Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Darkness Balances on the Edge of Freshness

Plus, When in Rome gets tossed to the lions.

by | January 28, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an angry detective (Edge of Darkness, starring Mel Gibson and Ray Winstone) and a Roman holiday (When in Rome, starring Kristen Bell and Josh Duhamel). What do the critics have to say?


Edge of Darkness

It’s been nearly a decade since Mel Gibson has played a leading role onscreen. And critics say the reason Edge of Darkness works as well as it does is Gibson’s presence, which elevates the film above a run-of-the-mill revenge thriller. Based upon the 1980s British TV series of the same name (also directed by Martin Campbell, who helms here), Edge stars Gibson as a Boston detective filled with grief after the murder of his daughter. However, as he investigates, he learns her death is part of a larger conspiracy. The pundits say Gibson is in fine form, delivering a world-weary, compelling performance that mostly makes up for the film’s contrivances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Gibsons’s best-reviewed films.)


When in Rome

When in Rome attempts to meld romantic comedy and fairy tale tropes into a picturesque travelogue. However, critics say this long-delayed would-be confection is hardly worth the trip — it’s a forced and unconvincing attempt at whimsy that falls flat. Kristen Bell stars as Beth, a single gal who finds herself in a sticky situation: after removing coins from a “fountain of love” in the Eternal City, she’s followed back to New York by a string of obsessed suitors. The pundits say When in Rome is leaden, generic, and occasionally creepy, wasting an excellent cast (including Will Arnett, Anjelica Huston, and Danny DeVito) on a largely laugh-free script.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • North Face, a historical drama about a pair of climbers attempting to conquer a perilous peak in the Swiss Alps, is at 89 percent.

  • Off and Running, documentary about a college track prospect grappling with her unconventional family life, is at 80 percent.

  • The Israeli import For My Father, a drama about a suicide bomber who finds himself living among his purported targets, is at 50 percent.
  • Saint John of Las Vegas, starring Steve Buscemi in a dramedy about a recovering compulsive gambler drawn back to Vegas, is at seven percent.

Finally, we’d like to send a big “EEYEAHH” to King Crunk (WHAT?!) for successfully guessing Legion‘s 17 percent Tomatometer. (OKAY!)

Tag Cloud

BBC One comiccon serial killer Music scene in color Box Office green book legend Marvel Studios Television Academy Emmys TCM halloween 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards American Society of Cinematographers Sundance TV Comics on TV Classic Film asian-american dramedy Warner Bros. National Geographic marvel cinematic universe teaser Western Winter TV rt labs critics edition high school obituary sitcom ID sequels stop motion name the review new york award winner slasher rt archives television films blaxploitation leaderboard lord of the rings Oscars Hallmark reboot Tags: Comedy TBS docuseries TIFF LGBTQ Epix Turner Comic Book independent The Purge political drama IFC dogs Spectrum Originals marvel comics theme song godzilla satire Pop TV boxoffice Peacock monster movies comic book movie Captain marvel Crackle cars Video Games President composers venice Paramount Plus Podcast mutant HFPA aliens witnail Pacific Islander Superheroe police drama Countdown The Academy Film Festival romance wonder woman rotten movies we love Winners Tubi comic book movies Cosplay Logo The CW emmy awards posters strong female leads mob TCA Winter 2020 Crunchyroll olympics 2018 zombies 71st Emmy Awards critic resources video on demand WGN CMT Tomatazos Sci-Fi Geeked Week TV renewals Amazon Studios Drama SundanceTV New York Comic Con Exclusive Video Sony Pictures 2021 joker YouTube Premium Turner Classic Movies discovery Country superman documentaries IFC Films spider-man Animation anthology spinoff streaming spy thriller VICE Awards Ovation Tokyo Olympics Women's History Month Kids & Family MCU feel good Teen telelvision Character Guide kids summer TV hispanic black Amazon Best and Worst psychological thriller PBS Television Critics Association 99% 93rd Oscars war football psycho zombie singing competition space Disney+ Disney Plus comedies BET Awards streamig blockbusters popular IMDb TV RT21 Netflix Christmas movies best cinemax robots 2020 007 Pop Sneak Peek Image Comics Sundance international harry potter sopranos Holidays WarnerMedia Spring TV Funimation Mystery worst rt labs LGBT SXSW dreamworks directors talk show obi wan Polls and Games BBC Shudder comic books ITV dexter Rocky parents ABC Signature hispanic heritage month fresh target ghosts blockbuster Grammys Super Bowl Focus Features Food Network new star wars movies FOX mcc Summer The Walking Dead genre Pixar movies Best Actress canceled universal monsters finale USA Network Musicals documentary supernatural cooking Amazon Prime Video Anna Paquin king kong Pirates gangster Disney streaming service Toys festival art house Amazon Prime Best Picture comics BAFTA Hulu OneApp quibi CBS All Access historical drama ratings remakes Marvel San Diego Comic-Con Fall TV NYCC Nat Geo fast and furious cults adenture child's play french Star Wars Celebration The Witch 4/20 Binge Guide VOD 45 Creative Arts Emmys Reality Best Director Marvel Television deadpool Stephen King Rock hist south america classics suspense Infographic Apple Mary Tyler Moore biography Disney Channel Writers Guild of America natural history First Reviews zero dark thirty Comedy Central Set visit reviews doctor who Lifetime Awards Tour versus X-Men toy story Mindy Kaling scene in color film series binge DC streaming service Pride Month Netflix docudrama Acorn TV Neflix trophy Film crime japan scene in color series comic revenge Syfy Britbox 94th Oscars ABC Discovery Channel thriller FX critics dceu adaptation Schedule know your critic GIFs boxing Lifetime Christmas movies AMC PlayStation Broadway Paramount Network Alien Emmy Nominations transformers trailers unscripted Hear Us Out Action Apple TV+ elevated horror Sundance Now Bravo golden globe awards Fox News Watching Series jurassic park GLAAD cancelled TV series BET Lionsgate sports slashers canceled TV shows MGM Avengers dark Comedy Starz japanese Red Carpet what to watch TCA james bond Holiday rotten Indigenous Certified Fresh hollywood 2017 scary SXSW 2022 Trailer jamie lee curtis South by Southwest Film Festival TV latino 73rd Emmy Awards all-time Opinion period drama a nightmare on elm street Brie Larson series YA 1990s travel Extras crime drama women NBC Nickelodeon chucky kaiju Cannes CBS The Walt Disney Company USA golden globes streaming movies NBA spanish Mudbound 2019 CW Seed Paramount Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt nfl politics basketball mockumentary Trivia die hard 72 Emmy Awards interviews 79th Golden Globes Awards Endgame Calendar Wes Anderson cancelled Esquire nbcuniversal justice league superhero Oscar GoT worst movies free movies Masterpiece Sony vs. Cartoon Network Baby Yoda HBO Go OWN Travel Channel Walt Disney Pictures Vudu Song of Ice and Fire debate kong Fargo renewed TV shows TCA 2017 ESPN sag awards Universal Pictures mission: impossible TLC Ellie Kemper APB MSNBC E3 prank Comic-Con@Home 2021 action-comedy twilight game of thrones criterion Best Actor summer TV preview true crime based on movie cats foreign Prime Video scorecard anime Black History Month Legendary PaleyFest FXX news science fiction DC Comics Marathons royal family Heroines Tumblr History live action sequel Academy Awards FX on Hulu screenings Apple TV Plus Photos Fantasy archives A&E Tarantino movie Black Mirror batman Adult Swim Fox Searchlight Rom-Com Disney Plus diversity aapi cancelled TV shows laika rom-coms summer preview richard e. Grant king arthur Biopics TruTV Reality Competition Chernobyl Star Trek breaking bad Paramount Pictures saw Valentine's Day Freeform 90s casting dragons cancelled television 2015 Star Wars Ghostbusters toronto social media Election young adult target scene in color Shondaland Quiz AMC Plus Showtime game show Premiere Dates crime thriller dc Family Trophy Talk Rocketman Mary Poppins Returns SDCC TCA Awards CNN stand-up comedy hidden camera RT History VH1 Native 20th Century Fox El Rey romantic comedy Disney YouTube Red cartoon TNT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina biopic book adaptation Mary poppins TV One werewolf Universal DGA miniseries Pet Sematary Year in Review Nominations book A24 Interview ViacomCBS DC Universe christmas movies See It Skip It 21st Century Fox Superheroes heist movie medical drama Elton John YouTube screen actors guild indiana jones facebook Horror Hallmark Christmas movies stoner spanish language ABC Family crossover The Arrangement MTV Dark Horse Comics Musical HBO children's TV cops spider-verse vampires technology nature italian Instagram Live halloween tv spain Spike new zealand black comedy Columbia Pictures Hollywood Foreign Press Association TV movies Christmas BBC America concert scary movies tv talk animated australia TV Land broadcast Lucasfilm festivals pirates of the caribbean razzies 24 frames E! HBO Max franchise DirecTV disaster video adventure Arrowverse live event indie Martial Arts Thanksgiving 2016 First Look