Comics On TV

Umbrella Academy’s Biggest Book-to-Screen Changes Explained

From Ellen Page's White Violin suit to Tom Hopper's toned-down eight-foot gorilla body, find out why the series changed several of the comic book's major looks.

by | February 21, 2019 | Comments

Netflix’s adaptation of The Umbrella Academy is both a delight and an often-sad look at difficult family lives and the scars of growing up with great expectations. Those expectations are even greater in the series considering that the mysteriously born children adopted by famous adventurer Sir Reginald Hargreeves were raised specifically to hone their extraordinary abilities and eventually save the world. Since the series is based on a comic book with super-powered people, it is reasonable to assume the show will have a few big fights or apocalyptic moments — and maybe some people in super-suits.

As it happens, the apocalypse comes courtesy of the least likely of the Hargreeves children: seventh child Vanya (Ellen Page).

The Umbrella Academy SEASON Season 1 EPISODE 10 PHOTO CREDIT Christos Kalohoridis/Netflix PICTURED Ellen Page

Finally free of the drugs her father put her on and aware of her potential thanks to the mixed-up plans of Leonard Peabody (John Magaro), she decides to perform a violin solo at her concert with her full powers on display. A similar scene occurs in “The Apocalypse Suite,” the first long-form Umbrella Academy story by Gerard Way and Gabriel Bá. But there is one big visual difference between the two versions of the scene: Vanya’s choice of outfit. In the comic book, her super-suit has a more traditional superhero (or supervillain) look — a form-fitting leotard with a black and white violin motif. In the television series, Vanya wears a smart, traditional suit that turns from black to white in the middle of her solo.

When Rotten Tomatoes caught up with the cast a few weeks back, both Page and showrunner Steve Blackman shared some thoughts on the decision to reshape Vanya’s most powerful look and the choice to downplay many of the superhero tropes on display in the comic. For Page, that started with Vanya’s switch from the leotard to a suit.

“I’m tired that women always have to look a specific way, particularly in superhero sorts of things,” she said. “I’m just tired of it.”

His star wanted to embrace the black and white motif of the comics, “but she didn’t see herself necessarily in that skin-tight outfit,” Blackman explained. “It didn’t feel right for her, so we respected that. We came as close as we could to the graphic novel in terms of sort of having her emotional transformation and this physical transformation. So it’s just a different ‘White Violin’ than the one from the graphic novel.”

Page called Blackman and Netflix’s decision to back her idea a “testament” to their good faith and willingness to listen.

“I have never worked on something that’s of this scale and been able to wear what I want to wear and not have ridiculous, stupid, f—ing conversations full of misogyny and homophobia and all kinds of things,” she said.

Emmy Raver-Lampman, Tom Hopper, David Castañeda in The Umbrella Academy (Christos Kalohoridis/Netflix)
(Photo by Christos Kalohoridis/Netflix)

But even beyond Page’s strong feelings about her costume in the finale, the television show scaled down and grounded some of the fantastic imagery artist Bá brought to the comic book. Blackman acknowledged part of the decision comes from purely practical reasons: i.e., Luther’s (Tom Hopper) eight-foot gorilla body from the comics would break the budget.

“It was just much harder to do it [that] way,” he explained.

Instead, Luther’s body is contained in clothing that still implies the character’s unusual size and strength without requiring constant visual effects (like the Hargreeves butler, Pogo).

Co-creator Way said the approach to Luther was “the best change” in terms of realizing Bá’s character designs on screen. But he admitted there was one stumbling block in talking with Blackman about the series: the deletion of the code names.

In the comic book, each character is referred to by the number Sir Reginald Hargreeves (Colm Feore) gave them, the personal names they later adopted, and a superhero identity procured during their days as teen adventurers. Luther, for example, was known as “Spaceboy,” while Klaus (Robert Sheehan) was “Séance” and Allison (Emmy Raver-Lampman) was known as “The Rumor.” Way and Bá refer to the characters by these names, while Blackman chose to focus on the personal names.

“There was a minute where they would use one of the kids’ real names, and I was like, ‘Who are they talking about,’ to Gabriel. ‘Oh, he’s taking about Spaceboy or he’s talking about Séance.’ That took some getting used to on my part,” Way said.

THE UMBRELLA ACADEMY (Courtesy of Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

However, the code names could always emerge in a subsequent season, Blackman said. He also noted that there were many times when Bá’s style worked for the series, like the striped shirt Diego (David Castaneda) wears when the family unites to confront Vanya — a direct pull from the artist’s character model. He even pointed out Bá’s influence on Klaus’s on-screen look.

Way added, “Klaus is a little more kind of rock and roll [in the comic] as opposed to this kind of dry goth he was in the show. There are changes like that, but I think they lend themselves to the way the actors were playing the characters.”

Support of the book-to-screen changes is a sentiment definitely shared by the actors.

“That’s why I was interested in making [Umbrella Academy],” Sheehan said. “It’s much more interesting to show people who are supposedly super, or have these allegedly super abilities, couched in a very normal, familial, dysfunctional context.”

Mary J. Blige, Cameron Britton in The Umbrella Academy (Christos Kalohoridis/Netflix)
(Photo by Christos Kalohoridis/Netflix)

And even if the characters trade in a less traditional look through most of the show, superhero iconography — like the domino masks worn by the children — still permeates the show via the flashbacks to the Academy’s heyday. Also, the inclusion of Hazel (Cameron Britton) and Cha-Cha (Mary J. Blige) speaks directly to their comic book appearance in the second long-form Umbrella Academy story, “Dallas.” The duo’s masks echo Bá’s design — if slightly scaled-down in stature — while their spirits largely transfer from the page to the screen. It was important to Blackman to bring those characters into the TV version of “The Apocalypse Suite” instead of waiting and adapting “Dallas” as a completely separate story.

“You assume you’re going to have four years or five years on television in the best of worlds — knock on wood — but I thought if I only have one season, I really wanted Hazel and Cha Cha to be a part of it,” he said of his decision to introduce those characters.

The Umbrella Academy SEASON Season 1 EPISODE 3 PHOTO CREDIT Christos Kalohoridis/Netflix PICTURED Emmy Raver-Lampman
(Photo by Christos Kalohoridis/Netflix )

The series may downplay the costumes and code names of more conventional superheroes, but the powers of the Academy are never too far from frame. Klaus spends much of the first season reconnecting with his powers while Vanya discovers hers.

One character more at odds with her abilities is Allison, whose ability to control minds is framed as a form of child abuse when the story begins. We are told throughout the series that she used her power to get her restless daughter to go to bed. Her husband happened to see it, took their child away from her, and filed for divorce. But when the audience finally sees the moment, it is not presented in a sinister light. As Raver-Lampman explained, the scene gives greater weight to Allison’s suggestion that “any parent who had my power would do the same.”

“I mean, that is a way of taking a little bit of the grief off of herself and the blame off of herself,” she added. “I think for her, it just was like, ‘I’m gonna do it just this one time.’”

To Raver-Lampman, Allison’s whole struggle stems from the small uses of her power to make her life a little easier.

“She got it from her father,” she said. “He was always asking her to use her power to make his life easier.”

From there it snowballed it something her ex-husband definitely saw as abuse. The scene may make it a little more innocent and forgivable, but Raver-Lampan finally admitted, “If I caught my spouse doing that to our child, I would never trust them again.”

The Umbrella Academy Credit: Netflix
(Photo by Netflix)

Of course, trust is a big issue among the Hargreeves, and it remains to be seen if they can build enough of it among each other to prevent the apocalypse — another change from the definitive end of “The Apocalypse Suite.” But as the adaptation of Umbrella Academy proves, deviating from the source can yield spectacular results.

The Umbrella Academy season 1 is available to stream on Netflix.

Tag Cloud

comic Netflix cults Extras mockumentary singing competition dramedy sequel Comic Book Freeform Star Wars Shudder Year in Review Pet Sematary vampires RT21 batman theme song Syfy 24 frames Fall TV free movies TV Land 45 Mystery Creative Arts Emmys Valentine's Day 2015 BBC America binge quibi FOX comiccon Turner Mary poppins discovery ghosts Film Tarantino Nat Geo Super Bowl Rocketman First Look rotten movies we love ESPN SDCC Discovery Channel CNN cancelled TV shows TCA Winter 2020 Pride Month Star Trek YA TCA Reality CBS El Rey nature First Reviews Winners Film Festival kids Dark Horse Comics Western anthology screen actors guild IFC Films 2019 south america Country miniseries historical drama Adult Swim Amazon Prime Emmy Nominations game show MSNBC Disney Plus Winter TV 2018 DC Universe stand-up comedy Cartoon Network screenings Academy Awards DirecTV Superheroe children's TV Holiday Election LGBTQ Netflix Christmas movies Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel Television Musicals 2017 E! TLC adaptation casting based on movie WGN teaser war Kids & Family Nickelodeon MCU Columbia Pictures spider-man Hulu VICE police drama Arrowverse Trailer robots unscripted AMC Rock Pixar Oscars BBC Vudu Song of Ice and Fire natural history adventure Musical Infographic social media Sundance Now video crime thriller Biopics BET series Trivia directors X-Men political drama GLAAD canceled TV shows TIFF Writers Guild of America cancelled cinemax biography dceu doctor who Mary Tyler Moore OneApp spanish language Epix television Cosplay Comedy Central Amazon Drama Universal Disney streaming service Marvel diversity 20th Century Fox Mary Poppins Returns Awards Tour ABC Family hispanic Tumblr The Arrangement Holidays Ellie Kemper true crime Classic Film composers Opinion SundanceTV CW Seed Lucasfilm space toy story Disney Channel golden globes latino strong female leads Endgame IFC Summer crossover Mudbound docudrama Comedy WarnerMedia 71st Emmy Awards President crime VH1 DC streaming service Animation TCA 2017 Comics on TV Countdown Bravo harry potter Interview mutant blockbuster American Society of Cinematographers Starz USA Network Reality Competition witnail Podcast NYCC CMT New York Comic Con Hallmark hist transformers TNT sports Martial Arts zombies supernatural Pop Sundance TV richard e. Grant Avengers Food Network Toys elevated horror Crackle serial killer travel psychological thriller Christmas psycho Character Guide ratings dragons cancelled TV series finale Esquire Apple TV+ See It Skip It Polls and Games Crunchyroll sag awards award winner Lifetime Spike Certified Fresh Mindy Kaling The CW TCM Binge Guide 2020 justice league revenge canceled MTV Turner Classic Movies Lionsgate OWN USA Disney+ Disney Plus The Witch jamie lee curtis boxoffice christmas movies Lifetime Christmas movies sitcom Sneak Peek period drama Music Teen blaxploitation Acorn TV Apple TV Plus Family Heroines PaleyFest History joker 21st Century Fox Shondaland anime medical drama werewolf renewed TV shows foreign Cannes Rocky spinoff streaming TBS Awards Quiz RT History breaking bad Thanksgiving E3 Video Games YouTube Premium name the review halloween TV talk show Peacock romantic comedy technology Chernobyl zero dark thirty GoT HBO Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FX versus Britbox Sci-Fi Calendar Tomatazos green book Action Anna Paquin Fox News YouTube Red Television Academy FXX aliens The Walking Dead Sony Pictures Nominations cops Stephen King Showtime independent festivals CBS All Access YouTube romance crime drama Set visit TV renewals Premiere Dates Marathons cancelled television cats Pirates ABC Baby Yoda Spring TV indie Brie Larson Grammys Red Carpet DGA Ghostbusters Tubi Paramount Network Women's History Month science fiction tv talk ITV DC Comics Disney game of thrones Walt Disney Pictures Photos comics Elton John what to watch GIFs 2016 Ovation Sundance Marvel Studios Horror politics PBS zombie A24 LGBT SXSW Warner Bros. The Purge Watching Series movies NBC Black Mirror Emmys Logo Fantasy thriller Superheroes cartoon spain Best and Worst reboot National Geographic Box Office A&E Schedule TruTV San Diego Comic-Con 007 Paramount Apple APB facebook Masterpiece spy thriller HBO Max Trophy Talk slashers Rom-Com Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Amazon Prime Video cooking animated disaster Spectrum Originals Captain marvel dc cars book