Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Paranormal Activity 2 Is A Solid, Scary Follow-up

Plus, Hereafter is an intriguing misfire.

by | October 22, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got spooky spectres (Paranormal Activity 2, starring Katie Featherston) and supernatural seekers (Hereafter, starring Matt Damon and Bryce Dallas Howard). What do the critics have to say?


Paranormal Activity 2

Upon its release, Paranormal Activity became something of a cult phenomenon — and the press was almost as intrigued by its budget-to-gross ratio as its lo-fi chills. Now, Paranormal Activity 2 is hitting theaters, and though it’s barely been screened for critics, those who have seen it say it’s a worthy — and very creepy — follow-up. Once again, there’s a house, there are strange, sinister goings-on, and there are cameras everywhere. However, the pundits say Paranormal 2 is no mere rehash — it’s smart, disturbing, and slow-burning, adding depth to the original while standing on its own. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we list some notable directors who got their starts in horror.)



As a director, Clint Eastwood deserves plenty of credit for refusing to play it safe in his august years. However, that doesn’t mean he’s always at the top of his game, and unfortunately, critics say the multi-stranded afterlife meditation Hereafter is an intriguing but ultimately murky misfire. After a French journalist has a near-death experience, she searches for answers; soon, she meets a man (Matt Damon) who can see beyond our worldly sphere. Pundits say Hereafter, despite its thought-provoking premise and sleek visuals, is a bit too melodramatic and dour to fully resonate.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Boxing Gym, legendary documentarian Frederick Wiseman’s examination of the sweet science, is at 92 percent.

  • Punching the Clown, a quasi-doc/satire about a struggling singer-songwriter, is at 86 percent.
  • Inhale, starring Dermot Mulroney and Diane Kruger in a drama about illegal organ-harvesting cartels, is at 42 percent.

  • Knucklehead, a WWE family comedy about a man who enters an MMA tourney to save an orphanage, is at 17 percent.
  • Kalamity, drama about a young man whose return home yields unwelcome secrets, is at zero percent.
  • Tag Cloud

    Avengers cults chucky DGA discovery nbcuniversal finale RT History talk show new york disaster rt archives TIFF Pop TV Turner Amazon OneApp scorecard 72 Emmy Awards Classic Film Spike political drama cartoon italian Marvel Television french comic book movie HFPA 2021 prank AMC Plus technology 4/20 festival casting spider-man SDCC Logo 2019 The Walt Disney Company festivals Starz christmas movies Arrowverse The Academy Thanksgiving DC Comics ESPN Nominations Marathons reboot mcc BAFTA Tags: Comedy godzilla Netflix Christmas movies green book BBC America BET Awards worst movies video Sony Pictures miniseries MCU Action Sundance witnail feel good kaiju Showtime biopic Mudbound A&E Awards Tour WGN Interview Prime Video women Wes Anderson VICE anime science fiction Image Comics YouTube Red Biopics Red Carpet Chilling Adventures of Sabrina best posters LGBT Freeform PBS crossover sports Exclusive Video know your critic Dark Horse Comics Musical documentary razzies TNT teaser Fox Searchlight Superheroe joker Calendar hispanic independent CW Seed australia rt labs obituary Pixar DC Universe breaking bad laika Film Festival Countdown robots SundanceTV Disney+ Disney Plus 2017 strong female leads spanish docuseries TCA japan Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Columbia Pictures aliens Opinion king kong dexter canceled Emmys stoner Rom-Com directors leaderboard live event Rocketman crime 007 Discovery Channel name the review BET TV movies comedies Pop Esquire Horror streaming popular Oscars versus HBO Go reviews golden globes based on movie book adaptation FX on Hulu IFC Films renewed TV shows PlayStation Quiz Holidays PaleyFest 2020 stop motion IMDb TV VOD MSNBC Toys aapi Academy Awards werewolf Netflix Reality Neflix SXSW Chernobyl spy thriller high school screenings New York Comic Con travel art house Sundance Now cooking Hear Us Out YouTube Brie Larson sag awards romance scary halloween Apple TV Plus cinemax movie vs. The Purge latino VH1 Christmas Kids & Family Trailer FOX black comedy adventure DC streaming service TCA 2017 Character Guide dark cancelled TV shows news biography elevated horror Holiday series E3 twilight Hallmark Christmas movies Tumblr Captain marvel Fall TV Tubi spider-verse Ovation romantic comedy Fargo TLC toy story Country medical drama A24 DirecTV hist Photos Musicals Endgame Funimation Rock supernatural Watching Series Creative Arts Emmys genre GLAAD 1990s scene in color satire comic books anthology Comedy Central MTV Hallmark Best and Worst ABC Family adaptation crime thriller royal family Lionsgate San Diego Comic-Con justice league CBS tv talk sequels space Television Academy monster movies lord of the rings FXX ITV video on demand Spectrum Originals ABC Signature thriller Nickelodeon Pacific Islander concert Awards zombies Martial Arts child's play HBO TV Adult Swim Women's History Month TCA Winter 2020 young adult Election toronto Teen gangster deadpool Ellie Kemper Masterpiece dragons Certified Fresh revenge archives trophy Turner Classic Movies Epix Film Grammys international Sneak Peek Video Games dceu 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Sundance TV singing competition 21st Century Fox Black History Month golden globe awards mockumentary Paramount emmy awards ratings psycho NBA Nat Geo Pride Month LGBTQ 71st Emmy Awards animated book nature YouTube Premium jurassic park fresh IFC debate sitcom Cannes transformers heist movie 99% Warner Bros. saw Infographic superhero canceled TV shows OWN Shudder blockbuster mutant japanese Cosplay game of thrones Spring TV Superheroes rotten movies we love Ghostbusters 79th Golden Globes Awards scary movies quibi Sci-Fi criterion game show Travel Channel NBC Instagram Live parents Summer Tomatazos hispanic heritage month theme song ID spanish language Song of Ice and Fire new zealand period drama 2015 die hard Marvel new star wars movies Premiere Dates Marvel Studios USA Network Peacock Acorn TV spain trailers 90s 24 frames Podcast mission: impossible historical drama jamie lee curtis TCA Awards Valentine's Day ABC 93rd Oscars politics telelvision sopranos action-comedy President Set visit 45 Bravo Star Trek docudrama National Geographic Mary Poppins Returns rotten Hulu Comics on TV HBO Max El Rey Year in Review television 20th Century Fox Elton John TV renewals Fantasy streaming movies foreign 2018 dramedy First Look Winners free movies zombie Lucasfilm movies Writers Guild of America Heroines Animation composers kong Universal dreamworks all-time Pirates Winter TV crime drama Television Critics Association blaxploitation Reality Competition serial killer FX GoT CMT cancelled unscripted richard e. Grant kids Super Bowl Alien james bond The Walking Dead wonder woman Mindy Kaling Polls and Games hollywood what to watch children's TV football dc Disney Plus CBS All Access slasher YA black Lifetime Christmas movies Trivia king arthur Legendary History See It Skip It spinoff Comic-Con@Home 2021 halloween tv Crunchyroll universal monsters nfl Food Network ViacomCBS hidden camera vampires worst facebook true crime war Music zero dark thirty rom-coms slashers comic superman Apple TV+ Crackle Cartoon Network Box Office venice APB Stephen King sequel Drama TV Land boxing films binge target Tokyo Olympics Binge Guide comics award winner adenture comiccon batman screen actors guild Emmy Nominations The Witch natural history Britbox WarnerMedia TruTV indie marvel comics harry potter USA Disney Channel social media indiana jones Vudu critics mob cancelled television cops rt labs critics edition Extras Amazon Studios Family Comedy NYCC RT21 comic book movies south america Lifetime Trophy Talk classics Paramount Plus Disney Anna Paquin cars diversity Amazon Prime Star Wars stand-up comedy Amazon Prime Video police drama marvel cinematic universe Syfy Fox News BBC franchise a nightmare on elm street blockbusters 2016 ghosts Hollywood Foreign Press Association psychological thriller pirates of the caribbean Shondaland Walt Disney Pictures Schedule TV One GIFs AMC Comic Book First Reviews Broadway TCM doctor who fast and furious olympics The Arrangement boxoffice remakes dogs The CW critic resources documentaries cancelled TV series BBC One Universal Pictures Pet Sematary 73rd Emmy Awards Mystery CNN suspense American Society of Cinematographers Apple Paramount Network E! Tarantino asian-american X-Men basketball Western cats TBS live action Mary Tyler Moore Mary poppins legend Baby Yoda Black Mirror Disney streaming service Rocky