Best-Reviewed Returning TV Shows 2019

They say that sophomore seasons are often when the greatest shows hit their strides, and in 2019 second seasons dominated our list of the best-reviewed returning TV shows of the year. Fleabag, Mindhunter, Barry, Succession, and Dark all just got better for their second outings, according to the critics, and crowded out our top 10. Elsewhere, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, returning not just from another season but from the brink of extinction having been saved by NBC, showed that it could still draw quality laughs in its sixth season, while other beloved series in our list – Broad City, Fleabag – sadly won’t be returning again.

The order of the rank below reflects the Adjusted Score as of December 31, 2019. Scores might change over time.

Fleabag: Season 2 (2019)
100%

#1
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Fleabag jumps back into the fray with a bracing second season that upholds its predecessor's frenzied wit and delicate heart, replete with Phoebe Waller-Bridge's indefatigable charisma.

#2
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Mindhunter expands its narrative horizons without losing sight of the details that made its first season so rich, crafting a chilling second season that is as unsettling as it is utterly absorbing.

Barry: Season 2 (2019)
100%

#3
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Barry follows up a pitch-perfect debut with a second season that balances darkness with comedy while steering clear of antihero overindulgence.

#4
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Succession returns in darkly funny form, with sharp writing, exceptional performances, and a surprising new level of sympathy for some of television's least likable characters.

#5
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Pamela Adlon fully asserts her authorial voice over Better Things in a triumphant third season that examines the exhaustion of motherhood with exhilarating artistry.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: As timely and tender as ever, One Day at a Time's third season manages to up to comedy ante without losing the intimate family moments that help it hit so close to home.

#7
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Rick and Morty's fourth season is both an exciting progression and a delightful return to form that proves more than worth the two-year wait.

Dark: Season 2 (2019)
100%

#8
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Dark's sumptuous second season descends deeper into the show's meticulously-crafted mythos and cements the series as one of streaming's strongest and strangest science fiction stories.
Directed By: Baran bo Odar

Broad City: Season 5 (2019)
100%

#9
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Glazer and Jacobson give the people exactly what they want in Broad City's final season - relatable content, questionable intimacy, and ingenious escapades through the glorious squalor of IRL NYC.

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Following a period of uncertainty and a shift to NBC, Brooklyn Nine-Nine reemerges with its cast and tone wholly intact.

Tag Cloud

dramedy YouTube feel good hispanic AMC Nat Geo Esquire supernatural Pop Schedule summer preview VICE television Character Guide Mudbound Columbia Pictures TruTV FOX james bond aliens South by Southwest Film Festival 72 Emmy Awards australia Best Actress E3 all-time summer TV preview Teen Film Festival 90s Rom-Com Comic Book franchise TV TLC boxing Amazon Studios cinemax Holiday italian Amazon Prime Video Extras Best Picture comiccon zombie Dark Horse Comics Vudu Podcast screenings Box Office Mindy Kaling Apple TV+ what to watch 007 E! DC streaming service SDCC HBO Max blockbuster directors Discovery Channel venice jurassic park heist movie dogs Cosplay MCU WarnerMedia Country scorecard Sci-Fi ESPN Musical MSNBC Oscar Lifetime cooking canceled saw genre crime parents TV movies news justice league Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt San Diego Comic-Con Star Trek Prime Video Reality Competition Rocky Quiz concert Red Carpet rotten reviews Women's History Month doctor who golden globes The Walt Disney Company VH1 period drama sports 20th Century Fox adventure 2018 cults biopic Disney+ Disney Plus Emmys Hulu 4/20 Hallmark Christmas movies Disney streaming service Black History Month anime Toys Year in Review Kids & Family Paramount asian-american Disney Plus Comic-Con@Home 2021 BBC based on movie Alien Shondaland CMT transformers Best Director adaptation docuseries spider-man Marathons 21st Century Fox twilight nfl See It Skip It streaming universal monsters Superheroe golden globe awards mission: impossible romance BET Awards posters 71st Emmy Awards PaleyFest Disney Channel BET streaming movies Academy Awards kong streamig Animation strong female leads dreamworks travel USA Star Wars Celebration Captain marvel indiana jones 2017 The Walking Dead singing competition Winter TV rt archives 99% critic resources classics Freeform X-Men TCA renewed TV shows legend summer TV MGM MTV live event mcc Showtime TCA Winter 2020 adenture Apple TV Plus Trivia Interview discovery psycho sequel royal family critics screen actors guild BBC One book adaptation Thanksgiving finale Indigenous 2016 OWN Action TCA Awards Musicals slashers Lionsgate Writers Guild of America sequels popular Emmy Nominations Fox News docudrama Watching Series rt labs deadpool Set visit video on demand green book comics criterion Infographic richard e. Grant Disney Music Universal History leaderboard pirates of the caribbean anthology ITV ghosts Chernobyl Masterpiece Spike Pet Sematary GLAAD child's play a nightmare on elm street Mary Tyler Moore archives Tags: Comedy National Geographic fast and furious HBO Wes Anderson dceu facebook werewolf Universal Pictures cops psychological thriller cars DC Universe Funimation Classic Film Certified Fresh Avengers TV renewals Mystery Amazon Prime Paramount Plus 45 comedies teaser Drama Pride Month comic books game of thrones cats worst vampires Oscars live action Sony Pictures 2020 target VOD Syfy book marvel comics black Geeked Week Sony Awards Tour Logo Turner Classic Movies Super Bowl crime thriller Western PBS remakes CNN Premiere Dates aapi 24 frames CBS Spectrum Originals laika The Purge Rocketman IFC nature versus Film NBA American Society of Cinematographers hollywood Spring TV Television Critics Association Rock 79th Golden Globes Awards cartoon Nominations crime drama mutant rt labs critics edition TNT thriller tv talk police drama Bravo kids PlayStation 73rd Emmy Awards godzilla japanese GIFs sitcom Star Wars Countdown Marvel Studios scene in color film series casting Christmas CW Seed diversity mob know your critic Shudder Exclusive Video satire Travel Channel composers Hear Us Out Pirates TCA 2017 The Witch ratings Native Pacific Islander best harry potter Legendary romantic comedy Nickelodeon Photos Hollywood Foreign Press Association YA french dragons new zealand scary movies Cannes Focus Features technology superhero vs. toy story Comedy cancelled TV shows science fiction halloween tv LGBTQ Hallmark FXX Superheroes Paramount Network chucky basketball spinoff zombies Crackle Comics on TV miniseries The Arrangement telelvision Image Comics international spanish Acorn TV quibi CBS All Access target scene in color Ellie Kemper award winner reboot Trophy Talk Stephen King independent south america Sneak Peek witnail comic book movies FX on Hulu spy thriller political drama A&E suspense spider-verse medical drama Instagram Live NYCC stoner Lifetime Christmas movies stand-up comedy BBC America HBO Go Reality video Mary Poppins Returns Cartoon Network Baby Yoda NBC Food Network spanish language Fargo 1990s new star wars movies unscripted olympics Elton John Ovation IFC Films A24 worst movies TV Land space lord of the rings Song of Ice and Fire Amazon hidden camera APB festivals Paramount Pictures Lucasfilm Marvel Television TV One ABC halloween Sundance TV marvel cinematic universe Best Actor movies Tomatazos Pop TV Heroines RT21 blockbusters Ghostbusters El Rey war ABC Family scary stop motion batman Marvel canceled TV shows 2015 trailers new york name the review Starz Calendar monster movies slasher disaster hist The Academy Election christmas movies boxoffice natural history Turner 94th Oscars First Reviews Arrowverse Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sundance Now IMDb TV broadcast Adult Swim ViacomCBS ID YouTube Premium movie black comedy high school joker Anna Paquin Sundance TIFF DirecTV DGA New York Comic Con cancelled television robots Apple latino women superman elevated horror Netflix sag awards YouTube Red comic trophy free movies Valentine's Day Comedy Central Polls and Games gangster zero dark thirty BAFTA spain Holidays wonder woman crossover ABC Signature SXSW blaxploitation Broadway DC Comics Biopics documentary Pixar Neflix obituary President die hard talk show Winners Best and Worst AMC Plus theme song toronto serial killer binge prank Tumblr documentaries king kong japan scene in color dexter scene in color series kaiju dc RT History Peacock 93rd Oscars Fall TV comic book movie Family sopranos hispanic heritage month festival debate 2019 young adult 2021 obi wan TBS king arthur Epix emmy awards OneApp Fantasy Summer Creative Arts Emmys Trailer rom-coms children's TV Brie Larson First Look foreign football nbcuniversal Crunchyroll politics TCM Fox Searchlight true crime FX Video Games Britbox animated Endgame jamie lee curtis GoT social media Tarantino WGN series SXSW 2022 action-comedy Grammys Tubi Warner Bros. Black Mirror dark The CW mockumentary rotten movies we love interviews HFPA Awards Opinion cancelled Television Academy Walt Disney Pictures Tokyo Olympics indie Mary poppins revenge historical drama Horror biography cancelled TV series breaking bad SundanceTV game show 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards fresh USA Network art house razzies films Netflix Christmas movies Martial Arts Binge Guide LGBT