We Just Updated Our Tomatometer Critics Criteria

The changes will see new platforms and hundreds of new voices added to the Tomatometer.

by | August 28, 2018 | Comments

Recently added Tomatometer-approved critics (clockwise from top left): Clarisse Loughrey, Bernard Boo, Joelle Monique, Jacob Oller, Sandie Angulo Chen, Jane Crowther, Lorraine Ali, Robert Daniels

Ever wondered how the Tomatometer gets made? Well, this week we’re peeling back the layers of the onion ­– and apologizing for our mixed fruit-and-veg metaphors – to give you a Fresh look at the process, and some changes we’re making to it.

Keen followers of Rotten Tomatoes probably know how we get Tomatometer scores for movies and TV shows, but for the uninitiated, here’s a quick rundown: When a movie comes out, we collect Tomatometer-approved critics’ reviews of that movie, note which are Fresh and which are Rotten (that’s RT speak for positive and negative), and calculate the overall percentage of reviews that are Fresh. This is the movie’s Tomatometer score. The same goes for TV and streaming shows, though we also calculate season and episode scores. ­You can find out more about the process, and things like our Certified Fresh designation, here.

Who are these critics, though? And how do we select which critics to include when generating the Tomatometer? That’s the question we’ve addressed with our refreshed Critics Criteria.

When Rotten Tomatoes began, just over 20 years ago, the media landscape was a much different place – weekend newspapers were fat with ads, the iPhone was but a twinkle in Steve Jobs’ eye, YouTube was six years away from disrupting basically everything, Netflix was snail-mailing DVDs to early adopters, and Siskel and Ebert were still on the air every week wagging their kingmaking thumbs. Rotten Tomatoes was conceived in that era, and our first set of criteria for the critics whose reviews we would count towards the Tomatometer reflected it. There was an emphasis on major publications and market-leading broadcasters, on staff positions and broad audience reach.

In the intervening decades, a lot has changed. By some estimates, the total daily circulation of newspapers in America has fallen by half, and the size of the newspaper workforce has been reduced by more than a third with the subsequent drop in revenue; broadcast TV and radio stations have faced similar challenges with the rise of cable, online news, streaming, podcasts, and YouTube. Often, the Arts Desk has been the first place to suffer cuts when things get tough – traditional full-time arts journalism jobs, let alone full-time working critics, are a rarity today.

At the same time, new kinds of critics emerged, innovative thinkers and commentators who have seized on new platforms, developed their own sites and publications, or forged strong freelance careers, to have their voices heard. Many of these voices went unheard when traditional media was at its dominant prime, and too many still go unheard today.

In revamping our Critics Criteria, we sought to bring the criteria into better alignment with the way media works today, to promote the inclusion of more voices that reflect the varied groups of people who consume entertainment, and to maintain the high standards we’ve always set for inclusion in the group of Tomatometer-approved critics.

When assessing applications from those wishing to be a Tomatometer-approved critic, or a Tomatometer-approved publication, we now take into consideration four key values as well as a revised set of eligibility requirements. These values are Insight, Audience, Quality, and Dedication, and you can find a full breakdown of each value here.

On our critics page, you can meet some of the critics who embody these values, among them more than 200 critics who have been Tomatometer-approved as of today. And stay tuned, because we will be adding hundreds more as the year goes on. We’ll be regularly updating the Critic Spotlight section of the page with new critic profiles, including links to their work and social media profiles – you may just find your next favorite podcaster, writer, or vlogger there.

One key thing to note on the value of “Audience” is that while we still seek critics and publications with a wide reach, we also give weight to those applicants whose coverage may be less wide-reaching, but which serves underrepresented groups. Similarly, elements of our eligibility requirements that in the past proved obstacles for some insightful and dedicated self-published individuals and freelancers have been rethought to align with the way many are working today. Our requirements have also been updated to reflect the growing number of platforms and different types of media on which people are sharing their movie and TV reviews.

One thing that hasn’t changed is our dedication to quality film and TV criticism, held to high standards, and to ensuring the integrity of the Tomatometer and its usefulness for movie and TV fans.

You can find out more about Tomatometer-approved critics here, and apply to become one here.

Tag Cloud

Writers Guild of America TBS MCU discovery American Society of Cinematographers Biopics NBC Mindy Kaling transformers Freeform LGBTQ singing competition children's TV Emmy Nominations Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Epix ABC crime Lionsgate Rocky series YouTube Premium streaming Musicals dc Box Office A&E Captain marvel Stephen King Kids & Family Teen Pirates Thanksgiving game show Amazon Prime Country comic festivals Chernobyl ITV war 2016 Ellie Kemper cooking Extras Family Spike Certified Fresh The Arrangement binge Rocketman Character Guide spinoff Action 2019 biography WGN CNN Year in Review Brie Larson Disney streaming service Disney Channel Red Carpet TCA 2017 Elton John psychological thriller Pride Month social media sequel Reality Cartoon Network Heroines Awards Tour dramedy Fall TV crime thriller hist VICE Election Sony Pictures Pet Sematary Winter TV miniseries Superheroes space justice league golden globes NYCC Esquire USA Network Comics on TV SXSW APB sports sitcom thriller theme song Horror anime TLC based on movie cinemax cats ESPN Disney See It Skip It Shudder Ghostbusters YouTube Red game of thrones VH1 E3 TruTV travel Christmas SDCC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Polls and Games CBS facebook Oscars IFC Spectrum Originals ghosts 007 Shondaland 2015 medical drama 21st Century Fox science fiction robots casting LGBT CMT SundanceTV Arrowverse TIFF docudrama CBS All Access Apple First Reviews cults Infographic comiccon adventure Vudu Mary poppins Best and Worst latino Pop green book Mary Poppins Returns romance movies Song of Ice and Fire animated President Logo PaleyFest Photos Drama stand-up comedy spy thriller San Diego Comic-Con Ovation Western Quiz Syfy Rom-Com quibi nature tv talk psycho Premiere Dates zombies Tumblr ratings Tarantino Podcast 20th Century Fox Crackle elevated horror diversity Grammys Binge Guide FXX Nat Geo Sci-Fi TV Land Rock Dark Horse Comics Mudbound Interview YA AMC GoT Fantasy police drama crime drama Mary Tyler Moore Countdown award winner Bravo BBC strong female leads 2017 mutant Comedy Central Britbox natural history Netflix Trailer Valentine's Day Animation Spring TV MTV crossover boxoffice GLAAD New York Comic Con politics History Women's History Month technology Acorn TV Amazon Emmys WarnerMedia supernatural book Calendar Black Mirror historical drama Toys Columbia Pictures political drama zombie Sundance Now 45 Fox News FX The Witch National Geographic finale BET harry potter Martial Arts Film Festival Nominations Cosplay kids The CW zero dark thirty Sneak Peek what to watch USA vampires PBS Showtime Creative Arts Emmys Warner Bros. FOX Lifetime DC Universe Video Games Universal Marvel dceu true crime toy story TNT blaxploitation Trophy Talk anthology Cannes mockumentary Opinion Super Bowl 2018 teaser Music GIFs OWN TV X-Men DGA Starz composers ABC Family Comedy spanish language foreign TCM Masterpiece 24 frames jamie lee curtis Winners Paramount Network TCA aliens south america Adult Swim Reality Competition CW Seed Food Network IFC Films RT History cars Amazon Prime Video DC streaming service spider-man Watching Series Lucasfilm period drama richard e. Grant Nickelodeon Trivia hispanic Pixar E! El Rey spain television disaster DirecTV HBO Max serial killer Musical HBO Superheroe First Look cops Anna Paquin adaptation Set visit revenge Walt Disney Pictures witnail Awards Marathons dragons Schedule BBC America Holidays MSNBC Comic Book Star Wars Mystery unscripted Star Trek DC Comics Film doctor who talk show Summer Hulu Tomatazos RT21 Paramount Sundance