Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Tropic Thunder Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Vicky Christina Barcelona scores but The Clone Wars misses. And guess Mirrors' Tomatometer!

by | August 14, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a war movie satire (Tropic Thunder, starring Ben Stiller, Jack Black, and Robert Downey Jr.), romantic foibles in Spain (Woody Allen‘s Vicky Cristina Barcelona, starring Scarlett Johansson and Penelope Cruz), animated Force-utilizers (George LucasThe Clone Wars), and killer reflections (Mirrors, starring Kiefer Sutherland). What do the critics have to say?

How better to lambaste the over-blown, summer blockbuster than with an over-blown, summer blockbuster? That’s the battle plan with Ben Stiller’s Tropic Thunder. While shooting a war drama in Vietnam, the pampered “all-star” cast (Stiller, Jack Black, Jay Baruchel, Brandon T. Jackson and Robert Downey Jr.) are taken off set and dropped into a camera-rigged jungle where they’re expected to pull off a guerrilla-style re-shoot and resurrect their Oscar-bait production turned over-budget disaster. While no one’s invoking the Academy (yet), critics are calling Stiller’s helming just the thing to promote his directorial resume (Reality Bites, The Cable Guy) from private to corporal. With references to major war films (Apocalypse Now, Platoon) as well as their making-of docs (Hearts of Darkness) and a few odd references thrown in (There’s There’s Something about Mary, Close Encounters of the Third Kind), critics are saying this foul-mouthed, politically incorrect farce proves war can be Hell-arious. It currently stands at 83 percent on the Tomatometer.


Macho Libre!


Rumors of Woody Allen’s creative demise may be dispelled by his new tragicomic travelogue Vicky Cristina Barcelona. Critics aren’t just referring to the film’s Spanish exteriors when they call it “warm,” “sun-drenched,” and “seductive.” Vicky Cristina follows two American girls (Scarlett Johansson and Rebecca Hall) who Venture to Spain for a summer only to become entangled with a passionate artist (Javier Bardem) and his borderline insane ex-wife (Penelope Cruz). Critics are saying the dazzling performances have elevated this bedroom comedy-cum-treatise on art, and put it in the lexicon of some of Allen’s saucier sagas of doomed romance. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, Vicky Cristina tops even 2005’s Match Point, and is getting the kind of love Allen’s work hasn’t seen since Bullets over Broadway (96 percent).



“Anyone up for a Bergman retrospective?”


The Clone Wars hits screens this week with what sounds like a leaden thud. The critics are using words that haven’t been uttered about the franchise since the ill-fated Holiday Special, implying there’s little pop-culture future for this Clone. A precursor to the CG series airing on Cartoon Network this fall, Clone Wars doesn’t go too far into the titular war, instead focusing on an ancillary mission to recover Jabba the Hutt’s kidnapped infant. Critics are citing the mechanical animation and lackluster plot as culprit for pushing the franchise towards decline. At 24 percent, this one might have been better suited for the small screen. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down the Tomatometers for every entry in the Star Wars franchise.)




“Bad reviews getting is this.”

We get the impression Mirrors is all about images that can kill, though that’s sort of conjecture. The studio isn’t screening it for press, which makes it sound like the only thing these images can kill are box office numbers. Keifer Sutherland plays an ex-cop whose house is haunted by ghosts with a fondness for reflective surfaces. The film, directed by Alexandre Aja, the Frenchman who brought us High Tension and the Hills Have Eyes remake, begs us to ask, “Mirror, mirror on the wall, what will be the Tomatometer after all?” Venture a guess, kids!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

See It Skip It canceled BBC America Nat Geo hidden camera Polls and Games zombies Spring TV 2016 Marvel Studios 45 batman Apple psychological thriller Best and Worst stoner Trivia Alien Broadway stand-up comedy nbcuniversal Superheroe Paramount Plus boxoffice 24 frames venice Vudu cinemax ITV Legendary quibi Disney Channel Esquire Discovery Channel Set visit Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Ellie Kemper romantic comedy RT21 Photos Fox Searchlight emmy awards hispanic ratings Emmy Nominations video on demand Rom-Com miniseries The Walking Dead Quiz AMC Podcast Shondaland golden globes Fantasy strong female leads VOD game of thrones spanish language zero dark thirty latino crossover Sundance Now 21st Century Fox Freeform Biopics The Academy foreign australia cancelled television television reviews superhero Apple TV Plus Netflix CNN YouTube Premium slashers Warner Bros. RT History Epix Comic Book space SXSW reboot Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Emmys screen actors guild TCA Winter 2020 crime drama GIFs Funimation monster movies cancelled TV series finale adaptation Country Holiday Walt Disney Pictures DC Comics festival BET razzies dragons Comics on TV Christmas based on movie comic books Hulu Election Lifetime Christmas movies Pop TV Britbox Awards Tour unscripted VH1 First Reviews south america indiana jones science fiction best king kong MTV disaster animated Endgame Travel Channel facebook versus The CW scary movies doctor who japanese The Purge Sneak Peek ABC Family asian-american Ghostbusters spy thriller Lifetime richard e. Grant rotten The Arrangement news Drama Rock Comedy Ovation directors Disney streaming service binge CBS All Access YouTube green book Starz remakes Lucasfilm BBC Creative Arts Emmys Music TV Land Super Bowl New York Comic Con TCM Reality Competition trailers period drama biography Character Guide National Geographic harry potter supernatural PBS Video Games TV One streaming pirates of the caribbean Cannes 20th Century Fox Musical rotten movies we love Pirates 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Musicals documentary indie golden globe awards sequels 2020 Acorn TV 007 99% E3 talk show TV renewals social media casting spanish Bravo medical drama prank archives singing competition Spectrum Originals independent stop motion Shudder twilight Food Network Red Carpet DGA Martial Arts christmas movies Amazon Prime IFC Films french free movies mission: impossible Stephen King witnail Logo breaking bad Rocketman sports Turner YouTube Red Countdown robots tv talk Oscars 71st Emmy Awards Extras superman TruTV cops TCA 2017 E! revenge docudrama The Walt Disney Company criterion Hallmark Christmas movies Heroines DirecTV SundanceTV james bond video Tubi Lionsgate Winter TV Tarantino TCA Mary Tyler Moore Trailer FX WarnerMedia San Diego Comic-Con OneApp 2019 name the review Thanksgiving CMT A24 Writers Guild of America worst Tumblr Summer Disney Plus Black History Month women boxing comics anime Sundance dc scorecard award winner Pet Sematary Sci-Fi chucky Black Mirror Nickelodeon book Television Critics Association Dark Horse Comics Pride Month Binge Guide Interview FXX vampires LGBT Box Office El Rey popular SDCC classics Avengers Rocky BET Awards VICE Adult Swim nfl A&E Horror Crunchyroll CBS fast and furious satire NBC FX on Hulu Tomatazos comiccon History sitcom Cartoon Network Western historical drama deadpool crime thriller 4/20 telelvision adventure halloween tv screenings Women's History Month Academy Awards psycho TIFF cancelled TV shows Marathons Infographic Comedy Central USA Network OWN movie series football ABC Signature CW Seed hollywood Turner Classic Movies Winners Showtime rom-coms Exclusive Video elevated horror sag awards Schedule critics dceu game show Paramount Network hist Fall TV Song of Ice and Fire child's play worst movies Syfy Mystery Fox News politics Hallmark Sundance TV joker thriller Apple TV+ Mudbound die hard Sony Pictures Pixar Masterpiece Crackle TV blockbuster Premiere Dates PaleyFest cartoon discovery franchise Watching Series what to watch transformers ghosts cults dramedy black DC streaming service a nightmare on elm street true crime werewolf fresh Spike crime teaser TLC serial killer dogs jurassic park toy story Kids & Family Star Trek canceled TV shows Mary poppins zombie theme song ABC Peacock Elton John Mary Poppins Returns dark Film Festival comedies docuseries children's TV TBS sequel Marvel MSNBC Year in Review nature Valentine's Day IFC Disney+ Disney Plus aliens spider-man BBC One blaxploitation political drama kids Superheroes Netflix Christmas movies 2017 Columbia Pictures Mindy Kaling mutant diversity USA Family concert festivals X-Men cooking 2015 kaiju Pop 72 Emmy Awards comic Classic Film Toys romance Amazon Studios ESPN cancelled YA renewed TV shows travel GoT Baby Yoda Film halloween FOX obituary WGN spinoff documentaries police drama Holidays composers President italian Brie Larson Nominations TCA Awards Chernobyl Animation APB DC Universe Captain marvel 2021 Television Academy Arrowverse PlayStation Anna Paquin Action MCU American Society of Cinematographers godzilla laika all-time rt archives HBO Max First Look technology NYCC HBO Go blockbusters Grammys Star Wars ID movies LGBTQ films mockumentary natural history toronto Reality Amazon Teen Universal BAFTA kong Calendar GLAAD Awards anthology Amazon Prime Video parents cars Trophy Talk Cosplay universal monsters 2018 The Witch cats Disney war spain Paramount justice league Certified Fresh HBO Opinion TNT jamie lee curtis ViacomCBS Marvel Television Hear Us Out