Black Panther on Track for Highest Superhero Tomatometer Ever

Would T’Challa beat Bruce Wayne in a fight? We are about to find out.

by | February 16, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

Marvel’s zeitgeist-eating mega-hit, Black Panther, is on track to be the highest-rated superhero movie ever on our Tomatometer with 98% as it enters its opening weekend, slightly ahead of Disney/Pixar’s The Incredibles (97%) and 4% ahead of The Dark Knight and the first Iron Man (both at 94%). The latter two movies currently share the Tomatometer crown among live-action superhero flicks; the former is the Tomatometer champ when you factor in animated movies, too.

But step into the ring, Black Panther, which, at last count, was sitting at 98% positive reviews from a total of 243. (Note, our last count is at 10:20am on Friday, February 16.) That’s just six Rotten reviews so far, and sets the Ryan Coogler-directed movie up for top Tomatometer honors. That is, if it holds.

See, the Tomatometer is a living, if not breathing, thing: As more reviews are written and added, the overall percentage of positive reviews for a film shifts. The Dark Knight, for instance, has a 94% rating from a total of 326 reviews. For the last few days, Black Panther has been oscillating between 97% and 98%. If and when it gets to The Dark Knight’s total, will it still be sitting at its near-perfect score?

Keen election-watchers will know that a 3% or 4% margin can be hard to lose, or gain, when the numbers are big. And even on our Adjusted Tomatometer, a calculation that allows RT to compare movies across the years by taking into consideration factors such as the average number of reviews per film for a given year, Black Panther is currently the best reviewed superhero movie ever.

If it remains that way this month, it still better watch its tail. Former Tomatometer record-holder The Incredibles is getting a sequel this year, Incredibles 2, and if it performs in the vein of Pixar sequels like Finding Dory (94%) and Toy Story 2 (100%)—and not Monsters University (79% from the original’s 96%) or Cars 2 (39% from the original’s 74%)—then T’Challa’s Rotten Tomatoes reign may be short lived.

Black Panther opens everywhere today, February 16. Read reviews for it here.

Tag Cloud

Pet Sematary Pacific Islander YouTube Premium Disney period drama Disney Plus Oscars NBC technology Anna Paquin adventure news Netflix Christmas movies 73rd Emmy Awards child's play gangster adaptation Cartoon Network reboot Holidays 99% Disney Channel RT21 Election Awards Tour 1990s Turner Classic Movies Rocketman Comics on TV archives know your critic documentary BET Awards Calendar CBS halloween tv Showtime target sequel sag awards james bond BBC halloween fresh travel GoT godzilla TBS Paramount Plus television Trailer Crunchyroll Hear Us Out Chilling Adventures of Sabrina DC Comics Comedy Central Trophy Talk Tubi crime drama 2019 nfl crime Alien true crime Emmy Nominations rt labs 71st Emmy Awards PBS TLC Acorn TV HBO Max Funimation chucky dexter serial killer twilight toronto Reality Competition Epix 93rd Oscars best animated concert die hard historical drama GIFs Certified Fresh royal family Polls and Games 2018 Photos DirecTV facebook Heroines franchise romantic comedy Red Carpet french cancelled TV shows HBO Go comic books free movies politics Freeform legend Sundance Now Biopics toy story Writers Guild of America streaming Vudu harry potter First Look Mystery heist movie hispanic VICE Teen Netflix ViacomCBS south america ESPN 90s critics book Pirates ABC Signature football independent Character Guide Christmas Film Syfy Travel Channel Hallmark laika talk show crossover CW Seed Baby Yoda emmy awards BET game of thrones telelvision VH1 Awards Martial Arts Musical Comedy Masterpiece YouTube Red comedies casting green book El Rey Spring TV sitcom Fox News composers 2015 Extras USA ABC Avengers festival Country scene in color all-time award winner Amazon Prime Video cartoon Shondaland revenge Binge Guide slasher First Reviews women Tarantino rotten movies we love psycho Endgame scorecard Best and Worst new star wars movies RT History Black History Month dark BBC America Amazon Studios thriller Sundance WarnerMedia Star Wars MTV comiccon Trivia live action Warner Bros. The Academy 45 medical drama social media festivals Mindy Kaling Grammys Adult Swim young adult AMC boxing nature miniseries 21st Century Fox Captain marvel Starz parents Set visit Comic Book Tomatazos Rom-Com spy thriller Amazon movies Schedule Brie Larson dceu Discovery Channel satire TV Land king arthur TV One comic Animation 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards olympics Lifetime kids Pop IFC Films Music rotten Rocky ABC Family blaxploitation quibi Sci-Fi Legendary breaking bad Apple TV+ docudrama Spectrum Originals YA hist what to watch sports aliens Spike MCU Video Games 24 frames Crackle 20th Century Fox FX The Walt Disney Company FXX blockbusters zombies TCA Awards Year in Review italian 72 Emmy Awards OWN USA Network WGN cats worst Sony Pictures vampires Winners E3 spinoff feel good Logo SDCC Kids & Family marvel cinematic universe classics natural history canceled TV shows black jamie lee curtis APB science fiction Star Trek canceled obituary YouTube TV renewals Pixar Fox Searchlight Marvel Studios Song of Ice and Fire Ghostbusters disaster San Diego Comic-Con dramedy Lionsgate universal monsters cooking Action films hispanic heritage month Walt Disney Pictures Family A24 2016 strong female leads police drama jurassic park 4/20 President docuseries theme song Fall TV anthology comic book movie TCA Winter 2020 discovery cults Food Network TCM kong Apple cancelled Toys spider-man NYCC marvel comics Black Mirror foreign boxoffice Marathons saw Infographic razzies Super Bowl joker monster movies japanese Opinion posters Esquire worst movies Paramount Network war Arrowverse Tokyo Olympics Universal wonder woman TruTV FOX Shudder 2021 romance golden globes rt labs critics edition Cosplay IFC Elton John Disney+ Disney Plus Film Festival Britbox mockumentary National Geographic Amazon Prime Quiz transformers History Turner VOD tv talk TCA Nominations renewed TV shows spanish HBO binge robots slashers Exclusive Video Mary Tyler Moore video LGBT supernatural The Witch The Arrangement American Society of Cinematographers crime thriller Superheroe prank Academy Awards Dark Horse Comics New York Comic Con Superheroes Holiday Wes Anderson debate Musicals action-comedy CMT mission: impossible blockbuster space aapi scary movies ghosts Nat Geo diversity superman Hallmark Christmas movies Ellie Kemper dragons remakes Women's History Month Classic Film Watching Series Mudbound Mary Poppins Returns a nightmare on elm street Comic-Con@Home 2021 Apple TV Plus Winter TV Emmys Chernobyl Horror spanish language popular cinemax GLAAD golden globe awards latino Countdown The Purge Drama directors superhero stand-up comedy dogs DC Universe PaleyFest TCA 2017 NBA children's TV cancelled television LGBTQ critic resources 2020 2017 japan The CW ITV fast and furious 007 video on demand ratings BBC One comic book movies based on movie A&E rt archives basketball adenture screen actors guild See It Skip It BAFTA political drama stop motion Interview screenings rom-coms mcc suspense criterion christmas movies Mary poppins TNT stoner finale Stephen King Reality DGA batman hidden camera series zero dark thirty Marvel Television psychological thriller comics cars versus cops dc doctor who TV The Walking Dead new zealand Pride Month indiana jones E! Peacock Ovation Bravo Image Comics Cannes Western new york teaser reviews movie Box Office werewolf king kong australia indie book adaptation CNN pirates of the caribbean Disney streaming service spain anime nbcuniversal Sneak Peek deadpool Television Critics Association Valentine's Day Columbia Pictures cancelled TV series asian-american Podcast Pop TV OneApp Summer streaming movies Broadway name the review TIFF game show Television Academy justice league MSNBC Lucasfilm Nickelodeon Sundance TV richard e. Grant DC streaming service unscripted Hulu singing competition high school sequels PlayStation lord of the rings documentaries trailers CBS All Access Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Creative Arts Emmys witnail SundanceTV Thanksgiving international FX on Hulu Lifetime Christmas movies biography zombie kaiju venice Premiere Dates X-Men Rock hollywood SXSW mutant Fantasy biopic Marvel TV movies elevated horror Paramount ID Tumblr