Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Battleship Is All Wet

Plus, What to Expect When You're Expecting does the expected, and The Dictator generates vicious laughs.

by | May 17, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got nautical combat (Battleship, starring Taylor Kitsch and Rihanna), pregnancy tribulations (What to Expect When You’re Expecting, starring Jennifer Lopez and Cameron Diaz), and a displaced despot (The Dictator, starring Sacha Baron Cohen and Anna Faris). What do the critics have to say?



A big-budget blockbuster based upon a board game, Battleship all but promises empty-headed thrills. On that count, critics say, it succeeds, though they also note that a few mindlessly awesome set pieces can’t totally compensate for the film’s thuddingly silly script. Years after NASA has sent a message to a nearby planet, a group of alien ships visit earth — and they do not come in peace. A group of naval officers leads the charge against the invading armada, and explosions ensue. The pundits say Battleship is about as absurd as it sounds, and although some of the battles are pretty cool, the fun to be had here is of the guilty pleasure variety. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down memorable examples of cinematic naval triumphs..)

What to Expect When You’re Expecting


Since it was first published in 1984, the popular self-help book What to Expect When You’re Expecting has helped to guide women through the turbulent months of pregnancy. Unfortunately, the big screen version lacks the unpredictability of real life, stranding its talented cast in a sitcommy plot. Starring Jennifer Lopez, Cameron Diaz, Elizabeth Banks, Anna Kendrick, Dennis Quaid, and Chris Rock, What to Expect When You’re Expecting is the story of five interconnected couples dealing with a variety of pregnancy and childbirth-related issues, and it features plenty of spirited discussions from both male and female perspectives. The pundits say What to Expect contains occasional laughs fleeting moments of insight, but mostly, this all-star ensemble piece is strictly by-the-book.

The Dictator


With the gonzo documentaries Borat and Bruno, Sacha Baron Cohen established himself as one of contemporary cinema’s most merciless satirists. Now he’s graduated to scripted comedy, and critics say that while The Dictator isn’t as outrageous or as teeth-clenchingly funny as Borat, it’s just funny and un-P.C. enough to prove that Cohen hasn’t gone soft. This loose remake of Charlie Chaplin’s The Great Dictator is the tale of an oppressive, buffoonish North African despot who survives a coup attempt that leaves him wandering the streets of New York City until a kindly hippie grocer (Anna Faris) takes a shine to him. The pundits say that not every joke in The Dictator works (and a few fall flat), but overall, the film provides enough gleeful tastelessness and sharp political observations to satisfy Cohen’s fans.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Elena, a Russian thriller about an estranged family plotting to take control of a large inheritance, is at 100 percent.
  • Indie Game: The Movie, a documentary about the development process behind independent video games, is at 100 percent.
  • Polisse, a drama about the professional and personal trials of Paris’ Child Protection Unit, is at 90 percent.
  • Beyond The Black Rainbow, a sci-fi/horror hybrid about a mute girl with psychic powers, is at 88 percent.
  • American Animal, a dramedy about two roommates whose friendship is tested when one decides to get a job, is at 83 percent.
  • Quill: The Life of a Guide Dog, a drama that follows a Labrador retriever from puppyhood to his days as a blind man’s companion, is at 77 percent.
  • Lovely Molly, a horror film about a recently married woman who discovers malevolent forces in her childhood home, is at 57 percent.
  • The Color Wheel, a road trip comedy about a pair of feuding siblings, is at 50 percent.
  • Hysteria, starring Hugh Dancy and Maggie Gyllenhaal in a period piece about the invention of the vibrator during the prudish Victorian era, is at 45 percent.
  • The Samaritan, starring Samuel L. Jackson in a thriller about an ex-con who finds the past difficult to shake, is at 35 percent.
  • Mansome, a documentary by Morgan Spurlock about men’s grooming habits, is at 20 percent.
  • Virginia, starring Ed Harris and Jennifer Connelly in a drama about a single mother and her long-term extramarital affair with the town sheriff, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Avengers Superheroe Comedy Apple TV Plus hispanic Hallmark movies Mary poppins First Look godzilla mockumentary romantic comedy Holidays true crime TNT transformers jurassic park Valentine's Day Western documentaries politics Cartoon Network vampires Hallmark Christmas movies Crackle nature Cosplay DC streaming service spain Musicals talk show stoner Pixar target Sundance Now FX werewolf YouTube The CW Grammys cats Comic Book Creative Arts Emmys ABC Signature blockbuster universal monsters Masterpiece See It Skip It Nat Geo TV renewals criterion Rock chucky scary movies American Society of Cinematographers cars festival 2021 Awards Tour Martial Arts toronto japanese Sony Pictures El Rey Television Academy 2015 free movies travel prank comiccon screenings IFC Films james bond Shondaland green book TCM Classic Film RT21 docuseries OWN Sneak Peek casting indie boxoffice Stephen King Video Games halloween Adult Swim Ghostbusters LGBT First Reviews Pop TV A&E screen actors guild live action Set visit dragons facebook Sundance TV Trailer Amazon Studios Paramount Plus laika Disney HBO Go sequel MTV superman TV Oscars 2018 Reality Pride Month worst TCA 2017 dogs Disney Channel new zealand Opinion Winter TV romance DC Comics football Sundance Reality Competition finale CBS All Access Turner Classic Movies The Purge Amazon sports Horror FOX Toys Britbox Funimation National Geographic TLC docudrama rotten movies we love Academy Awards name the review Superheroes CBS heist movie nfl space revenge Pet Sematary venice FXX cancelled television Apple rotten 4/20 WGN TV movies psychological thriller Captain marvel italian television Lucasfilm hollywood Calendar BBC a nightmare on elm street Lionsgate Summer Countdown golden globes stop motion suspense Disney streaming service justice league Tomatazos discovery SXSW foreign cancelled History Walt Disney Pictures witnail 93rd Oscars video on demand PBS Freeform Thanksgiving child's play aapi adenture SDCC monster movies Peacock doctor who scene in color social media VOD halloween tv spy thriller TV Land Discovery Channel Music Film australia Warner Bros. saw Television Critics Association Sci-Fi AMC reviews Rocketman satire parents Star Wars Red Carpet OneApp anthology spider-man Comic-Con@Home 2021 dramedy ABC Family lord of the rings Trophy Talk hist Family Heroines tv talk VICE ghosts Watching Series jamie lee curtis Year in Review high school zero dark thirty asian-american SundanceTV kong Film Festival diversity GIFs dceu Netflix Christmas movies kids Acorn TV know your critic Esquire obituary Crunchyroll Spike E3 USA archives singing competition Apple TV+ joker Tumblr adaptation anime french Fox Searchlight Premiere Dates 72 Emmy Awards composers breaking bad Spring TV harry potter animated cancelled TV shows zombie Teen Polls and Games Rom-Com what to watch Lifetime Wes Anderson 21st Century Fox hidden camera all-time cults theme song Tubi Super Bowl fresh disaster batman Emmys Hulu Awards binge Marvel Television Shudder APB international scorecard natural history sequels marvel cinematic universe canceled 24 frames wonder woman 2019 concert Biopics black renewed TV shows Starz streaming movies psycho PaleyFest dark Broadway telelvision Ovation HBO Brie Larson TIFF nbcuniversal twilight Amazon Prime Video Writers Guild of America Pop rt archives Cannes Travel Channel quibi science fiction emmy awards Paramount strong female leads Syfy TCA Awards Ellie Kemper 2020 crime 71st Emmy Awards award winner Emmy Nominations teaser worst movies Disney+ Disney Plus latino indiana jones films The Walking Dead stand-up comedy A24 festivals Nominations children's TV zombies comic Trivia mutant Pirates 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards DGA blockbusters Song of Ice and Fire Marathons USA Network Disney Plus Star Trek TCA Winter 2020 historical drama technology MSNBC king arthur cooking versus 2017 HBO Max war documentary Binge Guide Columbia Pictures Marvel 20th Century Fox YA ITV Vudu GLAAD ID die hard 99% toy story Animation Exclusive Video DC Universe Universal rom-coms Infographic Hear Us Out Paramount Network BET Extras YouTube Premium sitcom Character Guide 1990s women Baby Yoda police drama The Arrangement Nickelodeon miniseries The Walt Disney Company mission: impossible kaiju Food Network game show CNN WarnerMedia elevated horror Epix IFC Netflix boxing President X-Men Pacific Islander Quiz period drama Schedule Certified Fresh Marvel Studios legend movie ratings book adaptation king kong Photos FX on Hulu crime drama deadpool The Witch Alien Arrowverse The Academy south america TBS Fantasy Spectrum Originals best independent golden globe awards DirecTV trailers Tokyo Olympics 45 NBC Image Comics PlayStation Box Office sag awards Mindy Kaling aliens cops YouTube Red BET Awards olympics Turner directors pirates of the caribbean crime thriller Logo BBC One New York Comic Con GoT TruTV Fox News razzies CMT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Black Mirror richard e. Grant cancelled TV series Black History Month unscripted Musical japan Chernobyl Showtime new star wars movies series serial killer Women's History Month Amazon Prime TCA Interview Best and Worst Dark Horse Comics streaming Lifetime Christmas movies 2016 canceled TV shows comedies Mudbound new york NYCC 90s Election Tarantino Drama MCU medical drama BAFTA video based on movie Rocky news comics ESPN critics classics VH1 biography Christmas ABC fast and furious superhero Kids & Family Holiday game of thrones dc Chilling Adventures of Sabrina blaxploitation ViacomCBS slashers cinemax popular Anna Paquin basketball Action Winners RT History LGBTQ E! christmas movies Fall TV Comics on TV Mary Poppins Returns CW Seed Mystery Endgame supernatural Elton John 007 BBC America franchise Country NBA San Diego Comic-Con book Bravo comic books spanish language reboot spanish spinoff cartoon Legendary Mary Tyler Moore Podcast remakes TV One Comedy Central adventure thriller political drama robots crossover