Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Darkness Balances on the Edge of Freshness

Plus, When in Rome gets tossed to the lions.

by | January 28, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an angry detective (Edge of Darkness, starring Mel Gibson and Ray Winstone) and a Roman holiday (When in Rome, starring Kristen Bell and Josh Duhamel). What do the critics have to say?


Edge of Darkness

It’s been nearly a decade since Mel Gibson has played a leading role onscreen. And critics say the reason Edge of Darkness works as well as it does is Gibson’s presence, which elevates the film above a run-of-the-mill revenge thriller. Based upon the 1980s British TV series of the same name (also directed by Martin Campbell, who helms here), Edge stars Gibson as a Boston detective filled with grief after the murder of his daughter. However, as he investigates, he learns her death is part of a larger conspiracy. The pundits say Gibson is in fine form, delivering a world-weary, compelling performance that mostly makes up for the film’s contrivances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Gibsons’s best-reviewed films.)


When in Rome

When in Rome attempts to meld romantic comedy and fairy tale tropes into a picturesque travelogue. However, critics say this long-delayed would-be confection is hardly worth the trip — it’s a forced and unconvincing attempt at whimsy that falls flat. Kristen Bell stars as Beth, a single gal who finds herself in a sticky situation: after removing coins from a “fountain of love” in the Eternal City, she’s followed back to New York by a string of obsessed suitors. The pundits say When in Rome is leaden, generic, and occasionally creepy, wasting an excellent cast (including Will Arnett, Anjelica Huston, and Danny DeVito) on a largely laugh-free script.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • North Face, a historical drama about a pair of climbers attempting to conquer a perilous peak in the Swiss Alps, is at 89 percent.

  • Off and Running, documentary about a college track prospect grappling with her unconventional family life, is at 80 percent.

  • The Israeli import For My Father, a drama about a suicide bomber who finds himself living among his purported targets, is at 50 percent.
  • Saint John of Las Vegas, starring Steve Buscemi in a dramedy about a recovering compulsive gambler drawn back to Vegas, is at seven percent.

Finally, we’d like to send a big “EEYEAHH” to King Crunk (WHAT?!) for successfully guessing Legion‘s 17 percent Tomatometer. (OKAY!)

Tag Cloud

cats halloween serial killer disaster 2015 Sundance Now PBS Christmas Certified Fresh BET BBC America strong female leads Apple TV+ miniseries police drama New York Comic Con American Society of Cinematographers Extras television Oscars quibi Winners spinoff Character Guide Action singing competition video justice league boxoffice A&E Heroines Sneak Peek SDCC The CW CW Seed Winter TV MCU witnail Paramount Biopics tv talk The Witch cancelled TV shows Trailer Spectrum Originals romantic comedy theme song cancelled television Box Office TruTV Holidays History 2018 Paramount Network Pride Month Valentine's Day Teen LGBT robots Podcast Family Spring TV travel Hulu cults Shudder AMC Pirates YouTube Sci-Fi Infographic E! DC streaming service Star Wars Comedy Peacock Red Carpet Election psychological thriller RT21 sitcom renewed TV shows APB movies Song of Ice and Fire Warner Bros. VICE Disney Musicals Marvel sports dc Polls and Games Fantasy TV zombie Lifetime biography Best and Worst diversity Rom-Com GIFs GLAAD politics Pet Sematary canceled TBS Countdown Logo 20th Century Fox Mudbound Film ABC medical drama USA Britbox adaptation Emmys zero dark thirty Nominations CBS All Access PaleyFest Turner Photos toy story TV renewals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mutant docudrama unscripted Lionsgate Food Network anthology Ghostbusters Esquire based on movie Brie Larson stand-up comedy Comedy Central period drama Starz Shondaland Pop 45 golden globes Lucasfilm supernatural cops FX doctor who what to watch Grammys TIFF Thanksgiving Tarantino psycho crime drama dceu award winner El Rey Year in Review sequel Rocky south america CNN Western ESPN The Walking Dead 24 frames binge ABC Family GoT Epix Premiere Dates 21st Century Fox Video Games crime thriller DC Universe TCM Chernobyl Toys Masterpiece Spike Mary poppins Crunchyroll TV Land BBC blaxploitation Mystery VH1 Disney Plus dragons batman Schedule casting Women's History Month Television Academy First Reviews latino Martial Arts spy thriller Freeform Cannes free movies Film Festival Musical Nat Geo NBC The Purge Anna Paquin Summer cinemax Animation Awards Tour Turner Classic Movies hist Syfy Adult Swim Apple Calendar HBO Max Mary Tyler Moore Mindy Kaling Country Crackle Ellie Kemper SXSW zombies RT History Comic Book OWN Creative Arts Emmys Kids & Family aliens Elton John Nickelodeon Awards talk show Opinion Watching Series President Arrowverse Cosplay Superheroe Music WGN DGA 2019 jamie lee curtis MTV Vudu social media 2017 MSNBC spain Tomatazos Netflix discovery Stephen King Quiz SundanceTV political drama Disney Channel FOX USA Network Dark Horse Comics The Arrangement Fox News finale See It Skip It National Geographic Walt Disney Pictures spider-man spanish language cars Trivia true crime YouTube Red First Look Super Bowl Emmy Nominations streaming Showtime TNT war Black Mirror X-Men historical drama HBO Reality Competition Drama nature Classic Film Rock Fall TV romance series Comics on TV Amazon Prime NYCC TCA FXX space CMT TCA 2017 Columbia Pictures book kids vampires Sundance E3 slashers comiccon Writers Guild of America Captain marvel TLC Interview natural history DirecTV joker Rocketman hispanic Cartoon Network Amazon Prime Video Ovation crossover adventure cooking Trophy Talk Horror CBS 71st Emmy Awards transformers Mary Poppins Returns animated ratings Bravo breaking bad YA crime game of thrones game show foreign children's TV IFC Films technology revenge richard e. Grant Sony Pictures DC Comics harry potter cancelled Disney streaming service Star Trek Amazon facebook Binge Guide Tumblr ITV LGBTQ elevated horror Reality 007 WarnerMedia Pixar San Diego Comic-Con dramedy cancelled TV series ghosts comic Marathons IFC 2016 science fiction mockumentary festivals thriller teaser green book Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Acorn TV Set visit canceled TV shows anime YouTube Premium composers Superheroes Universal