90th Oscars Ceremony Scores Low Marks with Critics

Politics, host Jimmy Kimmel, and playing it safe all weighed on the event's Tomatometer score.

by | March 5, 2018 | Comments

The films and talent awarded Oscars on Sunday weren’t the only ones being weighed and measured – critics have reviewed the 90th Oscars ceremony itself, which is now Rotten at 50% on the Tomatometer with 24 reviews (updated).

The Academy Awards, broadcast live from the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood on ABC, split critics, who generally felt the event played it safe, but ran long. (When does it not?)

Below are a few of the early reactions.

What Some Liked About the Oscars – Its Surefootedness …

“This was the best, most inspiring, and most sheerly likable Academy Awards telecast I’ve ever seen and I’ve seen ’em all.” – David Edelstein, New York Magazine/Vulture

“What fun we had at this year’s Oscars! Long show, sure, but where to cut it?” – Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

“There are probably a lot of people adjacent to the Oscars who just didn’t want any surprises Sunday night. And the biggest takeaway from the evening — the good news and the bad news — is that there weren’t any.” – Linda Holmes, NPR

…Was Also What Others Hated About It

“The Oscars telecast, clocking in at four hours and 50 minutes, was chock-full of carefully-produced moments. Yet it couldn’t live up to its own.” – Kevin Fallon, The Daily Beast

“The unwieldy thing was a chore even for movie lovers who had seen the nominees.” – Hal Boedeker, Orlando Sentinel

“Little about Sunday’s show is likely to make the cut of future greatest-hit Oscar tributes.” – Matt Roush, TV Insider

“At the end of the evening Dunaway and Beatty presented the Oscar, with no hiccups, to The Shape of Water, an undramatic end to an undramatic evening.” – Willa Paskin, Slate

“Was it respectful? Absolutely. Did it make for kind of a dull, earnest Oscars show. Yeah, kind of.” – Kristi Turnquist, Oregonian

“The 90th Annual Academy Awards was the most tepid, predictable one in recent memory, devoid of anything resembling a spontaneous or dramatic moment until it was nearly time to wrap it all up.” – Sara Stewart, New York Post

“The jokes were funny, but, for the most part, the events of the evening were extraordinarily tame. The industry seems, above all, to be protecting itself — shielding itself from any sense that its corruption is built into the system.” – Richard Brody, New Yorker

Some Were Hoping for a Different Host

“[Jimmy] Kimmel didn’t appear to be trying to give a big home run performance; his goal was to serve as our dependable guide through rough waters, to celebrate Hollywood at a time when it is embattled. And he succeeded.” – Matthew Gilbert, Boston Globe

“With the exception of the theater stunt and two unnecessary tossed-off Matt Damon jokes — Kimmel really can’t resist — I thought he was good, probably even better than last year.” – Dan Fienberg, Hollywood Reporter

“The best thing Kimmel could have done was announce he was stepping aside to let a woman host… He chose not to do that and ended up much like the statue of the Oscar he made fun of for having no reproductive organ: It was a eunuch’s performance.” – Ken Tucker, Yahoo! TV

“A new host behind the mic… would have delivered a more powerful show. One that wouldn’t have felt nearly four hours long (even though it was); one thoroughly unforgettable instead of sporadically memorable.” – Ben Travers, indieWire

“Kimmel has shown that the telecast needn’t be anything but sharp and sure, with a funny host whose bits are manageable, shareable and — best of all — forgotten. We’re not making showbiz history here.” – Hank Stuever, Washington Post

Politics Divide Critics

“The Oscars have a long history of self-congratulation…This Oscar ceremony brought home the fact that the changes have been a long time coming. It was also a potent reminder that they have a long, long way to go.” – Rob Sheffield, Rolling Stone

“Both cloying and clever, gassy and game-faced, these Academy Awards did the best they could to address difficult things, short of canceling the whole thing and airing some kind of P.S.A…it was good to at least see the Academy thinking things through.” – Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

“No show can be apolitical. The Oscars as a ceremony basically tried to be, but its performers, presenters, and winners rejected it, and that’s to their credit.” – Daniel D’Addario, TIME Magazine

“The ceremony felt like a re-enactment of Hollywood’s progress on any number of fronts: Two steps forward, three steps back.” – Maureen Ryan, Variety

“Overall, it felt like the Oscars ceremony 2018 needed. Women were given a platform to talk that felt like more than just tokenism… [Frances] McDormand’s speech was a rallying cry to ensure equality isn’t just a buzzword.” – Hannah Woodhead, Little White Lies

“Much of Sunday’s broadcast, hosted for the second straight year by Jimmy Kimmel, seemed to point a way forward for the industry.” – Jake Coyle, Associated Press

“The whole ceremony was like this for me: halfway toward good. It dutifully mentioned #TimesUp and trotted out actresses to explain it…I didn’t want safe. Not this year. I wanted some anger, or at least passion.” – Johanna Schneller, Toronto Star

Tag Cloud

Red Carpet Best and Worst Cosplay OWN cars mockumentary Winners RT21 unscripted SundanceTV renewed TV shows Pop Syfy Calendar DC Comics theme song Animation Tumblr Universal streaming rotten movies we love adaptation hispanic Amazon Prime facebook Ovation Trophy Talk Marathons 2020 revenge comiccon Black Mirror Year in Review Discovery Channel justice league finale Comedy Disney Channel Amazon TCA YouTube Red Rom-Com joker screenings cinemax Endgame disaster Spring TV green book serial killer boxoffice Peacock Lifetime Christmas movies ESPN Emmy Nominations docudrama Sundance TV CMT Heroines 21st Century Fox Avengers blockbuster Rocky Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Quiz Amazon Studios Mary Tyler Moore screen actors guild Fox News Drama cancelled social media casting witnail Spike E3 Winter TV crime YouTube Food Network supernatural TCA 2017 Nominations composers Disney crime drama A&E strong female leads crossover Pixar Women's History Month IFC series A24 Crackle Extras Comic Book period drama werewolf canceled TV shows south america Film Festival hist MSNBC comic Showtime crime thriller police drama FXX Shondaland Martial Arts DC Universe sequel zombie video book sports Paramount Network directors Schedule GIFs IFC Films TCM Set visit Classic Film cancelled television Binge Guide ITV toy story Vudu Polls and Games Video Games indie talk show movie Bravo Sneak Peek spinoff Freeform Super Bowl Thanksgiving Tomatazos Oscars 2019 LGBT TCA Winter 2020 See It Skip It TV renewals 007 zero dark thirty diversity Nat Geo Television Academy animated Warner Bros. 2016 Star Trek MCU Hallmark Christmas movies jamie lee curtis Mudbound WGN Acorn TV Awards Tour Rocketman Fantasy Esquire Reality ratings batman Christmas richard e. Grant political drama Hallmark FOX BBC USA Network HBO Max spain NYCC tv talk movies 24 frames Academy Awards TLC Reality Competition travel Lucasfilm dogs Awards spanish language Lifetime breaking bad Podcast psycho Apple TV Plus dc thriller TIFF Tubi stand-up comedy GoT Marvel Comics on TV The Arrangement what to watch Disney streaming service Comedy Central Marvel Studios spider-man mutant harry potter FX kids Anna Paquin children's TV BET cooking Paramount cartoon Arrowverse Election RT History space The CW Logo miniseries politics Chernobyl Certified Fresh based on movie Apple TV+ Cannes E! Britbox canceled Disney+ Disney Plus Elton John VH1 psychological thriller spy thriller Action cancelled TV shows AMC ABC Family Mary Poppins Returns science fiction Premiere Dates teaser Holiday zombies X-Men war Trailer Film WarnerMedia HBO Horror TNT historical drama USA 2017 award winner Valentine's Day Shudder nature anthology 2015 christmas movies Song of Ice and Fire game of thrones sitcom Brie Larson quibi Sony Pictures Creative Arts Emmys ABC Dark Horse Comics Star Wars Nickelodeon VICE free movies Netflix Christmas movies golden globes cats El Rey Netflix SDCC biography TV medical drama 20th Century Fox Stephen King Western Toys PBS TV Land foreign Masterpiece reboot cancelled TV series Marvel Television Grammys Crunchyroll Superheroes Pride Month Disney Plus romance Musicals Writers Guild of America Opinion Cartoon Network 45 First Reviews Musical National Geographic LGBTQ Ellie Kemper independent latino singing competition YA Adult Swim Amazon Prime Video TBS The Witch TruTV BBC America ghosts Mystery cops The Walking Dead President name the review sag awards First Look San Diego Comic-Con Spectrum Originals Turner Turner Classic Movies slashers American Society of Cinematographers SXSW Pet Sematary Sci-Fi elevated horror aliens DirecTV halloween Country blaxploitation Watching Series Apple YouTube Premium Trivia CBS All Access CBS Fall TV DGA versus transformers television GLAAD vampires dragons robots Family true crime CNN natural history Sundance Interview Columbia Pictures OneApp Mary poppins anime technology Captain marvel Sundance Now dceu Countdown romantic comedy Kids & Family Biopics adventure PaleyFest CW Seed Holidays Rock Epix Ghostbusters Hulu APB doctor who Tarantino Infographic Mindy Kaling comics festivals 71st Emmy Awards Starz documentary binge Music Lionsgate Superheroe History dramedy New York Comic Con NBC The Purge game show Walt Disney Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Photos Emmys Box Office Character Guide 2018 DC streaming service Pirates cults Summer discovery Baby Yoda MTV Teen