News

Coming 2 America First Reviews: A Fun but Overly Familiar Trip Down Memory Lane

Critics say the Eddie Murphy sequel scores points for nostalgia, but it leans a little too heavily on callbacks to make your Soul Glo.

by | March 4, 2021 | Comments

Eddie Murphy reprises one of his most popular movie characters ever (actually a handful of them) for the long-awaited sequel to Coming to America, and if you like the 1988 original, you may also enjoy Coming 2 America. Unfortunately, early reviews of the Amazon new release indicate the sequel borrows more than just its title from the first film, as the main complaint in the negative reviews of Craig Brewer’s follow-up are the movie’s recycled bits.

However, a lot of the favorable takes highlight the same overly faithful familiarity as a positive, or at least a harmless fault, while celebrating the return of Prince Akeem, Semi (Arsenio Hall) and the rest of the ensemble representing Zamunda and Queens. Especially Wesley Snipes.

Here’s what critics are saying about Coming 2 America:


Does the sequel live up to the original?

I’m pleased to report the long-awaited, much-anticipated, will-it-ever-happen, heavily hyped Coming 2 America is just as gloriously funny and wonderful and original and gold-hearted.
– Richard Roeper, Chicago Sun-Times

Virtually no one does good comedy sequels, especially decades after the fact… of all the people to finally get it right, who would’ve expected it to be Eddie Murphy?
– Vince Mancini, Uproxx

A pale imitation that never comes close to the dizzying highs of the original.
– Matt Goldberg, Collider

Man, this is supposed to be the long-awaited follow up to Coming to America! Why does it feel so toothless and safe?
– Sean O’Connell, CinemaBlend


Will it cater to your nostalgia?

Man, is it a fun nostalgic ride to take.
Carla Renata, The Curvy Film Critic

The film will easily capitalize on the lingering nostalgic affection for one of Murphy’s most successful efforts, even if the original isn’t nearly as funny as you might remember.
Frank Scheck, Hollywood Reporter

Coming 2 America is cute and fun, a lovingly made exercise in nostalgia.
Kristen Baldwin, Entertainment Weekly

It’s a sequel that’s leaning heavily on your fond memories of the first movie without daring to bring anything new to the table.
Matt Goldberg, Collider


Coming 2 America

(Photo by Quantrell D. Colbert/©Amazon Studios)

Are there too many references to the original?

It works in plenty of odes to the original while updating it in, well, not really surprising ways, but at least they seem entirely heartfelt.
Jason Adams, Pajiba

Coming 2 America often risks dissolving into an assemblage of reference points, but Murphy’s Akeem provides just enough pathos to fuse the narrative together.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Craig Brewer, a superfan of Murphy and his films, doesn’t hide the joy he has for it and stuffs as much as he can in this film to prove it.
Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

Coming 2 America includes so many nods to its predecessor that it feels like a feature-length easter egg in search of a movie.
Frank Scheck, Hollywood Reporter


So is it just for the fans?

Coming 2 America is adamantly, unabashedly one for the fans. And, judged solely by that mission, it’s a straight-up, if modest, success.
Ann Hornaday, Washington Post

Those who adore the original will feel like they’ve been revisited by an old friend, or perhaps the dirty uncle, whose jokes are a bit frayed but still pointed enough.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Who’s curious to know what these folks have been up to in that span? If you count yourself as an ‘I do!’ then, well, this movie answers that question. Sometimes with terrific comedy!
Jason Adams, Pajiba


Coming 2 America

(Photo by ©Amazon Studios)

Do you need to have seen the original?

If you haven’t seen or can’t quite recall Coming to America, the relevant background is helpfully supplied here, along with some new information.
A.O. Scott, New York Times

A lot of the jokes will land even if you haven’t seen it. That being said, you will appreciate this one so much more if you have watched the first one.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky


Where do the main problems lie?

Brewer and the film’s three writers (Barry W. Blaustein, David Sheffield, and Kenya Barris) get so caught up in repeating what worked before that they neglect characters with the most promise and potential.
Rob Hunter, Film School Rejects

One of the chief problems with Coming 2 America is that it doesn’t even know who its protagonist should be.
Matt Goldberg, Collider


Is it funny?

If you are a fan of the first one, there are numerous callbacks that should have you laughing until your sides hurt.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

It delivers several genuine laughs, even if it never achieves the comedic excellence of its predecessor.
Kristen Baldwin, Entertainment Weekly

It didn’t always make me laugh (though I laughed plenty), but it always made me smile.
Vince Mancini, Uproxx

With no strong characters and a muddled plot, it’s no surprise that most of the jokes in Coming 2 America fail to land.
Matt Goldberg, Collider


Coming 2 America

(Photo by Quantrell D. Colbert/©Amazon Studios)

Does it veer into musical territory?

From time to time, Coming 2 America stirs to life, especially when it goes full-on musical pageant.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

There are more dance numbers than the first one, and they were some of my favorite scenes.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

It’s a winning, maximalist musical extravaganza.
Vince Mancini, Uproxx


How is Eddie Murphy?

Brash, lovable, and doused in irony at every turn, his outsized persona remains a singular figure in American comedy, evidently still capable of dominating the screen.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

The biggest letdown is seeing Murphy deliver such a generic, lifeless character after both the original film and his wildly charismatic and energetic performance in Brewer’s Dolemite Is My Name.
Rob Hunter, Film School Rejects


And the newcomers?

While [Jermaine] Fowler proves an appealing comic actor, he’s unable to bring much vibrancy to the formulaic goings-on.
Frank Scheck, Hollywood Reporter

Leslie Jones as Lavelle’s mother, Mary, and Tracy Morgan as his uncle, Reem, and they’re both as flat-out funny as you’d expect them to be.
Richard Roeper, Chicago Sun-Times

Leslie Jones is reliably hilarious.
Anna Menta, Decider

This movie provides further testimony to the absolute comic genius of Wesley Snipes.
A.O. Scott, New York Times

Wesley Snipes has never given such a riotous kind of deadpan performance.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire


Coming 2 America

(Photo by Quantrell D. Colbert/©Amazon Studios)

Are there any notable cameos?

The arrival of a certain famous baritone voice, who narrates a very ridiculous funeral, shows just how much the movie has invested in its jokey internal logic.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Much of the film’s fun stems from the celebrity cameos — including Morgan Freeman amusingly sending up his godlike narrator image and Trevor Noah as a “ZNN” anchor.
Frank Scheck, Hollywood Reporter


Is it more contemporary in its treatment of women characters?

What I most appreciate about this sequel is the women of Zamunda are self sufficient, strong-willed, strong-minded and not reliant upon the approval of a man to be their own person.
Carla Renata, The Curvy Film Critic

The film’s feminism – which sees the girls doing some fighting and not much else – feels tacked on.
Emma Simmonds, The List

Like the first movie, albeit to a less leering extent, this one wants to have its cake and eat it too when it comes to objectifying women.
Ann Hornaday, Washington Post


How are Ruth E. Carter’s costumes?

Perhaps the biggest star of the film isn’t an on-screen player but its costume designer Ruth Carter, who has gone all out in creating an Afrocentric aesthetic that bursts with richly hued fabrics, lush textures and gleaming metallics.
Ann Hornaday, Washington Post

The various royal garments give this film interesting ways to build off the characters and a wide array of colors to constantly work with, which shines just as brightly as the many happy faces seen throughout.
Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

I’m not exaggerating when I say that costume designer Ruth E. Carter deserves an(other) Oscar.
Vince Mancini, Uproxx

She could win another [Oscar] just for General Izzi’s warlord couture.
A.O. Scott, New York Times


Coming 2 America

(Photo by ©Amazon Studios)

Is Coming 2 America ultimately worth streaming at home?

It’s good at what it sets out to do. Which makes it great fun.
Ann Hornaday, Washington Post

It’s the kind of comedy with a “repeatability factor” that will have you making plans to see it again before the closing credits even finish rolling.
Richard Roeper, Chicago Sun-Times

Perhaps some of this movie’s jokes would kill on the big screen rather than simply expiring as they did on my laptop.
Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

If Coming 2 America had released in theaters, or on-demand for $19.99, I’m not sure it’d be worth it. But since it’s streaming free on Prime, and since you probably already have a subscription… Sure!
Anna Menta, Decider


Coming 2 America premieres on Amazon Prime on March 5, 2021.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

BBC America Amazon Prime satire Superheroe laika Mary poppins Horror Tumblr Exclusive Video pirates of the caribbean toy story marvel cinematic universe blockbuster period drama superman 94th Oscars theme song Television Academy Premiere Dates The Walt Disney Company Quiz documentary See It Skip It kaiju Lifetime Christmas movies science fiction venice FX on Hulu scorecard facebook Reality dark mission: impossible dceu New York Comic Con reboot Classic Film live action E! elevated horror australia ghosts justice league spanish language child's play hollywood Countdown Alien Starz Paramount Plus Photos Esquire Valentine's Day ViacomCBS Endgame talk show slasher Super Bowl christmas movies Mindy Kaling docudrama Star Trek aapi Action worst dexter black Disney streaming service razzies posters Comedy Central halloween tv biopic Columbia Pictures films war Sundance TV golden globe awards Rom-Com Nickelodeon Universal Pictures Turner The Purge Paramount FOX canceled CBS cancelled TV shows space richard e. Grant streaming movies docuseries high school Infographic Pacific Islander IMDb TV Funimation movie History scary art house anthology Cosplay Emmy Nominations 2015 Fall TV Drama cults TCA Winter 2020 rt labs new york Hollywood Foreign Press Association 90s Shondaland blockbusters Travel Channel Anna Paquin Broadway Mary Poppins Returns Brie Larson San Diego Comic-Con james bond MGM BAFTA spider-man spy thriller VICE Ellie Kemper LGBTQ Western biography adventure mutant universal monsters boxoffice Neflix trailers rt archives robots Marvel Television transformers renewed TV shows summer preview The Witch Image Comics Ghostbusters BBC One Britbox MSNBC composers DC Comics toronto The CW serial killer quibi feel good Pop TV DC Universe mockumentary die hard Lifetime crossover a nightmare on elm street critic resources ABC Family PlayStation Animation Election A24 gangster monster movies nature RT21 Film Festival streaming Emmys 2021 true crime news spinoff canceled TV shows singing competition Nat Geo witnail dogs Oscar Song of Ice and Fire jamie lee curtis Red Carpet Pride Month strong female leads cartoon Family Interview screenings USA Network genre supernatural technology Apple TV Plus summer TV preview worst movies Fox Searchlight RT History 007 documentaries know your critic king kong cancelled TV series Watching Series name the review festival legend Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Schedule Universal VH1 Star Wars El Rey Holidays 72 Emmy Awards japan Logo indiana jones book adaptation Instagram Live italian breaking bad popular politics social media Comics on TV Peacock spider-verse concert basketball OWN TV renewals comics Food Network WarnerMedia zombie revenge LGBT video on demand Trophy Talk Opinion comic book movies fast and furious Syfy A&E festivals Bravo adenture criterion NBA Christmas Tomatazos best action-comedy Pet Sematary Rocky GLAAD TV Land BET Awards new star wars movies TruTV DC streaming service king arthur asian-american 20th Century Fox video psycho prank movies royal family deadpool Crackle Netflix Christmas movies based on movie Epix Pop Box Office summer TV E3 Adult Swim comiccon ITV debate ABC Signature BET award winner directors scene in color CBS All Access golden globes hidden camera Chernobyl dramedy sitcom Trivia Walt Disney Pictures Stephen King parents obituary Spectrum Originals HBO Fargo cars remakes Sundance wonder woman new zealand kids versus green book 73rd Emmy Awards international Apple TV+ crime Rock Tubi ratings screen actors guild Rocketman heist movie NBC Hallmark Christmas movies Set visit women finale indie Best Picture 93rd Oscars Oscars Winter TV sag awards spanish 2018 Kids & Family HBO Go Arrowverse Marvel tv talk vs. TV young adult WGN batman sopranos Wes Anderson dragons Elton John game of thrones IFC 79th Golden Globes Awards AMC Black History Month Crunchyroll cops First Look The Walking Dead zero dark thirty french critics GIFs comic book movie Amazon archives chucky japanese olympics Biopics Nominations franchise Heroines rom-coms Film emmy awards discovery Awards Apple cinemax Legendary nbcuniversal 99% Creative Arts Emmys scary movies adaptation blaxploitation Cannes Musical Amazon Studios FX Writers Guild of America doctor who cats hispanic heritage month fresh jurassic park comedies superhero Comic-Con@Home 2021 OneApp 2016 football Acorn TV historical drama 45 sequels Tags: Comedy halloween Hear Us Out vampires telelvision natural history Lucasfilm binge Avengers Sundance Now free movies Best Director Women's History Month Trailer Martial Arts Video Games Best Actor rt labs critics edition YouTube Captain marvel thriller Turner Classic Movies Year in Review reviews television TCA Awards Calendar Television Critics Association crime thriller spain boxing Mystery Prime Video The Arrangement 1990s latino Vudu disaster HFPA Disney+ Disney Plus American Society of Cinematographers ESPN Warner Bros. romance Comic Book APB Extras Mary Tyler Moore what to watch AMC Plus TCA 2017 PaleyFest National Geographic comic Musicals Toys lord of the rings TIFF game show Ovation godzilla GoT Masterpiece Best Actress Tokyo Olympics CMT book Mudbound south america Reality Competition South by Southwest Film Festival unscripted twilight VOD SXSW 2022 Polls and Games Disney President leaderboard DGA Baby Yoda suspense Holiday 24 frames CNN classics Grammys Certified Fresh cancelled television hispanic 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Summer trophy all-time mcc cooking kong 2017 comic books animated TBS Podcast BBC Dark Horse Comics IFC Films Character Guide TV One black comedy Discovery Channel YA Binge Guide TNT Spike anime Sci-Fi Best and Worst USA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sneak Peek miniseries casting teaser ID MTV SundanceTV streamig cancelled TCM Freeform Teen TV movies live event ABC PBS rotten movies we love Fox News romantic comedy travel stop motion SDCC dreamworks medical drama psychological thriller Black Mirror series NYCC Superheroes 2020 YouTube Premium Marvel Studios 21st Century Fox FXX crime drama stand-up comedy Spring TV diversity YouTube Red Country DirecTV Showtime Hulu police drama nfl Sony Pictures Shudder political drama 4/20 Amazon Prime Video HBO Max Disney Plus TLC Hallmark joker Music Pixar X-Men First Reviews werewolf Marathons Thanksgiving Cartoon Network 71st Emmy Awards slashers Disney Channel Netflix Tarantino sequel saw Awards Tour harry potter obi wan zombies aliens target marvel comics children's TV Paramount Network Comedy foreign dc hist Academy Awards SXSW mob 2019 rotten Winners stoner The Academy independent MCU TCA Pirates Fantasy Lionsgate sports CW Seed