RT Archives

What Was It Like to Watch the World's First Feature-Length Film? Critics Paint a Picture.

The long-lost Story of the Kelly Gang was a technological groundbreaker in 1906 – reviews from the time of its release reveal an "sensational" crowd-pleaser.

by | November 20, 2020 | Comments

The Story of the Kelly Gang

(Photo by Courtesy of the Everett Collection)

It’s estimated that between 75 and 90 percent of films made before 1929 are either lost or only exist in incomplete form. As part of our RT Archives project, we are collecting contemporaneous reviews for those films – see a full list here and read what critics said about them at the time – and shining a spotlight on the stories and people behind them. Learn more about the RT Archives project here.

The 1906 film The Story of the Kelly Gang achieved a number of “firsts” when it premiered at Melbourne’s Athenaeum Hall in late December of that year. It was the first feature film about the Australian outlaw and pop culture hero Ned Kelly, who had died just 26 years before. It was also the first in the genre that would become known as “bushranger films,” stories of escaped convicts and bank- and coach-robbers who lived hidden in the Australian bush. Crucially, running more than an hour with a reel length of about 4,000 feet, The Story of the Kelly Gang was also the world’s first full-length feature film, according to the UNESCO Memory of the World Register. Tragically, it is also the world’s first lost full-length feature.

What we know about the film, for which writing and directing credits are often attributed to film and theatrical entrepreneur Charles Tait and his brothers, can be gleaned through a 17-minute restoration that pieced together bits of film discovered since the mid 1970s – including what could be salvaged from 400 feet of release print discovered by kids in a Melbourne rubbish dump in – and included still photographs to fill out scenes. We learn more, too, in theater programs from its initial exhibition in Australia, which outline the six-reel film’s six scenes, all depicting crucial moments in Ned Kelly and his gang’s criminal career, including the shootout that would eventually lead to Kelly’s arrest and for which he built his infamous metal bulletproof armor. (You might recall it from umpteenth Ned Kelly films – he’s been played by the likes of Heath Ledger, Mick Jagger, and, most recently, George Mackay in last year’s The True History of the Kelly Gang.)

The Story of the Kelly Gang

(Photo by Courtesy of the Everett Collection)

What’s harder to draw from these sources is what it was like to sit there, in a packed Sydney or Melbourne theater, and see The Story of the Kelly Gang live – to bear witness to a thrilling story about a man who, by that point, was a national icon, told in a groundbreaking and never-before-seen fashion. Perhaps the closest we can get to understanding that is in reviews written by critics and cultural commentators at the time, who filled columns in Australian and New Zealand newspapers with their reactions to the storytelling, the incredible new technology of a full-length-feature film, descriptions of crowd reactions, notes on the movie’s presentation – the reading of interstitial descriptions, accompanying sounds like fake gun shots – and who grappled with the country’s canonization of a man with so much blood, some of it from law enforcement on, his hands.

As part of our RT Archive project, we have been sourcing contemporaneous reviews for dozens of lost films, including The Story of the Kelly Gang, to help readers piece together in their minds these lost works of art. Below, we break down what writers thought of the film and its giant step forward in the evolution of this beguiling new moving-picture technology.

Did critics think this groundbreaking feature film was any good?

“[The pictures] illustrate with tolerable verisimilitude the most noteworthy events in the career of perhaps the most notorious gang of outlaws that ever infested the Australian bush.” – The Mercury (Tasmania), Monday, May 13, 1907

“[Many scenes] with galloping horses and beautiful bush views, were admirably presented, and voices behind the scenes supplied the realistic dialogue needed to keep the audience in touch with the action of the story.” Sydney Morning Herald, Monday, February 11, 1907

“…the Kelly pictures were reeled off at a rate which kept the attention of the audience closely concentrated on the career of the famous outlaws… A conscientious and, on the whole, a creditable effort has been made to reproduce the tragedies as they occurred, and if there were any imperfections in detail probably few in the hall had memories long enough to detect them.” – The Age (Melbourne), Thursday, December 27, 1906 (day after December 26 world premiere)

“… the attempted wrecking of the train sent from Melbourne with a posse of police to assist in the capture of the Glenrowan Hotel, with Rev. Father Gibney bravely rescuing and carrying away the wounded from the burning building. This scene was most vividly and realistically depicted, with some 50 police and the gang exchanging shots.” – Sunday Times (Sydney), Sunday, February 10, 1907

“The films are clear and distinct, the chief actors concerned in the bush drama are fairly recognizable, the photographs are taken in ‘Kelly country,’ and after due allowance is made for certain acknowledged liberties taken, the illustrated record is probably as satisfactory as anything of the kind at this distant date.” – The Daily Telegraph (Sydney), Monday, February 11, 1907 (the one Rotten review)

The Story of the Kelly Gang

(Photo by Courtesy of the Everett Collection)

What did the reviews reveal about the making of the film and how it was presented?

“Messrs. J and N Tait, in the result, presented an ingeniously realistic succession of pictures taken at Glenrowan, the Strathbogie and Wombat Ranges, and other Victorian spots at one time haunted by the robbers in question.” Sydney Morning Herald, Monday, February 11, 1907

“The films are the product of carefully rehearsed posing by men, women and children, who have copied characteristics of the principals, their accomplices and their victims.” – The Age (Melbourne), Thursday, December 27, 1906 (day after December 26 world premiere)

“In order to have the scenes of various incidents portrayed it was necessary sometimes to keep employed as many as 50 people at a time, and it even necessitated the co-operation of the railways and the engagement of special trains.” – The New Zealand Herald, Tuesday, June 18, 1907

“For the guidance of those unacquainted with the Kelly saga the operator introduces each series of pictures with a few lines of legible print, epitomizing the chapter next to be presented.” – The Mercury (Tasmania), Monday, May 13, 1907

Did the technology impress?

“The biograph picture has now come to be recognized as quite a necessary adjunct to civilization, and the wonder of its creation has vanished with the mystery of the telephone and the first motor-car…. To such a stage of perfection has the moving picture been brought, that audiences at this end of the world may have repeated for their benefit almost every detail, in actual spectacular panorama, events that have happened thousands of miles away, and no country is sacred form the enterprising picture-taker.” – The New Zealand Herald, Tuesday, June 18, 1907

“The cinematograph views of the murder of the constables in the Wombat Ranges, and baffled efforts to wreck the police ‘special’ by tearing up the railway track, the storming of the Glenrowan Inn and the capture of Ned Kelly were life-like, and, of course, highly sensational.” – The Age (Melbourne), Thursday, December 27, 1906 (day after December 26 world premiere)

Mick Jagger, George Mackay, Heath Ledger

Ned Kelly has been played through the years by Mick Jagger, George Mackay, Heath Ledger, and others. (Photo by Courtesy of the Everett Collection, © IFC Films, © Focus Features)

What was it like to be in the theater for these historic screenings?

“The Town-hall was filled to overflowing, and scores were turned away on Saturday night, when the biograph pictures of the adventures of the Kelly gang were exhibited for the first time. Growing boys formed a not inconsiderable portion of the spectators, and from the undertone of comment and the occasional outburst of applause, it was clear with what enthusiastic interest they followed the story as it was unfolded in the successive series of films.” – The Mercury (Tasmania), Monday, May 13, 1907

How did critics grapple with the portrayal of the criminal Ned Kelly as a heroic figure?

“The exploits of the Kelly gang, away back in the early eighties, were admittedly sufficiently daring in their character and tragic in their sequence to provide a sensational page of Australian history, but it is not the class of history to which a nation points with pride, nor is it a sort of thing the youth of a country will be asked to admire or to emulate…. Pasts of this description, one would suppose, were better buried deeply and the incidents associated with them kept in the background. Such, however, did not appear to be the view of the hundreds who scrambled wildly for seats at the Palace Theater on Saturday evening, in response to the announcement that there would be there presented ‘Australia’s greatest drama: The story of the Kelly gang, by the biograph–the most thrilling moving-picture series ever seen.’” – The Daily Telegraph (Sydney), Monday, February 11, 1907 (the one Rotten review)

“[The Kellys] are described on the program as ‘the last of the bushrangers,’ and it is to be hoped that may prove so, and that these vivid pictures may not ‘rear the tender thought, and teach the young idea how to shoot’–policemen.” Sydney Morning Herald, Monday, February 11, 1907

“To the Australian youth Ned Kelly and his associates are more real heroes than the whole catalogue of mythical champions from Hector and Achilles to Robin Hood, whilst the same youth may not be unjustly suspected of entertaining a sneaking prejudice against the police and other minions of the powers that be. These points have not been overlooked in the preparation of a biograph version of the Kelly gang; the outlaws are the heroes, the police cut a rather poor figure.” – The Mercury (Tasmania), Monday, May 13, 1907

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Heroines Western Video Games YA rt archives SXSW Binge Guide 21st Century Fox war 2019 Calendar Paramount Plus Disney Plus Black History Month cancelled TV series spider-man ITV jurassic park Chernobyl latino TCM Mary poppins 20th Century Fox a nightmare on elm street vampires BET Awards Teen The CW Sundance TV Kids & Family MSNBC WarnerMedia witnail RT History Starz sag awards YouTube Red crime thriller Warner Bros. crossover Disney streaming service Hallmark Christmas movies politics talk show series YouTube Premium documentaries First Reviews venice Superheroe blaxploitation zombie TruTV game show YouTube twilight Writers Guild of America dceu Rocky trailers docudrama Nat Geo nfl comiccon foreign Awards Tour OWN DGA Super Bowl Acorn TV AMC satire BBC One The Walking Dead OneApp Fox News Tomatazos technology golden globes universal monsters archives Reality Competition Film Festival TV One strong female leads TCA 2017 FOX TV Land ABC Family Chilling Adventures of Sabrina A24 travel GIFs spinoff adaptation Walt Disney Pictures VH1 Lucasfilm book quibi Mary Tyler Moore A&E NYCC National Geographic Classic Film boxing binge true crime Premiere Dates Fantasy sequel rom-coms MCU mutant 99% RT21 ID CBS Anna Paquin ratings supernatural deadpool medical drama award winner Extras Animation 45 blockbuster Mary Poppins Returns Set visit classics Nominations Cartoon Network PBS 2015 WGN NBC TNT Musicals nature Mindy Kaling Photos italian Country Arrowverse DC streaming service screenings Turner Classic Movies diversity Disney+ Disney Plus Holiday Star Wars Spring TV Apple TV Plus batman Marvel Television CW Seed Rock political drama History PlayStation robots Mudbound stand-up comedy Thanksgiving Music 71st Emmy Awards American Society of Cinematographers Turner dramedy USA Sneak Peek Paramount Network psycho chucky 007 Funimation IFC reviews anthology Sony Pictures miniseries ghosts scary movies aliens Reality canceled remakes 2016 zombies Emmy Nominations Hulu teaser Quiz Mystery Amazon Prime Video Amazon Studios all-time hispanic Summer dark Watching Series Rom-Com Trivia movies theme song scorecard joker spanish comic books french unscripted comic Opinion spy thriller natural history Freeform Song of Ice and Fire HBO Max DC Universe BBC comedies Food Network Cannes Brie Larson Tumblr X-Men richard e. Grant Year in Review Schedule christmas movies BAFTA mockumentary Elton John boxoffice Election TCA Awards TCA Toys die hard APB VICE TV cars Adult Swim ABC Film japanese Shudder Paramount Character Guide Comics on TV australia social media Crunchyroll Netflix Comedy james bond hollywood Drama television Syfy 2018 sports E3 Pop The Witch canceled TV shows movie video anime tv talk concert The Arrangement Showtime The Purge werewolf Lionsgate Winners Television Academy PaleyFest GoT best Lifetime disaster Horror Christmas 2020 composers Valentine's Day The Academy Dark Horse Comics free movies Stephen King Academy Awards Cosplay stoner TV renewals Ghostbusters Holidays Star Trek spanish language Disney 4/20 TLC Interview GLAAD dogs worst movies harry potter green book ABC Signature Trailer Action Television Critics Association discovery space Lifetime Christmas movies Pop TV Universal justice league indie Superheroes FX football animated nbcuniversal revenge Biopics breaking bad crime drama Fox Searchlight HBO See It Skip It Amazon Prime Pixar DirecTV Disney Channel Spike directors FX on Hulu IFC Films BBC America President Baby Yoda spain jamie lee curtis elevated horror The Walt Disney Company sequels Tarantino fresh screen actors guild franchise CBS All Access Spectrum Originals documentary indiana jones LGBT Masterpiece VOD adventure Comic Book criterion historical drama Bravo sitcom Britbox south america BET Columbia Pictures Ovation thriller dc TBS Esquire festival pirates of the caribbean cancelled television Netflix Christmas movies facebook obituary Pride Month streaming 2017 Red Carpet TCA Winter 2020 Marvel DC Comics Apple TV+ films romance stop motion news Sundance ViacomCBS rotten Vudu Peacock Marvel Studios video on demand El Rey First Look kids slashers Podcast cancelled Certified Fresh singing competition science fiction FXX emmy awards Apple halloween Hallmark 24 frames Fall TV USA Network 72 Emmy Awards cops cinemax Best and Worst Awards reboot Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Discovery Channel Musical Polls and Games San Diego Comic-Con Alien game of thrones finale fast and furious Countdown Trophy Talk HBO Go name the review Rocketman Ellie Kemper women independent Logo toronto 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards superhero Martial Arts cooking romantic comedy Oscars Pirates rotten movies we love cancelled TV shows cats New York Comic Con Winter TV Infographic child's play comics SDCC Avengers Emmys Marathons Black Mirror TIFF zero dark thirty asian-american laika dragons LGBTQ Sci-Fi Box Office children's TV Grammys cartoon parents Tubi festivals period drama critics based on movie casting Comedy Central ESPN CNN CMT Captain marvel Crackle Sundance Now E! Hear Us Out Family black toy story what to watch doctor who Endgame serial killer police drama renewed TV shows crime worst golden globe awards Amazon psychological thriller Nickelodeon Travel Channel cults mission: impossible Pet Sematary Women's History Month Creative Arts Emmys hist Shondaland halloween tv SundanceTV Epix biography versus MTV transformers