Black Panther on Track for Highest Superhero Tomatometer Ever

Would T’Challa beat Bruce Wayne in a fight? We are about to find out.

by | February 16, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

Marvel’s zeitgeist-eating mega-hit, Black Panther, is on track to be the highest-rated superhero movie ever on our Tomatometer with 98% as it enters its opening weekend, slightly ahead of Disney/Pixar’s The Incredibles (97%) and 4% ahead of The Dark Knight and the first Iron Man (both at 94%). The latter two movies currently share the Tomatometer crown among live-action superhero flicks; the former is the Tomatometer champ when you factor in animated movies, too.

But step into the ring, Black Panther, which, at last count, was sitting at 98% positive reviews from a total of 243. (Note, our last count is at 10:20am on Friday, February 16.) That’s just six Rotten reviews so far, and sets the Ryan Coogler-directed movie up for top Tomatometer honors. That is, if it holds.

See, the Tomatometer is a living, if not breathing, thing: As more reviews are written and added, the overall percentage of positive reviews for a film shifts. The Dark Knight, for instance, has a 94% rating from a total of 326 reviews. For the last few days, Black Panther has been oscillating between 97% and 98%. If and when it gets to The Dark Knight’s total, will it still be sitting at its near-perfect score?

Keen election-watchers will know that a 3% or 4% margin can be hard to lose, or gain, when the numbers are big. And even on our Adjusted Tomatometer, a calculation that allows RT to compare movies across the years by taking into consideration factors such as the average number of reviews per film for a given year, Black Panther is currently the best reviewed superhero movie ever.

If it remains that way this month, it still better watch its tail. Former Tomatometer record-holder The Incredibles is getting a sequel this year, Incredibles 2, and if it performs in the vein of Pixar sequels like Finding Dory (94%) and Toy Story 2 (100%)—and not Monsters University (79% from the original’s 96%) or Cars 2 (39% from the original’s 74%)—then T’Challa’s Rotten Tomatoes reign may be short lived.

Black Panther opens everywhere today, February 16. Read reviews for it here.

Tag Cloud

Ellie Kemper mutant Rock The Arrangement adventure Opinion Nat Geo APB dc CMT Showtime Walt Disney Pictures Extras Reality Competition See It Skip It politics 007 President Music Paramount Network Certified Fresh 45 spy thriller DirecTV crime thriller GoT Disney cults E3 Comedy Central Fantasy 2016 BBC America FXX TBS Nominations Freeform supernatural Marvel Superheroes Creative Arts Emmys Bravo singing competition festivals Schedule TCM Rocky travel transformers MSNBC ABC police drama Calendar Polls and Games serial killer TV aliens 2015 Western YA Super Bowl CW Seed Photos Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt History DC Universe Trivia romance Britbox Lucasfilm Sony Pictures MTV science fiction TCA 2017 zombies Warner Bros. ratings Sci-Fi vampires cooking sports Biopics cops Mindy Kaling YouTube Red Star Trek 20th Century Fox Grammys VH1 Pop anime Holidays Box Office X-Men Set visit Sundance USA Network TCA TruTV Horror WGN Nickelodeon Premiere Dates LGBTQ Song of Ice and Fire ITV dramedy thriller American Society of Cinematographers jamie lee curtis streaming Lifetime Emmys HBO SDCC Starz IFC Shudder psycho Oscars hist Ghostbusters 21st Century Fox NBC Disney Channel Marathons NYCC Masterpiece dceu TLC Comedy Red Carpet Fox News Martial Arts YouTube Premium Star Wars Election TNT boxoffice Christmas SXSW social media Spring TV ESPN biography historical drama Crackle Animation medical drama discovery Thanksgiving period drama Fall TV sitcom Summer Winners DC Comics technology Musicals Pirates docudrama Columbia Pictures VICE crime drama ABC Family political drama Esquire Netflix Tumblr Watching Series Action SundanceTV Country golden globes Mystery USA IFC Films Ovation Trailer Interview A&E FOX Pixar Best and Worst Logo 24 frames Superheroe Apple Universal Rom-Com CBS All Access Mary Tyler Moore Drama Writers Guild of America Winter TV PaleyFest TV Land crossover based on movie Acorn TV AMC RT History diversity harry potter DC streaming service Infographic Syfy Spike TIFF blaxploitation Video Games Cartoon Network The CW BET Teen Cosplay Countdown what to watch cinemax National Geographic Toys CBS cats war E! Podcast First Look Sneak Peek Lionsgate Dark Horse Comics PBS Amazon unscripted FX Tomatazos justice league Adult Swim Comic Book GLAAD zombie talk show Kids & Family Paramount Musical Valentine's Day Year in Review El Rey CNN binge 2017 GIFs comiccon Epix OWN Shondaland Character Guide robots Sundance Now crime composers finale Hulu Reality Food Network San Diego Comic-Con doctor who BBC Awards