Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: American Sniper Hits the Target, Paddington Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Blackhat does not compute, and The Wedding Ringer is short on laughs.

by | January 15, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fallen soldier (American Sniper, starring Bradley Cooper and Sienna Miller), a marmalade-loving bear (Paddington, starring Hugh Bonneville and Sally Hawkins), an ex-con hacker (Blackhat, starring Chris Hemsworth and Viola Davis), and a best man for hire (The Wedding Ringer, starring Kevin Hart and Josh Gad). What do the critics have to say?

American Sniper


As a director, Clint Eastwood is one of cinema’s greatest chroniclers of troubled tough guys. Critics say American Sniper is a tense, kinetic drama that has much to say about the emotional toll of war — even if it fudges some of the facts about its real-life subject. Bradley Cooper stars as Chris Kyle, a Navy SEAL sniper who achieved near-legendary status for his fearlessness and shooting accuracy. But when he left the service, Kyle’s place in the world became less certain. The pundits say American Sniper avoids some of the more controversial aspects of Kyle’s life, but it’s still a bracing, tense, powerfully acted portrait of a supremely talented soldier at war with himself.



The bear from darkest Peru is one of the brightest lights of the young movie year. Critics say Paddington is the best kind of family film — it’s funny, thoughtful, deeply heartfelt, and filled with strong characters. After stowing away on a boat, the titular bear arrives in London and is discovered by the Brown family, who bring him into their home. Paddington is a stranger in a strange land, but he does his best to adjust to city life; unfortunately, he also draws the attention of a devious taxidermist. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Paddington maintains the cheer and whimsy of Michael Bond’s books, while teaching children a gentle lesson in tolerance. (Check out star Hugh Bonneville’s Five Favorite Films, as well as our interviews with the cast and crew.)



It’s tough to make computing look cool on the big screen. Critics say even a talented director like Michael Mann can only add so much to something like Blackhat, a cyberthriller that’s long on visual razzle-dazzle but short on tension and believability. Chris Hemsworth stars as Nick Hathaway, a brilliant hacker who’s serving prison time. However, when U.S. intelligence agents team up with the Chinese government to investigate a devastating act of cyberterrorism, they spring Hathaway from the joint to help solve the case. The pundits say Blackhat squanders its timely premise on a silly plotting and dialogue, though it does have a sense of visual panache.

The Wedding Ringer


Kevin Hart is one of the funniest men on the planet, but critics say his comic exuberance can’t save The Wedding Ringer, a thoroughly so-so bromance with a few good gags but a whole lot of dead spots. Hart stars as Jimmy, who provides an unusual service: he serves as the best man for socially awkward, soon-to-be-wedded guys. While giving Doug (Josh Gad) instructions on how to act cool, Jimmy stars to actually like the big galoot. The pundits say Hart tries his best, but the pace is slack and too many of the jokes are of the gross-out variety. (Check out our interviews with Kevin Hart, Josh Gad, and Kaley Cuoco.)

What’s Hot On TV:

Critics say Togetherness (Certified Fresh at 94 percent) is a delightful surprise that interweaves day-to-day life with moving, dramatic characters who have an affinity for deprecating, squirmy humor.

The critics say Man Seeking Woman (92 percent) is easy to fall for, taking a ridiculously funny approach to a common theme with amusingly surreality and enjoyable oddness.

The pundits say Girls (Certified Fresh at 86 percent) is familiar after four seasons, but its convoluted-yet-comical depiction of young women dealing with the real world still manages to impress.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

OneApp comedies 2020 Disney Channel Walt Disney Pictures Netflix Christmas movies 2016 Funimation award winner Countdown TNT vs. Election australia Brie Larson Disney streaming service DC streaming service Hollywood Foreign Press Association Mary Tyler Moore japanese a nightmare on elm street cartoon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina CBS All Access green book Action posters 4/20 Elton John action-comedy international VOD political drama canceled Fall TV jurassic park Apple TV Plus LGBTQ Podcast new zealand versus television golden globe awards Discovery Channel Esquire obituary mockumentary jamie lee curtis Baby Yoda TCA Winter 2020 toronto Superheroes Superheroe hist crossover screenings docuseries heist movie Photos comic book movies Amazon Prime Pop Year in Review high school cancelled TV series Western Red Carpet Comic Book Masterpiece movie Endgame miniseries ABC Family composers Tarantino batman Starz sopranos Infographic king arthur Writers Guild of America Holidays HFPA politics A&E The Walt Disney Company Box Office art house canceled TV shows venice Freeform Summer El Rey worst E! harry potter Hallmark crime thriller ViacomCBS Ghostbusters Calendar Rom-Com south america Apple TV+ psycho OWN nbcuniversal TV movies Winter TV christmas movies Comedy football Universal Pictures Shondaland Ellie Kemper TV Land Tumblr Arrowverse Amazon Studios blockbusters blockbuster saw Marvel Television Cartoon Network cancelled television Academy Awards IFC Films HBO Go 45 parents Food Network The Witch mcc First Reviews 2017 ratings comic cats deadpool aliens period drama Fargo video on demand Christmas medical drama psychological thriller 90s ITV scorecard Sci-Fi Creative Arts Emmys Marathons young adult target FX on Hulu rt labs critics edition Mystery superman DGA social media doctor who live action remakes breaking bad USA Avengers AMC Plus YouTube Turner Classic Movies children's TV ESPN stand-up comedy PlayStation travel animated Horror FXX Nat Geo know your critic reviews comic books Hulu cults free movies Pride Month Trivia italian dceu CMT child's play Heroines game of thrones dogs all-time theme song suspense halloween tv anime aapi basketball TCA Awards 21st Century Fox rom-coms TCA Captain marvel comics Cosplay Awards Tour BET dramedy kong Women's History Month Stephen King Mudbound spanish Grammys The Walking Dead Holiday Paramount Network PaleyFest romantic comedy cancelled TV shows fresh The Arrangement cars Tokyo Olympics Neflix Kids & Family Marvel Rock Dark Horse Comics Alien Sneak Peek Schedule slashers GoT Family Tags: Comedy spy thriller CBS scary movies Country game show Mary Poppins Returns godzilla Best and Worst Pixar slasher Syfy TIFF Television Academy boxoffice Emmy Nominations 2015 mutant ABC Signature Pirates Film james bond Character Guide festivals Bravo Premiere Dates Cannes sag awards golden globes documentary DC Comics teaser anthology elevated horror docudrama SDCC space San Diego Comic-Con Trailer Biopics binge live event Tubi Pet Sematary witnail latino joker book 2021 Marvel Studios debate chucky book adaptation Winners Fox Searchlight spanish language comiccon royal family blaxploitation E3 Teen Lifetime Comic-Con@Home 2021 TCM TV One CW Seed Turner Mary poppins scene in color Spring TV 72 Emmy Awards Watching Series casting kids spinoff The CW 71st Emmy Awards war adenture BBC IMDb TV discovery japan news best Lucasfilm directors AMC olympics crime drama trophy reboot HBO leaderboard Showtime PBS Apple Hallmark Christmas movies Oscars technology SundanceTV adaptation Disney Plus Britbox pirates of the caribbean HBO Max video sitcom justice league Broadway hidden camera Super Bowl Rocky Netflix LGBT facebook dragons Exclusive Video tv talk diversity Image Comics 20th Century Fox sequel Television Critics Association Martial Arts french Musicals Polls and Games telelvision Paramount die hard Disney See It Skip It sequels Pop TV Valentine's Day renewed TV shows Amazon Prime Video romance The Academy Drama fast and furious crime concert foreign Sundance TV BBC America 99% Comedy Central Nominations Certified Fresh TV renewals Tomatazos twilight NYCC Peacock Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt satire laika Video Games Binge Guide Fox News Animation APB quibi stop motion RT21 TLC ghosts Toys 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards BAFTA science fiction screen actors guild GIFs The Purge independent TBS X-Men Columbia Pictures Instagram Live unscripted zombies boxing History superhero Wes Anderson strong female leads ID richard e. Grant Anna Paquin festival BET Awards FOX Mindy Kaling Hear Us Out MTV new york criterion disaster Ovation rotten movies we love Awards Star Wars natural history Spike Vudu Shudder Black Mirror emmy awards NBA based on movie Reality Competition Interview historical drama SXSW streaming movies YouTube Red Sony Pictures franchise kaiju VICE 2018 critics what to watch vampires Rocketman sports spain biopic hollywood YouTube Premium Spectrum Originals Reality monster movies GLAAD Film Festival Logo President rt labs CNN nature marvel cinematic universe 007 cinemax Paramount Plus mob scary Set visit worst movies USA Network universal monsters Universal cancelled Opinion dreamworks Crackle Legendary genre zero dark thirty robots Sundance Now cops documentaries spider-man new star wars movies DC Universe hispanic thriller Musical black comedy Prime Video comic book movie nfl Music MCU TV National Geographic IFC wonder woman women razzies MSNBC Song of Ice and Fire series king kong spider-verse 73rd Emmy Awards rt archives stoner Disney+ Disney Plus movies archives cooking DirecTV popular lord of the rings Acorn TV black 79th Golden Globes Awards finale YA legend NBC WGN critic resources TruTV hispanic heritage month zombie Chernobyl Trophy Talk Epix marvel comics halloween feel good Extras TCA 2017 serial killer Adult Swim Quiz asian-american police drama dc Travel Channel true crime films dark Thanksgiving revenge classics Fantasy biography VH1 BBC One adventure New York Comic Con First Look talk show Crunchyroll toy story Black History Month name the review WarnerMedia 1990s indie singing competition gangster prank ABC werewolf supernatural RT History streaming Star Trek American Society of Cinematographers Pacific Islander dexter Classic Film indiana jones rotten Lionsgate Nickelodeon FX Emmys 24 frames 93rd Oscars 2019 Amazon transformers Warner Bros. Lifetime Christmas movies mission: impossible trailers A24 Comics on TV Sundance