Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Moneyball is Certified Fresh

Plus, Dolphin Tale inspires, Killer Elite wanders, and Abduction sags.

by | September 23, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got baseball nerds (Moneyball, starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill), aquatic rehab (Dolphin Tale, starring Harry Connick Jr. and Morgan Freeman), an assassin-dodging teen (Abduction, starring Taylor Lautner and Lily Collins), and a tough-guy showdown (Killer Elite, starring Jason Statham and Clive Owen). What do the critics have to say?



Do you love The Natural, but wish the movie had found time to take a closer look at Roy Hobbs’s OPS and weighted on base average? Well then, Moneyball is the movie for you, and critics say it’s a moving, witty underdog tale that somehow manages to find drama in baseball stat geekdom. Oakland Athletics General Manager Billy Beane (Brad Pitt) is tasked with fielding a competitive team on a small-market budget. His solution is to ignore traditional scouting methods and focus almost exclusively on obscure statistics that measure players’ abilities in ways that have been overlooked by other teams. Will Beane’s feather-ruffling approach be accepted in the staid world of Major League Baseball — and more importantly, will it yield results on the field? The pundits say the Certified Fresh Moneyball is a smart dramedy with excellent performances and a razor-sharp script that is likely to appeal to folks who don’t know the first thing about our national pastime. (Check out our countdown of the best baseball movies here.)

Dolphin Tale


In these cynical times, we could use some good old fashioned inspirational family entertainment at the multiplex. And critics say the pleasant, uplifting Dolphin Tale fits the bill, thanks to solid acting and a script that manages to avoid schmaltz and still jerk tears. Based upon a true story, Dolphin Tale is the story of an injured seafaring mammal who damages her tail in a crab trap. A team of specialists and a lonely youngster band together to help our aquatic heroine — now sporting a prosthetic tail — to swim again. The pundits say Dolphin Tale deftly avoids the corniness that could have weighed it down, and the result is a heartwarming film that will please both kids and adults.



Given his high-profile gig in the Twilight franchise, it was inevitable that Taylor Lautner would get his own starring vehicle. Unfortunately, critics say he could have chosen a better one than Abduction, a predictable, mediocre thriller that never slows down long enough to make sense. Launter plays Nathan Harper, who learns that the family he’s living with is not his own. Soon, he’s on the run from an elite group of assassins, and he tries to piece together his mysterious past while staying one step ahead of his pursuers. The pundits say Abduction is Bourne-lite, with unintentionally funny dialogue and an absurdly complicated plot that strands a talented cast. (Check out Lautner’s Five Favorite Films here.)

Killer Elite


Killer Elite is a globe-trotting action flick with a top-notch cast and more on its mind than your typical thriller. Unfortunately, critics say those intriguing pieces don’t add up to a satisfying whole, and Killer Elite is ultimately a formulaic adrenaline-fest with a plot that wanders all over the place. Jason Statham plays Danny Bryce, a hired gun on the edge of retirement who’s lured back into action when his mentor Hunter (Robert De Niro) is taken hostage. Our hero must finish the job Hunter was contracted to do, but soon he’s run afoul with a rogue group of soldiers lead by Spike (Clive Owen), who’s now gunning for Danny. The pundits say Killer Elite has macho attitude to spare, but its execution is off, and the result is an overlong and confusing film that raises interesting moral questions without answering them. (Check this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Statham’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Weekend, a romantic drama about two men who meet and share their lives over the course of 48 hours, is at 100 percent.

  • Thunder Soul, a documentary about Houston’s astonishingly funky Kashmere High School Stage Band, is at 100 percent.

  • Pearl Jam Twenty, Cameron Crowe‘s documentary portrait of the grunge superstars, is at 71 percent.

  • Limelight, a doc about the rise and fall of New York nightclub impresario Peter Gatien, is at 71 percent.

  • The Whale, a doc about a killer whale who befriends some residents of Vancouver Island after being separated from his family, is at 67 percent.

  • Puncture, starring Chris Evans in a drama about a drug addicted lawyer who investigates a health care and pharmaceutical industry conspiracy, is at 57 percent.

  • Archie’s Final Project, dramedy about a high school filmmaker who announces he’s going to kill himself on camera, is at 40 percent.

  • Machine Gun Preacher, starring Gerard Butler in a drama about a former biker and born-again Christian who goes to Sudan to save as many children as he can, is at 29 percent.

Tag Cloud

cats Nat Geo streaming GIFs 45 sequel Video Games TCA Awards History streaming movies obituary National Geographic stand-up comedy adventure Apple TV+ trophy dceu Hulu spy thriller blaxploitation telelvision Trivia worst Sundance First Look trailers Marvel Television Neflix target james bond MGM universal monsters Action finale rotten international Oscar Best and Worst dark black Biopics screenings Netflix Christmas movies kaiju based on movie Amazon Prime Infographic Star Wars Holidays harry potter VOD Avengers MTV Black History Month APB Crackle action-comedy Writers Guild of America Peacock basketball rt archives Hallmark South by Southwest Film Festival Star Wars Celebration Film dc Exclusive Video kong sitcom Tomatazos Hollywood Foreign Press Association travel Creative Arts Emmys stop motion boxing new zealand concert 2021 Pacific Islander Sci-Fi 007 jurassic park blockbuster cooking halloween breaking bad Emmy Nominations Pride Month genre 2017 Best Picture TruTV comic books directors satire USA what to watch popular The Academy video E! Prime Video ABC rotten movies we love Country WGN 2019 foreign diversity Winter TV target scene in color summer TV preview HFPA The Arrangement golden globe awards vampires criterion japanese Britbox rom-coms game show The CW First Reviews black comedy theme song Fall TV Tags: Comedy 2016 X-Men sopranos 79th Golden Globes Awards Trophy Talk NBA hispanic canceled Arrowverse Cannes historical drama Sony Pictures PBS news italian Superheroe art house anthology Walt Disney Pictures Photos AMC Plus twilight BBC One book superman Rom-Com natural history best dreamworks movies WarnerMedia Certified Fresh streamig Disney Plus summer preview Esquire unscripted Discovery Channel dragons social media psycho YouTube Tarantino dexter Apple Reality aliens Super Bowl Mary Poppins Returns VH1 Fantasy ViacomCBS 93rd Oscars sag awards new york Oscars Cosplay fresh posters dogs cops award winner true crime ID 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards IFC medical drama politics Calendar australia free movies cinemax MCU MSNBC women Stephen King boxoffice Elton John indie archives pirates of the caribbean mission: impossible godzilla transformers Star Trek emmy awards New York Comic Con binge Amazon hollywood HBO Musicals Film Festival batman prank animated Warner Bros. child's play critics halloween tv scene in color film series Mindy Kaling Best Director Sundance Now casting Music Western Paramount Pictures war Grammys slasher TV Land Dark Horse Comics cartoon spinoff scene in color series Summer rt labs critics edition Heroines serial killer a nightmare on elm street President Musical BAFTA Syfy Hear Us Out BET Awards adenture TNT hist indiana jones toronto Disney zombies TBS TCA 2017 monster movies 71st Emmy Awards stoner video on demand classics Quiz jamie lee curtis dramedy composers adaptation Spectrum Originals heist movie 2018 Tokyo Olympics Paramount Plus thriller technology DC streaming service rt labs Pet Sematary fast and furious Lifetime Christmas movies OWN blockbusters high school Turner PaleyFest independent Pop TV marvel cinematic universe spanish football Nominations worst movies Food Network Black Mirror Amazon Prime Video scary FOX Anna Paquin 90s CW Seed spain nature hispanic heritage month versus cancelled TV shows Superheroes 20th Century Fox nfl feel good Cartoon Network police drama Kids & Family Martial Arts IMDb TV Funimation venice revenge ratings IFC Films marvel comics reboot Comic Book hidden camera zombie docudrama Television Academy Adult Swim Pixar Ghostbusters See It Skip It all-time American Society of Cinematographers Fox News mockumentary christmas movies ITV Universal Pictures romance Legendary Box Office richard e. Grant Comedy screen actors guild Classic Film Travel Channel 94th Oscars Winners romantic comedy 73rd Emmy Awards lord of the rings Marvel robots comics Baby Yoda DC Universe AMC elevated horror Marvel Studios mcc YA Countdown Mary poppins Columbia Pictures supernatural Sneak Peek CBS All Access game of thrones 21st Century Fox HBO Go legend suspense Comic-Con@Home 2021 Lucasfilm psychological thriller RT21 zero dark thirty LGBT chucky Freeform spider-verse Geeked Week south america SXSW Set visit 4/20 1990s teaser die hard Rocky asian-american Reality Competition comiccon slashers ABC Family critic resources Image Comics Showtime miniseries NYCC interviews leaderboard Polls and Games Marathons Family reviews Apple TV Plus The Walking Dead RT History quibi CNN The Walt Disney Company TCM Interview Spike Valentine's Day superhero comic book movie Song of Ice and Fire Chernobyl cancelled TV series doctor who Amazon Studios talk show Character Guide mob cancelled television Schedule Election justice league television strong female leads TIFF Sony YouTube Red Extras Brie Larson Pop spider-man biopic comedies Shondaland scorecard Women's History Month olympics Television Critics Association Comics on TV Podcast Mystery festivals Best Actress parents 24 frames Captain marvel comic Focus Features Paramount toy story Disney Channel Awards Opinion Academy Awards tv talk scene in color Acorn TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ghosts GLAAD Red Carpet Paramount Network 99% Fargo Awards Tour LGBTQ Native know your critic VICE aapi Tumblr PlayStation A24 debate biography YouTube Premium japan political drama Epix Fox Searchlight SundanceTV Tubi TV renewals movie DGA gangster Mudbound royal family discovery San Diego Comic-Con franchise sports TV movies wonder woman live event Pirates Emmys golden globes USA Network scary movies facebook Turner Classic Movies GoT Sundance TV young adult Holiday Starz king arthur TCA Masterpiece sequels crime thriller festival saw crime drama Ellie Kemper joker Mary Tyler Moore renewed TV shows obi wan Disney+ Disney Plus name the review E3 anime Lionsgate nbcuniversal FXX Binge Guide Vudu Horror Disney streaming service TLC live action canceled TV shows 2020 cancelled NBC laika DC Comics comic book movies razzies SXSW 2022 2015 DirecTV Thanksgiving Shudder Drama Best Actor Ovation FX on Hulu cars science fiction space TCA Winter 2020 72 Emmy Awards spanish language crossover CMT book adaptation Teen HBO Max mutant french OneApp Trailer green book Comedy Central Netflix SDCC disaster latino The Witch Watching Series Broadway The Purge films cults Spring TV docuseries TV Indigenous werewolf Christmas summer TV Universal ABC Signature Instagram Live Logo witnail documentaries king kong BET Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Premiere Dates Nickelodeon Lifetime series Crunchyroll Hallmark Christmas movies singing competition deadpool ESPN new star wars movies FX CBS Endgame El Rey remakes crime Bravo vs. A&E BBC Rock documentary BBC America kids TV One Toys Rocketman period drama Wes Anderson Animation Year in Review broadcast Alien children's TV