News

Annabelle Comes Home First Reviews: A Fun but Not Particularly Scary Monster Mash

Critics say the summer's second killer doll movie unfolds like a ghoulish theme park ride that expands the Conjuring Universe, for better or worse.

by | June 24, 2019 | Comments

Since its stellar start back in 2013, the Conjuring Universe has been a bumpy ride with critics. Even the Annabelle spin-offs have been met with a mix of positive and negative reviews. Now the third of that specific series, Annabelle Comes Home (the seventh in the overall cinematic universe), is itself garnering a mixture of responses. Some think its variety of monsters make for a fun outing, while others see the concept as too gimmicky and not scary enough for this brand of horror movie. One thing all seem to agree on, though, is that it’s full of more franchise fodder.

Here’s what critics are saying about Annabelle Comes Home:


How does it fit into the Conjuring Universe?

A breath of fresh air for the Conjuring Universe that both surprises with a lighter touch and demonstrates the incredible potential for the expanding continuity.
– Eric Eisenberg, CinemaBlend

Annabelle Comes Home is textured differently than the other films in the Conjuring Universe, yet it fits comfortably right into the legacy.
– Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Annabelle Comes Home never loses the streak of genuine humanity that sets the Conjuring movies apart from many of its horror franchise counterparts.
– William Bibbiani, Bloody Disgusting

Cheekily reflects the drive-in popcorn thrillers from the period in which the movie is set more than it does the other films in the series.
– Oliver Jones, Observer

It’s a mix of high points and low points, much like the overall series itself.
– Rafer Guzman, Newsday

Despite being a perfectly fine addition to the series, Annabelle Comes Home is just not as inventive or creepy or even scary as some of the other Conjuring films.
– Edward Douglas, The Beat


New Line Cinema
(Photo by New Line Cinema)

How does it compare to the other Annabelle movies?

Easily the best film in the Annabelle franchise.
Alyse Wax, ComingSoon.net

Annabelle Comes Home cements the Annabelle trilogy as a rare series that gets better with every installment.
Eric Eisenberg, CinemaBlend

Pure joy… better than ever.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Maybe the most hyper and generic.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

If Annabelle Comes Home should be the last Annabelle-centric film in the series, it feels like a perfect final chapter.
Juliet Bennett Rylah, IGN Movies


Is there too much to this installment?

Name your fear trigger, and it’s probably there, somewhere, in Annabelle Comes Home… it’s really the horror equivalent of speed dating.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

It felt a lot like Scooby-Doo: Monsters Unleashed.. Whatever you’re creeped out by, Annabelle Comes Home has got you covered.
Patrick Cavanaugh, The Wolfman Cometh

If the Conjuring franchise has run low on original methods of making ghosts jump-out-of-your-seat scary, then Dauberman has found a workaround in diversity.
Andy Crump, Paste Magazine

Starts to feel like a stack of random ideas.
Rafer Guzman, Newsday


New Line Cinema
(Photo by New Line Cinema)

Does it just feel like it’s made to introduce more spin-offs?

Annabelle Comes Home suffers, I think, from a mercantile quality, the sense you’re watching multiple elevator pitches crammed into feature shape.
Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

It kind of feels like we are getting a preview of what the next handful of films in the Conjuring Universe will be.
Alyse Wax, ComingSoon.net

There are more than a couple of evil entities featured that could eventually generate their own special branch of the Conjuring Universe.
Eric Eisenberg, CinemaBlend


Any favorites that could be spawned next?

I would bet money on either The Ferryman, The Wedding Dress or The Black Shuck getting a green light in coming weeks.
Benjamin Lee, Guardian

[Of] the new potential franchise spin-offs… by far the ferryman seems the most fleshed out of the line-up. He also had the best scares.
Joelle Monique, Geeks of Color

They’re all worthy of their own spin-offs.
William Bibbiani, Bloody Disgusting


Is it fun?

Annabelle Comes Home is lively, energetic and even fun…a hoot from start to finish.
Andy Crump, Paste Magazine

The best moments in this low-key domestic horror film have a tossed-off quality, like the whole production cycle was a fun weekend for everybody.
Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

Annabelle Comes Home often feels like a fun, periodically thrilling and slightly claustrophobic horror-tinged theme park ride.
Oliver Jones, Observer

An exceedingly fun ride.
Eric Eisenberg, CinemaBlend


New Line Cinema
(Photo by New Line Cinema)

But is it also scary enough?

Simply put, it’s a kaleidoscope of nightmare fuel.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

While previous chapters have taken sharper aim at generating nightmares, this is a horror movie particularly aimed at audiences who have fun being scared by horror movies.
Eric Eisenberg, CinemaBlend

The body count may be low but the peril is extreme.
William Bibbiani, Bloody Disgusting

What constantly amazes me about these movies is how the franchise still finds new ways to scare and freak you out.
Edward Douglas, The Beat

The thrills and shocks gradually become repetitive, as the writer-director recycles his own material.
Justin Lowe, Hollywood Reporter

There are some genuinely creative and beautifully shot scares.
Juliet Bennett Rylah, IGN Movies

The fake scares in Annabelle Comes Home are scarier than the real scares.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

The scariest thing about Annabelle Comes Home is that despite its utter emptiness, more sequels, prequels and spin-offs will follow regardless.
Benjamin Lee, Guardian


How does franchise writer Gary Dauberman do in his directorial debut?

He did a great job. He has lived in the Conjuring Universe for so long, he really knew the characters, the story, and what audiences want.
Alyse Wax, ComingSoon.net

First time director Gary Dauberman, who also wrote not only this movie but also The Nun, shows a lot of promise.
Joelle Monique, Geeks of Color

An exciting debut for a first-time director… an impressive debut.
Eric Eisenberg, CinemaBlend


New Line Cinema
(Photo by New Line Cinema)

Are there any breakout cast members?

Katie Sarife, whose subtly shaded performance as the wildly incautious friend augurs a fine career in tough-yet-tender roles.
Jeannette Catsoulis, New York Times

Sarife makes an impression… think eerie-cool Jodie Foster in The Little Girl Who Lives Down the Lane.
Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

Mckenna Grace, terrific as a loner kid whose budding skills as a clairvoyant mirror her mother’s, is the one actor who stands out.
Oliver Jones, Observer

McKenna Grace is probably the strongest of the young cast… though none of them are able to sell the scares as previous actors we’ve seen in these movies.
Edward Douglas, The Beat


What does the movie get right?

Smart writing supported by superb performances.
Eric Eisenberg, CinemaBlend

What’s most effective… [are] the layered characters to which we grow attached. Otherwise, the frights would be meaningless.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

What makes this Annabelle film such a delight is that, even without the scares, it’s incredibly charming… as opposed to other installments attempting to terrify you to your bones.
Patrick Cavanaugh, The Wolfman Cometh

Despite its R rating, the most endearing thing about Annabelle Comes Home is that it’s nearly a kid-friendly Conjuring spin-off, a Goosebumps-y saga about the worst babysitting gig ever.
Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly


New Line Cinema
(Photo by New Line Cinema)

And what does it get wrong?

My only complaint about Annabelle Comes Home is that it is a little slow in the second act.
Alyse Wax, ComingSoon.net

If Annabelle Comes Home has a serious flaw it’s that it builds so much tension as we wait for the demons to attack that it collapses under its own weight after a while.
William Bibbiani, Bloody Disgusting

Takes so long to get moving that Annabelle herself should demand a do-over.
Jeannette Catsoulis, New York Times

The storytelling is undone by questionable character decisions and some odd stylistic choices.
Tim Grierson, Screen International

There’s a handsome framework but nothing at its center, a script that quickly eschews anything resembling a plot, choosing to bombard us with cheap funhouse trickery instead.
Benjamin Lee, Guardian

Annabelle Comes Home suffers from terminal blandness… the different ghouls are hit-or-miss, and they start to feel like level bosses.
Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly


Annabelle Comes Home opens in theaters June 26, 2019. 

#1
#1
Adjusted Score: 72.165%
Critics Consensus: Fun for fans even if it isn't as frightening as some of its predecessors, Annabelle Comes Home suggests there's still some life left in the Conjuring franchise.
Synopsis: Determined to keep Annabelle from wreaking more havoc, demonologists Ed and Lorraine Warren bring the possessed doll to the locked... [More]
Directed By: Gary Dauberman

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Song of Ice and Fire DGA X-Men WGN Polls and Games E! green book LGBT 2016 CBS 21st Century Fox LGBTQ Oscars Certified Fresh cults war Reality Star Wars 007 singing competition Ghostbusters MCU FXX based on movie crossover YouTube Premium Fall TV FX Mindy Kaling Thanksgiving Food Network zombie Cannes psycho San Diego Comic-Con PBS Rocky 2015 MTV Fox News Rocketman doctor who serial killer Walt Disney Pictures Nominations boxoffice comiccon SundanceTV Black Mirror Syfy facebook Netflix See It Skip It Sci-Fi The CW Sony Pictures Acorn TV Bravo Interview Emmy Nominations VICE Ellie Kemper Lucasfilm El Rey hist period drama Biopics Martial Arts Mary poppins historical drama Grammys Trophy Talk Watching Series golden globes DC Comics GoT Box Office Paramount Awards Freeform Red Carpet sitcom robots thriller Tomatazos APB TNT television Valentine's Day Quiz Heroines Superheroe Schedule spinoff Fantasy Nat Geo Rom-Com witnail anime Comic Book Mudbound Cartoon Network Podcast A&E true crime Amazon Prime dceu ESPN nature Star Trek Premiere Dates TBS Superheroes YA Elton John President Pixar First Look romance Summer History GIFs Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Country disaster Cosplay Shondaland Esquire RT21 Election Universal Apple richard e. Grant Writers Guild of America casting award winner sequel teaser OWN Lifetime Rock zero dark thirty Winter TV PaleyFest TLC Marathons TruTV Hulu biography TV Dark Horse Comics SXSW MSNBC Stephen King Trivia what to watch dramedy Spring TV spy thriller Photos Trailer American Society of Cinematographers Holidays Paramount Network Comedy Central talk show CMT Super Bowl mockumentary Nickelodeon Spectrum Originals cinemax adaptation RT History New York Comic Con vampires strong female leads sports Video Games Spike DirecTV miniseries supernatural Starz cops The Arrangement theme song Tumblr VH1 Year in Review dc Set visit CW Seed Warner Bros. aliens 2017 National Geographic TCM toy story cooking WarnerMedia Reality Competition Creative Arts Emmys Best and Worst IFC Films unscripted Pop Sundance Now HBO Max justice league Pet Sematary USA Network Adult Swim Anna Paquin Amazon Kids & Family composers SDCC Columbia Pictures Animation Pirates TCA 2017 CNN Calendar NYCC Shudder Drama Sneak Peek Character Guide Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt police drama 20th Century Fox Disney Channel Marvel dragons FOX Women's History Month ABC Family Chernobyl Countdown Musicals spider-man binge Sundance Action Extras 2018 TCA Ovation IFC technology Horror E3 jamie lee curtis Opinion anthology diversity crime drama ABC Mary Tyler Moore 24 frames Lionsgate Winners TIFF Disney natural history Christmas docudrama discovery DC streaming service Brie Larson Logo Masterpiece psychological thriller ITV game show festivals adventure social media 45 Musical Awards Tour Teen Captain marvel Mary Poppins Returns Crackle political drama DC Universe CBS All Access comic mutant cats Tarantino BBC America Pride Month travel The Witch space Film Festival BBC streaming Vudu HBO YouTube Red animated Toys AMC TV Land Comedy BET transformers harry potter 2019 Comics on TV GLAAD Western Emmys ratings Music Epix zombies blaxploitation Britbox USA crime thriller NBC Showtime science fiction medical drama Infographic elevated horror finale politics crime Mystery