Total Recall

10 Awesome Video Games That Were Made Into Terrible Movies

In this installment of Total Recall, we look at some of Hollywood's worst attempts to bring video games to the big screen.

by | July 22, 2015 | Comments

As film fans know, video games have been used to inflict pain and senseless brutality at the cineplex for years now. In honor of that miserable tradition, we elected to devote this feature to a look back at some of the least entertaining game-to-film adaptations Hollywood’s ever produced, and while there was definitely no shortage of contenders, we narrowed it down to a particularly pungent few while making room for plenty of variety (in other words, only one Uwe Boll film made the list). Up Up Down Down Left Right Left Right B A Start: It’s time for Total Recall!


Alone in the Dark (2005) 1%

AloneDark2

(Photo by Lionsgate/Courtesy Everett Collection)

Here’s where we admit what many of you have known all along: If we’d done things a little differently, this list could have been largely comprised of Uwe Boll movies. For whatever reason, Mr. Boll has displayed a deep affinity for video game adaptations over the course of his remarkable career, and the “bad game movie” subgenre’s byways are clogged with the effluvia of his cinematic efforts. In the interest of variety, however, we decided to limit his appearances here, leaving us with one obvious choice: 2005’s Alone in the Dark, an alleged sci-fi thriller starring Christian Slater as a paranormal detective and Tara Reid as a scientist — both of whom are investigating the disappearance of an ancient civilization that prayed to space demons. Extremely loosely based on the Alone in the Dark game series — which was itself loosely based on H.P. Lovecraft’s writings — the movie found itself alone in the dark with scores of sparsely populated theaters playing host to scornful critics like the San Francisco Examiner’s Rossiter Drake, who guffawed, “The late Gene Siskel once devised a simple method of measuring a film’s worth: ‘Is this film more interesting than a documentary of the same actors having lunch?’ Alone in the Dark doesn’t come close to matching that standard.”

Watch Trailer


Doom (2005) 18%

Doom

(Photo by Universal/Courtesy Everett Collection)

He has since ascended to “franchise Viagra” status, but Dwayne Johnson’s early years as a Hollywood action hero were a little bumpy. After his breakout appearance in The Mummy Returns, he struggled to find a solid fit for his beefy build and natural screen charisma, occasionally turning in critically lauded performances in box-office misses (The Rundown) or working overtime to prop up misguided action flicks (Walking Tall). 2005’s Doom falls into the latter category, repurposing the hugely popular first-person shooter as a sci-fi thriller about a crew of soldiers sent to rescue a colony on Mars after residents accidentally open a portal to Hell and unleash a horde of murderous creatures. While the film included plenty of the tunnel-bound warfare that fans of the game had come to expect, the end result was — as critics would repeatedly point out regarding plenty of like-minded pictures over the years — more fun to play than to watch. “Doom,” pointed out Roger Ebert, “is like some kid came over and is using your computer and won’t let you play.”

Watch Trailer


Double Dragon (1994) 12%

(Photo by GramercyPictures/Courtesy Everett Collection)

 

How do you make a movie out of a game based on nothing more than a pair of brothers pummeling the bejeesus out of bad guys? If you’re Double Dragon screenwriters Michael Davis and Peter Gould, the unfortunate answer is “come up with a convoluted story involving halves of a mystical amulet” — and things only went downhill from there, after director James Yukich built a cast that included future Party of Five veteran Scott Wolf and former Who’s the Boss? star Alyssa Milano. The result was a deeply hokey 90 minutes of low-budget chop-socky action that provoked near-universal guffaws from critics like Luke Y. Thompson of the New Times, who wondered, “How hard would it be to come up with a story at least as good as that of the original Nintendo game? Impossible, apparently.”

Watch Trailer


Hitman (2007) 16%

Hitman

(Photo by 20th Century Fox/Courtesy Everett Collection)

There have been so many lame game-to-film adaptations that it can be tempting to believe there’s simply no point in trying to bridge the two mediums, but there really are video games that look like they might make good movies; unfortunately, as 2007’s Hitman proved, even the most cinematic backstory doesn’t necessarily mean a polished final product. Starring Timothy Olyphant as Agent 47, a member of an army of bald and bar-coded assassins who finds himself double-crossed by the shadowy organization that trained him from birth to kill, it looked on paper like just the sort of globe-trotting action thriller that might keep 007 fans satisfied between Bond sequels — yet the end result was a picture every bit as smoothly anonymous as its protagonist. A planned sequel was scrapped, and although Hitman’s $99 million box office tally ensured an eventual reboot (due in August) that might do a better job of distilling the game’s appeal, the original is still a case of sadly wasted potential. “47 doesn’t even want the girl,” pointed out a frustrated Tricia Olszewski for the Washington City Paper. “What kind of action movie is this? A skippable one, ultimately.”

Watch Trailer


Max Payne (2008) 15%

MaxPayne

(Photo by 20th Century Fox/Courtesy Everett Collection)

For a certain breed of filmgoer, all you really need to make an entertaining movie is hand Mark Wahlberg a gun. Max Payne, director John Moore’s adaptation of the hit video game series about a vigilante cop gunning for justice after the murders of his wife, child, and partner, was made exactly for those people and pretty much no one else — with the possible exception of Sin City fans who want to watch a movie that wishes it could be Sin City, or maybe noir enthusiasts who feel the genre needs more murderous winged man-creatures. For just about everyone else, Max Payne is a painfully misguided hash of “gritty” action and digital effects, all directed within an inch of its life; as Michael Phillips wrote for the Chicago Tribune, “You find yourself rooting against Payne’s survival, even with a good actor in the hollow role. There’s nothing inside the film’s sour, slovenly spirit of vengeance.”

Watch Trailer


Mortal Kombat Annihilation (1997) 4%

(Photo by New Line Cinema/Courtesy Everett Collection)

 

The first Mortal Kombat may not have been a major work of cinematic art, but it had its moments, and overall made for a pleasantly undemanding afternoon of chop-socky entertainment with mystical mumbo-jumbo overtones — and it was rewarded for achieving those limited goals with a surprising run of box office domination and a gross approaching $125 million. Sadly, little of that fun — or the original cast — remained by the time Mortal Kombat: Annihilation arrived in theaters, and the result was a box office bomb that put the nascent Kombat franchise into a development deep freeze from which, at the time of this writing, it’s still struggling to escape. “Never — at least not since the first Mortal Kombat,” sighed the Philadelphia Inquirer’s Steven Rea, “has tedium been so loud, so full of backward flips and flying fists to the kissers of centaurs from another realm.”

Watch Trailer


Silent Hill: Revelation (2012) 10%

(Photo by Kerry Hayes/Open Road Films/Courtesy Everett Collection)

 

Critics pooped all over the first Silent Hill movie, but it made nearly $100 million anyway, so six years later we were treated to Silent Hill: Revelation, which picked up after the events of the first film (but followed the plot of the Silent Hill 3 video game) by following the harrowing new exploits suffered by Christopher Da Silva (a returning Sean Bean) and his adopted daughter Sharon (Adelaide Clemens) after her mother (Radha Mitchell) is trapped in a sinister ghost dimension. It’s a premise with a certain spine-tingling promise; alas, very little of it translated to the screen, and Silent Hill: Revelation ended up grossing roughly half of what the original made. “It’s never a good sign,” groaned Mark Olsen of the Los Angeles Times, “when the trailers playing before a film have richer, more complete narratives than the feature you’ve paid to see.”

Watch Trailer


Street Fighter (1994) 11%

(Photo by MGM/Courtesy Everett Collection)

 

Given Street Fighter’s lowly reputation, one would hardly guess it made nearly $100 million during its box office run, but that’s the risk a filmmaker runs when he puts a beanie on Jean-Claude Van Damme and casts Raul Julia as a bizarre military dictator — and that’s exactly the sort of infamy that awaited this misbegotten attempt to turn mountains of arcade quarters into box office glory. As with Double Dragon, one of the chief problems was that of plot — specifically, how to spin one out of a game that revolved more or less solely around people beating each other up — and writer-director Steven de Souza compensated by imagining a surreal standoff between the megalomaniacal M. Bison (Julia) and a Megaforce-style military force dubbed the Allied Nations. We could delve into the narrative further, but the end result would be the same: Plenty of silly fight scenes and a heaping helping of horrible reviews from critics like Stephen Holden of the New York Times, who dismissed Street Fighter as “A dreary, overstuffed hodgepodge of poorly edited martial arts sequences and often unintelligible dialogue.”

Watch Trailer


Super Mario Bros. (1993) 28%

(Photo by Buena Vista Pictures/Courtesy Everett Collection)

 

We all knew this was going to make the list, right? The grandaddy of all game-to-film box office bombs, 1990’s Super Mario Bros. was supposed to be gaming’s Hollywood coming-out party — proof that not only had video games truly arrived as entertainment with real staying power, but that gamers were an audience just waiting to be tapped by film studios who could make millions bringing pre-existing franchises to the big screen. All of which sounds great, but fails to take into account the fact that directors Rocky Morton and Annabel Jankel were trying to make a movie out of a game about sibling plumbers who run through a series of bizarre worlds in pursuit of a princess who’s been captured by a giant turtle, and who have to battle an insane menagerie of villains (including sentient mushrooms) along the way. After an extensive casting search that included attempts to lure in Danny DeVito, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and Tom Hanks, the filmmakers eventually hired Bob Hoskins and John Leguizamo to play brothers Mario and Luigi, while Dennis Hopper agreed to portray the villainous humanoid reptile-thing King Koopa, but all the acting talent in the world couldn’t have made a dent in the cacophonous mess that is Super Mario Bros., which turned out to be such a critical and commercial dud that the game’s developer, Nintendo, swore off film adaptations for decades. “Kids might get a charge out of the mayhem,” groaned the Charlotte Observer’s Lawrence Toppman. “I got the vapors.”

Watch Trailer


Wing Commander (1999) 10%

(Photo by 20th Century Fox/Courtesy Everett Collection)

 

By the late ‘90s, Matthew Lillard and Freddie Prinze, Jr. were ready to graduate from teen romcoms… which they signaled, unfortunately, by signing up for the disastrous big-screen adaptation of Wing Commander, which found them trying in vain to wring big-screen thrills out of a hokey story involving a future interstellar war between humans and an alien race of catlike bipeds. It’s a premise that sounds thoroughly silly to Commander novices, and director Chris Roberts compounded the problem by making several key changes to the game’s characters and mythology that alienated core gamers who might have otherwise turned out for the film. Observed Anita Gates for the New York Times, “Wing Commander is based on a video game and has roughly the same degree of character development. That is all most moviegoers will need to know.”

Watch Trailer

Tag Cloud

IFC Films streaming movies The Arrangement foreign razzies SXSW 2022 YouTube Red twilight political drama Emmys Tomatazos Countdown nature Extras 2021 OWN Warner Bros. Animation feel good Musical Video Games Calendar TCA Winter 2020 true crime Oscars Star Wars Celebration Election See It Skip It AMC summer preview nfl independent Rom-Com First Reviews stand-up comedy aapi Tumblr Family olympics critic resources stoner BBC America blockbusters classics Star Trek 90s E3 Adult Swim remakes Holidays hispanic heritage month strong female leads Baby Yoda Disney Plus a nightmare on elm street thriller Arrowverse TV Land NBA spy thriller Mary Tyler Moore Discovery Channel sequels dark festivals Emmy Nominations universal monsters historical drama Freeform asian-american comic books animated DirecTV indiana jones stop motion Marvel TV movies vs. 79th Golden Globes Awards Dark Horse Comics Disney+ Disney Plus 2020 TruTV Sci-Fi supernatural Best Actor superhero CBS All Access young adult Apple TV Plus sports godzilla Britbox justice league Character Guide discovery debate comiccon marvel cinematic universe gangster GoT spain Marvel Studios Nickelodeon leaderboard Geeked Week Mary Poppins Returns TV renewals women CNN Classic Film Academy Awards Black History Month social media politics Pet Sematary Certified Fresh live event Marathons SundanceTV natural history basketball crossover pirates of the caribbean YouTube Quiz Rocky CW Seed psychological thriller 007 cancelled television Fox News Alien 2018 Comic-Con@Home 2021 joker Writers Guild of America 4/20 Legendary trailers popular Logo Star Wars festival 2017 Hollywood Foreign Press Association LGBTQ parents series Showtime new york BBC One Disney Channel Marvel Television cops Red Carpet VH1 book Captain marvel Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Stephen King scary Hallmark disaster kong japan Peacock E! Apple TV+ king arthur Masterpiece australia The Walking Dead monster movies tv talk Creative Arts Emmys what to watch Reality Competition 21st Century Fox FXX History Broadway Chernobyl Television Critics Association football GLAAD Rock Women's History Month FOX rt labs critics edition The Academy Winners TCM nbcuniversal GIFs Opinion scene in color boxing Sundance Now talk show spanish language Watching Series comics TBS genre RT History Lucasfilm streaming anime Interview HBO Go latino Shudder dceu Oscar X-Men sag awards The CW Song of Ice and Fire Netflix Paramount 99% South by Southwest Film Festival Pride Month prank WGN Heroines Paramount Network action-comedy black child's play Prime Video Trailer Focus Features theme song SDCC Comic Book batman Country Pop spinoff japanese Podcast doctor who 20th Century Fox chucky New York Comic Con movies transformers rotten criterion romance Christmas LGBT award winner 94th Oscars broadcast french mission: impossible Lifetime American Society of Cinematographers OneApp wonder woman cancelled TV series reboot hollywood composers toronto video Universal Ellie Kemper new zealand Avengers based on movie Epix art house Image Comics zero dark thirty Superheroe free movies best Amazon Prime Video Film Festival game of thrones period drama obituary The Witch Television Academy rotten movies we love dreamworks Walt Disney Pictures 93rd Oscars MGM blockbuster spider-verse cinemax AMC Plus cancelled high school cars zombie witnail scene in color film series Sneak Peek USA El Rey green book NBC halloween tv 73rd Emmy Awards slasher diversity Year in Review cults italian quibi Disney Action TCA new star wars movies golden globes adenture Valentine's Day HBO toy story Lifetime Christmas movies Vudu Binge Guide ghosts children's TV crime drama YouTube Premium Amazon Studios DC Universe adaptation Hallmark Christmas movies Bravo christmas movies Super Bowl Nat Geo romantic comedy Exclusive Video cancelled TV shows Turner Classic Movies Neflix Shondaland The Purge directors RT21 ABC Signature Winter TV suspense game show Paramount Pictures Fox Searchlight TIFF CBS MTV television Rocketman VOD black comedy APB spanish summer TV boxoffice A24 rt labs Sundance TV 2015 films reviews Mindy Kaling news Esquire dramedy Hulu Cannes Food Network Cosplay Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Biopics First Look Toys Paramount Plus king kong ESPN Reality teaser streamig miniseries rom-coms Disney streaming service superman DC Comics Anna Paquin die hard casting Grammys Photos Box Office Elton John Crackle book adaptation TCA Awards cartoon BET Awards Mystery Superheroes Drama DC streaming service video on demand screenings Pirates venice 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards HFPA comic book movie fast and furious deadpool slashers indie target interviews posters WarnerMedia royal family Awards Tour Instagram Live scorecard YA fresh Acorn TV singing competition hist Spike 24 frames Sundance canceled 72 Emmy Awards werewolf Tarantino DGA NYCC ITV Spring TV documentaries Infographic ABC Family jurassic park breaking bad BAFTA satire Pacific Islander Lionsgate golden globe awards The Walt Disney Company rt archives dogs finale war 1990s dc cooking Netflix Christmas movies Syfy jamie lee curtis Amazon space trophy Mudbound telelvision Sony Pictures cats dexter President ID Pop TV Comedy police drama halloween screen actors guild Wes Anderson Apple comic Ghostbusters spider-man know your critic emmy awards medical drama CMT crime james bond Film legend MCU MSNBC kaiju biopic mcc National Geographic documentary Nominations Endgame travel Best Picture Fantasy hidden camera Trophy Talk comedies facebook archives serial killer unscripted docuseries PaleyFest mutant Martial Arts IMDb TV Set visit FX hispanic blaxploitation Best and Worst Awards aliens Universal Pictures VICE worst movies sopranos BET 71st Emmy Awards Ovation Best Actress revenge IFC scene in color series USA Network name the review canceled TV shows PBS Indigenous SXSW Tubi sequel science fiction richard e. Grant Holiday zombies south america franchise dragons all-time ABC BBC Native 45 vampires international Black Mirror Amazon Prime mob Schedule TLC harry potter anthology PlayStation Western movie Best Director Cartoon Network Trivia Comedy Central summer TV preview Music TNT live action Fargo FX on Hulu Brie Larson renewed TV shows mockumentary Summer Teen ViacomCBS psycho concert Mary poppins technology Starz Horror Sony robots HBO Max binge Tags: Comedy lord of the rings target scene in color TV scary movies obi wan Hear Us Out saw Kids & Family Columbia Pictures Fall TV docudrama Turner 2016 biography Pixar Premiere Dates versus Thanksgiving comic book movies heist movie Spectrum Originals Tokyo Olympics Travel Channel TCA 2017 crime thriller kids Polls and Games critics sitcom ratings San Diego Comic-Con marvel comics Crunchyroll elevated horror adventure A&E Comics on TV Funimation worst 2019 Musicals laika TV One