Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Croods is Charming and Funny

Plus, Olympus Has Fallen is action-packed but silly, Admission meanders, and Spring Breakers is wild and crazy.

by | March 22, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a stone-age family (The Croods, with voice work by Nicolas Cage and Emma Stone); secret servicemen (Olympus Has Fallen, starring Gerard Butler and Aaron Eckhart); an Ivy League application reader (Admission, starring Tina Fey and Paul Rudd); and girls gone wild (Spring Breakers, starring Selena Gomez and James Franco). What do the critics have to say?

The Croods


Picking up where The Flintstones left off, The Croods is a comedy adventure about a Stone Age family. And critics say that while the storytelling in this animated feature isn’t highly evolved, it’s sweet, funny, and visually inventive. After the cave they call home is destroyed, a stone-age family journeys across its pre-historic environs, encountering wild beasts and learning to love and trust each other along the way. The pundits say The Croods lacks sharply-drawn characters, but it’s charming and exciting enough to delight both kids and their parents. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a look at the history of DreamWorks animation, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Nicolas Cage’s best-reviewed movies.)

Olympus Has Fallen


Is Olympus Has Fallen an enjoyable, over-the-top action flick or a jingoistic Die Hard ripoff? Well, it depends on which critic you ask. Gerard Butler stars as a disgraced secret service agent who’s called into action when the president (Aaron Eckhart) is held hostage in the White House by a group of ruthless terrorists. The pundits are pretty split on Olympus Has Fallen: some say it’s action-packed escapist fun, while others find it to be an excessively violent, by-the-numbers thriller. (Check out director Antoine Fuqua’s Five Favorite Films.)



Tina Fey and Paul Rudd in a romantic comedy? Sounds like a sure thing. Unfortunately, critics say the likable leads can only do so much with Admission‘s meandering script. Fey stars as a Princeton admissions officer burdened by the stresses of her romantic and professional life. She takes a road trip to see an old college classmate (Rudd) who’s now an unconventional teacher with a gifted but eccentric student who could use some help getting into college. The pundits say Admission is slight stuff, and though the fine cast keeps things watchable, the film veers unevenly between drama and comedy without finding a consistent tone.

Spring Breakers


Director Harmony Korine (Gummo) is known for pushing boundaries, but with Spring Breakers, he’s made something approximating a mainstream movie. Critics say it’s a pretty good fit; Spring Breakers is often debauched and trashy, but it’s also visceral and hypnotic. Selena Gomez and Vanessa Hudgens play members of a group of college girls who head to Florida to party but quickly get into trouble after meeting a rapper/criminal (James Franco). The pundits say Spring Breakers is undeniably lurid and occasionally monotonous, but it’s also thrilling and wildly unconventional. (Check out our interview with Korine here.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Gimme The Loot, a drama about a pair of graffiti artists looking to raise funds for a bold act of tagging, is at 100 percent.
  • My Brother The Devil, a drama about a pair of siblings who each find themselves drawn into the world of London’s street gangs, is at 100 percent.
  • 108 (Cuchillo de palo), a documentary about gay rights in Paraguay, is at 100 percent.
  • The Sapphires, a musical dramedy about a Australian Aboriginal soul group, is Certified Fresh at 92 percent.
  • Eden, starring Jamie Chung in a drama about a woman abducted into a human trafficking ring, is at 85 percent.
  • Starbuck, a comedy about a fourtysomething slacker who discovers he’s fathered hundreds of children through sperm back donations, is at 63 percent.
  • Hunky Dory, starring Minnie Driver in a comedy about a high school drama teacher who attempts to stage a glam rock version of The Tempest, is at 58 percent.
  • Come Out And Play, starring Vinessa Shaw in a horror film about a young couple on vacation who discover a band of possessed children, is at 50 percent.
  • Everybody Has a Plan, starring Viggo Mortensen in a drama about a man who assumes the identity of his dead brother and finds himself in the midst of criminality, is at 20 percent.
  • Love And Honor, starring Liam Hemsworth and Teresa Palmer in a drama about a soldier who goes AWOL to win back the girl who dumped him, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

A&E San Diego Comic-Con 2018 Rock Tumblr 2019 TCA 2017 game show Brie Larson mutant TV Land Valentine's Day Mary Tyler Moore streaming Year in Review Tomatazos jamie lee curtis NYCC CNN transformers Masterpiece President Logo Cartoon Network Star Wars richard e. Grant American Society of Cinematographers aliens psychological thriller Infographic YouTube Premium Drama 2016 TLC Sundance Now Rocketman CW Seed Rom-Com TCM Columbia Pictures Spring TV Lucasfilm Pride Month CBS PaleyFest Syfy miniseries composers facebook adventure Box Office 2017 Nickelodeon serial killer Awards Tour Crackle crime drama The Witch witnail Food Network Disney Channel vampires Comics on TV Election Nominations VICE cinemax spinoff Reality APB MSNBC sitcom YA DC Comics what to watch Paramount Network Photos political drama Fall TV casting Acorn TV Winter TV binge Elton John natural history Creative Arts Emmys technology robots DC streaming service VH1 harry potter mockumentary cats Music cults zero dark thirty SundanceTV politics crime Sony Pictures social media National Geographic DC Universe 007 Warner Bros. Schedule blaxploitation New York Comic Con FX Super Bowl Superheroe See It Skip It true crime Mary poppins ABC Family Sci-Fi RT21 teaser period drama Opinion Hulu 2015 Calendar television Stephen King Christmas Writers Guild of America ESPN doctor who Pop Freeform Horror TCA theme song GIFs Awards Mindy Kaling Ghostbusters Starz TV TruTV Country Musicals Adult Swim IFC Ellie Kemper Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Superheroes sports Polls and Games HBO Teen LGBT FXX E! dragons Trailer science fiction unscripted toy story strong female leads Dark Horse Comics SXSW Ovation History MTV Nat Geo Biopics AMC Musical Apple Pixar Winners golden globes Cannes Podcast CBS All Access CMT justice league 21st Century Fox crossover anthology zombie green book comic Lifetime finale disaster Fox News Comic Book supernatural BBC WGN The CW Martial Arts TBS Sneak Peek DGA Shudder El Rey thriller Quiz Spike First Look Spectrum Originals Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Premiere Dates Western NBC Set visit Toys Countdown GLAAD Marvel spider-man sequel Vudu Marathons dramedy TNT Esquire USA Network Animation The Arrangement adaptation Pet Sematary Reality Competition cops ITV Thanksgiving boxoffice Shondaland RT History Trivia Watching Series USA romance Interview nature YouTube Red biography Pirates Anna Paquin discovery crime thriller zombies war Trophy Talk Summer hist Comedy animated police drama talk show OWN Paramount Bravo Chernobyl PBS Song of Ice and Fire Captain marvel award winner Mystery Cosplay Rocky Certified Fresh SDCC Disney Star Trek BBC America BET Extras Lionsgate singing competition E3 Black Mirror Best and Worst 20th Century Fox Netflix elevated horror Red Carpet MCU Showtime ABC Amazon Prime 45 travel Grammys Women's History Month Holidays based on movie historical drama Britbox Film Festival Amazon docudrama Kids & Family GoT TIFF diversity X-Men 24 frames cooking Video Games festivals Action Universal Sundance LGBTQ anime spy thriller Oscars Heroines Emmys Tarantino medical drama psycho DirecTV Comedy Central dc Epix ratings dceu space Mudbound Mary Poppins Returns Character Guide IFC Films Fantasy comiccon Walt Disney Pictures FOX