Comics On TV

Everything We Know About HBO's Watchmen TV Series

Much-anticipated graphic novel adaptation stars Regina King, Jeremy Irons, Tom Mison, Tim Blake Nelson, Louis Gossett Jr., Jean Smart, Don Johnson, and more.

by | September 11, 2019 | Comments

One of the more surprising series joining the comic book TV show universe is HBO’s Watchmen, an ambitious project that seems like the concept’s best destiny. The 2009 feature film version, which was directed by Zack Snyder and received only a 64% Tomatometer score, was the end result of a protracted development process that saw filmmakers like Terry Gilliam suggest the material was better suited to a high-end television miniseries. But what fans of the comic book will get when it debuts Oct. 20 is something much stranger and more daring than a simple adaptation. Take a look at what we what know about the program so far.


The Source Material

WATCHMEN, Rorschach, as drawn by co-creator Dave Gibbons, 2009. ©Warner Bros./courtesy Everett Collection

(Photo by ©Warner Bros./courtesy Everett Collection)

Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons’ landmark 12-issue series debuted in 1985 to immediate acclaim. Based on the Charlton Comics characters DC Comics acquired in 1983, Moore and Gibbons envisioned a world in which costumed heroes surfaced in the 1930s and changed the course of history. True historical events like the Vietnam War and the Nixon presidency were drastically altered by costume vigilantes and the one genuine super-powered being in their midst.

The story itself is set after the various mystery men have all retired, died, or found themselves on the wrong side of the law. Some, like Adrian Veidt parlayed their notoriety into corporate success. Others, like the masked Rorschach, still try to hold back the tide of anarchy in a world completely and utterly tired of their shenanigans. Meanwhile, the one genuine superhero, Dr. Manhattan, finds himself less and less concerned with humanity’s petty squabbles as his consciousness continues to expand into cosmic realms.

And as the tale begins, one of their number – the Comedian – is found dead. Rorschach sets out to learn the truth behind the murder and uncovers a vast and seemingly sinister plot.

The events detailed in the book are, according to executive producer Damon Lindelof, 100 percent canon and the official past of the television series.

“We’re not going to mess with it,” he told reporters at the Television Critics Association summer press tour. “One of the rules that we had as storytellers, writers, and even once we got into the production of the show was that everything that happened in those 12 issues could not be messed with. We were married to it and so there’s no rebooting happening.”


The Premise

Watchmen season 1 teaser trailer 1 screenshot (HBO)

(Photo by HBO)

The canonicity of the original Watchmen comic book series matters because the television series takes place decades after those events. As Lindelof revealed in a letter to fans last year, the series will be something of a sequel (though he avoided using that word) set in contemporary times. Rorschach uncovered the truth behind the Comedian’s death, Adrian Veidt executed his plan, and Dr. Manhattan disappeared 34 years ago.

View this post on Instagram

Day 140.

A post shared by Damon (@damonlindelof) on

But as Lindelof told reporters in August, “It is definitely not supposed to be a world that you recognize. We’re using alternate history, science fiction, [and] popular fiction to Trojan Horse themes that are prevalent in the real world in a fictional one.”

The essence of Watchmen, both the comic book and the television series, at least in his view, is to use the superhero tropes to examine “institutions and culture and politics and the things that inform our society, and that’s the rich mix that makes the show the show.”

So what is it actually about? To start with, it’s about white supremacy. A group known as the Seventh Calvary adopts the Rorschach mask and begins targeting police officers in Tulsa, Oklahoma. To protect themselves, the police are forced to take on masks of their own. To the producer, the issues of race and policing felt like “the equivalent of the nuclear standoff between the Russians and the United States” in 2019.


Regina King portrait Watchmen season 1 (HBO)

(Photo by HBO)

Click for full image (new tab)

Of course, with protagonist Angela Abar (Regina King) – a wife, mother of three, and lead detective in Tulsa Police Force – taking part in masked law enforcement, the issue of institutionalized white supremacy may not seem as clear-cut as it otherwise might be, but Lindelof said “those contradictions … were things that we were very aware of in the storytelling, and tried to square to the best of our ability, but there are no easy answers.”

As in the Watchmen comic, complex social issues cannot be solved with a faked alien invasion.

“There’s no defeating white supremacy,” Lindelof added. “It’s not going anywhere, but it felt like it was pretty formidable foe.”

The series will also examine what it means to wear a mask. As executive producer and episode director Nicole Kassell put it in a recent featurette, Watchmen “explores the complexity of who you are when you wear a mask, who you are when you’re not wearing a mask.” With characters directly stating opinions like “masks save lives” and “masks make men cruel,” it is tempting to see the costume accessory as a metaphor for the gun control debate. But looking back at the Watchmen comic, we’re tempted to say the mask — and the anonymity it offers — is more a metaphor for the use of force itself regardless of the tools involved.

But as Irons says in the featurette, “Like all good stories, the truth unwraps itself slowly,” so our understanding of the program may be very different by the end of its first season.”

Other details we know include the lack of an internet in Watchmen’s 2019 and the president who shut down the entire concept: Robert Redford. As Lindelof explained, the Nixon of Watchmen remained in office until his death. Vice President Gerald Ford replaced him, but lost to Redford in 1992. The former actor remains in power in 2019. While the notion contains a satirical jab – just as Nixon’s life-long presidency did in the comic book – Lindelof said he plans to use the Redford presidency to explore another powerful idea: a well-intentioned liberal who stayed in power too long.


The Cast

Besides King, the cast includes Don JohnsonTim Blake Nelson, Louis Gossett Jr., Adelaide ClemensAndrew Howard, Jeremy Irons, Tom Mison, Frances FisherJacob Ming-Trent, and Yahya Abdul-Mahteen II.

Other cast members include Jean Smart, Sara Vickers, Hong Chau, Dustin Ingram, and James Wolk, as well as child actors Dylan Schombing, Lily Rose Smith, and Adelynn Spoon.

In November 2018, word broke that Iron would be playing Adrian Veidt, confirming Lindelof’s intent to include at least one familiar character from the comic book. In the teaser, he can be seen mediating on a desk, recalling the Veidt of the comic book. In that story, he was the ultimate perpetrator of the conspiracy the Comedian and Rorschach uncovered. But in defiance of all comic book bad guys, his monstrous plan would ultimately better the world. Well, at least for a time. Rorschach sent his journal detailing Veidt’s crime to an extreme right-wing publication – no doubt the reason he becomes a hero among the Seventh Cavalry – its publication seemingly prevented Veidt’s utopia from surviving the Nixon Administration.

Meanwhile, Clemens will play Pirate Jenny, a clear reference to the Tales of the Black Freighter comic strip inside Watchmen, which is itself a reference back to the song “Pirate Jenny” from The Threepenny Opera. Smart is playing FBI Agent Angela Blake, who in a former life was the hero known as Silk Spectre. Also, as evidenced from the Comic-Con trailer, Dr. Manhattan will be returning to Earth, though it is still unclear who is playing him.


Watchmen season 1 teaser trailer 1 screenshot (HBO)

(Photo by HBO)

Also, the earlier teaser suggested a new mirror-masked Rorschach will be on the scene. This appears to be Nelson’s character Looking Glass, whose name underscores the anonymity he tries to utilize. In fact, that theme of obscured identity is strong across the television series as the police, militia members, and potential vigilantes alike use masks to hide themselves from opponents and the public at large. Clearly, privacy is on Lindelof’s mind. And in a 2019 where both Apple and Facebook trade on their ability to keep user information safe (but don’t always succeed), it serves as a good underlying panic in the same way the original comic book traded on the fear of nuclear annihilation.


The Reznor/Ross Sound

Watchmen season 1 teaser trailer 1 screenshot (HBO)

(Photo by HBO)

Proving the series will be very different from other superhero shows, the musical score will be provided by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross of The Social Network and Gone Girl. Unlike the often rousing themes of superhero films or even the pulse-pounding tracks of The Flash or Arrow during its action scenes, Reznor and Ross are known for quieter, deliberate work. Fitting for a show that will no doubt eschew the usual superhero fights for something more graphic, harrowing, and pointed. Of course, they are capable of the bigger sweep as well, but one look at the teaser indicates bombastic music will be used in a more ironic way than, say, Avengers: Endgame.


The Original Writer Is Not Involved

LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM - SEPTEMBER 6: Portrait of English comic book writer Alan Moore, taken on September 6, 2013. Moore is often considered the finest writer in the comics medium, and is best known for his graphic novels Watchmen and V For Vendetta. (Photo by Kevin Nixon/SFX Magazine via Getty Images)

Unlike many comic book adaptations these days, Watchmen will not feature input or even the approval of writer Moore. The notoriously cantankerous author had a bad run with Hollywood thanks to projects like V for Vendetta and League of Extraordinary Gentleman, leading to him refusing credit on subsequent films and even the money owed to him from those adaptations and sending the profit participation off to artists like Watchmen’s Dave Gibbons.

Lindelof told TCA reporters that he tried to reach out to Moore, but was met with the ire the author reserves for all Hollywood types trying to adapt his work. But as the original comic book itself appropriated older ideas from the Charlton Comics, Lindelof felt he was right to follow in Moore’s footsteps and appropriate Watchmen for himself.

“I do feel like the spirit of Alan Moore is a punk rock spirit, a rebellious spirit, and that if you told Alan Moore in 1984 or ’85 or ’86, ‘You’re not allowed to do this because Superman’s creator or Swamp Thing’s creator doesn’t want you to do it,’ he would say, ‘F— you, I’m doing it anyway,’” he explained. “I’m channeling the spirit of Alan Moore to tell Alan Moore, ‘F– you, I’m doing it anyway.’”


Release Date

Don Johnson in Watchmen season 1 teaser trailer 1 screenshot (HBO)

(Photo by HBO)

The nine-episode series will debut at 9 p.m. on Sunday, October 20. Considering the sort of passion Watchmen inspires from its fans – look at any discussion thread about Snyder’s film version or DC’s decision to make Watchmen prequel comics in 2010 – it is likely the series will become one of the most talked about comic book–based projects of 2019.

Watchmen will premiere Oct. 20, 2019 on HBO.

Updated Sept. 3 with release date.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

FX on Hulu DC Universe supernatural A&E crossover Crunchyroll zero dark thirty IFC sequels Ellie Kemper Lifetime composers Awards Tour Hallmark Valentine's Day hispanic YouTube vampires PBS sequel Writers Guild of America 007 Trivia GLAAD Mary Tyler Moore Family Polls and Games National Geographic Christmas See It Skip It Trophy Talk Tumblr HBO Go Film werewolf Starz Musicals Fantasy romance golden globe awards facebook IFC Films CBS spain Opinion Pixar festivals OneApp San Diego Comic-Con harry potter sports video on demand scorecard cancelled television toronto critics indie revenge reboot Horror Hear Us Out laika TIFF Peacock scary movies Rocky name the review movies Sneak Peek based on movie diversity Hallmark Christmas movies video Calendar women theme song Warner Bros. aliens Sundance Now Tarantino HBO true crime 2018 Britbox Song of Ice and Fire all-time Freeform Year in Review what to watch venice ABC The CW nature Reality Pop Disney+ Disney Plus TV renewals BET Biopics 72 Emmy Awards TV Land Cartoon Network Emmy Nominations Chernobyl spinoff Crackle E! Podcast Amazon Prime Video biography social media cars Photos FX Action canceled TV shows Schedule ViacomCBS Paramount best American Society of Cinematographers Sony Pictures AMC First Reviews HBO Max elevated horror Discovery Channel Heroines Reality Competition Shondaland Pet Sematary halloween cats zombies PaleyFest Cannes Television Academy james bond Walt Disney Pictures Election 2016 war chucky Mindy Kaling stop motion dark psycho Disney Channel Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cartoon doctor who TCA 2017 Toys classics game show MTV transformers The Academy mutant Star Trek Disney streaming service cancelled TV series child's play TruTV Sundance finale Hulu Mary poppins Animation 2017 TCA Awards blaxploitation Universal serial killer black anthology rom-coms spider-man BAFTA Winter TV movie pirates of the caribbean animated 45 Masterpiece Rock CNN Disney Plus Box Office dogs Interview kids fast and furious DC Comics VH1 dramedy ABC Family Lucasfilm travel Best and Worst die hard spy thriller Baby Yoda dragons documentary Brie Larson rt archives cancelled Travel Channel TNT SDCC 4/20 medical drama Netflix Christmas movies BBC superhero Infographic boxoffice 2019 History SXSW Arrowverse MCU FXX Amazon Studios comic books Comic Book television Nominations miniseries YA A24 talk show President Summer Superheroe Western universal monsters DirecTV discovery Watching Series Star Wars strong female leads USA Network mockumentary TCM Turner cinemax quibi batman The Arrangement worst movies OWN archives Apple TV+ comedies TLC Sci-Fi Funimation Columbia Pictures Amazon Esquire Spring TV DGA golden globes GoT Nickelodeon anime Film Festival sitcom BET Awards worst spanish language 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards First Look Super Bowl Showtime Marvel Television Adult Swim latino dc series Spike BBC One Stephen King CBS All Access fresh Spectrum Originals Holiday mission: impossible italian Captain marvel BBC America NYCC The Walt Disney Company The Witch remakes Comedy trailers DC streaming service Paramount Plus VOD satire Awards natural history slashers justice league Apple TV Plus criterion crime thriller Marvel Lionsgate Logo documentaries renewed TV shows MSNBC technology Nat Geo docudrama parents crime drama free movies christmas movies foreign halloween tv Tomatazos a nightmare on elm street WGN Country ESPN franchise singing competition asian-american Alien Academy Awards Video Games Creative Arts Emmys Netflix Binge Guide screen actors guild ID versus Thanksgiving 24 frames Premiere Dates WarnerMedia ghosts adaptation Martial Arts Rom-Com CMT Pirates Black History Month 71st Emmy Awards GIFs blockbuster LGBT Pride Month festival rotten Teen french zombie Trailer 2015 cooking canceled indiana jones robots green book ratings comiccon Certified Fresh Bravo Mudbound Apple Ovation crime cops Quiz cults Amazon Prime emmy awards Mary Poppins Returns Holidays dceu stoner reviews Musical boxing YouTube Red Classic Film Character Guide Anna Paquin binge south america Food Network 99% toy story Epix E3 2020 Elton John Countdown TBS unscripted rotten movies we love award winner obituary The Walking Dead Marvel Studios space Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt teaser Superheroes politics VICE news tv talk jurassic park ABC Signature political drama Comedy Central comic jamie lee curtis witnail Comics on TV australia TCA Tubi Red Carpet directors breaking bad Rocketman Kids & Family nbcuniversal concert football Set visit children's TV RT21 APB cancelled TV shows independent Extras films TCA Winter 2020 streaming deadpool Marathons Vudu CW Seed Fox Searchlight Drama disaster period drama Disney psychological thriller Grammys New York Comic Con hollywood game of thrones richard e. Grant NBC El Rey Paramount Network Shudder TV SundanceTV X-Men Music Mystery Lifetime Christmas movies thriller science fiction Women's History Month Emmys PlayStation historical drama Dark Horse Comics Avengers Ghostbusters The Purge Sundance TV spanish adventure Fox News Cosplay book japanese nfl ITV 20th Century Fox stand-up comedy joker LGBTQ Oscars romantic comedy hist screenings Acorn TV Fall TV comics Pop TV FOX Syfy USA sag awards 21st Century Fox police drama Endgame TV One Television Critics Association twilight Winners RT History casting Turner Classic Movies Black Mirror YouTube Premium