Further Reading: Celebrating the Brilliance of The King of Kong

Kim Newman reassesses the much-loved videogaming doc.

by | August 7, 2008 | Comments

Further Reading by Kim Newman

One documentary from the US last year spoke to avid videogamers more than any other, and in the process told a brilliantly human story about good, evil and Donkey Kong. In this week’s Further Reading, Kim Newman celebrates The King of Kong.

This is the most exciting, audience-involving film of any kind I’ve seen this year. At none of the previews of the summer’s blockbusters was I part of such a vocal, enthusiastic and wholly-gripped crowd as I was at a relatively small screening of a picture which has made its UK debut as a DVD retail item.

The King of Kong is an aptly ragged-looking documentary which takes a completely uninviting subject — a controversy in the world of retro-computer gaming about whether longtime Donkey Kong champion Billy Mitchell should cede his title to contender Steve Weibe — and makes it the stuff of legends. Donkey Kong, for those who don’t remember, is (or, rather, was) an early, fiendishly difficult game from the Super Mario Bros stable, in which the plumber tries to ascend various ladders to rescue a princess, while avoiding missiles tossed by a malign ape. From the DVD extras, I learned that the game was originally supposed to feature Popeye, Olive Oyl and Bluto, but the Japanese designers couldn’t get the rights to the characters and came up with their own.

The King of Kong

Billy Mitchell, hailed as ‘the gamer of the century’, is a reptilian, faux-cool smarm-bucket who invokes fanatical loyalty from longtime rivals and associates, including Brian Kuh (the third-highest DK scorer), who scuttles around with Renfield-like devotion to his master, and Walter Day, the bizarre Roberts Blossom lookalike who has taken on the mantle of definitive judge for the field (an accolade confirmed when he strikes an alliance with the Guinness Book of Records).

Though a patriot, a family man, a successful hot sauce tycoon and rated as ultra-cool by his circle, the goateed and distinctively coiffed Mitchell comes across onscreen as a classic villain. Even his closest friends call him devious, but he is also tragically puffed up in his idea of celebrity, flirting with the interviewer and referring to himself in the third person as if he were a world leader planning a counter-coup rather than a probable saddo whose highest achievement (a perfect Pac-Man score) means less and less with every passing minute.

The King of Kong

Wiebe, by contrast, is a classic underdog: following a run of near-miss careers in baseball and music, he took up the game after being laid off, then reinvented himself as a science teacher loved by his students. Crucially, in this showing at least, he doesn’t even seem to think that much of his knack for DK, though he is clearly as obsessively devoted to chasing the record as Mitchell is to keeping it.

Director Seth Gordon intended a more general inside-retro-gaming documentary but lucked into an astonishingly potent storyline and must have sorted through acres of footage to get stuff this good. So good, in fact, a dramatised remake is reportedly in the works. It has vivid supporting characters, including Roy Schild (aka ‘Mr Awesome’), a secondary ‘evil mastermind’ in Wiebe’s camp and Wiebe’s amazing children (a young son who shouts ‘stop playing Donkey Kong‘ as Dad is on his first record-breaking attempt, a tweenage daughter who wryly observes that a lot of people ruin their lives trying to get into the Guinness Book of Records).

Further Reading by Kim Newman

You also get as many ups and downs as a sports fiction film, with the added plus that since it’s a true story the outcome isn’t decreed by cliché — though there are triumphs and disasters near the end, the story goes on and you can’t stop yourself looking up on the internet to find out who reigns as the current King of Kong. Everyone, including the near-saintly but not sanctimonious Wiebe, reveals more about themselves than the average reality TV contestant would, with many jaw-dropping statements about epochal achievements and grand calamities that took place in a world of game-playing marginalised by the end of the 1980s.

The King of Kong

Mitchell and cohorts act in such a way that, even if it turned out Gordon manipulated and edited the hell out of the footage, it would be impossible for your conclusions about these people not to be — to some extent – horribly true. When Wiebe sends in a tape of his first record-breaking score, Day has agents talk their way into his house to assess his personal DK machine to see if it’s been tampered with, Mitchell claims only scores achieved in public count and the record doesn’t go into the books. When Wiebe does it again at a games convention, Mitchell has protégé Doris Self (an 80-year-old Q*Bert whizz) hand over a blurry, splicey tape in which he purportedly sets a higher record which Day and company accept within ten minutes.

I don’t see how this incident could be spun in a way which doesn’t suggest the tiny sub-culture was stacked against the outsider, though there’s a subtle thread later in the film, which I suspect comes from a dawning awareness of what they look like on the record, as Day and his crowd (except the loyal Kuh) begin to feel the long-time champion has been less than honest with them and respond to Wiebe’s essential decency even as they consistently mispronounce his name.

The King of Kong

There’s a stunning moment when the antagonists almost meet, for the only time in the film, as Wiebe is openly friendly to Mitchell, who cruises by ignoring him at a games machine while making a snide remark to his wife; it may be that when the cameras weren’t on them, these men have played each other or treated each other courteously, but the audience I saw it with hissed a pantomime villain and cheered for the decent contender. Even Mitchell’s obviously genuine decency towards Doris, a little old lady whose gaming career he enabled and championed, doesn’t take the sting out of his Dick Dastardly act elsewhere.

It makes good use of 1980s inspirational pop music, and — like the best of these ‘American weirdo’ documentaries (American Movie, Spellbound) — works up a vein of melancholy sympathy for folks who fanatically and unselfconsciously pursue goals that seem absurd. The middle-aged guy dressed like a teenager who wistfully remembers thinking that the guys who racked up big arcade scores would have hot babes clustering about them perfectly encapsulates the delusional, funny-sad heroism of the world of Kong.

Good documentaries can be made about significant subjects, like the recent Iraq/torture-themed Standard Operating Procedure and Taxi to the Dark Side, but sometimes outstanding true life films spin gold out of ostensibly ridiculous, trivial material.

Tag Cloud

San Diego Comic-Con Certified Fresh Western crime Esquire Song of Ice and Fire Freeform RT21 Mudbound halloween Red Carpet YouTube Premium kids VICE 45 AMC See It Skip It TV Land Mary Tyler Moore BBC Superheroes series Animation talk show Schedule Comedy Central Sundance Amazon Tumblr Rom-Com 2019 psychological thriller Polls and Games NBC breaking bad supernatural television Tarantino animated Mindy Kaling Set visit Sci-Fi politics DC Comics GLAAD 2017 Character Guide Marvel harry potter Brie Larson police drama MTV theme song based on movie Musical binge Countdown BET Amazon Prime cancelled Trophy Talk CNN FXX Pop south america The Arrangement Cosplay American Society of Cinematographers The Purge ratings Creative Arts Emmys Paramount video BBC America NYCC YouTube SundanceTV Rock Disney streaming service El Rey adventure Warner Bros. DC streaming service Ovation Family Britbox romance Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Christmas biography Sneak Peek comic OWN serial killer E! 24 frames zero dark thirty Reality 2016 SXSW VH1 discovery thriller sports nature crime thriller crime drama joker festivals Kids & Family GoT aliens LGBT YA game of thrones IFC Music canceled TLC TNT Spike Heroines tv talk Fall TV batman Martial Arts Awards Lionsgate zombies Apple TV+ FX technology RT History teaser Elton John Toys Calendar Fantasy HBO Max dramedy political drama Netflix Extras DirecTV Valentine's Day USA Spring TV CMT Sony Pictures mockumentary social media History quibi Podcast Syfy Quiz latino natural history SDCC what to watch anthology Pet Sematary cancelled television TCA 2017 TV Thanksgiving Opinion Bravo Trivia Stephen King FOX Comic Book stand-up comedy miniseries Apple crossover medical drama Peacock Tomatazos Universal USA Network Ghostbusters Chernobyl MCU CW Seed Spectrum Originals diversity comiccon Showtime slashers book Marathons MSNBC HBO singing competition canceled TV shows Photos Shondaland travel Trailer Mystery Film Cannes transformers Crackle adaptation green book Interview Shudder elevated horror TCM Emmys Pride Month Teen golden globes Biopics jamie lee curtis TruTV Action dragons IFC Films war Oscars spider-man Election First Reviews Video Games Winners cars blaxploitation zombie Fox News Disney cats vampires streaming Rocky Super Bowl Pixar robots hispanic Starz sitcom children's TV Mary Poppins Returns boxoffice 2015 Comedy Acorn TV Disney Plus Nominations Summer TIFF President Holidays Sundance Now true crime cancelled TV shows ITV Lifetime disaster Emmy Nominations cinemax free movies Mary poppins Country 71st Emmy Awards romantic comedy Columbia Pictures Premiere Dates Logo TV renewals cancelled TV series Food Network space WGN Television Academy YouTube Red GIFs Nickelodeon WarnerMedia witnail The CW spain game show movies Binge Guide Pirates Year in Review 20th Century Fox Horror mutant cults composers Reality Competition Nat Geo 2018 The Witch First Look dceu richard e. Grant facebook Disney Channel National Geographic Writers Guild of America docudrama casting historical drama Box Office DC Universe Paramount Network Vudu dc ESPN Captain marvel sequel Superheroe TCA spy thriller award winner Masterpiece science fiction finale Lucasfilm Musicals CBS Drama Cartoon Network PaleyFest Amazon Prime Video Chilling Adventures of Sabrina PBS Watching Series period drama Adult Swim 21st Century Fox Comics on TV 007 toy story Black Mirror Anna Paquin doctor who spinoff X-Men psycho Women's History Month Grammys The Walking Dead Ellie Kemper Film Festival cooking foreign ghosts justice league cops Star Wars spanish language Rocketman Star Trek ABC Family Walt Disney Pictures E3 renewed TV shows Dark Horse Comics Hulu Best and Worst Infographic APB Awards Tour A&E Epix unscripted LGBTQ TBS anime Arrowverse revenge Winter TV strong female leads ABC New York Comic Con DGA CBS All Access hist