Black Panther on Track for Highest Superhero Tomatometer Ever

Would T’Challa beat Bruce Wayne in a fight? We are about to find out.

by | February 16, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

Marvel’s zeitgeist-eating mega-hit, Black Panther, is on track to be the highest-rated superhero movie ever on our Tomatometer with 98% as it enters its opening weekend, slightly ahead of Disney/Pixar’s The Incredibles (97%) and 4% ahead of The Dark Knight and the first Iron Man (both at 94%). The latter two movies currently share the Tomatometer crown among live-action superhero flicks; the former is the Tomatometer champ when you factor in animated movies, too.

But step into the ring, Black Panther, which, at last count, was sitting at 98% positive reviews from a total of 243. (Note, our last count is at 10:20am on Friday, February 16.) That’s just six Rotten reviews so far, and sets the Ryan Coogler-directed movie up for top Tomatometer honors. That is, if it holds.

See, the Tomatometer is a living, if not breathing, thing: As more reviews are written and added, the overall percentage of positive reviews for a film shifts. The Dark Knight, for instance, has a 94% rating from a total of 326 reviews. For the last few days, Black Panther has been oscillating between 97% and 98%. If and when it gets to The Dark Knight’s total, will it still be sitting at its near-perfect score?

Keen election-watchers will know that a 3% or 4% margin can be hard to lose, or gain, when the numbers are big. And even on our Adjusted Tomatometer, a calculation that allows RT to compare movies across the years by taking into consideration factors such as the average number of reviews per film for a given year, Black Panther is currently the best reviewed superhero movie ever.

If it remains that way this month, it still better watch its tail. Former Tomatometer record-holder The Incredibles is getting a sequel this year, Incredibles 2, and if it performs in the vein of Pixar sequels like Finding Dory (94%) and Toy Story 2 (100%)—and not Monsters University (79% from the original’s 96%) or Cars 2 (39% from the original’s 74%)—then T’Challa’s Rotten Tomatoes reign may be short lived.

Black Panther opens everywhere today, February 16. Read reviews for it here.

Tag Cloud

2019 Cannes PBS Turner Classic Movies video unscripted Pop anime quibi 2020 24 frames CNN Rom-Com Trophy Talk based on movie werewolf talk show hist cooking Rocky Showtime thriller Apple TV+ comic Marvel Studios CMT canceled zombie FXX A&E WGN Western science fiction sag awards free movies Creative Arts Emmys technology Star Trek Classic Film south america romance Country Avengers Arrowverse blockbuster Mary Poppins Returns cops ABC Family finale PaleyFest AMC Reality NBC streaming book Ovation Walt Disney Pictures Brie Larson docudrama disaster Endgame See It Skip It RT21 aliens SundanceTV Universal christmas movies Certified Fresh Sundance Now DC streaming service doctor who Lifetime Christmas movies psychological thriller adaptation Valentine's Day medical drama History Martial Arts Tubi Christmas Comic Book 2018 vampires composers ITV series Writers Guild of America Shudder 71st Emmy Awards comics Elton John 21st Century Fox TCA TCM San Diego Comic-Con Song of Ice and Fire GLAAD CBS cartoon Paramount hispanic Character Guide Oscars Holiday Extras stand-up comedy Box Office Teen DGA spy thriller E! Superheroe Paramount Network transformers strong female leads Lionsgate cults revenge cats Nominations Amazon Studios Musicals MCU Women's History Month OneApp reboot Watching Series TV Toys canceled TV shows spanish language Schedule Infographic Stephen King award winner elevated horror Mary poppins Peacock SXSW period drama miniseries Cosplay 45 Discovery Channel mutant Mystery Amazon Lucasfilm DC Universe Masterpiece Grammys tv talk facebook 007 Amazon Prime screen actors guild RT History Adult Swim independent Film Festival Anna Paquin anthology El Rey mockumentary documentary Freeform Trivia Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Shondaland Crunchyroll Winter TV Marvel dramedy LGBTQ Pirates Netflix Christmas movies serial killer CW Seed Kids & Family President comiccon Cartoon Network directors jamie lee curtis Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Nat Geo VICE psycho Holidays TCA 2017 Action natural history ABC Comics on TV cancelled TV shows Set visit harry potter versus American Society of Cinematographers crossover television HBO Max FOX Columbia Pictures HBO Animation Sundance TV cars Best and Worst Countdown toy story teaser adventure game show screenings blaxploitation discovery OWN Photos TV renewals supernatural 20th Century Fox The Witch war political drama Awards Tour Disney Amazon Prime Video Music zero dark thirty nature Film Podcast joker Sony Pictures LGBT Captain marvel APB cancelled TV series Sundance travel Comedy Central Hulu cancelled Baby Yoda game of thrones crime Election The CW Quiz ghosts Family robots Hallmark YouTube Premium foreign latino TBS 2017 name the review Musical Epix spinoff Disney Channel indie Horror Comedy Marvel Television DC Comics movie Disney Plus TCA Winter 2020 First Look Star Wars TruTV cancelled television kids Food Network Mudbound BBC America biography Emmy Nominations USA Network Rock theme song Lifetime Opinion Britbox Turner NYCC dragons A24 BBC witnail The Walking Dead Fall TV children's TV politics sports singing competition MSNBC CBS All Access Binge Guide TV Land Tarantino DirecTV Summer Pride Month historical drama Spectrum Originals Spike Starz Nickelodeon Trailer USA Awards Black Mirror Rocketman dc FX Interview cinemax MTV Calendar binge Ellie Kemper police drama Disney streaming service renewed TV shows X-Men Vudu Red Carpet Mary Tyler Moore Crackle VH1 Premiere Dates Winners breaking bad GIFs dceu rotten movies we love slashers justice league sitcom WarnerMedia golden globes YA festivals dogs Year in Review Sneak Peek Super Bowl Disney+ Disney Plus Reality Competition Tomatazos Drama green book Apple TV Plus Heroines space sequel romantic comedy IFC Films BET crime drama GoT Tumblr The Arrangement TNT zombies what to watch Pixar diversity Thanksgiving Ghostbusters TLC Acorn TV ESPN true crime Pet Sematary casting Biopics The Purge Logo Polls and Games SDCC spider-man halloween Sci-Fi Fantasy Chernobyl E3 TIFF Bravo Video Games social media IFC Emmys crime thriller ratings Academy Awards Television Academy Fox News Apple Superheroes movies richard e. Grant Dark Horse Comics National Geographic Marathons 2016 batman Spring TV First Reviews spain Esquire Warner Bros. 2015 boxoffice YouTube Mindy Kaling YouTube Red New York Comic Con Hallmark Christmas movies animated Syfy Netflix