News

Winner Emerges in Rotten Tomatoes' Benedict Cumber-bracket

What happens when renowned British actor Benedict Cumberbatch becomes his own worst enemy? A character battle of epic proportions.


Doctor Stephen Strange Marvel Cinematic Universe Necromancer Sauron The Hobbit series Grinch The Grinch (Nov. 9, 2018 release) tiger photo standing in for Shere Khan (courtesy of Getty) Alan Turing The Imitation Game Thomas Edison The Current War Peter Guillam Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Classified Penguins of Madagascar Hamlet National Theatre Live Richard III The Hollow Crown Smaug The Hobbit series Severus Snape The Simpsons Khan Star Trek: Into Darkness Sherlock Holmes Sherlock Patrick Melrose Patrick Melrose (premieres 5/12) Julian Assange The Fifth Estate (Walt Disney Pictures; Warner Bros.; Todd Antony/Hartswood Films 2016 for MASTERPIECE; The Weinstein Company)

What happens when Benedict Cumberbatch goes head-to-head with … Benedict Cumberbatch? The British thespian’s biggest parts squared off against each other in an epic battle for character supremacy.

In a harrowing final contest that was neck-and-neck all the way through, Sherlock Holmes of Masterpiece series Sherlock wins by a hair! With 6,740 votes cast, Sherlock prevailed by only 41 votes over Avengers: Infinity War’s magical MVP.

Sherlock Holmes – 3,392 (50.3%)
Doctor Stephen Strange – 3,351 (49.7%)


How it worked

Voting began at 10 a.m. ET/7 a.m. PT on each of the following days:

  • COMPLETED! Monday, April 30 – vote in the Round 1 matches. (See round 1 results)
  • COMPLETED! Tuesday, May 1 – find out who won the Round 1 matches, and vote in Round 2. (See round 2 results)
  • COMPLETED! Wednesday, May 2 – find out who won the Round 2 matches, and vote in Round 3. (See round 3 results)
  • COMPLETED! Thursday, May 3 – find out who won the Round 3 matches, and vote in Round 4.
  • Friday, May 4 – find out who wins the Benedict Cumber-bracket!

Final Round

Results: Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3

Pages: 1 2 3 4 Next

Tag Cloud

BBC One TCA Winter 2020 Pop TV toy story Thanksgiving teaser Syfy Fall TV dc FOX classics venice Writers Guild of America strong female leads LGBTQ Television Academy romantic comedy Photos indie natural history Pop canceled TV shows RT History transformers crime comic Film spanish scorecard Set visit HBO Go 71st Emmy Awards foreign best ITV witnail directors discovery Mudbound halloween tv Winter TV FX on Hulu series 2020 cooking Awards Tour Universal sequel Turner social media Interview SXSW zombies travel movie zombie award winner YouTube Red films DGA Musical football talk show Music Crackle chucky spider-man WGN worst movies HBO Max MCU President Netflix Christmas movies GLAAD psycho The Arrangement 24 frames Cartoon Network Columbia Pictures Marathons PlayStation Television Critics Association CMT anime cinemax Creative Arts Emmys nfl movies Song of Ice and Fire Sci-Fi CBS 007 Esquire BAFTA cats technology comedies Mystery binge 72 Emmy Awards video Character Guide First Look scary movies Film Festival zero dark thirty Lionsgate Holidays adaptation Western 2015 werewolf American Society of Cinematographers Spring TV Toys Video Games LGBT Netflix 2018 dramedy Hear Us Out Walt Disney Pictures Oscars Teen spinoff Dark Horse Comics Britbox satire Animation TCM MSNBC Comic Book dceu reviews war BET cancelled anthology WarnerMedia kids revenge Box Office Turner Classic Movies VICE Kids & Family free movies Drama joker Captain marvel hollywood political drama Heroines APB Comedy Masterpiece concert IFC Films reboot Martial Arts Trailer universal monsters independent period drama crime thriller Certified Fresh twilight Spectrum Originals Election adventure biography NBC comiccon Disney Channel all-time renewed TV shows rotten dark canceled Fantasy Tomatazos finale comics BBC America game show Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TNT Travel Channel laika halloween Starz boxoffice Apple Spike french Calendar First Reviews Disney+ Disney Plus news TLC Anna Paquin 21st Century Fox richard e. Grant Action The CW TV Land The Witch hist Shondaland Star Wars HBO ABC TIFF 2019 Holiday Sundance Pixar worst indiana jones mockumentary child's play christmas movies screen actors guild medical drama Cosplay TCA Awards unscripted VOD TCA 2017 Grammys ratings Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Food Network PBS Warner Bros. obituary GIFs Polls and Games Endgame Marvel Studios Academy Awards a nightmare on elm street science fiction USA animated OWN Nominations Apple TV Plus El Rey Shudder Sundance TV Podcast Premiere Dates sitcom ESPN SundanceTV X-Men Ellie Kemper parents stoner Vudu Disney streaming service FXX festival Tumblr E3 Extras Rock Cannes based on movie remakes Schedule disaster 45 CW Seed TruTV nature Comics on TV Elton John Amazon OneApp singing competition emmy awards book Mary poppins TV Funimation stop motion Lucasfilm Watching Series versus breaking bad theme song The Walking Dead quibi sequels Valentine's Day Marvel composers cancelled television Sundance Now archives Lifetime Crunchyroll Sony Pictures sag awards Opinion spanish language PaleyFest Baby Yoda Pet Sematary USA Network YouTube Premium Biopics YouTube toronto Emmys doctor who YA Apple TV+ Rocky Nickelodeon Superheroes Mary Poppins Returns blaxploitation spy thriller Comedy Central space RT21 Arrowverse A&E Lifetime Christmas movies NYCC Rom-Com IFC 2017 Sneak Peek TCA sports National Geographic Logo Mary Tyler Moore FX stand-up comedy latino Women's History Month batman Country Amazon Prime Brie Larson thriller Showtime Disney elevated horror critics Avengers game of thrones true crime Superheroe docudrama cancelled TV series Ghostbusters BET Awards cars cults Chernobyl nbcuniversal Classic Film Paramount Infographic Pirates children's TV Best and Worst festivals politics A24 hispanic rotten movies we love See It Skip It crossover Paramount Network aliens CBS All Access San Diego Comic-Con Winners Stephen King Horror Fox Searchlight cartoon Marvel Television dragons E! robots harry potter dogs Hulu japanese Awards franchise Amazon Prime Video Super Bowl Adult Swim Nat Geo Black Mirror Tubi Hallmark justice league Bravo GoT jamie lee curtis The Purge AMC Quiz Rocketman diversity History green book Binge Guide Freeform Christmas golden globes MTV SDCC DirecTV ghosts 4/20 Trophy Talk cancelled TV shows supernatural psychological thriller mission: impossible Hallmark Christmas movies DC streaming service spain blockbuster TBS superhero italian Emmy Nominations Peacock crime drama Musicals Fox News CNN mutant 2016 screenings Countdown DC Comics facebook streaming Pride Month 20th Century Fox Acorn TV Summer video on demand Year in Review miniseries Red Carpet DC Universe Reality Mindy Kaling documentaries Reality Competition ABC Family slashers name the review Ovation die hard Family fast and furious police drama VH1 criterion cops Black History Month Disney Plus television Star Trek Epix documentary south america TV renewals serial killer tv talk The Academy asian-american vampires casting BBC Discovery Channel Tarantino historical drama romance Amazon Studios New York Comic Con Trivia what to watch