Further Reading: Marion Cotillard and Forest Whittaker in Abel Ferrara's Mary

The wild director attempts to tame a mad take on the bible.

by | October 3, 2008 | Comments

Further Reading by Kim Newman

As the NFT in London prepares a Juliette Binoche season, Kim looks at Abel Ferrara‘s Mary which also stars Marion Cotillard and Forest Whitaker.

Say what you like about wild man writer-director Abel Ferrara (probably still best known for The Driller Killer), but he knows how to land the talent. His 2005 picture Mary — which gets its first UK screenings, at the NFT in London as part of a Juliette Binoche season, on the 2nd and 3rd of October — not only casts the 1995 Best Supporting Actress Oscar winner (The English Patient), but finds room for 2007 Best Actor Forest Whitaker (The Last King of Scotland) and 2008 Best Actress Marion Cotillard (La Vie en Rose), plus Matthew Modine (returning as a Ferrara alter ego after The Blackout) and Euro-favourite Stefania Rocca (best known for The Talented Mr Ripley).


In the past, Ferrara has managed (against the odds) to get solid work from hit-or-miss talents like Madonna (reasonably credible in Snake Eyes aka Dangerous Game), Asia Argento (outstanding in New Rose Hotel) and Ice-T (good in R’Xmas), and guided powerhouses like Christopher Walken and Laurence Fishburne (The King of New York), Harvey Keitel (Bad Lieutenant) and Lili Taylor (The Addiction) through method performances which would fill shelves with statuettes if folks in Beverly Hills paid attention to films as rough, challenging and strange as the Ferrara oeuvre.

Made partially as a response to Mel Gibson‘s The Passion of the Christ, Mary is a hard-to-categorise exercise in street theology — which touches on Da Vinci Code-ish speculations about the gospels, and wrestles with the age-old problems of faith and uncertainty in a mix of subtle character interplay and outright silent movie-style melodramatics. Tony Childress (Modine) has just finished directing and starring in a film called This is My Blood (not to be confused with There Will Be Blood), which is attracting Last Temptation of Christ-style organised protests for supposed blasphemy and anti-semitism. Marie Palesi (Binoche), the actress cast as Mary Magdalene, has been so overwhelmed by the experience of playing the role that she has opted to abandon her career and go to Jerusalem (‘what are you doing,’ Tony asks, ‘healing lepers?’) to explore spiritual pursuits and dispense enigmatic wisdom via cell-phone.


It seems that she has come to believe that the depiction of Mary as a prostitute in the gospels and as Jesus’s wife in modern fiction are both male-perpetrated myths designed to cover up the fact that the messiah chose her, not Saint Peter, as his chief disciple — this is an interesting ‘what if’ in itself, and the scenes from This is My Blood in which Mary resists being shut out of the disciples’ boys’ club have a Pasolinian vigour that bests Gibson’s Christian torture porn and at least competes with Scorsese’s It’s a Wonderful Life heresies.

Further Reading by Kim Newman

A year later, with the film edited and due for release, Tony has shaved off his Jesus beard and retreated behind dark glasses while embarking on an embattled publicity tour for the film, responding to the protests with desperate aggression and hurt-little boy pride (Ferrara has been playing autobiographical games on the theme of artist as childish monster ever since The Driller Killer, and Modine enthusiastically plays up to the director’s out-of-the-room image). Ted Younger (Whitaker), a New York-based talk show host, conducts nightly interviews with theologians and Biblical historians (what channel could this possibly air on?) and Tony agrees to appear on the program (hinting that Marie might show up to solve the mystery of her disappearance) if Ted covers the scheduled premiere, which is expected to feature a possibly-violent clash with protestors (in a jarring shock scene, what seems to be a mix of hasidic Jews and a street gang attack the limo Tony and Ted are riding in).


Ted is being unfaithful to his pregnant wife Elizabeth (Heather Graham) with actress Gretchen (Cotillard), and this ‘sin’ is punished when Elizabeth gives premature birth to a baby who struggles to live (it’s probably a mercy that Ferrara uses a plainly healthy baby, though this undercuts the desperation of the hospital scenes). Just as Harvey Keitel’s Bad Lieutentant bared his soul to Jesus, so Whitaker’s straying commentator stops the show with an angst-driven prayer — very few actors can get away with praying on screen, especially if they have to talk out loud to God and the audience, but Whitaker is as good here as in any given Idi Amin scene.

With his spirituality completely turned around by this travail, Ted doesn’t give Tony the easy ride he expects on his show — and brings in the distant voice of Marie, who remains certain and centered as the men around her descend into mania. Like many a Ferrara film, the home stretch is deliberately chaotic and hard to follow, but a bomb threat disrupts the This is My Blood premiere and Marie takes to a fishing boat in Israel as she blends even more with Mary Magdalene. As cued by a debate in which characters (and the audience) are enjoined to ‘really think’ about the crucifixion, everyone gets a ‘big suffering scene’: Modine’s turn comes when Tony goes crazy as he works a projector, screening his film to the cops searching the auditorium for a bomb and gloating that there are ‘lines around the block in Chicago’. Only Binoche remains serene, though Marie’s abandonment of the life of a movie star for that of a saint might prompt audiences to muse that when Ferrara gives her great iconic close-ups he is turning saintliness back to old-fashioned stardom.


Ferrara has always had one foot in the grindhouse and the other in the arthouse. He even made (and starred in) a porn movie (9 Lives of a Wet Pussy), which is unusual for someone as inclined as fellow New York Italian-American Martin Scorsese to make bizarre religious films. Then again, ‘really think’ about the crucifixion, as Mel Gibson did, and you find the horror movie bleeding heart of Roman Catholicism — previously strongest in the Ferrara filmography in the revisionist vampire movie The Addiction.

Perhaps to put further distance between Mary and Gibson’s film, it inclines towards the respectable end of Ferrara’s output, which means even fans who cherish the likes of Ms .45 and Body Snatchers (on which he first worked with Whittaker) haven’t completely embraced it. Like Ferrara’s New Rose Hotel, R’Xmas, Go Go Tales and the documentary Chelsea on the Rocks, Mary has mostly screened at film festivals. Since The Blackout in 1997, even independent distributors haven’t got behind his films in the UK: they don’t even go direct to DVD, where you could find a Driller Killer 2 if any schlockmeister got the rights to it. This is the penalty for making films at a volume of eleven.

Tag Cloud

all-time Schedule Musical BET Awards Crackle crime drama toy story period drama TV Mary poppins FX criterion Amazon action-comedy Drama Valentine's Day Disney Channel video Black Mirror WarnerMedia Super Bowl TV renewals black comedy serial killer dogs The Purge 90s Television Academy AMC SundanceTV hispanic women Film child's play critics E! Lucasfilm Showtime dreamworks The CW VH1 animated scene in color 45 2015 4/20 asian-american Rocky cancelled Sci-Fi Countdown biography 21st Century Fox theme song unscripted kong Trailer Opinion anthology Chernobyl Teen green book Masterpiece cars AMC Plus American Society of Cinematographers batman screenings nature Instagram Live Mudbound television rt archives award winner Fantasy NBC nfl young adult APB trophy Toys Disney+ Disney Plus zero dark thirty Sneak Peek Thanksgiving slashers Hallmark Christmas movies crime TCA Awards worst spider-man Infographic medical drama cinemax series worst movies strong female leads rt labs critics edition comic book movies trailers spanish language ID Disney Plus nbcuniversal comic books Britbox tv talk Comics on TV elevated horror HBO Go name the review Lifetime Christmas movies Discovery Channel blockbusters Film Festival ESPN CBS The Walt Disney Company joker Exclusive Video game show new york prank See It Skip It Broadway rotten Ghostbusters The Walking Dead Hallmark psychological thriller based on movie Mary Poppins Returns Trivia LGBTQ reboot ABC Action leaderboard dceu justice league USA cancelled TV series romance international 007 aapi renewed TV shows Best and Worst BBC America Nominations Spectrum Originals romantic comedy wonder woman Amazon Prime Video adenture comiccon sitcom TCA Winter 2020 Legendary The Arrangement mutant Horror Paramount fast and furious TCA Martial Arts Elton John biopic MCU DC streaming service E3 political drama Awards Tour cults TV Land Hulu zombies San Diego Comic-Con Shudder cats sports mcc ABC Signature Paramount Network Bravo italian science fiction mission: impossible Christmas boxoffice Oscars TV movies rom-coms Avengers new star wars movies Crunchyroll revenge Comic-Con@Home 2021 BBC One Amazon Studios Reality Competition Western superman indiana jones war Mystery news politics sequel Certified Fresh heist movie Pride Month Apple TV+ stoner marvel comics Acorn TV Nat Geo emmy awards canceled docuseries CNN kaiju ITV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina transformers Sundance Now technology scary movies Dark Horse Comics mockumentary psycho supernatural Rock DGA cops breaking bad Grammys thriller dragons sequels Walt Disney Pictures NYCC Marvel Studios golden globe awards fresh monster movies talk show spy thriller zombie Red Carpet Rom-Com BET RT21 Alien new zealand Summer live event cartoon 93rd Oscars Mary Tyler Moore A&E reviews Netflix Food Network festival Writers Guild of America Captain marvel legend Marathons social media Trophy Talk OWN YouTube Premium PaleyFest Disney DC Comics debate Netflix Christmas movies witnail VOD blockbuster versus Black History Month football Fall TV king arthur Spring TV TIFF Tumblr IMDb TV robots classics black casting PBS Country VICE anime spain obituary Comic Book composers SXSW Family TCM crime thriller HBO USA Network game of thrones popular GoT ABC Family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Stephen King singing competition Superheroe Travel Channel Brie Larson Sundance Winners Polls and Games Shondaland binge screen actors guild foreign MSNBC natural history Endgame live action movies Fargo Television Critics Association video on demand razzies Arrowverse Pirates Musicals Esquire Mindy Kaling 2017 Turner Fox Searchlight rotten movies we love Academy Awards olympics telelvision 2021 YA 72 Emmy Awards dramedy TruTV Holidays Universal Pictures comic Binge Guide godzilla Winter TV Turner Classic Movies El Rey Paramount Plus Syfy dc Photos streaming Disney streaming service Comedy Central 20th Century Fox National Geographic CMT ViacomCBS harry potter die hard a nightmare on elm street aliens TLC 2018 Apple chucky Sundance TV james bond kids saw japanese venice YouTube comic book movie jurassic park french Pet Sematary Wes Anderson werewolf Fox News Star Trek directors Neflix genre Logo Calendar CBS All Access adaptation OneApp FX on Hulu GLAAD Vudu crossover FXX feel good scorecard Classic Film Video Games 2020 royal family Song of Ice and Fire vs. what to watch Premiere Dates films Marvel teaser best book adaptation Spike twilight festivals President hidden camera scary Adult Swim gangster richard e. Grant 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards streaming movies TNT cooking Reality Warner Bros. ghosts quibi halloween marvel cinematic universe Hear Us Out Cartoon Network Pop TV franchise Starz boxing documentary TV One australia book Pop Music Quiz sopranos DirecTV New York Comic Con facebook slasher cancelled television Lifetime remakes comedies Emmy Nominations art house Cosplay pirates of the caribbean miniseries Pixar Anna Paquin SDCC Amazon Prime space spanish GIFs 2016 The Witch Heroines FOX superhero travel 73rd Emmy Awards indie LGBT Image Comics BAFTA BBC HBO Max Baby Yoda halloween tv Biopics CW Seed know your critic Ovation YouTube Red 24 frames Creative Arts Emmys Election First Reviews Emmys Universal The Academy ratings south america Podcast parents stand-up comedy Columbia Pictures Star Wars stop motion laika hollywood Animation historical drama Cannes latino 71st Emmy Awards First Look NBA universal monsters Interview Watching Series posters vampires satire Comedy hispanic heritage month Set visit canceled TV shows disaster Year in Review japan blaxploitation Marvel Television golden globes documentaries diversity rt labs docudrama A24 WGN true crime Ellie Kemper Apple TV Plus dark target Extras DC Universe deadpool Epix Sony Pictures MTV king kong suspense TBS spider-verse high school Tomatazos children's TV Tubi Peacock 1990s IFC Films jamie lee curtis History Pacific Islander lord of the rings Superheroes X-Men dexter TCA 2017 Holiday discovery Lionsgate doctor who christmas movies PlayStation Kids & Family sag awards critic resources adventure hist Tokyo Olympics toronto Funimation Awards Rocketman cancelled TV shows Nickelodeon RT History 2019 Character Guide Box Office Women's History Month police drama Tarantino spinoff basketball archives 99% mob concert independent IFC Freeform comics free movies finale movie