Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Moneyball is Certified Fresh

Plus, Dolphin Tale inspires, Killer Elite wanders, and Abduction sags.

by | September 23, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got baseball nerds (Moneyball, starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill), aquatic rehab (Dolphin Tale, starring Harry Connick Jr. and Morgan Freeman), an assassin-dodging teen (Abduction, starring Taylor Lautner and Lily Collins), and a tough-guy showdown (Killer Elite, starring Jason Statham and Clive Owen). What do the critics have to say?


Do you love The Natural, but wish the movie had found time to take a closer look at Roy Hobbs’s OPS and weighted on base average? Well then, Moneyball is the movie for you, and critics say it’s a moving, witty underdog tale that somehow manages to find drama in baseball stat geekdom. Oakland Athletics General Manager Billy Beane (Brad Pitt) is tasked with fielding a competitive team on a small-market budget. His solution is to ignore traditional scouting methods and focus almost exclusively on obscure statistics that measure players’ abilities in ways that have been overlooked by other teams. Will Beane’s feather-ruffling approach be accepted in the staid world of Major League Baseball — and more importantly, will it yield results on the field? The pundits say the Certified Fresh Moneyball is a smart dramedy with excellent performances and a razor-sharp script that is likely to appeal to folks who don’t know the first thing about our national pastime. (Check out our countdown of the best baseball movies here.)

Dolphin Tale


In these cynical times, we could use some good old fashioned inspirational family entertainment at the multiplex. And critics say the pleasant, uplifting Dolphin Tale fits the bill, thanks to solid acting and a script that manages to avoid schmaltz and still jerk tears. Based upon a true story, Dolphin Tale is the story of an injured seafaring mammal who damages her tail in a crab trap. A team of specialists and a lonely youngster band together to help our aquatic heroine — now sporting a prosthetic tail — to swim again. The pundits say Dolphin Tale deftly avoids the corniness that could have weighed it down, and the result is a heartwarming film that will please both kids and adults.


Given his high-profile gig in the Twilight franchise, it was inevitable that Taylor Lautner would get his own starring vehicle. Unfortunately, critics say he could have chosen a better one than Abduction, a predictable, mediocre thriller that never slows down long enough to make sense. Launter plays Nathan Harper, who learns that the family he’s living with is not his own. Soon, he’s on the run from an elite group of assassins, and he tries to piece together his mysterious past while staying one step ahead of his pursuers. The pundits say Abduction is Bourne-lite, with unintentionally funny dialogue and an absurdly complicated plot that strands a talented cast. (Check out Lautner’s Five Favorite Films here.)

Killer Elite


Killer Elite is a globe-trotting action flick with a top-notch cast and more on its mind than your typical thriller. Unfortunately, critics say those intriguing pieces don’t add up to a satisfying whole, and Killer Elite is ultimately a formulaic adrenaline-fest with a plot that wanders all over the place. Jason Statham plays Danny Bryce, a hired gun on the edge of retirement who’s lured back into action when his mentor Hunter (Robert De Niro) is taken hostage. Our hero must finish the job Hunter was contracted to do, but soon he’s run afoul with a rogue group of soldiers lead by Spike (Clive Owen), who’s now gunning for Danny. The pundits say Killer Elite has macho attitude to spare, but its execution is off, and the result is an overlong and confusing film that raises interesting moral questions without answering them. (Check this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Statham’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Weekend, a romantic drama about two men who meet and share their lives over the course of 48 hours, is at 100 percent.
  • Thunder Soul, a documentary about Houston’s astonishingly funky Kashmere High School Stage Band, is at 100 percent.
  • Pearl Jam Twenty, Cameron Crowe‘s documentary portrait of the grunge superstars, is at 71 percent.
  • Limelight, a doc about the rise and fall of New York nightclub impresario Peter Gatien, is at 71 percent.
  • The Whale, a doc about a killer whale who befriends some residents of Vancouver Island after being separated from his family, is at 67 percent.
  • Puncture, starring Chris Evans in a drama about a drug addicted lawyer who investigates a health care and pharmaceutical industry conspiracy, is at 57 percent.
  • Archie’s Final Project, dramedy about a high school filmmaker who announces he’s going to kill himself on camera, is at 40 percent.
  • Machine Gun Preacher, starring Gerard Butler in a drama about a former biker and born-again Christian who goes to Sudan to save as many children as he can, is at 29 percent.

Tag Cloud

dreamworks hidden camera news halloween tv sequels Disney streaming service GLAAD Academy Awards popular witnail dexter women 45 streaming crime drama cartoon Sci-Fi Legendary Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hispanic heritage month Writers Guild of America scary movies Binge Guide breaking bad Marvel YouTube Red Food Network Stephen King kids Nickelodeon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt fast and furious American Society of Cinematographers Creative Arts Emmys lord of the rings Reality transformers what to watch foreign adaptation dragons 2019 royal family discovery RT21 NBA Schedule scorecard NYCC comiccon diversity YouTube Premium 4/20 mcc TCM Infographic Endgame concert marvel comics Mindy Kaling Best and Worst Amazon Studios Epix universal monsters TIFF trophy Election Spectrum Originals venice art house First Look dark award winner quibi live action video composers olympics supernatural Chernobyl laika Spring TV PlayStation Biopics facebook FX on Hulu HBO Pixar Classic Film Television Academy Martial Arts biography Ghostbusters Peacock Universal BBC America Red Carpet a nightmare on elm street Mary Tyler Moore Pop TV Spike cancelled TV series San Diego Comic-Con cancelled fresh cinemax independent Superheroe new york anthology rom-coms Sundance worst movies CMT TNT Music ABC Family black comedy X-Men Acorn TV comic book movie Cosplay DC Comics OWN stand-up comedy dceu ABC werewolf Teen versus trailers Exclusive Video Hulu Ovation science fiction Amazon indie ID nbcuniversal Toys comics See It Skip It Mudbound Box Office AMC spider-verse directors Set visit Lifetime Christmas movies halloween superhero Disney+ Disney Plus hist football Pet Sematary VICE sports classics Awards Tour animated cults rt archives obituary OneApp Marvel Studios batman National Geographic unscripted war Reality Competition christmas movies Alien blockbusters cancelled television new zealand Neflix mutant Bravo VH1 Lifetime Character Guide First Reviews 99% History Esquire Elton John The Walking Dead Podcast IMDb TV docudrama Hallmark Christmas movies Disney Christmas child's play technology green book 2020 heist movie TruTV mission: impossible Tubi BBC Baby Yoda 2021 CW Seed spider-man slasher Horror The Witch australia prank parents archives HFPA Tomatazos high school Rocky Holidays basketball ratings cooking scary Shondaland nature Pacific Islander Super Bowl satire Dark Horse Comics Photos Discovery Channel series Trivia scene in color Polls and Games ViacomCBS Logo television Television Critics Association dc The Purge aapi E! docuseries boxing canceled FX Women's History Month IFC biopic spanish language Prime Video stop motion teaser Fantasy Comedy Central 2017 mob Adult Swim BET Awards Comic Book Apple Mary Poppins Returns japanese kaiju BAFTA slashers Fargo debate CBS All Access french Netflix Christmas movies Pride Month Amazon Prime Video free movies Fall TV target Heroines MCU aliens SundanceTV Comic-Con@Home 2021 action-comedy thriller Pirates Interview LGBT true crime Rocketman Nat Geo Emmys Rock historical drama 79th Golden Globes Awards vampires 73rd Emmy Awards Sneak Peek DC streaming service Amazon Prime 24 frames Walt Disney Pictures disaster kong Country Crackle sag awards black young adult 20th Century Fox name the review Broadway new star wars movies Avengers renewed TV shows book adaptation YA APB FOX Emmy Nominations HBO Max YouTube 2018 rt labs critics edition A24 singing competition remakes Family dramedy psychological thriller Musicals E3 WGN Hear Us Out TLC ABC Signature emmy awards robots Awards serial killer Paramount BET films franchise President hollywood psycho boxoffice suspense political drama Instagram Live screenings TV Land Image Comics ESPN A&E Drama PBS 21st Century Fox doctor who Comics on TV game of thrones children's TV CNN Cartoon Network posters twilight Film Festival DGA cats Kids & Family Film anime Syfy Action Summer sequel theme song comic books Musical wonder woman finale Anna Paquin toronto Netflix CBS all-time casting Apple TV+ Wes Anderson Extras Year in Review gangster Countdown TCA Awards Certified Fresh canceled TV shows feel good Lucasfilm TV movies El Rey travel italian reboot period drama blockbuster genre Holiday New York Comic Con romantic comedy Shudder spinoff spain Tarantino Cannes Song of Ice and Fire natural history 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Lionsgate rt labs BBC One SXSW zombies Sony Pictures Hollywood Foreign Press Association Calendar streaming movies Thanksgiving Disney Channel Britbox Disney Plus Ellie Kemper TV 2015 criterion comedies die hard DC Universe sopranos festival Star Wars sitcom elevated horror Crunchyroll legend 007 Marathons game show Marvel Television joker vs. crime adventure Warner Bros. Star Trek romance justice league worst jurassic park space 2016 Brie Larson golden globes NBC nfl police drama asian-american 72 Emmy Awards crossover Black History Month Video Games Tags: Comedy 90s godzilla PaleyFest razzies video on demand Winners Sundance Now james bond Pop MSNBC hispanic Paramount Plus Animation saw TCA 2017 comic Watching Series Fox Searchlight WarnerMedia FXX chucky know your critic SDCC 71st Emmy Awards HBO Go politics Rom-Com ITV screen actors guild spanish Superheroes Trophy Talk Oscars Comedy TCA stoner Travel Channel movie Freeform latino ghosts Western movies Sundance TV best Turner Classic Movies blaxploitation rotten movies we love pirates of the caribbean marvel cinematic universe DirecTV RT History comic book movies Tokyo Olympics Valentine's Day USA Opinion Starz miniseries talk show GoT zero dark thirty book Hallmark Mary poppins TBS mockumentary Nominations monster movies 1990s Funimation Fox News crime thriller GIFs cancelled TV shows VOD The CW king arthur social media richard e. Grant cars MTV based on movie strong female leads spy thriller IFC Films Turner The Walt Disney Company adenture Mystery leaderboard 93rd Oscars Trailer festivals Tumblr documentaries TCA Winter 2020 critics Paramount Network TV renewals USA Network toy story Captain marvel LGBTQ The Academy Premiere Dates international south america Black Mirror AMC Plus TV One Vudu Universal Pictures superman tv talk Masterpiece live event Showtime Winter TV cops king kong golden globe awards reviews rotten harry potter The Arrangement medical drama Grammys binge jamie lee curtis zombie japan Apple TV Plus documentary Columbia Pictures dogs telelvision revenge critic resources deadpool Arrowverse indiana jones Quiz