Five Favorite Films

Five Favorite Films with Richard Kelly

The director of The Box and Donnie Darko talks Kubrick and the merits of being ambiguous.

by | July 24, 2009 | Comments

Richard Kelly


Is it possible that after only two films (his cult hit debut Donnie Darko and his infamously panned follow-up, Southland Tales), director Richard Kelly has already achieved auteur status? Audiences will find out this Halloween, when Kelly’s next film, The Box, opens in theaters. Based on Richard Matheson’s short story Button, Button, the old-fashioned thriller follows a married couple (Cameron Diaz and James Marsden) who are given a choice: if they push a button they’ll receive one million dollars, but someone somewhere will die. Rotten Tomatoes spoke with Kelly in San Diego just hours before he debuted extended footage from The Box and discussed his favorite films, the genesis of The Box, and his hopes to return to Southland Tales with an eventual Director’s Cut.

2001: A Space Odyssey (1968,
96% Tomatometer)

2001: A Space Odyssey
It pioneered everything, and it’s a film that says pretty much everything that needs to be said about our species (laughs). It was just such a groundbreaking film on every level. I don’t know if anyone has broken ground quite in the way that Kubrick did with that film.

Barry Lyndon (1975, 94% Tomatometer)

Barry Lyndon
On the flipside, Barry Lyndon, for me, is the most beautiful film ever made, for its beauty and also for its statement about our hubris as a species, in the character of Barry Lyndon being a fool who destroys everyone around him. After that it’s really murky.

Vertigo (1958, 98% Tomatometer)

My favorite Alfred Hitchcock film would have to be Vertigo.

Close Encounters of the Third Kind
(1977, 95% Tomatometer)


Close Encounters of the Third KindMy favorite Spielberg film is probably Close Encounters of the Third Kind.

The Big Lebowski
(1998, 77% Tomatometer)

The Big Lebowski
Who’s another director I like? My favorite Coen Brothers film has gotta be The Big Lebowski.


Next: Kelly talks about the merits of ambiguity in cinema, and why The Box is his most personal film.

RT: So what of The Box will be show at Comic-Con?

RK: It’s a four and a half minute montage that I cut together. It has the score from the film, so I’m really excited for everyone to see it.

RT: What interested you in The Box?

RK: This was a short story that I optioned about six years ago, so I’ve been trying to figure out how to turn it into a film for several years now. In 2006, it finally all clicked for me. I figured out how to crack the story. The timing was right, and I felt like I wanted to make this my third film. I felt I wanted to go back and make a film in Virginia, where I grew up. [I wanted] to take my parents and my family and the elements of their lives and merge it with Richard Matheson’s short story, to flesh out Arthur and Norma in a very personal way, and to do an old-fashioned suspense film. It’s kind of an old-fashioned film in the sense that there’s not one swear word in it, there’s very little violence ultimately. It’s a very suspenseful film that I hope we’ve made, in the tradition of the kinds of films that my parents grew up with. I guess it would be Alfred Hitchcock who’s someone that I think of. My parents introduced me to Alfred Hitchcock films.

RT: And like Hitchcock’s work, The Box has a moral quandary buried within a thriller.

RK: Yeah, it has this tantalizing concept of this button that could cause the death of another human being. And receiving a million dollars for it — that’s a question that you could propose to anyone. I think it’s interesting to think about how many people would go through with it (laughs), and to think about why they would go through with it. Arthur’s a scientist, and he looks at this button unit, and there’s no technology in it. It’s a piece of wood. When he opens it up, the button doesn’t do anything. And so, in his mind, push it! There’s no way this could cause the death of another human being. Push it a hundred times. Who cares? It’s just superstition. But then, when you get into the idea of, is there something greater at work? Is there some sort of magic or a higher power at work? That’s when Arthur’s made to believe, OK, this is real. And Mr. Stewart has some sort of greater ability.

RT: Are we speaking in religious terms here?

RK: I think we’re talking about science and religion, and ultimately, some sort of supernatural entity that is kind of controlling all of this that Mr. Stewart has access to. That’s part of the investigation into the mystery.


RT: Do feel like your fans will see this as a “Richard Kelly film?”

RK: I hope so. I’ve taken something that was six pages long, that was Richard Matheson’s creation, and I’ve been very reverential to it. But I’ve definitely brought a lot [to it]. It’s the most personal film I’ve ever made. At the same time, it’s also my first studio film, and [it’s] more mainstream than the previous two films. It feels very much like something that people would expect from me, I guess (laughs). Specifically with Donnie Darko; I think it feels tonally similar to Donnie Darko in a lot of ways.

RT: I appreciate the fact that Donnie Darko doesn’t spell out its meaning. Is that something you strive for in all of your films?

RK: I always like that there’s a degree of ambiguity, and that there’s a lot for people to digest and think about. I hope to always make films that people can watch more than once and continue to see new things, because for me, those are the films that continue to age well. At the same time, it’s also about giving people enough answers so that they don’t feel alienated of confused. It’s about finding that balance in the middle.


RT: I found Southland Tales fascinating. Does that movie still stay with you?

RK: I’m so proud of that film. What I really want to do is to be able to go back and do a longer director’s cut of it at some point. There are still some unfinished visual effects that I’d like to do. And then the whole graphic novel prequel, that will always stay with me, and I hope that one day I’ll get to revisit all of that.

RT: What’s the optimal length you’re thinking of?

RK: I’d love to put an additional 10 or 15 minutes back into the film. Then, I’d love to do the whole prequel saga as an animated motion-capture film at some point. If the actors aren’t all in wheelchairs by that point (laughs).

Click here for more Comic-con coverage, and here for Kelly’s complete filmography.

Get our latest Comic-Con 2009 updates here:

Comic-Con Day 1 News Ticker

Comic-Con Day 1 Wrap-up

Comic-Con Day 2 News Ticker

Comic-Con Day 2 Wrap-up

Comic-Con Day 3 News Ticker

Comic-Con Celebrity Gallery

Comic-Con Costume Gallery

Tag Cloud

Oscars boxoffice sequel Song of Ice and Fire jamie lee curtis 2017 AMC The Witch Syfy TLC Mystery Walt Disney Pictures Super Bowl YA 2018 MSNBC Film Festival Elton John comiccon Black Mirror LGBTQ Starz Spectrum Originals BBC Biopics docudrama Certified Fresh Christmas based on movie romance TCA Pop ESPN MCU Winners Mary Poppins Returns justice league travel historical drama thriller Captain marvel golden globes what to watch Comedy Central Epix zombies Mindy Kaling Paramount Network VH1 Heroines Set visit HBO Spring TV adventure See It Skip It American Society of Cinematographers medical drama Interview mockumentary President San Diego Comic-Con harry potter theme song Fantasy biography festivals crime drama dragons Winter TV Calendar CMT comic Music Crackle Best and Worst CBS Lionsgate mutant green book SXSW GoT political drama Adult Swim CNN Pixar History TNT Star Wars NBC war Fox News Writers Guild of America DC Comics finale Cannes FX Cartoon Network dc Trivia Ghostbusters Sundance toy story Trailer Teen LGBT Polls and Games 2019 Spike Red Carpet TV Character Guide Cosplay Universal Box Office Lucasfilm Anna Paquin Paramount Thanksgiving Reality RT History aliens sitcom TCM Marvel Nominations discovery Ellie Kemper Watching Series robots transformers Brie Larson sports Superheroe IFC Films Martial Arts 45 Fall TV Logo Tumblr crime TBS animated Star Trek composers DirecTV Awards Tour hist Holidays dramedy cooking New York Comic Con E3 unscripted Sneak Peek ABC anime USA Network YouTube Premium Mary poppins Sci-Fi social media Lifetime Acorn TV Awards Ovation Columbia Pictures ABC Family spy thriller IFC BET adaptation Summer doctor who Trophy Talk A&E FXX miniseries Country VICE BBC America Amazon Prime Comedy TCA 2017 technology CW Seed Emmys cops Shudder Food Network PaleyFest The Arrangement Rocketman Photos Horror Infographic Britbox Extras Superheroes SDCC Western anthology facebook Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt blaxploitation First Look Apple nature science fiction PBS witnail Rocky Disney Channel Video Games OWN zero dark thirty spinoff television Premiere Dates casting Comic Book Amazon Vudu psychological thriller FOX APB disaster DC Universe TruTV CBS All Access elevated horror ITV TIFF Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Action Esquire Creative Arts Emmys ratings Pet Sematary Tomatazos Nickelodeon strong female leads Toys richard e. Grant cinemax Reality Competition talk show game show streaming Valentine's Day El Rey DC streaming service DGA Grammys crime thriller Stephen King Rock supernatural Musical Mary Tyler Moore vampires TV Land Pirates serial killer 20th Century Fox natural history WGN 21st Century Fox psycho Mudbound binge spider-man MTV 2016 GLAAD politics Drama Warner Bros. Tarantino National Geographic SundanceTV Shondaland Hulu USA Netflix Schedule Rom-Com Women's History Month true crime Election Masterpiece award winner diversity Quiz Bravo The CW Opinion Disney Freeform crossover GIFs period drama Year in Review police drama Animation cults Podcast singing competition 24 frames Sony Pictures Nat Geo Comics on TV Dark Horse Comics Pride Month RT21 Musicals dceu NYCC X-Men Showtime space Sundance Now Countdown teaser YouTube Red 2015 Chernobyl Kids & Family E! cats Marathons zombie 007