Critics Consensus

Annabelle: Creation Is a Potent Prequel

Plus, The Glass Castle is a bumpy biopic , critics aren't down with Nutty by Nature, and Mr. Mercedes Season 1 is Certified Fresh.

by | August 10, 2017 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got an origin story for an evil toy (Annabelle: Creation, starring Anthony LaPaglia and Miranda Otto), an adaptation of an incredible memoir (The Glass Castle, starring Brie Larson and Woody Harrelson), and a squirrel fighting City Hall (The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature, featuring the voices of Will Arnett and Katherine Heigl). What are the critics saying?


Annabelle: Creation (2017) 71%


For filmgoers old enough to remember the days of regularly issued Friday the 13th and Nightmare on Elm Street sequels, the idea of a horror franchise that retains its spine-tingling effectiveness as it goes along — to say nothing of actually improving — might sound more than a little absurd. There’s an exception to every rule, however, and the spookily consistent Conjuring series seems ready to keep making bumps in the night (and at the box office) for the foreseeable future: while 2014’s Annabelle spinoff failed to resonate with critics, it scared up enough ticket receipts to warrant a sequel — and as reviews for this weekend’s Annabelle: Creation attest, this is one creepy-looking doll who’s far from finished making filmgoers scream. Critics say this prequel story doesn’t do much audiences haven’t seen before, but for once, the old genre tropes are trotted out in service of a well-told story whose effective scares are bolstered by strong atmosphere and acting. Grab a few friends and get ready for a solidly undemanding horror outing — and maybe plan on sleeping with the lights on for a few nights too.


The Glass Castle (2017) 52%


For those in search of a sadly more realistic brand of horror this weekend, there’s The Glass Castle, which reunites director Destin Daniel Cretton with his Short Term 12 star Brie Larson in a dramatization of author Jeannette Walls’ bestselling autobiography. Starring Larson as Walls opposite Woody Harrelson and Naomi Watts as the mother and father of the family, Castle details the peripatetic lifestyle and abject poverty in which the four Walls children grew up, as well as their painful path to adult independence from their dysfunctional parents. It’s undeniably compelling material for a memoir, let alone a screen adaptation; unfortunately, critics say The Glass Castle doesn’t quite do it justice, setting out to split the difference between harrowing and heartwarming and failing to fully hit either mark. Still, there’s a tremendous cast here, united in service of one heck of a real-life story, and Castle‘s stronger elements aren’t always overpowered by its flaws. If you’re in the mood for adult drama or in need of a good cry, this just might hit the spot.

The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature (2017) 14%


Much of the time, being a movie critic seems like a pretty sweet gig: You get to see the big films before everyone else, you’re being paid to do something most people do for fun, and if you’re lucky and/or talented enough to reach an audience, you enjoy a certain measure of cultural gatekeeper status. There’s a downside to everything, however, and for many film critics, it takes the shape of releases like The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature. A follow-up to the 2014 original — which amassed a grim 10 percent on the Tomatometer but raked in more than $120 million worldwide — this installment reunites members of the voice cast (including Will Arnett and Katherine Heigl) for another colorfully animated adventure about talking critters facing a crisis. Will Surly and the gang be able to foil the mayor’s plan to turn their home into an amusement park? We’re pretty sure you can guess how it’ll all turn out, just as you could have predicted critics wouldn’t exactly be enthused about having to turn out for a Nut Job sequel. Like a lot of poorly reviewed cartoons, Nutty by Nature should prove reasonably diverting for the youngest audience members, but there’s no shortage of clearly superior alternative options.

What’s New on TV

Mr. Mercedes: Season 1 (2017) 86%

Mr. Mercedes propels its tense, creepy narrative with quick-witted dialogue, strong characters, and terrifying surprises.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Farthest (2017) , a documentary about the incredible journey of the spacecraft Voyager, is at 100 percent.
  • After Love (L'économie du couple) (2017) , a French dramedy about the fallout endured by a family after a husband and wife decide to split up but both refuse to leave their home, is at 97 percent.
  • In This Corner of the World (Kono sekai no katasumi ni) (2017) , an animated drama about a young Japanese girl’s experiences during World War II, is at 97 percent.
  • Whose Streets? (2017) , a documentary look at the civil unrest that erupted in Ferguson, Missouri after the killing of Michael Brown, is at 97 percent.
  • Good Time (2017) , starring Robert Pattinson as a failed bank robber trying to work his younger brother and himself out of a desperate situation, is Certified Fresh at 90 percent.
  • Ingrid Goes West (2017) , starring Aubrey Plaza as a woman who befriends her celebrity stalking obsession, is Certified Fresh at 85 percent.
  • The Trip to Spain (2017)Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon‘s latest chatty travelogue, is at 82 percent.
  • Nocturama (2017) , in which Parisian teens plot to carry off a violent act, is at 80 percent.
  • The Ghoul (2017) , about a police detective whose latest case draws him to the brink of a total breakdown, is at 76 percent.
  • Pilgrimage (2017) , about the perilous journey undertaken by 13th-century monks transporting a holy relic, is at 74 percent.
  • The Nile Hilton Incident (2017) , about a Cairo cop pursuing a case that could expose widespread political corruption, is at 60 percent.
  • The Only Living Boy in New York (2017) , about a young man whose first uncertain steps into adulthood are thrown off by the discovery of his father’s affair, is at 25 percent.
  • The Summoning (Planetarium) (2017) , starring Natalie Portman and Lily-Rose Depp as a pair of fortune tellers lured into a businessman’s world of intrigue, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

Superheroe Election directors Amazon Prime Fox News Crackle documentary quibi BET best finale hist The Walking Dead dogs Certified Fresh YA breaking bad Comedy Central Endgame Trophy Talk A&E Mary Tyler Moore Film Festival die hard PlayStation latino 2016 cooking 007 television asian-american spanish language YouTube Apple Disney mission: impossible Nat Geo documentaries Captain marvel Shondaland Columbia Pictures Emmys IFC Films Classic Film parents Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spain Horror BBC One 2015 CBS All Access Tubi Shudder adventure Arrowverse game show TV Land jamie lee curtis TIFF 2019 Rom-Com facebook teaser Pop 2018 Hear Us Out unscripted Christmas 71st Emmy Awards DC streaming service war Turner Classic Movies Film romantic comedy revenge batman FX Ellie Kemper The Arrangement elevated horror TCA Winter 2020 Comics on TV canceled TV shows Apple TV Plus WarnerMedia Amazon Studios AMC Super Bowl Comic Book screenings LGBT stoner MCU Creative Arts Emmys TV cancelled TV series technology Star Trek Western Reality Competition Disney+ Disney Plus comedies New York Comic Con HBO Go rotten movies we love Mindy Kaling First Look Esquire Avengers GLAAD Schedule Fall TV robots Syfy Marvel Television Amazon all-time cults Ovation History twilight First Reviews TBS Sundance Now slashers Trivia The Witch Opinion Comedy Pixar green book Podcast psycho game of thrones films Superheroes Pet Sematary what to watch Photos Mystery golden globes crime drama National Geographic disaster HBO Musical Binge Guide Lucasfilm Disney streaming service mockumentary American Society of Cinematographers Marvel strong female leads Sci-Fi Country police drama 45 natural history DC Universe kids BET Awards thriller Pop TV dceu San Diego Comic-Con Apple TV+ foreign Animation Rocky Family ESPN Disney Plus book Grammys Spike PBS Hallmark Christmas movies biography Baby Yoda spinoff richard e. Grant FX on Hulu Sundance TCA 2017 Ghostbusters satire a nightmare on elm street Television Academy transformers Spring TV See It Skip It Mary poppins Turner screen actors guild psychological thriller Vudu MTV dc Song of Ice and Fire cars FOX doctor who Logo Starz Biopics medical drama cancelled Rocketman NBC ITV Watching Series Holidays CMT cops ratings Lifetime Christmas movies adaptation Music Thanksgiving name the review south america crime harry potter Summer cancelled television HBO Max Chernobyl series OWN Sneak Peek Star Wars Cannes El Rey TCA MSNBC Writers Guild of America children's TV Nickelodeon space Stephen King Disney Channel comics spider-man tv talk DGA Interview zombie diversity DirecTV versus Extras animated nature Universal free movies miniseries Hallmark BBC Tumblr Musicals Tomatazos 20th Century Fox Netflix justice league anthology 2017 WGN SDCC The CW TruTV TCM Food Network festivals dark reboot serial killer critics politics talk show FXX Academy Awards dragons Black History Month USA Network President Hulu video on demand LGBTQ sag awards theme song RT21 emmy awards universal monsters joker USA Reality Red Carpet YouTube Premium 21st Century Fox CW Seed discovery werewolf Warner Bros. Premiere Dates docudrama Polls and Games Nominations cats IFC 2020 BAFTA Television Critics Association Fantasy Tarantino Box Office VH1 Winners VICE Drama Crunchyroll NYCC christmas movies Awards Paramount Network Bravo blockbuster YouTube Red vampires CBS X-Men zero dark thirty indiana jones mutant Adult Swim Mudbound Discovery Channel Spectrum Originals Action political drama TNT dramedy Travel Channel blaxploitation Women's History Month Heroines Calendar historical drama Video Games reviews movie Dark Horse Comics Winter TV streaming SundanceTV social media DC Comics sequel concert Holiday Best and Worst cancelled TV shows Elton John Rock Anna Paquin Amazon Prime Video Lifetime criterion stand-up comedy OneApp Brie Larson Freeform binge GoT Kids & Family sports E! Netflix Christmas movies GIFs halloween anime based on movie Pirates zombies Pride Month canceled travel child's play true crime TLC ABC Family crime thriller TCA Awards Paramount hispanic comiccon Martial Arts Sundance TV aliens A24 Oscars scary movies ghosts 4/20 comic Mary Poppins Returns Teen franchise science fiction boxoffice chucky supernatural Masterpiece Quiz CNN sitcom casting Cartoon Network movies Trailer Acorn TV APB VOD Lionsgate Black Mirror Character Guide RT History TV renewals crossover Epix witnail Countdown award winner cartoon Peacock romance video The Purge Funimation composers Walt Disney Pictures Valentine's Day SXSW ABC Marvel Studios singing competition Toys Set visit Marathons BBC America 24 frames Showtime Emmy Nominations Cosplay news Infographic renewed TV shows spy thriller Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Sony Pictures Britbox Awards Tour toy story period drama cinemax independent indie Year in Review E3 PaleyFest