News

WandaVision First Reviews: A Whimsical Homage to Classic TV and a Tantalizing Slow-Burn Mystery

Elizabeth Olsen and Paul Bettany deliver the comedic goods, as the series drops delightful comic book Easter eggs and its mystery unfolds in the highly-anticipated return to the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

by | January 14, 2021 | Comments

After the pandemic brought the industry to a halt, delaying multiple release dates for the studio, Marvel has finally returned with limited series WandaVision, kicking off the beginning of its Phase 4 slate. It’s also the studio’s first foray into delivering some original programming to Disney+, with the first two episodes of the series premiering to the streamer on Friday, January 15.

The highly-anticipated series puts Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch (Elizabeth Olsen) and her synthezoid boyfriend Vision (Paul Bettany) in the spotlight. A 1950s-style sitcom spotlight, to be specific. On the surface, WandaVision looks to be unlike anything Marvel has done within the 13-year framework of its Marvel Cinematic Universe.

But does the program work? Here’s what critics are saying about WandaVision:


HOW DOES THE SITCOM NARRATIVE WORK?

Elizabeth Olsen and Paul Bettany in WandaVision

(Photo by Marvel Studios/Disney+)

“Each new episode replicates a different decade of yesteryear sitcoms beginning with 1950s’ I Love Lucy and The Dick Van Dyke Show in the premiere episode. The second episode tackles series like Bewitched and I Dream of Jeannie, and the third shadows The Mary Tyler Moore Show, and so on.” —Megan Vick, TV Guide

“It’s played almost as a straight tribute to those ancient shows, but there are tiny touches, here and there — beyond the employment of superpowers — that suggest that something is very wrong.” — Helen O’Hara, Empire Online

“In a break from the traditions of the ’50s and ’60s, the faux-sitcom vehicles of the first two episodes go out of their way to cast people of color, and to poke at the blatant misogyny that turned shows like Leave It to Beaver into symbols of a bygone era. When actress Teyonah Parris pops up in episode 2 as one of Wanda’s new neighborhood pals, Geraldine, WandaVision has its cake. Old shows never had Black women playing this type of role to chipper perfection, but “Geraldine” clearly knows she isn’t supposed to be there.” — Matt Patches, Polygon

“With each installment, a few more cracks in the sitcom facade appear, but the bigger mystery is unveiled at an excruciatingly slow pace. In the second episode, Teyonah Parris is introduced as mysterious neighbor Geraldine, but those who have been following Marvel casting news will know there’s more to her than that. The third offers some tantalizing peeks at what might really be going on but stops short of explaining it. As a weekly series, it’s an aggravating and unsuccessful structure.” — Kelly Lawler, USA Today

WandaVision isn’t just another story about superheroes; WandaVision is a love letter to the history of sitcoms, one that sharply dissects how and why the format endures and why it remains culturally significant. Yep—WandaVision is a superhero show (a genre that’s frequently dismissed by critics) that analyzes sitcoms (a format frequently overlooked by critics).” — Brett White, Decider


HOW IS THE PRODUCTION QUALITY?

Elizabeth Olsen and Paul Bettany in WandaVision

(Photo by Marvel Studios/Disney+)

“The set design, the performances, and the specific feel of a multi-camera sitcom — WandaVision’s pilot was filmed in front of a live studio audience — reflect a love for these indelible shows.” — Alex Abad-Santos, Vox

“The look and feel of each episode is true to the spirit of its respective sitcom era as much as to any one show, as it’s clear everyone did their homework(*).” — Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone

“Though it gets off to a slow start, the show has plenty going for it, from gorgeous, extremely expensive-looking production design and breathtaking special effects to punchy performances, a trippy mood and a plot that does eventually become quite absorbing.” — Judy Berman, TIME Magazine

“Christophe Beck nails the jaunty sitcom score interstitials that bookend scenes, while Frozen songwriters Robert Lopez and Kristen Anderson-Lopez gift our leads with period-appropriate jingles that befit whatever decade they’re trapped in now.” — Clint Worthington, The Spool


HOW DOES IT CONNECT TO THE MCU?

Elizabeth Olsen and Paul Bettany in WandaVision

(Photo by Marvel Studios/Disney+)

“As the saturation drains from the title card, and the opening notes of WandaVision’s first theme song begins to play, the episodic nature of the series jumps out, and reminds you that this debut Marvel series on Disney’s streaming service isn’t quite trying to conjure up your traditional MCU shock and awe.” — Charles Pulliam-Moore, io9.com

“These Disney+ series, though, expand the story of characters we know from the movies in way that the movies simple did not have time to do. It also allows WandaVision creator Jac Schaeffer and director Matt Shakman to put a uniquely stylized and deeply emotional spin on a story that would have (had this been a movie) otherwise been shackled by the mandated aesthetics of the overall MCU.” — Allison Keene, Paste Magazine

“There is an overarching story to the series, one that will presumably explain how these very surreal events connect back to the lives (and deaths) of matter-and-mind manipulating Wanda Maximoff (Elizabeth Olsen) and the artificial “synthezoid” known as Vision (Paul Bettany) from the more cinematic entires of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Through the first third of WandaVision’s season, though, its Marvel mythology remains in the background.” — Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

“What’s really going on here, given where movie-goers saw these Avengers last? That’s the fundamental mystery, one the producing team is clearly in no hurry to divulge. Patience becomes a virtue, taking in the sitcom homages while maintaining a watchful eye for sly Marvel references and cleverly placed dollops of color, presenting possible cracks in the black-and-white veneer.” — Brian Lowry, CNN


HOW ARE ELIZABETH OLSEN AND PAUL BETTANY?

Elizabeth Olsen and Paul Bettany in WandaVision

(Photo by Marvel Studios/Disney+)

“Olsen and Bettany are delightful as they channel sitcom performers of the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s, demonstrating their sharp comedic timing. It’s a testament to their strengths as actors that they don’t come across as doing imitations of the old shows WandaVision draws from, which helps immerse viewers in each new period.” — Chris Agar, ScreenRant

“If you were looking for charming stars to convey a Mary Tyler Moore/Dick Van Dyke vibe, you couldn’t do much better as Olsen and Bettany get to spell out the sweet chemistry that the movies have only hinted at.” — Dan Fienberg, Hollywood Reporter

“Bettany has had a few comedic roles in the past, but none that demanded this level of full-on slapstick commitment — yet his follow-through makes him feel like a pro with 100+ episodes of syndicated hilarity under his belt. And it’s not just that he can deliver some killer punchlines, it’s how fiercely he throws himself into the relevant archetypes of each era while always allowing the glimmer of artifice to stand out.” — Liz Shannon Miller, Collider


WHAT ABOUT THE SUPPORTING CAST?

Kathryn Hahn in WandaVision

(Photo by Marvel Studios/Disney+)

“The leads aren’t left alone to do all the heavy lifting thanks to a terrific supporting cast of character actors that wouldn’t normally find their way into a Marvel Studios production. Notably, Kathryn Hahn uses her comedic skills to great effect as the precocious neighbor Agnes and That 70’s Show alum Debra Jo Rupp, as the wife of Vision’s boss, is a perfect addition to add to the period feel of the show.” — Kyle Wilson, Lamplight Review

“Alongside Olsen and Bettany is Kathryn Hahn as a nosy neighbor, whose comic relief develops and darkens as the show moves into the 1970s. She’s as invaluable in WandaVision as she is in most things, perfectly capturing the series’s mood of perky, tireless energy slowly being consumed by paranoid sci-fi dread.” — Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

“The supporting cast is also a delight, with hints of further meaning yet to be unveiled, with the impeccable Kathryn Hahn bringing the sass as the couple’s helpful neighbour Agnes and Mad Men’s Teyonah Parris as the mysterious Monica Rambeau.” — Lewis Knight, Daily Mirror (UK)


ANY FINAL THOUGHTS?

“Unabashed, off-kilter, and unlike anything Marvel has ever attempted, WandaVision is a reality-warping joy that promises a new beginning of the MCU.” — Lauren J. Coates, Consequence of Sound

“Stretched out into three (and likely more) episodes, the stuck-in-a-TV-show premise starts to seem like a better idea for an interlude within something larger, rather than a whole thing unto itself.” — Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

“Working as both a love letter to classic sitcom television and a modern comic book mystery, WandaVision is just weird and charming enough to work.” — Kyle Wilson, Lamplight Review

“Consider WandaVision an unusual first step for this new Marvel phase. The best parts lovingly conjure the mood of very old television shows. The worst parts feel like just another movie.” — Darren Franich, EW

WandaVision premieres its first two episodes on Friday, January 15 on Disney+.

Tag Cloud

LGBT Tomatazos political drama archives 2018 Showtime children's TV movie adventure Crunchyroll police drama Heroines Arrowverse Christmas comiccon Nat Geo History Family Freeform TCA 2017 E3 universal monsters YouTube south america ESPN Sony Pictures canceled TV shows Comedy Central Discovery Channel superhero Black History Month Tumblr Syfy emmy awards Comic Book Women's History Month spain green book Sneak Peek a nightmare on elm street ABC stoner hispanic japanese science fiction Acorn TV Podcast A24 cancelled TV series CW Seed The Walking Dead transformers Bravo YouTube Red worst movies Biopics Paramount Network Nickelodeon Mary poppins Fox Searchlight game show trailers Reality Competition serial killer latino Pet Sematary award winner Song of Ice and Fire renewed TV shows comic books YA Universal nature sports Watching Series Apple TV+ Mindy Kaling anime cancelled television festival italian teaser mockumentary Avengers BET Awards scary movies Comics on TV series Ghostbusters Marathons WarnerMedia Emmys Disney Plus Opinion scorecard TV One obituary ABC Family ABC Signature toronto Pride Month 4/20 Anna Paquin critics Best and Worst Character Guide zombie Amazon Prime Video television Countdown indie El Rey Grammys The Purge Mudbound breaking bad PBS blockbuster Premiere Dates Valentine's Day Video Games New York Comic Con travel Quiz Red Carpet Box Office technology finale Country hollywood TCA Winter 2020 TCM Captain marvel game of thrones cooking Pixar boxoffice Lucasfilm DGA BAFTA Food Network Musical GIFs First Reviews San Diego Comic-Con rotten video 007 Super Bowl Vudu films toy story TNT singing competition stand-up comedy Photos cancelled TV shows Logo miniseries halloween streaming TV renewals halloween tv slashers Ellie Kemper fresh classics Masterpiece witnail golden globes IFC Films ghosts quibi crime drama Star Wars TCA Amazon Studios TBS BET National Geographic Turner 2017 Rock Winter TV medical drama foreign screenings book adaptation Summer venice Funimation CBS satire french diversity harry potter christmas movies Lifetime 72 Emmy Awards football jamie lee curtis VOD Star Trek joker supernatural crime thriller Set visit Spike AMC MTV Horror Schedule space movies concert Thanksgiving Mystery cops best Polls and Games Pirates OneApp Creative Arts Emmys tv talk golden globe awards period drama GLAAD name the review HBO Go Disney+ Disney Plus Kids & Family Calendar crime news Trailer PaleyFest SDCC deadpool facebook natural history Apple Awards laika Binge Guide HBO Max MCU TruTV black worst Black Mirror Superheroe YouTube Premium chucky Marvel pirates of the caribbean Year in Review Disney streaming service Western Classic Film psycho unscripted Oscars spider-man Tubi 21st Century Fox Writers Guild of America 45 Animation psychological thriller Emmy Nominations Adult Swim 2015 doctor who fast and furious comics Trophy Talk justice league Martial Arts The Arrangement APB hist Paramount Mary Poppins Returns Hallmark Elton John Amazon batman X-Men Toys Marvel Studios E! FX on Hulu 2016 RT21 what to watch ID Pop independent The Academy dark spanish comic Trivia cults spinoff HBO festivals Britbox Sci-Fi reboot FOX war dogs Awards Tour Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Interview sitcom cancelled TLC boxing Walt Disney Pictures Baby Yoda NBC Academy Awards CBS All Access Esquire Infographic ITV versus rt archives richard e. Grant child's play all-time nfl Sundance Now werewolf screen actors guild blaxploitation australia based on movie Superheroes Television Academy The Witch Epix Shudder SXSW binge Film Festival biography DC Universe Travel Channel Brie Larson 20th Century Fox ratings BBC anthology GoT cinemax Holidays disaster crossover indiana jones elevated horror Crackle Fall TV comedies Comedy Disney Channel mission: impossible 2019 Mary Tyler Moore Marvel Television animated 99% jurassic park mutant SundanceTV Nominations DirecTV DC Comics Spring TV Dark Horse Comics historical drama Rocky talk show Film Lionsgate Certified Fresh Hallmark Christmas movies Musicals docudrama 24 frames zero dark thirty See It Skip It Reality TV Land Shondaland Disney Apple TV Plus FXX Fox News revenge sequel Drama rom-coms Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt twilight discovery Holiday CNN CMT true crime cars Starz Turner Classic Movies Tarantino Cosplay vampires Winners Cannes spy thriller A&E sequels james bond Netflix zombies VH1 criterion Rom-Com OWN Stephen King nbcuniversal robots composers Peacock strong female leads romance IFC RT History dc stop motion video on demand LGBTQ kids Netflix Christmas movies documentaries cartoon Hear Us Out TV free movies BBC One dragons social media aliens Chernobyl Ovation remakes USA Cartoon Network NYCC parents directors sag awards Hulu MSNBC Spectrum Originals Election Fantasy dramedy President The Walt Disney Company The CW Action spanish language VICE PlayStation franchise TCA Awards WGN Columbia Pictures Lifetime Christmas movies Amazon Prime USA Network 2020 Rocketman American Society of Cinematographers casting TIFF Extras canceled thriller theme song asian-american politics romantic comedy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Teen Alien Sundance rotten movies we love die hard Warner Bros. Music 71st Emmy Awards Television Critics Association FX Pop TV cats dceu BBC America Sundance TV Endgame DC streaming service documentary reviews First Look