa who can actually grant little kids’ wishes and a miserable orphanage flashback which makes Oliver Twist seem cheery.

Santa's Slay

On the third day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
Santa’s Slay (2005)

A maniacally evil Santa (wrestler Bill Goldberg) turns out to be the Devil’s son, and has only been nice to children for the last thousand years because he lost a bet with an angel. Now the term of the promise is up, and he can revert to his favoured mode of celebrating the ‘slaying’ time of year. Ho ho horror!

On the fourth day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
Black Christmas (1972)

Even before Halloween, there were holiday slashers, and Bob Clark’s sorority-set horror film is among the best of ’em, with Olivia Hussey, Margot Kidder and Andrea Martin as sorority girls persecuted by a prank caller (yes, they trace the calls and… they’re coming from the attic!) at Christmas. The remake has murder by sharpened candy cane, but isn’t as good.

Black Christmas

On the fifth day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
36:15 – Code Pere Noel (1989)

It’s almost impossible to see this Christmas horror film — which I voted to win several awards at a film festival in 1989 when I was on a jury — because it’s never been distributed outside France. At the time, director Rene Manzor said that Hollywood wanted to remake his story about a shut-in, ingenious kid (Alain Musy) who improvises booby-traps to defend himself from a killer Santa Claus (Patrick Florsheim) over the holidays – but drop the Santa angle. Funnily enough, Home Alone came out a year later and doesn’t credit this as a source. The French film is darker, funnier and has more guts than John Hughes’ version — but good luck trying to find it.

On the sixth day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
You Better Watch Out (1980), aka Christmas Evil

My personal favourite psycho-Santa movie, this is about an embittered, holiday-loving employee (Brandon Maggart) of a nasty toy company who spends the holidays murdering folks who abuse the spirit of Christmas and giving away toys for orphans. John Waters said of this film, “I wish I had kids. I’d make them watch it every year, and if they didn’t like it, they’d be punished.” For a real holiday horror, double bill it with New Year’s Evil.

On the seventh day of Christmas, my true love watched with me….
Don’t Open til Christmas (1984)

If you ever get fed up with Christmas horror films with psychopathic Santas — the worst I’ve ever seen is To All a Goodnight — then check out this dreadful British picture, in which a psychopath (Alan Lake) murders old gits in Santa Claus outfits.

On the eighth day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
Silent Night, Deadly Night (1984)

Though there were enough homicidal maniac Santas in movies before 1984 to form a football team — with reserves — this was the picture that excited pro-Christmas protesters to picket at the sacrilege of depicting old Kris Kringle as a murdering lunatic. Maybe it was the scene where Linnea Quigley gets impaled topless on some reindeer antlers. All the fuss didn’t stop Silent Night, Deadly Night from having four sequels. For true perversity, I recommend the immediate follow-up Silent Night, Deadly Night Part II (1987), which cheekily recycles about an hour of footage from the original to pad out the minimal new story, but does run to a wonderful sequence — blatantly ripped off in Scary Movie — as the vigilante killer is taken to see a film about a murdering Santa (“that’s the worst idea for a film I’ve ever heard”) and gleefully takes a knife to some clown who talks throughout the picture.


On the ninth day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
Gremlins (1984)

A classic — for Phoebe Cates’ “and that’s why I hate Christmas” speech alone. The studio wanted it cut, but Joe Dante insisted it stay in.

On the tenth day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
The Addams Family (1991)

The opening of the film brings to life Charles Addams’ wonderful Christmas spirit cartoon, in which his gruesome family celebrate their own variety of togetherness by pouring boiling oil onto the heads of a parcel of merry carol-singers.


On the eleventh day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
P2 (2007)

Rachel Nicholls is trapped in a parking structure on Christmas Eve by a lunatic stalker (Wes Bentley) who wants to have take-out turkey with her and is going to torture her nasty boss to death as a present. There has to be a Christmas-themed torture porn/abduction movie, and this is it.

On the twelfth day of Christmas, my true love watched with me…
The Devil Doll (1936)

This is the one about Lionel Barrymore escaping from Devil’s Island and teaming up with mad scientists to wreak vengeance on his tormentors — he drags up as a little old lady and opens a toyshop, selling shrunken, hypnotised human beings as dolls who also work as assassins. The best scene has a miniature killer smuggled into a victim’s home as a Christmas present for a little girl, then coming to life while tied to the tree and scurrying through the wrapped gifts to leave a nasty surprise come Christmas morning.

Tag Cloud

FX period drama Arrowverse psychological thriller disaster black 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards CBS All Access psycho Funimation DC Comics DGA Paramount Pictures live action ghosts Epix sopranos Black History Month 94th Oscars Pop TV Film Festival Nickelodeon DC streaming service concert The Purge deadpool Mary Tyler Moore television X-Men vampires game of thrones PBS franchise TCA Winter 2020 Creative Arts Emmys CW Seed Exclusive Video Box Office miniseries Set visit Endgame Country WarnerMedia mockumentary james bond hollywood cancelled TV shows Action Mystery versus parents news Tubi nbcuniversal best Western cars Horror MCU christmas movies Pop 45 Disney+ Disney Plus Sony Pictures 2016 Tokyo Olympics Premiere Dates rt archives Star Wars summer TV blockbuster FXX streaming anthology mission: impossible historical drama Drama VOD Focus Features Cartoon Network TCM New York Comic Con Ovation nfl Musical video on demand stoner sports strong female leads golden globe awards superman posters Black Mirror Election Best Actor comic book movies SundanceTV E! 2019 rotten movies we love mcc Interview reboot TruTV Fargo Amazon Prime PlayStation Red Carpet Video Games documentaries Columbia Pictures canceled TV shows 2015 gangster comedies ITV HBO Max Hulu Christmas Super Bowl Summer kaiju Martial Arts South by Southwest Film Festival Tags: Comedy cults History WGN Travel Channel docuseries ABC Music mob debate biography animated adaptation twilight trophy Oscars TV One tv talk Brie Larson 4/20 Starz quibi archives remakes Bravo Warner Bros. Family universal monsters Heroines facebook dceu Trailer police drama President Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Nat Geo harry potter Pacific Islander Fox Searchlight GIFs criterion TCA NBA festivals OWN The Arrangement Discovery Channel Extras Fall TV SDCC rt labs critics edition scene in color Marvel name the review comic supernatural dc scary movies Instagram Live Best and Worst Marvel Studios cancelled sag awards MGM game show biopic crime thriller diversity Turner Classic Movies A&E Neflix Biopics Disney Channel Sundance Now comic book movie MSNBC Spring TV Apple TV+ marvel cinematic universe kong Logo theme song Tarantino Acorn TV DirecTV Food Network Amazon Mary poppins Holiday joker 007 Rocketman technology telelvision BBC America National Geographic fast and furious travel thriller Masterpiece Pixar Podcast suspense Academy Awards finale free movies Hollywood Foreign Press Association action-comedy BET First Look The Walt Disney Company crime drama Adult Swim what to watch Valentine's Day saw SXSW 2022 Quiz king kong boxoffice Cosplay Disney streaming service hist romance GoT space breaking bad IMDb TV HFPA Lifetime Christmas movies teaser child's play TLC TBS dexter australia 24 frames BBC Hear Us Out Syfy singing competition Polls and Games Emmys trailers OneApp south america Cannes docudrama cinemax Legendary war YA El Rey feel good dogs Broadway Infographic Shondaland book dramedy TV movies football politics Certified Fresh movies interviews razzies children's TV USA Network Marvel Television ViacomCBS anime IFC Films obituary popular italian broadcast Photos BAFTA Television Academy movie LGBT FOX prank latino rt labs Spike sequels satire Amazon Prime Video Reality Britbox HBO Go revenge Comics on TV godzilla Awards Paramount Network slashers kids screenings The CW YouTube Premium Trivia halloween tv Oscar NYCC summer TV preview Disney Plus TCA 2017 award winner robots Paramount richard e. Grant series golden globes die hard spain know your critic serial killer batman Schedule Fox News Crackle canceled composers Comic Book cancelled television indiana jones renewed TV shows hispanic TCA Awards worst movies classics VICE social media spy thriller streaming movies scorecard target comiccon dragons Best Actress LGBTQ 1990s reviews legend First Reviews binge leaderboard Winter TV aapi Netflix Christmas movies Countdown venice GLAAD Mindy Kaling superhero Prime Video jamie lee curtis blaxploitation marvel comics RT History japanese AMC 2018 Walt Disney Pictures HBO new star wars movies art house discovery Mudbound new zealand vs. king arthur Television Critics Association Winners Sundance TV all-time The Witch a nightmare on elm street Trophy Talk royal family Women's History Month Thanksgiving Rom-Com Holidays American Society of Cinematographers TIFF Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CMT 99% dreamworks Showtime Apple TV Plus Image Comics TV renewals Opinion genre cartoon green book critic resources Paramount Plus romantic comedy halloween Vudu DC Universe justice league foreign Sci-Fi See It Skip It witnail elevated horror Film comics basketball Turner new york 90s Hallmark independent Ellie Kemper screen actors guild rom-coms boxing french Grammys zero dark thirty YouTube Year in Review werewolf hidden camera slasher Lucasfilm based on movie worst directors VH1 71st Emmy Awards spider-verse aliens jurassic park toy story cooking BET Awards dark Lionsgate black comedy 2020 20th Century Fox natural history women Comic-Con@Home 2021 Song of Ice and Fire Pirates ABC Signature Esquire Writers Guild of America Captain marvel talk show indie Binge Guide Sundance cops chucky book adaptation Alien Avengers 72 Emmy Awards Nominations 21st Century Fox spinoff fresh SXSW Stephen King A24 political drama obi wan Animation ratings Best Picture Peacock crime Tomatazos USA nature lord of the rings Superheroe TV Land Character Guide video Rock monster movies Rocky summer preview Wes Anderson blockbusters japan zombies Sneak Peek crossover Superheroes 2021 2017 Disney Amazon Studios APB sequel YouTube Red Best Director young adult Kids & Family Calendar high school transformers casting E3 spider-man Mary Poppins Returns sitcom hispanic heritage month Fantasy toronto doctor who ABC Family AMC Plus pirates of the caribbean zombie Lifetime Chernobyl Spectrum Originals 73rd Emmy Awards Dark Horse Comics PaleyFest Shudder San Diego Comic-Con Universal comic books international adventure TNT Marathons RT21 Hallmark Christmas movies Baby Yoda Pride Month Comedy Central unscripted ID critics The Walking Dead MTV Universal Pictures IFC Star Trek Elton John rotten Classic Film The Academy spanish language medical drama Teen science fiction Tumblr Netflix BBC One Toys stand-up comedy NBC FX on Hulu olympics adenture scary 93rd Oscars Musicals heist movie Freeform Pet Sematary CNN stop motion ESPN wonder woman Comedy Reality Competition festival true crime Emmy Nominations emmy awards TV cancelled TV series streamig cats spanish Watching Series documentary Crunchyroll asian-american live event laika Apple CBS Awards Tour Ghostbusters mutant films 79th Golden Globes Awards Anna Paquin