Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: American Sniper Hits the Target, Paddington Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Blackhat does not compute, and The Wedding Ringer is short on laughs.

by | January 15, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fallen soldier (American Sniper, starring Bradley Cooper and Sienna Miller), a marmalade-loving bear (Paddington, starring Hugh Bonneville and Sally Hawkins), an ex-con hacker (Blackhat, starring Chris Hemsworth and Viola Davis), and a best man for hire (The Wedding Ringer, starring Kevin Hart and Josh Gad). What do the critics have to say?

American Sniper


As a director, Clint Eastwood is one of cinema’s greatest chroniclers of troubled tough guys. Critics say American Sniper is a tense, kinetic drama that has much to say about the emotional toll of war — even if it fudges some of the facts about its real-life subject. Bradley Cooper stars as Chris Kyle, a Navy SEAL sniper who achieved near-legendary status for his fearlessness and shooting accuracy. But when he left the service, Kyle’s place in the world became less certain. The pundits say American Sniper avoids some of the more controversial aspects of Kyle’s life, but it’s still a bracing, tense, powerfully acted portrait of a supremely talented soldier at war with himself.



The bear from darkest Peru is one of the brightest lights of the young movie year. Critics say Paddington is the best kind of family film — it’s funny, thoughtful, deeply heartfelt, and filled with strong characters. After stowing away on a boat, the titular bear arrives in London and is discovered by the Brown family, who bring him into their home. Paddington is a stranger in a strange land, but he does his best to adjust to city life; unfortunately, he also draws the attention of a devious taxidermist. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Paddington maintains the cheer and whimsy of Michael Bond’s books, while teaching children a gentle lesson in tolerance. (Check out star Hugh Bonneville’s Five Favorite Films, as well as our interviews with the cast and crew.)



It’s tough to make computing look cool on the big screen. Critics say even a talented director like Michael Mann can only add so much to something like Blackhat, a cyberthriller that’s long on visual razzle-dazzle but short on tension and believability. Chris Hemsworth stars as Nick Hathaway, a brilliant hacker who’s serving prison time. However, when U.S. intelligence agents team up with the Chinese government to investigate a devastating act of cyberterrorism, they spring Hathaway from the joint to help solve the case. The pundits say Blackhat squanders its timely premise on a silly plotting and dialogue, though it does have a sense of visual panache.

The Wedding Ringer


Kevin Hart is one of the funniest men on the planet, but critics say his comic exuberance can’t save The Wedding Ringer, a thoroughly so-so bromance with a few good gags but a whole lot of dead spots. Hart stars as Jimmy, who provides an unusual service: he serves as the best man for socially awkward, soon-to-be-wedded guys. While giving Doug (Josh Gad) instructions on how to act cool, Jimmy stars to actually like the big galoot. The pundits say Hart tries his best, but the pace is slack and too many of the jokes are of the gross-out variety. (Check out our interviews with Kevin Hart, Josh Gad, and Kaley Cuoco.)

What’s Hot On TV:

Critics say Togetherness (Certified Fresh at 94 percent) is a delightful surprise that interweaves day-to-day life with moving, dramatic characters who have an affinity for deprecating, squirmy humor.

The critics say Man Seeking Woman (92 percent) is easy to fall for, taking a ridiculously funny approach to a common theme with amusingly surreality and enjoyable oddness.

The pundits say Girls (Certified Fresh at 86 percent) is familiar after four seasons, but its convoluted-yet-comical depiction of young women dealing with the real world still manages to impress.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

tv talk ID game of thrones Sci-Fi Amazon Netflix Christmas movies Fox News streaming boxoffice theme song biopic spy thriller The Walt Disney Company Sony Apple zombie travel venice 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Fargo Holiday Logo fast and furious hispanic Mary Tyler Moore Comedy strong female leads Freeform sequel Set visit Nominations crime drama cancelled television halloween tv SXSW 2022 blockbusters Rock Adult Swim rom-coms cars emmy awards Thanksgiving reviews Christmas binge australia cops Columbia Pictures BET Awards Comics on TV Black History Month streaming movies dramedy diversity Animation Funimation Mary poppins Captain marvel genre harry potter suspense saw composers TCA 2017 toronto crossover royal family book Mudbound jurassic park marvel comics Country AMC Chernobyl NBC festival summer TV Pirates hollywood Song of Ice and Fire gangster vampires comics pirates of the caribbean disaster Pop singing competition video Fall TV casting First Look Walt Disney Pictures Marathons Spectrum Originals game show Hollywood Foreign Press Association remakes Esquire rotten movies we love obi wan cancelled TV series Year in Review Extras Emmy Nominations children's TV Awards Watching Series Sundance Now TCM Quiz Musicals Shondaland comic teaser Chilling Adventures of Sabrina GoT Disney El Rey Fantasy spinoff The Witch Premiere Dates BBC One Pride Month X-Men ViacomCBS directors scary TLC VH1 TV One monster movies black medical drama Red Carpet political drama Heroines critic resources Tomatazos toy story DC Universe IFC Films new york comic book movies Tags: Comedy sequels docuseries Sony Pictures 21st Century Fox television DC Comics independent Valentine's Day GIFs anime Marvel 1990s technology Focus Features facebook aliens YouTube Red young adult Holidays TIFF spanish Drama sopranos FX Tubi documentaries Disney+ Disney Plus high school women Broadway Tarantino HFPA SXSW Hear Us Out new star wars movies Ovation spider-verse romantic comedy hidden camera art house prank Polls and Games Mystery Bravo archives aapi marvel cinematic universe cults based on movie ABC Family wonder woman rotten 007 Sundance TV Best Director werewolf WarnerMedia Travel Channel mutant Avengers ITV HBO Toys Best Picture 2018 summer preview President 93rd Oscars mcc A&E adaptation child's play HBO Go Universal Pictures Hallmark Christmas movies 72 Emmy Awards razzies spain space TV Land 71st Emmy Awards MSNBC comedies See It Skip It halloween 2016 Lionsgate YouTube Premium Instagram Live broadcast Certified Fresh Cannes new zealand crime Podcast Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt summer TV preview screenings stoner PlayStation Grammys Amazon Studios USA Spike Nickelodeon Creative Arts Emmys Sneak Peek Hallmark CNN natural history police drama joker canceled adenture a nightmare on elm street franchise best cinemax robots Star Wars concert dceu TNT breaking bad Comic Book Arrowverse discovery period drama action-comedy feel good comic books dreamworks Family 2017 worst video on demand MCU psycho First Reviews Academy Awards Calendar Summer Countdown Legendary Superheroe CW Seed die hard Endgame Paramount Network Oscar critics king kong Ghostbusters olympics Peacock Martial Arts name the review social media 4/20 LGBT nfl french comiccon spider-man deadpool dexter hispanic heritage month obituary Showtime supernatural elevated horror The Arrangement quibi RT21 nature blockbuster Superheroes Pixar MTV black comedy ESPN Sundance Acorn TV APB Epix nbcuniversal TruTV 79th Golden Globes Awards Star Trek docudrama YouTube rt labs critics edition Image Comics golden globe awards BBC Amazon Prime Video Mindy Kaling Lifetime Christmas movies lord of the rings Trivia live event Character Guide Anna Paquin canceled TV shows Starz Cartoon Network fresh Comic-Con@Home 2021 football Awards Tour Teen Infographic Schedule versus A24 Mary Poppins Returns Video Games Oscars Disney Channel Paramount Plus streamig Shudder transformers YA South by Southwest Film Festival criterion stop motion VICE cooking Reality Competition boxing Film USA Network Warner Bros. war 2021 Crunchyroll 99% renewed TV shows trophy Comedy Central politics DC streaming service Crackle ratings scary movies Star Wars Celebration CBS Turner christmas movies mob TV renewals TV ABC free movies sitcom The Academy E! worst movies Discovery Channel TCA Awards The Walking Dead Native witnail basketball superman movie PBS serial killer Food Network CMT Apple TV+ SundanceTV golden globes Elton John popular Trophy Talk PaleyFest science fiction Nat Geo 20th Century Fox Amazon Prime series posters Wes Anderson interviews Stephen King Geeked Week Reality foreign History 94th Oscars SDCC Pacific Islander scene in color BBC America Musical king arthur IMDb TV NYCC Turner Classic Movies finale Masterpiece TBS RT History E3 Kids & Family Disney streaming service LGBTQ Television Academy 90s ghosts Best and Worst mission: impossible DirecTV target scene in color 2020 The CW spanish language Hulu FOX comic book movie Cosplay italian kids Western leaderboard jamie lee curtis japan zombies Vudu scene in color series Tumblr Photos talk show 2019 films historical drama Best Actor Tokyo Olympics MGM FX on Hulu trailers batman romance parents Baby Yoda dark NBA Television Critics Association scorecard animated Rom-Com Black Mirror Music book adaptation revenge American Society of Cinematographers Biopics AMC Plus heist movie zero dark thirty biography Paramount Horror international Winter TV adventure stand-up comedy Lucasfilm IFC Best Actress miniseries sag awards Writers Guild of America sports Women's History Month National Geographic Box Office Election dogs indiana jones Netflix VOD movies superhero Interview what to watch Pop TV screen actors guild universal monsters OneApp james bond WGN indie unscripted award winner blaxploitation Emmys crime thriller Disney Plus 24 frames Apple TV Plus ABC Signature know your critic justice league The Purge live action TCA Neflix Super Bowl Marvel Television target Trailer rt archives Syfy anthology Action scene in color film series Fox Searchlight green book Ellie Kemper vs. twilight all-time 45 godzilla asian-american satire mockumentary richard e. Grant Britbox classics festivals japanese debate cancelled TV shows doctor who TCA Winter 2020 Rocky dc rt labs cats Alien Film Festival FXX slashers 73rd Emmy Awards Brie Larson Exclusive Video kaiju San Diego Comic-Con Marvel Studios Classic Film psychological thriller Indigenous HBO Max legend true crime GLAAD Winners documentary south america Spring TV Universal BET laika dragons latino DGA cartoon news OWN kong hist New York Comic Con Pet Sematary Opinion Paramount Pictures Binge Guide Lifetime cancelled Dark Horse Comics Prime Video thriller Rocketman BAFTA 2015 TV movies telelvision reboot CBS All Access chucky slasher