Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: That Awkward Moment When Your Movie is Rotten

Plus, Labor Day can't rise above its unbelievable premise.

by | January 31, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got three single bros (That Awkward Moment, starring Zac Efron and Michael B. Jordan) and a family-oriented fugitive (Labor Day, starring Josh Brolin and Kate Winslet). What do the critics have to say?



That Awkward Moment

22%

If you’ve had your fill of movies featuring young women griping about their relationship woes, you’re in luck: That Awkward Moment is a movie featuring dudes griping about their relationship woes. Unfortunately, critics say that’s about all that distinguishes this romantic comedy, which saddles its talented young cast with a predictable plot and a shortage of witty lines. It’s the story of three friends (Zac Efron, Michael B. Jordan, and Miles Teller) who make a pact to stay single — that is, until each of them find themselves grappling with potential relationships. The pundits say That Awkward Moment attempts to make a statement about modern love, but it’s fatally short on both insight and believability. (And be sure to check out Miles Teller’s Five Favorite Films here.)



Labor Day

35%

Even the most preposterous scenario can be redeemed by a strong cast and a carefully sustained tone. Sadly, despite the best efforts of its leads, Labor Day fails to rise above its contrived premise. Josh Brolin stars as Frank, a convicted killer who escapes from prison and takes Adele (Kate Winslet), a depressed single mother, hostage in her own home. Over a long weekend, Adele falls for Frank, who takes up a position as the man of the house. The pundits say that Labor Day remains watchable because of Brolin and Winslet, but the material is ultimately too implausible to work as a whole. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Brolin’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • 12 O’clock Boys, a documentary about a group of teenage dirt bikers in Baltimore, is at 95 percent.
  • Tim’s Vermeer, a documentary by Teller about a Texas inventor researching the process behind the great Dutch painter’s works, is Certified Fresh at 94 percent.
  • Charlie Victor Romeo, a documentary about airline pilots dealing with in-flight emergencies, is at 85 percent.
  • Love Is In The Air, starring Ludivine Sagnier in a romantic dramedy about a pair of exes seated next to each other on a trans-Atlantic flight, is at 83 percent.
  • At Middleton, starring Andy Garcia and Vera Farmiga in a romantic comedy about two parents of prospective college students who bond on a campus tour, is at 56 percent.
  • The Wait, starring Chloë Sevigny and Jena Malone in a drama about a pair of sisters who hope to resurrect their recently deceased mother, is at 29 percent.
  • May I Kill U?, a black comedy about a mild-mannered bike cop who becomes a vigilante after a head injury, is at 15 percent.
  • Brightest Star, a drama about a young man who attempts to change himself in order to win the girl of his dreams, is at 14 percent.
  • Best Night Ever, a comedy from Jason Friedberg and Aaron Seltzer about a group of bachelorettes’ wild Vegas excursion, is at zero percent.

Finally, props to Chris Frost for coming the closest to guessing I, Frankenstein‘s six percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Mindy Kaling Film christmas movies documentary BBC One Epix Black Mirror Oscars sports war cancelled television TV movie game of thrones critics Universal Pirates Warner Bros. nbcuniversal dc Logo The CW cars adventure Disney Plus sitcom renewed TV shows romantic comedy TCM Lifetime Christmas movies Fantasy Acorn TV Showtime BBC America Video Games Musicals Polls and Games Superheroe Reality name the review 72 Emmy Awards revenge chucky Star Wars binge versus Bravo The Arrangement AMC batman GoT A&E cops Tomatazos robots 2017 The Walking Dead films PlayStation sequel Premiere Dates Dark Horse Comics 21st Century Fox worst movies obituary LGBTQ Action History Awards Disney Channel Comics on TV casting Columbia Pictures DC Comics dark Netflix Watching Series LGBT DC streaming service GLAAD transformers cinemax Nat Geo 71st Emmy Awards Mary poppins Apple TV+ Country television foreign satire YouTube Red 24 frames south america Winners classics Drama Music Lionsgate animated franchise Chernobyl Calendar kids Year in Review ratings Discovery Channel Disney streaming service Fox Searchlight Hallmark Hear Us Out cancelled TV series breaking bad See It Skip It composers indiana jones BBC festival SXSW mission: impossible Interview Academy Awards hispanic Masterpiece stoner video Awards Tour Paramount Network discovery fast and furious justice league best Amazon Prime Video green book dragons Tarantino Marvel technology book Trophy Talk Marvel Television Heroines hist E3 Ghostbusters documentaries rotten Song of Ice and Fire Syfy Certified Fresh IFC Quiz First Reviews Pride Month Walt Disney Pictures talk show Box Office Countdown Spike TCA Emmy Nominations Creative Arts Emmys TruTV PaleyFest french Best and Worst HBO Go Film Festival WGN Summer indie TIFF Teen biography parents independent ESPN Cosplay 2018 20th Century Fox japanese Thanksgiving USA MTV TCA Winter 2020 vampires TCA 2017 NYCC Captain marvel slashers serial killer Arrowverse Podcast Shudder comiccon DGA Netflix Christmas movies award winner halloween tv halloween CBS anthology Lifetime Christmas New York Comic Con Travel Channel DirecTV BET Awards die hard Brie Larson screenings game show TV renewals Reality Competition streaming dogs toronto facebook superhero singing competition strong female leads 45 FX Fall TV dceu Infographic doctor who spanish Western Sundance Now Winter TV sequels Crackle Rom-Com Nominations stand-up comedy unscripted Peacock true crime Biopics President Food Network supernatural Women's History Month Sundance YouTube Premium directors 2016 anime elevated horror stop motion Sundance TV natural history reboot Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt political drama ABC Family Anna Paquin Extras Horror spain mockumentary Photos Apple period drama cartoon crime Sony Pictures Comedy psycho American Society of Cinematographers screen actors guild werewolf BET 007 MCU blockbuster criterion Crunchyroll Mudbound Vudu TLC Adult Swim jamie lee curtis twilight hollywood mutant toy story thriller Grammys CMT free movies festivals aliens Rocky Comic Book based on movie Pet Sematary universal monsters Emmys A24 GIFs spy thriller BAFTA 4/20 Elton John blaxploitation teaser Endgame Stephen King HBO Max VICE The Witch Amazon asian-american ABC space movies Amazon Studios The Academy what to watch RT21 Tubi Pixar HBO comedies science fiction disaster Election San Diego Comic-Con series harry potter Holidays crime drama El Rey boxoffice Pop TV Set visit Writers Guild of America Funimation finale Sci-Fi child's play APB Red Carpet Ellie Kemper Disney Musical nfl video on demand VOD Animation Apple TV Plus scary movies Schedule children's TV TCA Awards Opinion latino docudrama TBS Marathons X-Men politics Character Guide CBS All Access quibi news Rock TNT FX on Hulu RT History venice E! a nightmare on elm street reviews Rocketman crime thriller YouTube Disney+ Disney Plus zombies remakes theme song medical drama social media sag awards 2019 scorecard SundanceTV spider-man canceled diversity italian Paramount football Amazon Prime zero dark thirty Binge Guide all-time Superheroes OneApp USA Network Black History Month tv talk TV Land Martial Arts concert Ovation OWN dramedy Cannes Lucasfilm cooking Cartoon Network Sneak Peek Britbox Spring TV laika comic Shondaland IFC Films police drama Super Bowl adaptation witnail cancelled Freeform Nickelodeon Trailer richard e. Grant FXX PBS Trivia comics joker VH1 zombie Mary Poppins Returns ITV Fox News NBC Baby Yoda 2020 Turner Classic Movies Esquire 2015 canceled TV shows cancelled TV shows CNN miniseries cats Star Trek crossover Turner Mystery Classic Film spinoff Kids & Family historical drama Spectrum Originals Hulu nature WarnerMedia SDCC Family Television Critics Association MSNBC worst archives Marvel Studios YA DC Universe spanish language emmy awards Pop Comedy Central Mary Tyler Moore golden globes CW Seed Tumblr ghosts Starz Holiday travel Valentine's Day Hallmark Christmas movies FOX Television Academy National Geographic psychological thriller First Look rotten movies we love Toys Avengers Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Purge cults romance