Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Flags" Flies High; "The Prestige" Is Magic; "Flicka" Is A Pretty Good Ride; "Marie Antoinette" Spared Critical Guillotine

by | October 19, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a complex tale of heroism (Clint Eastwood‘s "Flags of Our Fathers," starring Ryan Phillippe), a story of dueling magicians (Christopher Nolan‘s "The Prestige," starring Christian Bale, Scarlett Johansson, and Hugh Jackman), a yarn about a girl and her horse ("Flicka," starring Alison Lohman and Tim McGraw), and a post-punk-scored period piece about the least punk human being ever (Sofia Coppola‘s "Marie Antoinette," starring Kirsten Dunst). What do the critics have to say?

Is America a great country? Yes. Do the soldiers who fought in WWII, the Greatest Generation, deserve our utmost praise for their sacrifices? Without a doubt. Is the truth often more complicated than the myth? Definitely. Clint Eastwood‘s latest, "Flags of Our Fathers," tells the story of that famous photo of the servicemen raising the flag atop Iwo Jima, and the trials and tribulations their celebrity caused. Critics say the film is so rich with historical information and inherent drama that it’s occasionally a little too much, but strong performances and Eastwood’s sure directorial hand keep things on track. At 69 percent on the Tomatometer, "Flags" may not reach the heights of Eastwood’s last film, "Million Dollar Baby" (92 percent), but it’s still flying pretty high. (Check out our feature on Clint’s filmography here.)

Clint Eastwood pays tribute to the Greatest Generation.

With "Memento," Christopher Nolan made a name for himself by holding his secrets close to the vest to the bitter end. Now comes "The Prestige," in which the director again serves up a brain-teaser, this time involving a pair of public manipulators in their own right. Christian Bale and Hugh Jackman star as bitterly competitive magicians in turn-of- the-century London who play a deadly game of one-upmanship. While some scribes say the movie is uneven in spots, "The Prestige" is winning praise for its remarkable production design, sharp performances, and more than enough cinematic sleight-of-hand to keep audiences interested. At 68 percent, this is Nolan’s worst reviewed film, and it’s still getting its share of prestige.

"Headlines don’t sell papes. Newsies sell papes."

There is no shortage of stories involving adolescents and their beloved equine friends, from Steinbeck‘s "The Red Pony" to "The Black Stallion" to last year’s "Dreamer." Critics say "Flicka," itself a remake, is a strong and affecting entry into this sub-genre. The film stars Alison Lohman as a 16-year-old who loves her untamed horse and the freedom of the open range, and Tim McGraw as her father, a man with different ideas about her future. Some critics say "Flicka" is an old-fashioned, solid family drama with a notable lack of schmaltz, but others say the material is too well-trodden to really hit home. At 60 percent on the Tomatometer, "Flicka" ain’t Secretariat, but it’s not ready for the glue factory, either.

"Flicka": Full of horsing around!

In the song "Natural’s Not In It," the socialist British post-punk band Gang of Four sarcastically lamented "the problem of leisure / what to do for pleasure," words that are especially resonant if you’re a teenage monarch ruling a country you know little about, and your subjects are calling for your head. Sofia Coppola‘s long-awaited (and already controversial) "Marie Antoinette" tells the story of the queen (Kirsten Dunst), her inattentive husband, Louis XVI (Jason Schwartzman), her gossipy, silver-tongued court, and all the empty fun she had before she gets her head chopped off. Critics say Coppola’s film offers a wealth of visual riches and makes Marie’s hardships somewhat empathetic, but they’re split over its apparent lack of substance, as well as the anachronistic use of music by the likes of New Order, the Strokes, and Siouxsie and the Banshees. At 64 percent on the Tomatometer, this is definitely a cut (pun intended) below Coppola’s last feature, "Lost in Translation" (95 percent), but it’s still a pretty tasty piece of cake.

"A new royal family / A wild nobility / We are the family."

Also opening this week in limited release: "51 Birch Street," a documentary exploring the hidden lives of the filmmaker Doug Block’s parents, is at 100 percent on the Tomatometer; "Requiem," a German tale of epilepsy/demonic possession, is at 100 percent; Tim Burton‘s stop motion anti-holiday classic "The Nightmare Before Christmas," getting a re-release, is at 96 percent; "Sweet Land," a sweeping tale of the American immigrant experience, is at 93 percent; "Jonestown: The Life and Death of Peoples Temple," a documentary about cult leader Jim Jones and his flock, is at 92 percent; "Hair High," a perverse animated comedy about a strange high school, is at 63 percent; "Sleeping Dogs Lie," Bobcat Goldthwait‘s sweet, taboo-busting rom-com, is at 59 percent; and "Running with Scissors," a tale of therapy and growing pains starring Annette Bening and Gwyneth Paltrow, is at 17 percent.

Recent Clint Eastwood-Directed Movies:
92% — Million Dollar Baby (2004)
86% — Mystic River (2003)
56% — Blood Work (2002)
78% — Space Cowboys (2000)
50% — True Crime (1999)

Recent Kirsten Dunst Movies:
28% — Elizabethtown (2005)
62% — Wimbledon (2004)
7% — Kaena: The Prophesy (2004)
93% — Spider Man 2 (2004)
93% — Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)

Recent Christian Bale Movies:
59% — The New World (2005)
84% — Batman Begins (2005)
85% — Howl’s Moving Castle (2005)
72% — The Machinist (2004)
68% — Laurel Canyon (2003)

Tag Cloud

Action YouTube Red comic doctor who political drama crime Best and Worst medical drama Amazon dceu Nominations TV Land composers SundanceTV teaser Sundance Now Shondaland disaster Pixar Infographic FXX Oscars Fox News History television richard e. Grant Pop Podcast Bravo biography APB CMT MTV Freeform theme song Sundance Lucasfilm Polls and Games discovery SDCC Countdown serial killer Britbox Mary Tyler Moore Adult Swim science fiction mockumentary Calendar 21st Century Fox toy story Tarantino Comedy Central Elton John RT21 crime thriller Song of Ice and Fire FX VH1 Paramount San Diego Comic-Con The Witch TCM blaxploitation cats BET Rocky ABC Family Mystery sports President elevated horror 2018 American Society of Cinematographers Reality Competition E3 Amazon Prime mutant Watching Series dc festivals TLC binge Nickelodeon Superheroe YouTube Premium green book Awards Tour politics Paramount Network Stephen King Warner Bros. space MCU streaming Winners game show Red Carpet 24 frames Superheroes Hulu cops Extras Ellie Kemper Winter TV Trivia DC streaming service animated sequel TNT vampires zombies adaptation CBS Writers Guild of America true crime Fantasy YA Teen GoT ITV ABC 2015 Thanksgiving Black Mirror TCA Sneak Peek casting AMC finale dramedy DC Comics CNN ESPN ratings Mary poppins strong female leads Showtime hist Syfy cinemax docudrama Heroines cooking TIFF Fall TV nature 007 Mary Poppins Returns Photos HBO Columbia Pictures Box Office USA technology FOX Cartoon Network war harry potter OWN PaleyFest Valentine's Day 2019 Comics on TV DGA 2017 golden globes TBS crossover Spike TruTV WGN Set visit Certified Fresh Super Bowl Tumblr MSNBC Awards Emmys Tomatazos sitcom Masterpiece zero dark thirty Comedy Character Guide Star Wars Food Network TV DirecTV facebook IFC Trailer Rocketman New York Comic Con historical drama BBC America Music Election Reality SXSW Premiere Dates diversity Summer Pet Sematary anime cults justice league The CW PBS Chernobyl Ghostbusters Biopics spy thriller Star Trek talk show Spring TV IFC Films transformers Starz Martial Arts thriller aliens USA Network Film Festival miniseries Christmas psycho The Arrangement Musicals psychological thriller Marvel TCA 2017 Pirates Walt Disney Pictures Crackle GIFs Grammys Acorn TV spinoff comiccon Western Toys Spectrum Originals Ovation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Lifetime El Rey VICE Video Games Disney unscripted RT History witnail Vudu jamie lee curtis Brie Larson period drama spider-man Captain marvel Epix award winner Rom-Com adventure crime drama Women's History Month Creative Arts Emmys Schedule Logo NBC Marathons See It Skip It based on movie LGBTQ singing competition Quiz Pride Month Esquire zombie GLAAD Cannes Animation 2016 Mudbound Comic Book BBC Kids & Family dragons Dark Horse Comics what to watch Disney Channel DC Universe romance NYCC social media Drama First Look Nat Geo police drama travel Shudder Netflix Interview robots 20th Century Fox Rock Lionsgate Trophy Talk supernatural Year in Review 45 Anna Paquin CBS All Access Sony Pictures Sci-Fi Horror Country X-Men boxoffice Apple anthology Mindy Kaling Holidays Universal E! Opinion Musical natural history Chilling Adventures of Sabrina CW Seed National Geographic A&E Cosplay