Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Darkness Balances on the Edge of Freshness

Plus, When in Rome gets tossed to the lions.

by | January 28, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an angry detective (Edge of Darkness, starring Mel Gibson and Ray Winstone) and a Roman holiday (When in Rome, starring Kristen Bell and Josh Duhamel). What do the critics have to say?


Edge of Darkness

It’s been nearly a decade since Mel Gibson has played a leading role onscreen. And critics say the reason Edge of Darkness works as well as it does is Gibson’s presence, which elevates the film above a run-of-the-mill revenge thriller. Based upon the 1980s British TV series of the same name (also directed by Martin Campbell, who helms here), Edge stars Gibson as a Boston detective filled with grief after the murder of his daughter. However, as he investigates, he learns her death is part of a larger conspiracy. The pundits say Gibson is in fine form, delivering a world-weary, compelling performance that mostly makes up for the film’s contrivances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Gibsons’s best-reviewed films.)


When in Rome

When in Rome attempts to meld romantic comedy and fairy tale tropes into a picturesque travelogue. However, critics say this long-delayed would-be confection is hardly worth the trip — it’s a forced and unconvincing attempt at whimsy that falls flat. Kristen Bell stars as Beth, a single gal who finds herself in a sticky situation: after removing coins from a “fountain of love” in the Eternal City, she’s followed back to New York by a string of obsessed suitors. The pundits say When in Rome is leaden, generic, and occasionally creepy, wasting an excellent cast (including Will Arnett, Anjelica Huston, and Danny DeVito) on a largely laugh-free script.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • North Face, a historical drama about a pair of climbers attempting to conquer a perilous peak in the Swiss Alps, is at 89 percent.

  • Off and Running, documentary about a college track prospect grappling with her unconventional family life, is at 80 percent.

  • The Israeli import For My Father, a drama about a suicide bomber who finds himself living among his purported targets, is at 50 percent.
  • Saint John of Las Vegas, starring Steve Buscemi in a dramedy about a recovering compulsive gambler drawn back to Vegas, is at seven percent.

Finally, we’d like to send a big “EEYEAHH” to King Crunk (WHAT?!) for successfully guessing Legion‘s 17 percent Tomatometer. (OKAY!)

Tag Cloud

The Witch remakes canceled TV shows Mary Tyler Moore Thanksgiving true crime critic resources kaiju Pacific Islander YouTube Red Premiere Dates NYCC mcc cats 20th Century Fox Ellie Kemper monster movies President Chernobyl 007 sopranos sag awards Biopics Emmy Nominations Calendar Amazon Prime Video a nightmare on elm street obituary Shondaland Film Festival casting Year in Review Marvel Television kids ID Mindy Kaling movies leaderboard Awards Tour ABC TCA Awards Food Network Apple TV Plus anthology HBO ESPN genre crossover zombies royal family name the review Tubi Disney historical drama comic trailers LGBTQ mutant History Holiday dreamworks south america twilight superman diversity Christmas miniseries politics Lifetime Comedy Election WarnerMedia sitcom Winter TV documentary video Pop Oscars criterion Walt Disney Pictures Country Valentine's Day ViacomCBS new york BAFTA screen actors guild harry potter TruTV game of thrones satire cars Esquire dogs talk show RT History political drama The Purge Starz adenture The Arrangement docudrama critics universal monsters prank MSNBC See It Skip It Animation USA Network target fresh Ghostbusters New York Comic Con fast and furious Tags: Comedy AMC police drama movie DGA Broadway 79th Golden Globes Awards Paramount Plus Ovation tv talk TCA 2017 Epix archives TCA Winter 2020 composers HBO Max Masterpiece 24 frames ABC Signature Marathons GIFs black comedy Fox News PaleyFest Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt halloween versus hispanic heritage month Star Trek nature Britbox golden globe awards chucky Syfy Summer young adult natural history Writers Guild of America Neflix Horror Heroines king kong Freeform WGN APB Martial Arts razzies Sundance TV telelvision Set visit The Walt Disney Company PlayStation Awards canceled hidden camera video on demand blockbuster batman First Look TV Land A24 USA Red Carpet American Society of Cinematographers TV renewals scene in color TV movies spanish language boxing DC Universe SXSW Marvel Studios french 2020 godzilla Sony Pictures Instagram Live IFC spanish live action basketball Extras psycho TNT japan hist marvel comics E! FX AMC Plus Arrowverse Comic-Con@Home 2021 Bravo joker TLC Fall TV nbcuniversal die hard Pop TV rt archives finale YouTube Premium based on movie heist movie Tarantino Baby Yoda Travel Channel BET dragons Stephen King 45 E3 laika Women's History Month Image Comics vs. Tomatazos FXX Podcast comic books crime drama cancelled television screenings Tumblr Crackle comic book movies BBC X-Men First Reviews Reality Competition ABC Family Comics on TV Rock hollywood scary The Academy 73rd Emmy Awards Nominations Hallmark Christmas movies Action anime Pet Sematary DC Comics Prime Video Certified Fresh Mary poppins MTV Disney+ Disney Plus ghosts sports 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Turner Classic Movies Hulu Musical supernatural streaming Spectrum Originals james bond TCM period drama National Geographic Watching Series toronto werewolf Universal popular high school Box Office mockumentary Avengers Nat Geo dc LGBT Apple wonder woman Family Pirates Funimation Superheroe dceu Disney Plus BBC One blockbusters festival Countdown dark international MCU Spike zombie new zealand kong legend Disney streaming service olympics feel good latino blaxploitation stop motion Lucasfilm BBC America VOD Classic Film comiccon war debate biopic marvel cinematic universe comedies revenge Adult Swim Acorn TV Elton John The CW Musicals rt labs critics edition Mary Poppins Returns Netflix Christmas movies Television Academy crime series Paramount Kids & Family Captain marvel travel what to watch Dark Horse Comics Sneak Peek deadpool Discovery Channel YouTube 72 Emmy Awards halloween tv San Diego Comic-Con 2019 Video Games 2015 news Creative Arts Emmys Quiz justice league Film Amazon Prime OWN Legendary transformers Black History Month 2021 Photos elevated horror scorecard Fargo robots Music films GLAAD science fiction Academy Awards strong female leads stoner theme song richard e. Grant indie breaking bad mob SundanceTV comic book movie El Rey CW Seed Toys crime thriller mission: impossible Grammys 1990s NBA disaster gangster doctor who live event Hallmark Universal Pictures IMDb TV space pirates of the caribbean Showtime Warner Bros. emmy awards Amazon Studios king arthur Columbia Pictures Rom-Com Reality Trivia Superheroes trophy 99% medical drama reviews Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ITV NBC cults Sci-Fi 93rd Oscars facebook Logo CMT RT21 Best and Worst VICE Sundance animated dramedy cancelled TV shows YA stand-up comedy documentaries DC streaming service Mudbound Pride Month asian-american Song of Ice and Fire hispanic foreign romantic comedy Fox Searchlight child's play Lifetime Christmas movies Alien GoT serial killer witnail TCA Holidays Trailer aapi teaser Black Mirror Trophy Talk Anna Paquin Polls and Games TBS spider-verse Opinion italian jamie lee curtis ratings Wes Anderson Mystery Cartoon Network cops Star Wars romance sequel binge IFC Films free movies Brie Larson Crunchyroll 4/20 saw singing competition Sundance Now spy thriller book adaptation rotten Cannes Binge Guide TV One suspense Drama Spring TV cartoon Amazon Lionsgate biography television scary movies parents comics 2018 Western slashers all-time award winner Shudder concert children's TV venice Super Bowl 2017 21st Century Fox TIFF CBS 2016 Teen worst movies FOX franchise rom-coms Comedy Central Television Critics Association Nickelodeon cinemax football Rocketman Tokyo Olympics slasher action-comedy Rocky game show discovery Fantasy reboot Apple TV+ A&E book Schedule japanese FX on Hulu VH1 Hear Us Out quibi indiana jones PBS vampires rt labs art house aliens posters golden globes Vudu festivals thriller classics independent TV spain unscripted streaming movies Interview cancelled TV series HBO Go dexter technology Comic Book best renewed TV shows docuseries worst HFPA Winners spinoff social media cancelled Infographic Paramount Network CNN lord of the rings BET Awards Marvel nfl Peacock black The Walking Dead Hollywood Foreign Press Association Emmys women green book zero dark thirty CBS All Access SDCC know your critic OneApp Turner Cosplay australia psychological thriller adventure jurassic park boxoffice sequels 90s rotten movies we love christmas movies Netflix Endgame DirecTV Character Guide Pixar spider-man cooking directors Exclusive Video new star wars movies adaptation Disney Channel 71st Emmy Awards superhero toy story