Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Tropic Thunder Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Vicky Christina Barcelona scores but The Clone Wars misses. And guess Mirrors' Tomatometer!

by | August 14, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a war movie satire (Tropic Thunder, starring Ben Stiller, Jack Black, and Robert Downey Jr.), romantic foibles in Spain (Woody Allen‘s Vicky Cristina Barcelona, starring Scarlett Johansson and Penelope Cruz), animated Force-utilizers (George LucasThe Clone Wars), and killer reflections (Mirrors, starring Kiefer Sutherland). What do the critics have to say?

How better to lambaste the over-blown, summer blockbuster than with an over-blown, summer blockbuster? That’s the battle plan with Ben Stiller’s Tropic Thunder. While shooting a war drama in Vietnam, the pampered “all-star” cast (Stiller, Jack Black, Jay Baruchel, Brandon T. Jackson and Robert Downey Jr.) are taken off set and dropped into a camera-rigged jungle where they’re expected to pull off a guerrilla-style re-shoot and resurrect their Oscar-bait production turned over-budget disaster. While no one’s invoking the Academy (yet), critics are calling Stiller’s helming just the thing to promote his directorial resume (Reality Bites, The Cable Guy) from private to corporal. With references to major war films (Apocalypse Now, Platoon) as well as their making-of docs (Hearts of Darkness) and a few odd references thrown in (There’s There’s Something about Mary, Close Encounters of the Third Kind), critics are saying this foul-mouthed, politically incorrect farce proves war can be Hell-arious. It currently stands at 83 percent on the Tomatometer.


Macho Libre!


Rumors of Woody Allen’s creative demise may be dispelled by his new tragicomic travelogue Vicky Cristina Barcelona. Critics aren’t just referring to the film’s Spanish exteriors when they call it “warm,” “sun-drenched,” and “seductive.” Vicky Cristina follows two American girls (Scarlett Johansson and Rebecca Hall) who Venture to Spain for a summer only to become entangled with a passionate artist (Javier Bardem) and his borderline insane ex-wife (Penelope Cruz). Critics are saying the dazzling performances have elevated this bedroom comedy-cum-treatise on art, and put it in the lexicon of some of Allen’s saucier sagas of doomed romance. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, Vicky Cristina tops even 2005’s Match Point, and is getting the kind of love Allen’s work hasn’t seen since Bullets over Broadway (96 percent).



“Anyone up for a Bergman retrospective?”


The Clone Wars hits screens this week with what sounds like a leaden thud. The critics are using words that haven’t been uttered about the franchise since the ill-fated Holiday Special, implying there’s little pop-culture future for this Clone. A precursor to the CG series airing on Cartoon Network this fall, Clone Wars doesn’t go too far into the titular war, instead focusing on an ancillary mission to recover Jabba the Hutt’s kidnapped infant. Critics are citing the mechanical animation and lackluster plot as culprit for pushing the franchise towards decline. At 24 percent, this one might have been better suited for the small screen. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down the Tomatometers for every entry in the Star Wars franchise.)




“Bad reviews getting is this.”

We get the impression Mirrors is all about images that can kill, though that’s sort of conjecture. The studio isn’t screening it for press, which makes it sound like the only thing these images can kill are box office numbers. Keifer Sutherland plays an ex-cop whose house is haunted by ghosts with a fondness for reflective surfaces. The film, directed by Alexandre Aja, the Frenchman who brought us High Tension and the Hills Have Eyes remake, begs us to ask, “Mirror, mirror on the wall, what will be the Tomatometer after all?” Venture a guess, kids!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

007 toronto politics franchise dc universal monsters stop motion Mary Poppins Returns Rocketman animated GIFs DGA sopranos genre Reality Emmy Nominations FX aliens dceu Rom-Com Black Mirror Summer Toys thriller facebook cancelled TV series sitcom indiana jones Drama 2020 saw Hollywood Foreign Press Association blockbuster DirecTV what to watch 2021 National Geographic elevated horror Reality Competition FX on Hulu Discovery Channel scene in color TCA 2017 Paramount Plus Syfy WarnerMedia Stephen King telelvision composers BET Awards Action AMC Plus reviews dark travel HBO Christmas Mary Tyler Moore hollywood ghosts Women's History Month venice black Fox News BET TruTV ViacomCBS cancelled television psycho south america cinemax crime drama chucky 93rd Oscars police drama Disney PaleyFest Pirates Neflix Watching Series WGN Emmys mission: impossible Broadway DC Universe Logo blaxploitation boxing scary movies Schedule singing competition Freeform NBA criterion debate The Walking Dead Podcast new zealand Vudu asian-american television CW Seed royal family finale parents rt labs critics edition political drama green book TIFF Winners APB monster movies Exclusive Video Hallmark Christmas movies Election Spectrum Originals Television Academy Best and Worst independent TCA Awards jurassic park Marvel toy story mob Ghostbusters Teen joker child's play concert films marvel cinematic universe aapi australia Rock Awards Sundance TV HFPA Oscars spinoff Anna Paquin San Diego Comic-Con halloween kaiju spider-man Marvel Television video Sundance Now NBC spanish language crossover MSNBC canceled TV shows zombie miniseries stand-up comedy romance mutant renewed TV shows streaming movies festival streaming 90s Captain marvel Walt Disney Pictures Nominations Opinion Western Paramount Network spanish breaking bad name the review live event feel good natural history Pacific Islander ITV Britbox Elton John comic Epix Cannes Amazon Prime Video award winner razzies revenge cooking versus movies leaderboard 2019 The CW Valentine's Day medical drama VH1 CBS book adaptation canceled Disney streaming service Heroines 21st Century Fox Nat Geo Shondaland emmy awards Thanksgiving Classic Film Comedy vampires A24 Holiday suspense Ellie Kemper Alien Certified Fresh mcc Music biopic spain trophy international See It Skip It Chilling Adventures of Sabrina lord of the rings 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Baby Yoda spy thriller rom-coms Family NYCC laika war live action heist movie art house based on movie TLC CNN Paramount Rocky new star wars movies sag awards Acorn TV The Witch black comedy science fiction GLAAD jamie lee curtis Esquire Universal 99% Premiere Dates Fargo 79th Golden Globes Awards richard e. Grant Pride Month 4/20 Extras Year in Review japan Spike USA worst game of thrones italian Film Festival cops werewolf teaser ESPN hispanic heritage month king arthur zero dark thirty hist Star Wars X-Men Instagram Live crime E! Creative Arts Emmys Biopics E3 Superheroe critics docuseries japanese zombies Martial Arts Tarantino hispanic comic book movies technology TCM Starz nature book Mindy Kaling TV renewals action-comedy wonder woman tv talk SDCC Nickelodeon blockbusters comiccon Sneak Peek Turner nfl trailers Writers Guild of America LGBT Marathons Tokyo Olympics Super Bowl Avengers Comedy Central deadpool golden globes strong female leads Food Network best romantic comedy New York Comic Con scorecard comic book movie target First Reviews FXX Animation biography diversity worst movies Mystery Pop TV dragons FOX History LGBTQ spider-verse Chernobyl psychological thriller Trophy Talk indie Fantasy Interview Video Games CMT Trivia Star Trek American Society of Cinematographers Warner Bros. vs. Dark Horse Comics TCA cults rt labs Apple gangster classics Mary poppins golden globe awards free movies Comic Book Superheroes cartoon a nightmare on elm street disaster slasher kong prank Infographic stoner Trailer 45 Bravo TV Land VOD Black History Month die hard The Arrangement Arrowverse TCA Winter 2020 El Rey king kong nbcuniversal ABC Shudder slashers Tumblr popular docudrama Film crime thriller Comics on TV 2016 Pixar Cosplay witnail screen actors guild A&E Country The Purge Hear Us Out Pet Sematary screenings olympics The Academy quibi archives YouTube Premium historical drama Character Guide President women Endgame comics RT History dexter supernatural sports IFC basketball Disney+ Disney Plus batman dogs 24 frames marvel comics legend posters Photos DC streaming service Red Carpet young adult Musicals binge Television Critics Association football BAFTA The Walt Disney Company sequel Masterpiece Lucasfilm DC Comics Turner Classic Movies cars Musical discovery HBO Max Song of Ice and Fire Calendar Sundance casting Box Office remakes high school Apple TV Plus SundanceTV Hallmark cats TV movies halloween tv YouTube Red ratings boxoffice obituary new york james bond news godzilla Funimation robots Winter TV IFC Films period drama sequels Showtime harry potter christmas movies RT21 MCU Amazon Studios 71st Emmy Awards latino IMDb TV french Amazon 2018 Tubi video on demand all-time ID GoT Prime Video justice league Columbia Pictures Adult Swim ABC Signature 2017 Academy Awards directors pirates of the caribbean rotten movies we love critic resources dreamworks Apple TV+ Hulu children's TV Peacock TNT kids satire adaptation Sony Pictures movie cancelled TV shows anime 2015 AMC Polls and Games cancelled Fall TV Netflix Christmas movies BBC USA Network doctor who Legendary rotten Crunchyroll Amazon Prime YouTube superman Travel Channel Lifetime Christmas movies transformers Wes Anderson Binge Guide comedies serial killer adenture Awards Tour Netflix reboot First Look SXSW Pop Lifetime social media Tags: Comedy Brie Larson Quiz Ovation space festivals Kids & Family 20th Century Fox BBC One ABC Family Horror Lionsgate YA fast and furious Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Tomatazos PlayStation Fox Searchlight rt archives game show unscripted fresh Comic-Con@Home 2021 CBS All Access adventure TBS Disney Plus Cartoon Network twilight scary Set visit series documentary Countdown Crackle 72 Emmy Awards PBS TV HBO Go Marvel Studios know your critic OWN 73rd Emmy Awards 1990s true crime VICE Mudbound talk show theme song Grammys comic books Disney Channel foreign Spring TV OneApp Sci-Fi TV One documentaries dramedy BBC America Holidays Universal Pictures MTV mockumentary superhero hidden camera Image Comics anthology