Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: A Christmas Carol Dazzles But Disappoints

Plus, The Box is a mixed bag, The Fourth Kind is lost in space, and Goats is worth a look.

by | November 5, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got some modern-day Dickens (Disney’s A Christmas Carol, starring Jim Carrey and Gary Oldman); a button-pushing thriller (The Box, starring Cameron Diaz and James Marsden); vanishing Alaskans (The Fourth Kind, starring Milla Jovovich and Elias Koteas); and some psychic soldiers (The Men Who Stare at Goats, starring George Clooney and Jeff Bridges). What do the critics have to say?


Disney’s A Christmas Carol

Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol is one of literature’s most haunting morality tales — and one of the most adapted. Critics are largely split on two key aspects of Robert Zemeckis’ motion-capture version starring Jim Carrey: whether it honors the, ahem, spirit of Dickens’ classic, and whether the motion-capture technology is aesthetically appealing. No need to rehash the plot; if you’ve never heard the tale of mean ol’ Ebenezer Scrooge (Carrey) and his long-suffering employee Bob Cratchit (Gary Oldman), get thee to a library immediately. While some find Zemeckis’ live action/animation hybrid an echanting way of updating a seasonal classic, others feel the visuals bog down the classic tale with an overabundance of empty action.


The Box

Richard Kelly has only made three films, but he’s had a roller-coaster of a career. His debut was the cult-fave Donnie Darko, which was followed by the ambitious but roundly-panned Southland Tales. Now comes his latest mind twister The Box, which is splitting critics; some say it’s an intriguing head trip, while others say it’s preposterous and inconsistent. Cameron Diaz and James Marsden play a married couple presented with a mysterious proposition from a stranger: there’s a button in a box, and if they push it, they will receive a million dollars, but someone will die. Some pundits say The Box is tense, edgy, and original, while others deride its plot holes and lack of overall cohesion. (Check out Kelly’s Five Favorite Films here.)


The Fourth Kind

With its combination of a government conspiracy, extraterrestrial visitors, and the foreboding climes of Alaska, The Fourth Kind seemingly has all the elements in place for a gripping horror flick. Too bad the execution’s so clumsy, critics say. Milla Jovovich stars as a shrink whose patients all tell her similar tales of nighttime frights; could aliens be to blame? The pundits say The Fourth Kind has some decent shocks, but its gimmicky presentation — a split screen technique in which patients describe their experiences alongside pseudo-documentary footage of the events — doesn’t quite come off, and the performances are uneven.


The Men Who Stare at Goats

For the most part, the recent wave of Iraq war films has brought downbeat dramas, so the satirical aim of The Men Who Stare at Goats is certainly welcome. And critics say that the film, though scattershot, has moments of brilliant absurdist humor. Hinting that its story is not terribly far from the truth, Goats is the tale of a secret military program that involves the use of psychics who attempt to use their mind power to defeat the enemy. The pundits say the film is elevated by the deadpan comic presence of George Clooney, and if the film never fully comes together, many of its scenes are sharp and funny. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Clooney’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

werewolf 72 Emmy Awards Black History Month VH1 Certified Fresh TLC Premiere Dates Amazon Prime travel Television Academy Martial Arts Fantasy movies Apple TV+ TNT south america CNN Disney Channel Video Games CMT Classic Film sitcom ABC Family Tarantino video on demand versus Turner stoner disaster Summer films award winner adventure Oscars game of thrones BAFTA teaser series Academy Awards blockbuster supernatural elevated horror Starz OneApp hispanic name the review DC Universe batman Awards Tour TCA Awards war Toys Amazon Prime Video witnail The CW El Rey justice league dark Brie Larson Polls and Games Mystery Red Carpet OWN Election A24 romance Fall TV spider-man miniseries Spectrum Originals singing competition Chilling Adventures of Sabrina fast and furious based on movie hollywood 2015 Disney+ Disney Plus BET Awards concert LGBT christmas movies Action golden globes Star Wars Superheroes USA Captain marvel Calendar Crunchyroll Hear Us Out Comic Book franchise Baby Yoda worst Creative Arts Emmys unscripted Discovery Channel American Society of Cinematographers Country criterion IFC Films DirecTV children's TV Vudu FX 2018 period drama scary movies free movies Netflix true crime Countdown Marvel Studios Podcast Showtime animated cops Family First Reviews NYCC MCU adaptation indiana jones Star Trek Super Bowl composers Extras FX on Hulu GLAAD Emmy Nominations SDCC die hard psycho Spring TV Netflix Christmas movies Schedule TCA Reality Competition richard e. Grant GoT spinoff game show video Pop obituary Comics on TV Trivia directors YouTube Premium slashers cooking President rotten nbcuniversal Sci-Fi chucky stand-up comedy Mudbound Stephen King First Look 2016 Pop TV Women's History Month Epix Amazon Studios Year in Review VOD Shudder spain kids IFC zero dark thirty Pet Sematary WarnerMedia asian-american CBS All Access foreign Nominations docudrama nature HBO Go San Diego Comic-Con Musical Peacock comics Winners 20th Century Fox Trailer Chernobyl HBO Endgame Nickelodeon Rom-Com sag awards Lifetime Christmas movies Tumblr Tubi Horror cancelled TV shows screen actors guild romantic comedy doctor who BBC The Walking Dead Disney Acorn TV screenings Trophy Talk 21st Century Fox best latino twilight talk show Reality diversity Freeform Food Network Ghostbusters cartoon New York Comic Con Holiday History Black Mirror DC streaming service Bravo Mary poppins rotten movies we love comic independent what to watch Opinion DGA Interview joker Marvel Television space WGN Avengers USA Network Mindy Kaling Ovation festivals E3 Sundance TV Writers Guild of America theme song mission: impossible APB crime thriller Elton John parents comiccon thriller comedies YA natural history toy story Animation CW Seed Pixar Music Columbia Pictures sequels canceled TV shows BBC One Masterpiece MTV BET Sundance TCA 2017 ratings revenge book crime NBC reboot biography FOX zombies a nightmare on elm street National Geographic Heroines Set visit RT21 YouTube Red renewed TV shows Funimation transformers PlayStation Disney streaming service 2020 Fox News crime drama Binge Guide Disney Plus harry potter YouTube movie technology Ellie Kemper TIFF robots halloween binge Nat Geo The Witch classics The Purge blaxploitation anthology ESPN television crossover A&E Walt Disney Pictures Travel Channel 2019 Quiz sequel breaking bad Winter TV ITV boxoffice Christmas Esquire Rock cars all-time cancelled television zombie Holidays dc aliens satire Musicals TV renewals Marathons Photos Mary Tyler Moore sports jamie lee curtis documentaries Infographic strong female leads Syfy Film VICE casting Apple LGBTQ tv talk Grammys universal monsters finale superhero Rocketman reviews PaleyFest Watching Series news laika MSNBC Mary Poppins Returns Song of Ice and Fire TV discovery GIFs 24 frames canceled mutant Cannes social media Arrowverse Pirates ABC psychological thriller Lucasfilm historical drama stop motion 45 Lionsgate 2017 Best and Worst Amazon cats critics Cosplay HBO Max Teen spy thriller Dark Horse Comics Apple TV Plus Hallmark Character Guide SXSW 4/20 Biopics Comedy TV Land Universal anime PBS TCA Winter 2020 Sneak Peek green book child's play medical drama Superheroe political drama streaming Pride Month TruTV Rocky Comedy Central Sundance Now CBS politics mockumentary dragons BBC America The Arrangement Hallmark Christmas movies indie Anna Paquin AMC Television Critics Association SundanceTV Emmys documentary quibi DC Comics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dceu ghosts Adult Swim X-Men Awards See It Skip It dramedy cinemax Hulu Britbox Marvel facebook Logo 71st Emmy Awards cancelled TV series Warner Bros. Valentine's Day TBS serial killer Paramount 007 Tomatazos Shondaland Thanksgiving Film Festival spanish language science fiction cancelled Cartoon Network Paramount Network Spike Drama Western Sony Pictures police drama Turner Classic Movies TCM dogs Lifetime FXX cults RT History Crackle Kids & Family E! emmy awards hist vampires Box Office