Total Recall

Billy Bob Thornton's 10 Best Movies

We look back at the best-reviewed work of the Bad Santa 2 star.

by | November 23, 2016 | Comments

Actor, writer, director, recording artist: there’s nothing Billy Bob Thornton can’t do, including bringing a sequel to a cult comedy to the screen over a decade after the original played in theaters. In celebration of the latter achievement, playing out in this weekend’s Bad Santa 2, we turn our attention to Mr. Thornton’s estimable filmography, whose critical highlights boast eclectic riches you may not suspect. It’s time for Total Recall!

10. Primary Colors (1998) 81%


Based on a thinly fictionalized account of the 1992 presidential campaign written by Joe Klein (who hid, for a time, behind the nom de plume “Anonymous”), and featuring cameos by Geraldo Rivera, Charlie Rose, Larry King, and Bill Maher as themselves, 1998’s Primary Colors could easily have been overshadowed by the real-life circus that followed Bill Clinton’s administration during both of his terms — but director Mike Nichols and screenwriter Elaine May had been a creative team for decades, and their comfort with one another, as well as a terrific cast, made Colors one of the better-reviewed films of the year. Thornton, tasked with providing a caricature of Democratic strategist James Carville that was still layered enough to make sense in an ostensibly grounded drama, passed with flying colors; as Stanley Kauffmann wrote for the New Republic, “Sheerly as film, Primary Colors generally sizzles.”

Watch Trailer

9. Chrystal (2004) 80%


As a guy who habitually writes and directs his own movies, perhaps Billy Bob Thornton is predisposed to have a soft spot for films led by triple-threat talents — or maybe he just appreciated Chrystal, the 2004 directorial debut from actor-screenwriter Ray McKinnon, on its own merits. Either way, this drama about an Arkansas ex-con (Thornton) grappling with the painful aftereffects of his crimes earned a number of positive reviews during its limited release; despite its dark themes, wrote Duane Byrge of the Hollywood Reporter, the movie comes across as “A grand story of redemption, laced with barbecued wit and slopped with intrigue.”

Watch Trailer

8. The Man Who Wasn't There (2001) 81%


The Coen brothers went neo-noir for 2001’s The Man Who Wasn’t There, drafting a stellar batch of character actors (including Thornton, Richard Jenkins, Tony Shalhoub, and Frances McDormand) to tell the story of a barber (Thornton) whose placid-seeming suburban post-WWII existence unravels into a crazy tangle of blackmail, murder, and one very precocious teenage girl (Scarlett Johansson). The black-and-white Man failed to make much of an impression at the box office, but it enthralled critics like ReelViews’ James Berardinelli, who praised it as “An unconventional, unpredictable thriller that Hitchcock probably would have enjoyed.”

Watch Trailer

7. Friday Night Lights (2004) 82%


Before it was an acclaimed cult favorite on the TV dial, Friday Night Lights was a Buzz Bissinger non-fiction book about life on the Texas high school gridiron — and then it was a Peter Berg drama starring Billy Bob Thornton as a football coach with the weight of a small town’s hopes and dreams on his program’s shoulders. In hindsight, it seems awfully easy to say Lights was always destined to play out more powerfully on the small screen, but the film stands up pretty well on its own; as Michael O’Sullivan wrote for the Washington Post, “The movie is full of both crushing disappointment and hope, resignation and joy, ugliness and great beauty.”

Watch Trailer

6. Daddy and Them (2001) 86%


Thornton and Miramax enjoyed a fairly fruitful relationship (see Sling Blade), but the industry is always changing — as are studio fortunes. You’d think the guy who won an Oscar for writing, directing, and starring in Sling Blade would have a blank check, but 2001’s Daddy and Them — made for a paltry $4 million — barely eked out a limited release before heading off to DVD. As far as critics were concerned, it was a shame: starring Thornton and Laura Dern as an Arkansas couple embroiled in family drama after his uncle gets carted off to the hoosegow for attempted murder, it earned praise from scribes such as Variety’s Edie Cockrell, who wrote, “Beneath its deadpan and often absurdist exterior, Daddy and Them feels like a very personal piece of work about how family really does come first, warts and all.”

Watch Trailer

5. Monster's Ball (2001) 85%


There are dark indie dramas, and then there’s Monster’s Ball. Starring Halle Berry as a widow raising her child after the death of her husband — and Thornton as the former prison guard who strikes up an affair with her after helping supervise his execution — it’s a film whose characters are flawed to the point that most of them spend much of the film doing awful things to the few who aren’t predisposed toward unspeakable cruelty. But if it didn’t leave most viewers feeling fuzzy inside, Ball was certainly warmly received: Berry won a Best Actress Oscar for her work, and Arizona Republic critic Bill Muller echoed the thoughts of many of his peers when he called it “A textbook example of fearless filmmaking, exhibiting a brand of gritty realism that’s hard to watch but impossible to ignore.”

Watch Trailer

4. A Simple Plan (1998) 90%


Are people inherently good or evil, or are their morals and ethics driven by the choices available to them? That’s the devilishly grim question at the heart of Sam Raimi’s A Simple Plan, an adaptation of the Scott Smith book about a pair of brothers (played by Thornton and Bill Paxton) who happen upon a downed plane full of cash during a hunting expedition with a friend (Brent Briscoe). One secret and one lie seem like a small price to pay for a $4.4 million windfall split three ways, but their simple plan begins to unravel surprisingly quickly, making the trio — and, by extension, the audience — helpless witnesses to an increasingly gruesome tumble into darkness. “A Simple Plan is a suspenseful, unnerving movie that ranks as one of the best thrillers in recent years,” marveled Mike McGranaghan for Aisle Seat. “The plot and characters converge nicely, and by the end, you are left to wonder how much money is enough to entice you to sell your soul.”

Watch Trailer

3. The Apostle (1998) 90%


Two years after Robert Duvall appeared in Billy Bob Thornton’s labor of love Sling Blade, Thornton repaid the favor, taking on a role as a town resident whose views and temperament threaten to cause problems for Duvall’s titular man of the cloth. Like Sling Blade, The Apostle found its leading man working behind the camera, directing from his own screenplay — and also like Thornton’s film, Duvall’s passion project united an unusual but well-seasoned ensemble that included Miranda Richardson, Farrah Fawcett, June Carter Cash, and Walton Goggins. The result, wrote Roger Ebert, “is like a lesson in how movies can escape from convention and penetrate the hearts of rare characters.”

Watch Trailer

2. Sling Blade (1996) 96%


Thornton had been around for awhile by the time he made Sling Blade, but it really marks the spot where he became a known quantity for moviegoers — and for power players in Hollywood, who sat up and took notice when it turned into an Oscar-winning sleeper hit. He wrote, directed, and starred in the rural-set drama, which centers on a developmentally disabled man who returns to his hometown years after being institutionalized for murdering his mother and her lover; not exactly cheerful stuff, but it was a story that resonated with filmgoers through its telling — and partly thanks to an eclectic cast that also included Robert Duvall, John Ritter, and Dwight Yoakam. “The lure of Sling Blade is both elemental and hauntingly familiar,” wrote’s Tom Keogh, “and I would not be surprised if Thornton’s breakthrough film is one day considered a classic in its own right.”

Watch Trailer

1. One False Move (1991) 94%


Its commercial prospects were fatally hobbled by a lack of studio faith so profound that it wasn’t even originally supposed to have a theatrical release, but thanks to overwhelmingly positive reviews, 1992’s One False Move — starring Thornton as the ringleader of a gang of criminals that runs afoul of an Arkansas sheriff (Bill Paxton) who teaches them a thing or two about small-town justice — ended up sneaking into theaters long enough for Gene Siskel to call it his favorite movie of the year. Siskel’s enthusiasm for the Carl Franklin-directed thriller was shared by the majority of his peers, including Michael Upchurch of the Seattle Times, who enthused, “Franklin’s convincing portrait of life on both sides of the color line isn’t quite like anything I’ve come across before, making One False Move one very assured directorial move. We need more filmmakers like him.”

Watch Trailer

Tag Cloud

ViacomCBS criterion serial killer Trophy Talk dramedy legend italian Oscar summer preview Sneak Peek screenings ABC Family Focus Features Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt king arthur cancelled TV series Pop TV book adaptation 2020 Baby Yoda Pirates Opinion south america cops quibi Walt Disney Pictures Sci-Fi action-comedy renewed TV shows venice space Arrowverse football Writers Guild of America joker asian-american 2016 dogs Fantasy Amazon Studios Masterpiece Kids & Family a nightmare on elm street marvel cinematic universe The Purge 72 Emmy Awards Video Games Comic-Con@Home 2021 PaleyFest new star wars movies latino medical drama festivals classics Fox Searchlight TCA Awards Travel Channel spy thriller Alien halloween tv SXSW Pet Sematary Family boxing Box Office game show Winter TV die hard scorecard fresh Amazon Prime Shudder Premiere Dates game of thrones Spring TV zombie BET Awards New York Comic Con Broadway National Geographic First Look OneApp green book SDCC adaptation 45 war films Biopics animated black comedy Action crime thriller theme song Musicals canceled adventure Watching Series Captain marvel cinemax Thanksgiving Best Director Election Lifetime Netflix The Arrangement cartoon dragons jamie lee curtis Spectrum Originals CBS comedies Anna Paquin slashers royal family independent halloween zero dark thirty crime Animation kaiju diversity Television Academy superhero comic book movies batman witnail PlayStation Pixar MGM french Mary Tyler Moore 2019 hist TCM Acorn TV Shondaland Winners 93rd Oscars Endgame razzies Film Drama Chernobyl YouTube Premium scene in color 73rd Emmy Awards period drama elevated horror BBC America sports hispanic heritage month The Academy live action james bond Classic Film TV movies Tumblr Reality documentaries Disney+ Disney Plus Star Wars Tokyo Olympics Wes Anderson stop motion DC Universe dc cults VH1 spanish language Red Carpet 2017 Summer live event Marvel Television worst movies USA Marvel Studios psychological thriller science fiction romance christmas movies American Society of Cinematographers satire X-Men RT21 wonder woman FX binge composers TruTV award winner Extras 21st Century Fox Holidays 2021 Oscars miniseries BBC 94th Oscars Hallmark Reality Competition romantic comedy Film Festival facebook festival President jurassic park YouTube Red toy story Rock TLC Western Cannes canceled TV shows political drama BET 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Grammys young adult rotten movies we love Polls and Games Music dark cars NBC unscripted RT History natural history movies Avengers obi wan BAFTA VOD popular rt archives Best Picture hidden camera Character Guide Black Mirror 2015 sopranos debate ESPN aapi Television Critics Association new york Ghostbusters know your critic based on movie blockbuster FXX technology Sundance Now South by Southwest Film Festival Pacific Islander Peacock 007 TCA 2017 Apple TV Plus SundanceTV streaming movies Crunchyroll crime drama Universal Pictures telelvision crossover Fox News Martial Arts universal monsters DC streaming service laika Disney Plus basketball child's play Tubi sequels blaxploitation The Walt Disney Company Paramount Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina YouTube lord of the rings tv talk Paramount Network Trivia Mary poppins Certified Fresh saw LGBTQ HBO Max CNN Best and Worst Rocketman E! 24 frames Brie Larson children's TV Tags: Comedy Universal Mystery cooking 1990s Amazon Prime Video biography casting what to watch singing competition monster movies critic resources Epix historical drama free movies sequel TV Land superman mission: impossible Lifetime Christmas movies Sony Pictures international Pride Month Hulu concert IFC richard e. Grant dexter SXSW 2022 chucky DC Comics AMC Teen thriller Neflix japanese twilight Calendar discovery Black History Month vampires APB black Super Bowl Legendary psycho VICE nbcuniversal spain Starz new zealand Pop Lionsgate Horror breaking bad The CW versus name the review finale Paramount revenge streamig dreamworks Vudu TV renewals Comics on TV video on demand cancelled Comedy Central Nickelodeon pirates of the caribbean anthology sitcom NBA television stand-up comedy Emmys vs. mutant suspense Cartoon Network Paramount Plus Set visit Elton John nfl Disney Warner Bros. sag awards scary movies Ovation CW Seed Awards Tour Marvel reboot feel good transformers BBC One franchise TCA obituary harry potter archives Discovery Channel Country gangster OWN Best Actress mockumentary Hear Us Out emmy awards king kong docuseries Podcast rotten ABC Dark Horse Comics E3 leaderboard Bravo blockbusters Tomatazos TCA Winter 2020 hollywood Infographic stoner Quiz book Superheroe art house Ellie Kemper summer TV WGN mob boxoffice YA Mary Poppins Returns kong HFPA Netflix Christmas movies doctor who 79th Golden Globes Awards Nat Geo remakes screen actors guild nature disaster Funimation Comic Book Academy Awards Image Comics ghosts cancelled TV shows deadpool genre Stephen King movie Rocky TNT History Lucasfilm news Cosplay rt labs critics edition slasher spanish Trailer mcc cats comics Spike toronto Tarantino Countdown Esquire Song of Ice and Fire fast and furious worst heist movie Valentine's Day parents directors target The Witch kids trailers Star Trek Musical See It Skip It CMT The Walking Dead Awards australia CBS All Access cancelled television TBS MCU streaming Disney Channel comic books Photos talk show Apple Rom-Com Sundance TV Fargo AMC Plus Showtime aliens ITV scary 2018 Holiday DirecTV MSNBC hispanic Best Actor HBO Go PBS reviews spider-man werewolf NYCC trophy TIFF Hallmark Christmas movies Year in Review IFC Films 4/20 Freeform Binge Guide golden globes IMDb TV politics Columbia Pictures MTV rom-coms FOX Exclusive Video Crackle Schedule Comedy Creative Arts Emmys Sundance Hollywood Foreign Press Association anime documentary foreign ID best Disney streaming service A24 series posters adenture DGA social media olympics San Diego Comic-Con comic GIFs LGBT Fall TV comiccon WarnerMedia ratings 20th Century Fox video summer TV preview biopic dceu police drama Mudbound Mindy Kaling Emmy Nominations spider-verse El Rey indie Britbox ABC Signature Turner Women's History Month 99% japan First Reviews Turner Classic Movies Marathons USA Network supernatural Adult Swim HBO Instagram Live Interview Logo Nominations strong female leads A&E TV Toys Amazon prank docudrama TV One justice league travel Syfy high school women 71st Emmy Awards GoT GLAAD critics godzilla Superheroes comic book movie Prime Video Christmas rt labs robots indiana jones true crime 90s Food Network FX on Hulu all-time teaser spinoff Heroines marvel comics zombies Apple TV+ golden globe awards