Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Megamind Is Sometimes Super

Plus, Due Date runs out of gas, and For Colored Girls lacks the strength of its source material.

by | November 5, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a reformed supervillain (Megamind, with voice work from Will Ferrell and Tina Fey); a crazed cross-country trek (Due Date, starring Robert Downey Jr. and Zach Galifianakis); and some pained, poetic women (For Colored Girls, starring Thandie Newton and Janet Jackson). What do the critics have to say?



Megamind shares some cosmetic similarities with a couple of recent animated features – namely, The Incredibles and Despicable Me. Still, critics say Megamind has a strong voice cast, strong visuals, and a loopy sense of humor that help to make up for a slightly stale premise and some pacing problems. After apparently defeating his nemesis, Metro Man (Brad Pitt), Megamind (Will Ferrell) finds that his fair city has taken a turn for the worse. Needing an image makeover, he imports a new rival to fight – and hopefully gain some popularity in the process. The pundits say Megamind is generally decent, with a few big laughs and some impressive artwork, but its many pop-culture references mostly serve to remind audiences of the superhero flicks they’ve seen — and loved — before.


Due Date

Director Todd Phillips scored big with The Hangover, and Due Date seemingly has all the elements in place for a stellar follow-up: it’s got a red hot cast, and its combination of cross-country tomfoolery and antisocial behavior would seem to be right in Phillips’s wheelhouse (he directed both Road Trip and Hated: GG Allin and the Murder Junkies, after all). Unfortunately, the critics say Due Date is just so-so, an occasionally unpleasant trip that lacks the headlong comic intensity of The Hangover. Robert Downey Jr. stars as a dad-to-be who’s trying to be with his wife for the birth of their child. However, when he has problems with his flight, he hastily hitches a ride with an antisocial oddball (Zach Galifianakis); hi-jinks ensue. The pundits say Due Date benefits from its stars and several excellent cameos, but it slavishly follows the templates of a number of other road comedies and suffers from both poor taste and a lack of forward momentum. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we list some memorable movie road trips.)


For Colored Girls

On the surface, For Colored Girls has a lot going for it. It’s based upon a Tony Award-winning play by Ntozake Shange; it’s got a fantastic cast that includes Janet Jackson, Thandie Newton, Whoopi Goldberg, and Kerry Washington, just to name a few; and its director, Tyler Perry, has been riding a relative critical hot streak lately (his 2009 helming effort, I Can Do Bad All By Myself, got the best notices of his career, and he was a producer on the Oscar-winning Precious). Unfortunately, critics say For Colored Girls largely bowdlerizes the play’s evocative, impassioned language in favor of grim melodrama. For Colored Girls is the tale of eight African American women, each in the midst of a personal crisis, and how their lives intersect. The pundits say that while For Colored Girls was made with the best of intentions — and contains some dynamite acting — it’s ultimately undone by Perry’s over-the-top scripting and direction, and the result is a soapy, painful slog.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Ne change rien, a documentary about the working methods of French chanteuse Jeanne Balibar, is at 100 percent.
  • Client 9: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer, a doc about the disgraced Wall Street crusader-turned-New York governor, is at 94 percent.

  • Danny Boyle’s 127 Hours, starring James Franco as mountain climber trapped under a rock, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • Four Lions, a comedy about a quartet of inept British jihadists, is at 84 percent.
  • Fair Game, starring Naomi Watts and Sean Penn in the based-on-true-events tale of the Valerie Plame scandal, is at 79 percent.
  • Guy and Madeline on a Park Bench, a low-budget indie musical about an uncertain romance between a jazz musician and a student, is at 71 percent.
  • Red Hill, an Aussie crime drama about a young detective in the midst of a prison escape crisis, is at 69 percent.
  • Outside the Law, a drama about three Algerian brothers whose lives intersect after following their own destinies, is at 56 percent.

Finally, props to August M., Doomz Davo, Easter In The Batcave, Jacob The Basterd, and trukandji for coming the closest to guessing Saw 3D‘s nine percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Superheroe Universal Discovery Channel posters witnail marvel comics Hollywood Foreign Press Association sequels 79th Golden Globes Awards Disney Plus 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Sundance TV feel good psycho news remakes Disney streaming service IFC Films Drama green book Captain marvel DGA series spider-verse king kong Box Office Polls and Games HFPA black Comedy Central First Look 71st Emmy Awards Bravo reviews Mary Tyler Moore Awards Paramount Plus spanish language History RT History documentaries worst what to watch Heroines mob basketball anime MSNBC indie Crunchyroll kong best parents Neflix Character Guide 93rd Oscars 007 Apple TV Plus reboot TCA Winter 2020 Amazon Studios space sopranos rotten rom-coms comiccon comic dramedy festival YouTube Red VOD travel critic resources WGN Tomatazos live event christmas movies Cartoon Network tv talk wonder woman Universal Pictures adventure popular RT21 nbcuniversal period drama biography versus Musicals Watching Series Stephen King crossover Nickelodeon CNN natural history A&E Brie Larson Creative Arts Emmys USA Network Animation Women's History Month doctor who Video Games cops TV Land disaster trophy PBS crime thriller Baby Yoda true crime ESPN rt archives cooking worst movies talk show romance Holidays rt labs Music aapi AMC Plus Tubi Rocky Emmys cinemax Schedule ABC Country 1990s Disney Kids & Family comic book movie FOX The Witch dark transformers Emmy Nominations cancelled TV shows LGBTQ See It Skip It APB italian supernatural TCA 2017 Marathons TIFF kaiju Extras Pop ABC Signature TCM Paramount President canceled TV shows Endgame Trailer Interview Superheroes Sundance YouTube golden globe awards adenture ratings Comic Book south america 99% X-Men superhero Oscars superman golden globes Comics on TV movies scorecard diversity Freeform nfl thriller Pet Sematary E! Nat Geo Columbia Pictures historical drama 2017 crime drama Amazon Prime Video Holiday Martial Arts Ghostbusters stoner Hallmark crime japanese DC streaming service child's play suspense Adult Swim Turner prank gangster Mary Poppins Returns dexter james bond NYCC CW Seed screen actors guild 24 frames Epix comic book movies ViacomCBS legend Lucasfilm 72 Emmy Awards pirates of the caribbean Netflix Christmas movies revenge directors Shondaland hollywood OWN screenings cars slasher medical drama kids docuseries fast and furious DirecTV television Shudder Film casting 2020 royal family justice league mission: impossible Reality Competition OneApp CMT mcc VH1 The Walking Dead Esquire DC Universe video Reality Star Wars Red Carpet criterion TruTV IMDb TV war BBC One adaptation Pixar social media CBS All Access franchise DC Comics Best and Worst dreamworks HBO Go foreign BET Awards slashers WarnerMedia IFC a nightmare on elm street werewolf 45 73rd Emmy Awards Black Mirror Set visit sag awards Arrowverse Britbox telelvision TNT FX Travel Channel hispanic The CW blockbuster deadpool Super Bowl archives GoT Year in Review BBC America Photos BBC Fox News satire young adult Mudbound Winter TV Instagram Live Family CBS YouTube Premium Logo Opinion lord of the rings Walt Disney Pictures king arthur BET heist movie latino football Television Critics Association cancelled television The Purge Food Network streaming TLC spider-man Vudu 2021 australia classics Winners Binge Guide boxing international Cannes Lifetime Christmas movies spanish boxoffice teaser MCU twilight vs. ghosts serial killer 2016 Podcast Legendary discovery spain YA award winner saw chucky anthology 90s Broadway mockumentary Marvel 2018 HBO Max Rock vampires Certified Fresh The Academy Hear Us Out SundanceTV sitcom A24 Countdown emmy awards mutant Disney Channel new york Dark Horse Comics genre cartoon Disney+ Disney Plus jamie lee curtis Mindy Kaling Television Academy Exclusive Video Lionsgate Christmas Academy Awards Horror Western elevated horror Tags: Comedy Awards Tour marvel cinematic universe game of thrones Action toy story Starz Spike obituary women spinoff San Diego Comic-Con book Rom-Com animated name the review Sci-Fi composers romantic comedy unscripted Star Trek Turner Classic Movies rotten movies we love New York Comic Con Amazon all-time singing competition Cosplay finale new zealand Fantasy Pop TV Sundance Now Musical comedies game show PlayStation Tokyo Olympics zero dark thirty Showtime cults comics spy thriller 2015 TCA First Reviews NBA scary movies art house SDCC psychological thriller universal monsters aliens Fargo harry potter laika BAFTA SXSW concert comic books The Walt Disney Company Comic-Con@Home 2021 trailers children's TV Infographic Quiz stop motion Apple independent know your critic ID Ellie Kemper TV One french renewed TV shows Crackle razzies Funimation Pirates high school jurassic park Film Festival asian-american festivals Avengers GLAAD indiana jones batman Mary poppins blaxploitation Sony Pictures book adaptation critics hidden camera zombies fresh E3 TV renewals hispanic heritage month strong female leads streaming movies Comedy Netflix toronto olympics Rocketman Song of Ice and Fire Hallmark Christmas movies scary scene in color quibi based on movie technology Fox Searchlight halloween HBO dceu El Rey breaking bad National Geographic Teen robots miniseries joker Writers Guild of America AMC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt facebook Classic Film zombie black comedy Election ABC Family nature dc cancelled TV series Trophy Talk rt labs critics edition Wes Anderson 21st Century Fox Sneak Peek Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Spectrum Originals Lifetime Nominations die hard Syfy Spring TV movie Valentine's Day ITV Acorn TV stand-up comedy live action free movies Trivia theme song venice cats Chernobyl sequel Amazon Prime Summer hist Mystery USA biopic Tumblr Hulu PaleyFest politics Grammys godzilla Premiere Dates The Arrangement binge Apple TV+ TCA Awards Masterpiece TBS action-comedy Thanksgiving FXX Black History Month japan TV movies Alien Ovation dogs video on demand police drama monster movies 2019 FX on Hulu cancelled MTV new star wars movies Pride Month dragons richard e. Grant canceled Fall TV docudrama Toys Peacock Tarantino VICE NBC GIFs TV Marvel Studios Prime Video Paramount Network 20th Century Fox target 4/20 science fiction Anna Paquin documentary LGBT blockbusters sports halloween tv Image Comics debate films leaderboard Warner Bros. Biopics Calendar Pacific Islander political drama Marvel Television American Society of Cinematographers Elton John