Critics Consensus

Annabelle: Creation Is a Potent Prequel

Plus, The Glass Castle is a bumpy biopic , critics aren't down with Nutty by Nature, and Mr. Mercedes Season 1 is Certified Fresh.

by | August 10, 2017 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got an origin story for an evil toy (Annabelle: Creation, starring Anthony LaPaglia and Miranda Otto), an adaptation of an incredible memoir (The Glass Castle, starring Brie Larson and Woody Harrelson), and a squirrel fighting City Hall (The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature, featuring the voices of Will Arnett and Katherine Heigl). What are the critics saying?


Annabelle: Creation (2017) 70%


For filmgoers old enough to remember the days of regularly issued Friday the 13th and Nightmare on Elm Street sequels, the idea of a horror franchise that retains its spine-tingling effectiveness as it goes along — to say nothing of actually improving — might sound more than a little absurd. There’s an exception to every rule, however, and the spookily consistent Conjuring series seems ready to keep making bumps in the night (and at the box office) for the foreseeable future: while 2014’s Annabelle spinoff failed to resonate with critics, it scared up enough ticket receipts to warrant a sequel — and as reviews for this weekend’s Annabelle: Creation attest, this is one creepy-looking doll who’s far from finished making filmgoers scream. Critics say this prequel story doesn’t do much audiences haven’t seen before, but for once, the old genre tropes are trotted out in service of a well-told story whose effective scares are bolstered by strong atmosphere and acting. Grab a few friends and get ready for a solidly undemanding horror outing — and maybe plan on sleeping with the lights on for a few nights too.


The Glass Castle (2017) 52%


For those in search of a sadly more realistic brand of horror this weekend, there’s The Glass Castle, which reunites director Destin Daniel Cretton with his Short Term 12 star Brie Larson in a dramatization of author Jeannette Walls’ bestselling autobiography. Starring Larson as Walls opposite Woody Harrelson and Naomi Watts as the mother and father of the family, Castle details the peripatetic lifestyle and abject poverty in which the four Walls children grew up, as well as their painful path to adult independence from their dysfunctional parents. It’s undeniably compelling material for a memoir, let alone a screen adaptation; unfortunately, critics say The Glass Castle doesn’t quite do it justice, setting out to split the difference between harrowing and heartwarming and failing to fully hit either mark. Still, there’s a tremendous cast here, united in service of one heck of a real-life story, and Castle‘s stronger elements aren’t always overpowered by its flaws. If you’re in the mood for adult drama or in need of a good cry, this just might hit the spot.

The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature (2017) 15%


Much of the time, being a movie critic seems like a pretty sweet gig: You get to see the big films before everyone else, you’re being paid to do something most people do for fun, and if you’re lucky and/or talented enough to reach an audience, you enjoy a certain measure of cultural gatekeeper status. There’s a downside to everything, however, and for many film critics, it takes the shape of releases like The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature. A follow-up to the 2014 original — which amassed a grim 10 percent on the Tomatometer but raked in more than $120 million worldwide — this installment reunites members of the voice cast (including Will Arnett and Katherine Heigl) for another colorfully animated adventure about talking critters facing a crisis. Will Surly and the gang be able to foil the mayor’s plan to turn their home into an amusement park? We’re pretty sure you can guess how it’ll all turn out, just as you could have predicted critics wouldn’t exactly be enthused about having to turn out for a Nut Job sequel. Like a lot of poorly reviewed cartoons, Nutty by Nature should prove reasonably diverting for the youngest audience members, but there’s no shortage of clearly superior alternative options.

What’s New on TV

Mr. Mercedes: Season 1 (2017) 86%

Mr. Mercedes propels its tense, creepy narrative with quick-witted dialogue, strong characters, and terrifying surprises.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Farthest (2017) , a documentary about the incredible journey of the spacecraft Voyager, is at 100 percent.
  • After Love (L'économie du couple) (2017) , a French dramedy about the fallout endured by a family after a husband and wife decide to split up but both refuse to leave their home, is at 97 percent.
  • In This Corner of the World (Kono sekai no katasumi ni) (2017) , an animated drama about a young Japanese girl’s experiences during World War II, is at 97 percent.
  • Whose Streets? (2017) , a documentary look at the civil unrest that erupted in Ferguson, Missouri after the killing of Michael Brown, is at 97 percent.
  • Good Time (2017) , starring Robert Pattinson as a failed bank robber trying to work his younger brother and himself out of a desperate situation, is Certified Fresh at 90 percent.
  • Ingrid Goes West (2017) , starring Aubrey Plaza as a woman who befriends her celebrity stalking obsession, is Certified Fresh at 85 percent.
  • The Trip to Spain (2017)Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon‘s latest chatty travelogue, is at 82 percent.
  • Nocturama (2017) , in which Parisian teens plot to carry off a violent act, is at 80 percent.
  • The Ghoul (2017) , about a police detective whose latest case draws him to the brink of a total breakdown, is at 76 percent.
  • Pilgrimage (2017) , about the perilous journey undertaken by 13th-century monks transporting a holy relic, is at 74 percent.
  • The Nile Hilton Incident (2017) , about a Cairo cop pursuing a case that could expose widespread political corruption, is at 60 percent.
  • The Only Living Boy in New York (2017) , about a young man whose first uncertain steps into adulthood are thrown off by the discovery of his father’s affair, is at 25 percent.
  • The Summoning (Planetarium) (2017) , starring Natalie Portman and Lily-Rose Depp as a pair of fortune tellers lured into a businessman’s world of intrigue, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

richard e. Grant Marvel Studios Stephen King 20th Century Fox Disney Channel PBS strong female leads Dark Horse Comics Tarantino Polls and Games Box Office harry potter Captain marvel sequel DirecTV Toys CMT Superheroes free movies supernatural Rock ITV cartoon TIFF 71st Emmy Awards halloween Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Emmys social media vampires comiccon versus Comic Book foreign Mindy Kaling E! Crackle Mary Tyler Moore movies VICE cooking The Arrangement Election 45 Amazon Prime Awards New York Comic Con award winner cancelled TV shows Comics on TV Hulu Interview cars Lifetime miniseries Extras Premiere Dates Character Guide sitcom serial killer ESPN zero dark thirty Television Academy canceled Marathons Pirates Marvel Television comics indie justice league 24 frames Comedy Central YouTube Nominations Classic Film TV Land teaser natural history Sneak Peek 2019 TLC FXX PaleyFest Sundance joker facebook Pet Sematary Star Wars Women's History Month Infographic Binge Guide disaster Rom-Com Shudder Sundance Now spinoff NBC travel GIFs USA Paramount Nat Geo children's TV medical drama Countdown Ovation Grammys Animation Logo RT History anime game show ABC Family A&E SDCC Hallmark Ghostbusters Lionsgate Marvel CW Seed Walt Disney Pictures Opinion CBS zombies HBO Max DGA crime thriller latino dramedy WarnerMedia Fox News kids doctor who cancelled television Cosplay cults Britbox psychological thriller Ellie Kemper Netflix technology science fiction Pixar Esquire A24 thriller discovery Cannes Emmy Nominations sports boxoffice 2018 Oscars ghosts Trivia cancelled 2020 Thanksgiving war crime talk show Writers Guild of America Valentine's Day SundanceTV Country X-Men CBS All Access Lifetime Christmas movies MSNBC Starz NYCC Warner Bros. Rocketman RT21 Showtime binge Drama Mystery composers APB IFC Films werewolf TV Epix dc adaptation Reality Competition batman 21st Century Fox Disney Plus mutant Fall TV dragons Creative Arts Emmys IFC biography theme song Super Bowl Awards Tour comic diversity Horror Arrowverse book christmas movies 007 space crime drama Hallmark Christmas movies Tumblr Turner Classic Movies Apple TV Plus Bravo Best and Worst MTV First Look CNN aliens zombie true crime National Geographic Video Games politics Heroines spain Set visit GoT Podcast series Star Trek ratings Comedy romantic comedy renewed TV shows canceled TV shows TruTV Shondaland Syfy video Mary poppins south america TV renewals WGN AMC television TBS Disney streaming service Mary Poppins Returns Holidays DC streaming service The Walking Dead YA TCM what to watch Mudbound BBC America screenings The CW Apple police drama jamie lee curtis cancelled TV series spy thriller DC Comics dceu cinemax Disney TNT Pop blaxploitation Musicals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina revenge Photos Nickelodeon Black Mirror HBO Kids & Family Red Carpet Cartoon Network Sci-Fi Masterpiece anthology romance FOX DC Universe adventure Biopics Martial Arts 2015 History Christmas Vudu historical drama Netflix Christmas movies Watching Series Tomatazos Peacock Disney+ Disney Plus OWN slashers cats Winter TV The Purge Song of Ice and Fire game of thrones Rocky Sony Pictures spider-man Lucasfilm hispanic YouTube Premium Teen See It Skip It LGBT tv talk Acorn TV witnail robots Brie Larson BET cops transformers Spectrum Originals Year in Review The Witch Spring TV Reality Action Paramount Network based on movie USA Network Apple TV+ Holiday spanish language Adult Swim Calendar Superheroe animated Fantasy MCU Western TCA FX toy story Film quibi SXSW casting Spike Amazon Prime Video docudrama period drama San Diego Comic-Con festivals Summer mockumentary breaking bad Quiz Columbia Pictures streaming 2017 TCA 2017 Freeform hist Family crossover Film Festival Trophy Talk unscripted political drama 2016 Crunchyroll nature Trailer Schedule Winners VH1 singing competition Musical YouTube Red Anna Paquin rotten movies we love Food Network E3 BBC psycho ABC American Society of Cinematographers finale El Rey stand-up comedy elevated horror Certified Fresh golden globes LGBTQ independent Music First Reviews GLAAD President Elton John Amazon Universal blockbuster Chernobyl green book Pride Month Turner