Best Animated Series 2023

How do you follow a near-perfect, Golden Tomato Award-winning first season? By releasing a near-perfect, Golden Tomato Award-winning second season, of course, and that’s exactly what Prime Video’s Invincible did in 2023 to top the Best Animated Series category.

Invincible: Season 2 (2023)
100%

#1
Adjusted Score: 103544%
Critics Consensus: Still as bracing as a punch to the face and invigorating with its vivid worldbuilding, Invincible is practically impervious to disappointing audiences in this sterling sophomore season.

Adjusted Score: 100543%
Critics Consensus: Retaining the heart and wit of the original movie while also carving out a fresh path for itself, Scott Pilgrim takes off in the animated medium and soars.

Adjusted Score: 97771%
Critics Consensus: Visually dazzling while paying deft attention to character, Blue Eye Samurai is a masterfully rendered animated adventure.

#4
Adjusted Score: 97549%
Critics Consensus: Having settled into one of DC's most dependably entertaining series, Harley Quinn continues to be funny, quirky, and romantic.

Adjusted Score: 101438%
Critics Consensus: Disturbing and wondrous, Scavengers Reign presents a vividly realized world that beckons exploration by its marooned characters and television viewers alike.