With Henry Cavill (Maybe) Out, Five Ways to Save The DC Extended Universe

With a focus on its strengths, the DC Comics big-screen universe could rival Marvel.

by | September 12, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by © Clay Enos/©Warner Bros.)

While Warner Bros. Pictures’ upcoming slate of films based on DC Comics charactersAquaman, Shazam!, and Wonder Woman 1984 – has the potential to change the narrative course of the studio’s DC film universe, some misfires from early planning continue to plague its attempt to become a competitor to Disney’s Marvel Cinematic Universe. And on Wednesday morning, it seems the film series, known by fans as the “DC Extended Universe” for lack of an official title, lost its Superman. Maybe.

Though there are some conflicting reports – and tweets – it appears Henry Cavill is ready to quit playing Superman. Talks between the studio and Cavill regarding an appearance in Shazam! broke down recently, and coupled with his new status as the star of Netflix’s upcoming Witcher adaptation, it looks like further opportunities to play the first comic book superhero will become limited or impossible. (There is some hope for fans, though: According to the studio, “no decisions have been made regarding any upcoming Superman films” and their relationship with the actor “remains unchanged.” Even Cavill’s manager, Dany Garcia, tweeted on Wednesday that “the cape is still in his closet.”)

Meanwhile, Ben Affleck is probably, almost definitely (though not completely) out as the Batman.

Should the studio suddenly be without the actors playing its most high-profile comic book characters, how does the DC Comics-based film series soldier on? Though it’s earned a certain reputation thanks to a series of well-publicized blunders and some rough Tomatometer scores, there are serious strengths in the universe that could inform how it moves forward on a good foot. Looking at those strengths, and the underlying strengths of DC’s stable of characters, here are just a few ways DC’s film future can be bright should Cavill choose to fly away.

1. Pivot To Wonder Woman

(Photo by @ Warner Bros.)

To a certain extent, all Warner Bros. really needs to do is stay the current course and depend on Wonder Woman. While the films prior to Wonder Woman‘s release were commercial success, their critical appraisal faltered or waned over time. Even incoming WarnerMedia CEO John Stankey had to admit “some of our franchises, in particular at DC, we all think we can do better.” But Wonder Woman shook off the DCEU reputation by finally giving the character a definitive screen treatment that both rang true to the comics and gave filmgoers a compelling reason to invest emotionally in her story. It also probably helped that star Gal Gadot felt natural in the part and in the costume. So while the studio looks for actors to replace Cavill and Affleck, why not make her the unambiguous leader of its nascent film superhero team?

She already has a tremendous amount of goodwill earned from the first film – which, at 93%, has the highest Tomatometer score of the DCEU – and she was a highlight of Justice League. Though no sequel to that film is planned, maybe having her pop up in Aquaman, Shazam!, and The Flash to assemble the team again would build the sort of momentum that made The Avengers work critically and commercially.

Warner Bros. is also pivoting toward Wonder Woman, or at least its vibe, in another way: it is developing a Supergirl feature film. If successful, it may make the need for a Superman less of an immediate issue.


(Photo by @ Warner Bros.)

In rebuilding the universe, one thing may have to be purposefully overlooked: Zack Snyder’s DC trilogy of Man of Steel, Batman v Superman, and Justice League. Starting with Man of Steel, the pictures felt more like ordeals to some viewers than enjoyable film adventures. And though there is an appeal to taking the DC Comics characters super-seriously – any reader of comics in the 1990s will tell you that – part of their allure is their larger-than-life powersets and personas. A trilogy about the impact of Superman is, ultimately, less enjoyable than a movie centered on Superman trying to foil the plans of Lex Luthor, Darkseid, or Brainiac.

With Cavill (and Affleck) gone, the faces of Snyder’s interpretation vanish. Perhaps that overly serious tone will go as well. Warner Bros. is already on its way to that, with Wonder Woman 1984 ignoring a key plot point from Snyder’s story – Diana’s 100 year exile – while Shazam! looks like it could not be further away from the tone of Man of Steel. Even Aquaman, the project most tied to the early days of DC film planning, looks to go brighter and lighter than its cinematic forebears.

Of course, the darkness of the previous Christopher Nolan-helmed Batman film series always appeals to Warner Bros. Former studio president Jeff Robinov infamously said, after the success of The Dark Knight, that he wanted to “try to go dark to the extent that the [DC Comics] characters allow it.” Though he left the studio before the DC film plan developed, his concept remained part of the mission statement. For the most part, this only works for Batman, as the Snyder trilogy revealed. And at this point, it is better to trust the tone of the individual characters than force them into a Gotham City gloom.

3. Dig Deeper Into The DC Library

(Photo by @ Warner Bros.)

Assuming it will take some time to find a new Superman – Batman will likely be cast first as director Matt Reeves will need an actor for his upcoming The Batman – Warner Bros. can look deeper into the DC Comics library for characters with the power and charisma to pick up the slack.

In possessing the top three superheroes, the studio missed the lesson of Iron Man – sometimes it is advantageous to work with a second-string character. As it happens, Iron Man was so successful, it obliterated the perception of the character as a B-Lister. Within the pages of DC Comics are vast swathes of characters ready to be promoted to marquee status in Superman’s absence. Fans of Booster Gold and Blue Beetle, for example, have been dying to see the superbuds on screen for ages. Characters like Starman Jack Knight, Nightwing, and Manhunter Kate Spencer all possess the necessary qualities to build screen success.

In fact, the DC Comics notion of legacy – in which characters like the Flash and Green Lantern hand over their costumed identities to new generations of heroes – is a strength never utilized in film. While it may not work for Superman, it could work when Ezra Miller is ready to put away his running shoes.

Warner Bros. is headed in this direction with projects like Lobo, Birds of Prey, and Batgirl in development. Each features a few characters new to the big screen and full of potential. Even the planned Green Lantern Corps will focus on a wider array of DC characters. Perhaps with Superman on ice for the next few years, a few of the outlier projects, like Nightwing, will go into production.

4. Build Up The Villains and Bring on the Legion of Doom

(Photo by @ Warner Bros.)

In defining the major differences between Marvel and DC, former Starman and Justice League writer James Robison once claimed Marvel had the better rogues gallery, with complicated villains like Magneto, Dr. Doom, and unambiguous universal threats like Galactus. But DC’s assortment of thieves, eco-terrorists, alien invaders, and would-be despots rival the masters of Marvel mayhem on any day. In fact, the DC group has the better name: the Legion of Doom. Granted, it comes from the Superfriends cartoon – in comics, the Legion of Doom is generally known as the Injustice Gang – but it offers a direction to the DC film universe not as readily available to Marvel Studios.

The blueprint for this has always been there in the critique that Batman’s screen villains often outshine the Caped Crusader. It also appears to be the direction that any further Justice League pictures would have gone, as evidenced by the post-credits stinger in which Jesse Eisenberg’s Lex Luthor suggests he and Deathstroke (Joe Manganiello) make a league of their own. If one thing could be salvaged from the Snyder trilogy, it is this tantalizing concept.

Following up on the scene also allows some of the other films to spotlight great villains like perennial Green Lantern foe Sinestro, Flash nemeses like Reverse-Flash and Grodd, the infamous Black Adam (to be played by Dwayne Johnson in his own solo feature film), and Wonder Woman 1984 antagonist Cheetah. As seen in the 1989 Batman and The Dark Knight, making the villains shine can lead to stronger films with a ton of box office appeal.

Not that this means every villain needs a feature of their own. While Black Adam and Joker have the potential to be strong lead characters without their heroic foes, Grodd needs the Flash. Also, imagine a movie called Grodd.


(Photo by @ Marvel Studios / @ Walt Disney Pictures)

Of course, finding a new Superman will be a challenge. Despite both Brandon Routh and Cavill possessing an innate “Superman-ness,” their appearances as the characters never quite gelled with some fans. And unlike characters such as Barry Allen, Aquaman, and even Captain America, Superman’s facial features are key elements to the look. For better or worse, Kal-El of Krypton is a square-jawed, blue-eyed classical Adonis, which puts Manganiello – who nearly played the part before – back in the frame. Sure, he appeared in Justice League as Deathstroke and was intended to appear as the character in Affleck’s version of The Batman, but he could still pull off a mature Superman.

If the studio wants to go younger, it could always promote TV Superman Tyler Hoechlin. His few appearances as Clark on The CW’s Supergirl prove he has the looks and at least some of that innate Superman quality. Yes, he is an untested big-screen presence, but so was Christopher Reeve 40 years ago. And if bankability is a primary concern, there’s always Zac Efron.

Then again, in a time when Superman is surrounded by established actors playing established characters, the studio could go with the choice director Richard Donner made with Reeve in Superman: cast an unknown who maintains all the qualities of the character and none of the star persona of an Efron or – back in the ’70s – a Robert Redford.

Granted, this is presuming the next Superman will retain the character’s traditional look. Rumors already indicate the studio is eyeing Black Panther‘s Michael B. Jordan for the role. And we are definitely here for that casting choice.

Sadly, there is one thing in-universe that Warner Bros. cannot do – play up Superman’s absence. That story beat was used in Justice League, and even if the films going forward ignore most of the events of the Snyder trilogy, the audience still remembers, and they’re not hungry for a retread. In this, the use of comic book-style continuity hinders the studio’s goals the most. Unlike the Flash, who can simply be replaced by a character like Wally West, Bart Allen, or Jenni Ognats, there is only one Superman; DC’s own attempts to give him a successor generally falter. Even if his days as Kal-El are over, Cavill is still the face of the character until someone steps into his tights and takes possession of the role. And despite anything the studio may do in the interim, that loss will make the DC film universe less cohesive.

Meanwhile, it’s always possible Cavill could return. Though there has never been more than preliminary discussions about a direct Man of Steel sequel, that could be the carrot necessary to bring him back into the fold. As his future is still uncertain, it may take a leading role — and leading-role money — to keep him in the DC Universe.

Tag Cloud

Fox News Infographic films BBC America know your critic screen actors guild Comedy Mindy Kaling Kids & Family Countdown IFC Films golden globe awards documentaries Academy Awards Geeked Week Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt true crime thriller discovery Sony Funimation south america Lucasfilm Holiday cartoon FX Television Academy lord of the rings Cannes elevated horror 45 Film Festival finale video foreign NBC Writers Guild of America universal monsters Best Director Creative Arts Emmys stop motion tv talk A&E marvel comics Pride Month sitcom christmas movies Ovation 24 frames live event CBS streaming movies BET Awards sports Toys hollywood high school IMDb TV Rock docudrama Comics on TV BBC One Best Picture reviews Paramount Pictures sequel FXX The Purge saw black VOD Hallmark Christmas movies halloween archives what to watch zombies Election asian-american YA free movies worst Summer crossover spain posters PBS nbcuniversal medical drama BET First Look casting FX on Hulu Country parents Crackle Premiere Dates Best Actor spinoff young adult anthology teaser golden globes reboot remakes CBS All Access psychological thriller harry potter renewed TV shows feel good trophy DC streaming service docuseries trailers mission: impossible Fantasy wonder woman ghosts Oscars football GoT Prime Video Tokyo Olympics children's TV Pop CNN DirecTV TCA Winter 2020 Classic Film canceled romance Epix VICE marvel cinematic universe summer TV chucky Song of Ice and Fire transformers Pirates NYCC E3 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards best award winner Lifetime Christmas movies Walt Disney Pictures Broadway 90s kaiju YouTube Red HBO versus Hulu Britbox Crunchyroll diversity scene in color film series movie legend justice league Sundance Now Horror game of thrones scary Adult Swim 94th Oscars Elton John book adaptation action-comedy sag awards Food Network japan boxoffice black comedy facebook 2021 worst movies live action cancelled Emmys streaming Universal Pictures Opinion 2019 TV Land venice Trophy Talk Amazon Studios Image Comics miniseries latino 72 Emmy Awards Endgame Emmy Nominations talk show 2015 based on movie MSNBC vs. television 4/20 stoner robots twilight international Hollywood Foreign Press Association Superheroes Wes Anderson Paramount Plus police drama Warner Bros. Quiz Brie Larson DC Universe all-time Chernobyl Oscar The Witch Winter TV Video Games hidden camera Turner cops Mary Poppins Returns witnail Baby Yoda social media political drama See It Skip It 2020 Native dark pirates of the caribbean singing competition Holidays summer TV preview name the review USA Network dragons Superheroe razzies target french Netflix Christmas movies Watching Series Travel Channel debate Mystery 2017 Photos Heroines Tags: Comedy Logo strong female leads History Star Trek streamig documentary Hear Us Out a nightmare on elm street AMC The Arrangement Arrowverse Comedy Central video on demand doctor who Comic-Con@Home 2021 cancelled TV shows Acorn TV kids movies Amazon Prime Video RT History Binge Guide The CW Marvel Television science fiction Disney streaming service cooking unscripted Sundance Sony Pictures El Rey news die hard Cosplay dramedy Musical WGN dc crime drama deadpool Captain marvel Family 1990s TBS Podcast TV Netflix Trailer HFPA crime thriller festival james bond Dark Horse Comics comic book movies Syfy jamie lee curtis Star Wars Celebration fast and furious Red Carpet Rocky comiccon new zealand Freeform New York Comic Con E! godzilla breaking bad comic book movie Animation SXSW MCU 73rd Emmy Awards dreamworks spider-man Legendary psycho Martial Arts Polls and Games supernatural DGA gangster TIFF zero dark thirty joker mutant spanish 21st Century Fox South by Southwest Film Festival BAFTA GLAAD Marathons spanish language crime vampires Exclusive Video RT21 festivals independent First Reviews comedies hispanic heritage month anime Shondaland binge war space fresh Pop TV Disney+ Disney Plus nature biopic Universal serial killer genre Grammys Best and Worst Disney obi wan Discovery Channel Disney Channel OWN TCA broadcast superman Spring TV quibi rt archives toy story aliens nfl rotten movies we love Star Wars theme song scene in color series Stephen King Peacock Awards Tour laika Ghostbusters Calendar Paramount telelvision Film Starz DC Comics rotten ABC adenture TCA 2017 mob directors LGBT Spike Avengers basketball Tumblr richard e. Grant Cartoon Network The Academy slashers revenge hist Black Mirror Apple TV Plus VH1 king kong Apple satire slasher 71st Emmy Awards Alien TruTV Rocketman Reality Competition American Society of Cinematographers FOX A24 ID Best Actress 93rd Oscars Rom-Com interviews TCA Awards dogs TV One werewolf President politics Tarantino women Women's History Month Sneak Peek Marvel Studios romantic comedy historical drama Lifetime Year in Review halloween tv National Geographic disaster green book Fox Searchlight Marvel Pet Sematary X-Men concert ViacomCBS monster movies franchise boxing Trivia stand-up comedy cancelled TV series classics mockumentary Hallmark CMT Character Guide HBO Go Comic Book APB comic TNT Set visit indiana jones rom-coms ESPN Mudbound indie child's play prank Apple TV+ AMC Plus Neflix MTV Spectrum Originals Black History Month blockbuster dexter critic resources jurassic park 20th Century Fox dceu kong Awards Masterpiece GIFs critics sopranos australia Western YouTube Vudu cars art house 2016 PlayStation batman Music new york natural history technology 007 Action TV movies SXSW 2022 screenings TLC spider-verse cancelled television summer preview Chilling Adventures of Sabrina SundanceTV animated scorecard PaleyFest CW Seed Lionsgate king arthur olympics scene in color cats Shudder book LGBTQ toronto Nat Geo BBC Sci-Fi Television Critics Association spy thriller Pixar Musicals NBA Mary Tyler Moore scary movies Pacific Islander Columbia Pictures ratings 99% new star wars movies Thanksgiving YouTube Premium Esquire OneApp USA Focus Features Ellie Kemper Nickelodeon target scene in color emmy awards San Diego Comic-Con Bravo blockbusters Schedule SDCC cinemax cults sequels composers Certified Fresh Fall TV canceled TV shows Anna Paquin zombie HBO Max comic books Super Bowl Tomatazos TV renewals leaderboard comics blaxploitation period drama travel Amazon Drama ITV Fargo italian Paramount Network mcc Indigenous game show Christmas Amazon Prime heist movie ABC Signature Nominations hispanic superhero biography rt labs critics edition popular adaptation Interview ABC Family Winners aapi Turner Classic Movies MGM suspense Mary poppins Teen The Walking Dead Showtime japanese royal family Instagram Live Valentine's Day Sundance TV Disney Plus WarnerMedia The Walt Disney Company rt labs IFC Biopics Tubi 2018 adventure Box Office Extras 79th Golden Globes Awards Reality series criterion obituary TCM