News

First Ready Player One Reactions: Classic Steven Spielberg, Dorky, and Fun

Critics give Spielberg's latest a standing ovation and plenty of Twitter love

by | March 12, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Jaap Buttendijk / © 2018 WARNER BROS. ENTERTAINMENT INC.)

Fans in Austin received a special treat this weekend, when Ready Player One was revealed to have a South By Southwest Film Festival premiere on Sunday night. Director Steven Spielberg was on hand to introduce what he clarified to be “not a film…a movie,” and was joined on stage before and after the screening by cast members and Ready Player One author and co-screenwriter, Ernest Cline. The audience ate the “movie” up in enthusiastic SXSW fashion — and stuck with it even when the sound cut out and the film had to be restarted, twice, as the climax was unfolding. When the credits rolled, the crowd gave Spielberg a mighty standing ovation.

As the night unfolded, the critics in attendance weighed in with their first thoughts on Twitter (some early full reviews have started to drop, too, so keep an eye on the Tomatometer). Most of the buzz matched that ovation, but not all was so positive. Here are the initial reactions via social media:


IT’S A WHOLE LOT OF DORKY FUN…

“Well everyone relax, Ready Player One will indeed be the biggest thing in the world.” – Emily Yoshida, New York Magazine/Vulture

Ready Player One is full of giant, dorky heart. I both want to hug it and give it a noogie.” – Meredith Border, Fangoria

Ready Player One is a whole lot of fun. Those who are stuck in pre-release hate mode better prepare to be disappointed.” – Scott Weinberg, Nerdist

…EVEN FOR THE DOUBTERS

“I am completely shocked but I really enjoyed Ready Player One. The pop culture references are often overwhelming but if you focus on the story and filmmaking, it’s a completely solid adventure film. I pity the blogger who tries to do a ‘Complete Easter Egg’ list.” – Robert Saucedo, Birth.Movies.Death.

Ready Player One is really fun. (?) I think it’s fun. Is it OK to say it’s fun? It’s fun.” – Sean Fennessey, The Ringer

“Went into Ready Player One skeptical as hell. Came out largely as a joyous convert. I have a handful of issues with the structure and characters, but it improves on the book in important ways, the action is riveting, and I really bought the humor.” – Tasha Robinson, The Verge

IT’S CLASSIC STEVEN SPIELBERG

“So, yeah, Ready Player One is the most fun I’ve had watching a Steven Spielberg film since Catch Me If You Can.” – Jordan Ruimy, The Film Stage

“Classic Steven Spielberg. It’s got the references, the ferocious effects and the great ‘80s soundtrack, sure, but also the charm, the heart, the humor and a fantastic Alan Silvestri score. I loved it…We haven’t seen this Spielberg in a long time — it’s just pure entertainment, and it’s hard not to watch it with a dorky smile on your face the whole time. – Erik Davis, Fandango

“Mark Rylance can shine in literally anything. That I will say.” – Joanna Robinson, Vanity Fair

IT’S TECHNICALLY AMAZING

“TOTALLY engrossed in every second of Ready Player One. It is one of the most technically brilliant things I have EVER seen. Spielberg is one of the few directors who could orchestrate this kind of visual symphony that SO many people will enjoy. Pretty amazing.” – Grae Drake, Rotten Tomatoes

Ready Player One feels like Spielberg watched a ton of Luc Besson movies and decided to outdo them. In terms of pure spectacle, it’s the most astonishing thing he’s done. Never underestimate Steve.” – Eric Kohn, IndieWire

YES, THERE ARE MORE POP-CULTURE REFERENCES THAN YOU CAN THROW A RUBIK’S CUBE AT

“So so so much movie. Sometimes too much but what I kept thinking over and over again was ‘my kids are gonna LOVE THIS.’ It is joyous and thrilling for the people who it’s designed to joy and thrill.” – Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com

“The pop culture references are a LOT of fun, geeky glee to see everything together on the big screen. I just wanted more of the real world and more character backstory. I definitely recommend reading the book first!” – Alicia Malone, Fandango

BUT NOT EVERYONE’S HOPPING ABOARD THE DELOREAN

“I’m not sure this film will appeal to non-gamers. Also, it does a poor job of world building. In addition, the bad narration (a narrative crutch) in intro doesn’t work. Might’ve been in better hands with an indie director who focused on human story and class disparity, which is better explored in the book. But there are a ton of references. Overall feels dated.” – Chris Gore, Film Threat

“A cacophonous eye-sore…This is no love letter to pop culture. It’s a crass play to nostalgia; it offers nothing new or exciting…I’m genuinely angry that Spielberg is so careless with his own legacy, slapping in references to Jurassic Park with all the care of a monkey slinging feces.“ – Kristy Puchko, Pajiba

Ready Player One was…meh. Some great moments but nothing special.” – Jonathan Barkan, Dread Central


Check out the trailer for Ready Player One below and check in with Rotten Tomatoes as reviews officially start rolling in. The film opens everywhere on March 29.

Tag Cloud

cooking Freeform Music A&E period drama Lionsgate Reality Competition hist Spring TV Pop Infographic vampires Interview romance BET Horror Rocky DirecTV cats TCM Country TBS dc transformers thriller Best and Worst Acorn TV Thanksgiving TLC Summer serial killer 21st Century Fox Nominations Oscars Sundance Podcast First Look composers Superheroe Musical 24 frames Comedy FX dceu Rock spy thriller crime science fiction Toys politics FXX Pixar Marathons medical drama USA Network jamie lee curtis DC Comics DC Universe ABC NYCC Star Wars Walt Disney Pictures Amazon San Diego Comic-Con GLAAD AMC Columbia Pictures CBS docudrama Netflix Awards crossover Ovation APB Sony Pictures Action Hulu Universal Drama TCA doctor who Logo CBS All Access Food Network Lucasfilm Winter TV Adult Swim Bravo Mindy Kaling Christmas Election war Watching Series Mary Tyler Moore Disney Showtime cops CNN political drama Creative Arts Emmys Syfy social media psycho USA Musicals MSNBC Certified Fresh Opinion Epix Dark Horse Comics Fantasy MTV Sneak Peek streaming ESPN based on movie Trailer SXSW IFC Fall TV Valentine's Day boxoffice TruTV Starz YA ratings Sci-Fi Superheroes Teen TV Land Apple National Geographic 2015 zombies Set visit Red Carpet Sundance Now Mystery Crackle mutant Biopics Box Office unscripted Emmys Masterpiece Calendar Animation Grammys Martial Arts The Arrangement Kids & Family Video Games PaleyFest OWN Marvel BBC Lifetime binge Tumblr Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt SDCC SundanceTV dramedy Premiere Dates NBC technology Disney Channel YouTube Red DC streaming service 2017 singing competition TIFF sports comiccon The CW RT History TCA 2017 E3 Cartoon Network X-Men Comedy Central Nickelodeon TV biography Extras what to watch blaxploitation Shudder festivals President HBO Comic Book robots Britbox ABC Family Holidays Song of Ice and Fire Star Trek FOX History Character Guide 007 justice league Esquire 20th Century Fox police drama VH1 El Rey crime thriller Year in Review anime Rom-Com PBS 2016 travel Shondaland TNT BBC America Spike CW Seed adventure finale Schedule cinemax talk show discovery 45 Polls and Games Ghostbusters harry potter sitcom Ellie Kemper Paramount Trivia E! WGN Winners aliens historical drama cults Cosplay Super Bowl CMT supernatural American Society of Cinematographers Warner Bros. Writers Guild of America Reality Tomatazos IFC Films YouTube Premium zombie Paramount Network golden globes diversity GoT LGBTQ Pirates Nat Geo GIFs Countdown ITV Fox News crime drama Western See It Skip It VICE Photos