Them Creator and Stars on Making a Show Out of Real-Life Jumpscares

Creator Little Marvin asks what's scarier: a mysterious sound in the basement or a neighbor glaring at your house?

by | April 7, 2021 | Comments

The most disturbingly brilliant thing about Amazon Prime Video’s new anthology series Them might just be its perfect title.

The horror series premieres April 9 on the streaming service and aims to explore America’s history of discriminating against (and sometimes physically assaulting) people of marginalized backgrounds. The first season is set in 1950s Compton, California, when a Black family from North Carolina moves into the shiny, new — and very white — Los Angeles neighborhood. Just who, exactly, constitutes a them simply depends on which side of the driveway you stand.

Deborah Ayorinde and Ashley Thomas in Them

(Photo by Amazon Studios)

Deborah Ayorinde stars as Lucky Emory, a homemaker and mother going through her own loss who is uncomfortable with her husband Henry’s (Ashley Thomas) plans to move the family across the country. Ayorinde, a British-born person of Nigerian descent who moved to the U.S. as a child, told Rotten Tomatoes that she understood the title immediately.

“Here’s the thing: we live in a world where people are actually terrified of being them,” she said. “So what they do is they tend to highlight other people as them, for lack of a better phrase, so that people will not pay attention to their own ways to which they are different.”

Alison Pill in Them

(Photo by Amazon Studios)

The all-too familiar antagonist of the first season of Them is Alison Pill’s Betty Wendell, the blonde, white, and self-appointed queen bee of the block’s (not-so) welcoming committee. She rules the neighborhood bridge parties with well-manicured exactness and everyone knows that there’s no way the desserts she brings to the potluck came from Vons. Just try not to mention what Betty believes to be her one imperfection: that she and her husband Clarke (Liam McIntyre) cannot have children. Sending her minions after the Emorys when the new family moves to town secures Betty’s power.

But the title’s definition could also mean something … supernatural. Or spooky. Or suspenseful. And, sometimes in Them, it’s all of those things and then some. Soon the audience, and Lucky and her family, begin to wonder how much of eerie and unfortunate stuff is really happening and how much of it is the circumstances of their living situation. After all, we’re told from the very beginning that this is a story about a family who lives in a house for only 10 days.

“We always had a question in the writers’ room, which we would ask ourselves a lot, which was: ‘What scares us most: that sound in the basement that you can’t explain? Or that neighbor from down the street who has been staring at your house every single day?’” series creator Little Marvin said. “And in our collective experience, it’s usually always that neighbor … I find human beings to be deeply scary. I think rooting the terror in something deeply human was our very first impulse.

“I’m not particularly interested in just empty jumpscares for the sake of jumpscares,” said the series creator, who goes by “LM” on second reference. “I like things that feel emotionally rich, and then let the horror kind of come from there.”

He said the thesis for the anthology is “this idea that, since the dawn of this country … there’s always been them. There’s always been the folk who have been subjected to the sort of ire and suspicion and paranoia, and frankly, hatred and terror, of the dominant folk.”

Deborah Ayorinde, Melody Hurd, Shahadi Wright Joseph, and Ashley Thomas in Them

(Photo by Amazon Studios)

As a Black man, LM said it made sense to explore “the terror of being Black” for season 1. Focusing on the post-World War II economic boom of 1953 also fit because it was when home ownership became attainable for the middle class.

But, LM added, “as Black folks know, the dream of home ownership has been anything but. [So] I wanted to definitely go back and peel apart the floorboards and look at the roots of that particular nightmare.”

The look and sounds of the show are also unique in that they look period — but not the period you’d imagine. The music is anachronistic, in part, LM said because “no offense to musicians in 1953, but that was a deeply sh—y year for music.”

“We set out to make a show about the ’50s that felt like it was shot in the ’60s or ’70s. And by doing that, it allowed us to think about the way we framed, the way we shot and the way we styled. But, also, the soundscape and the music that we used,” LM said.

Telling a story that takes place only over a week and a half “creates an instant pressure cooker,” LM said. Not only does it keep the pace moving, but it also gave the writers “the time and the space to dig in on a day and to live with these characters as they’re maneuvering and navigating their lives every day.”

Ashley Thomas (center) in Them

(Photo by Amazon Studios)

This also created an intense experience for the actors. Stars Ayorinde and Thomas said they were only given four of the scripts at first, meaning that they didn’t know what was real or imaginary either. She said that LM would frequently talk to her on set, not just about how her character, Lucky, would be doing but how she was handling it all.

Thomas said he liked that his Henry was an upwardly mobile engineer and veteran, and that he was battling the very real issue of PTSD while also being “a character that was multi-layered and nuanced who loved his family unconditionally” who was “present emotionally and present physically.”

The hard part for him was unpacking his own privilege of living in modern society and “making sure that I played the restraint correctly.”

“I had to make sure that I stripped away my ego to play the character and service the character,” Thomas explained. “I can afford to react differently to something in 2021, 2022, 2023 than someone can in 1953 when it is literally the difference between life and death.”

Shahadi Wright Joseph in Them

(Photo by Amazon Studios)

These are all weighty topics, particularly given the current political climate. The show was accused of mining Black trauma after a trailer was released in March — especially since Lena Waithe, one of its executive producers, is also the creator of the Showtime drama The Chi. It also, inevitably, was compared to Jordan Peele’s 2019 horror film Us, both because of the title and because they each feature actress Shahadi Wright Joseph as a strong-willed eldest child.

LM said that the word “them” was the first one that came to his mind when he was conceiving a name for the project — something that happened before he’d heard of Us. He also claims the casting was also coincidental; he was busy making a TV show and didn’t have time to concentrate on when the movie’s hiring was announced.

And while neither Thomas nor Ayorinde say they know if (or how) they’d be in a second season of the anthology, LM says the plan is for “the people and the time period and the place will be different every season.”

“As we move forward in our progression of the anthology, the hope is to take folks who have been historically marginalized or pushed to the sides of those frames and really center them in their own tales of American terror every year,” he said.

Unfortunately, there are plenty of them out there.

Them premieres on Friday, April 9 on Amazon Prime Video.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Certified Fresh finale The Walt Disney Company SXSW parents venice Paramount ABC Family dreamworks science fiction Anna Paquin vs. sequel mockumentary serial killer Academy Awards golden globe awards jurassic park adenture Hulu anime Broadway cops twilight Netflix Christmas movies Lifetime Christmas movies Star Trek king kong children's TV laika Film sports Oscars thriller Action LGBTQ TIFF 2017 90s MTV documentaries CBS Alien MSNBC Fox News Tubi Sundance TV Spectrum Originals VICE scary movies franchise Nat Geo zombie asian-american First Reviews richard e. Grant Vudu Reality Set visit slashers IMDb TV Box Office kaiju 21st Century Fox Hallmark Christmas movies japanese ITV south america See It Skip It Pop hispanic heritage month archives Comic-Con@Home 2021 Netflix Sony Pictures Drama black royal family natural history Shudder Sneak Peek genre LGBT spinoff classics OneApp Peacock reboot Epix teaser TV movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina DirecTV hollywood 2021 TV Land sitcom Television Critics Association Columbia Pictures spanish sopranos Ghostbusters Britbox 2020 Syfy DC streaming service Sundance vampires 99% FX on Hulu Photos festival HBO Disney Plus Family Fantasy Pixar HBO Go Showtime San Diego Comic-Con spanish language NYCC aapi RT21 Country football History mission: impossible Brie Larson Disney video TCA Awards Masterpiece rt labs chucky game show Year in Review Legendary Biopics robots all-time Mary Tyler Moore Superheroe Women's History Month discovery historical drama anthology streaming concert live action 4/20 diversity emmy awards critics SundanceTV BBC Instagram Live olympics Reality Competition stoner dceu Awards Tour toy story gangster OWN 93rd Oscars Food Network aliens Rom-Com police drama Podcast E! halloween tv action-comedy GoT Disney+ Disney Plus Dark Horse Comics streaming movies 72 Emmy Awards 45 Creative Arts Emmys 2018 romantic comedy Polls and Games Avengers prank Animation TLC docuseries biography Kids & Family Emmy Nominations composers posters nfl dragons Tumblr Fox Searchlight marvel cinematic universe book criterion mutant Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cancelled zero dark thirty Funimation Summer Universal Pictures psychological thriller award winner BBC One Marvel Wes Anderson versus SDCC Musicals Amazon know your critic Arrowverse technology Discovery Channel TCA Baby Yoda Sci-Fi Star Wars Rock AMC YouTube Premium TCA Winter 2020 marvel comics justice league Cosplay razzies binge Crunchyroll Mary Poppins Returns crossover 2015 telelvision heist movie Western breaking bad black comedy war what to watch ABC Signature Thanksgiving Red Carpet independent cats foreign wonder woman Nominations based on movie Superheroes nature Christmas PBS halloween kong critic resources BET Pet Sematary docudrama japan universal monsters Image Comics superman romance Nickelodeon rt labs critics edition Shondaland canceled BAFTA Neflix Tomatazos HBO Max Martial Arts The Purge sequels kids Logo unscripted Ovation name the review Cannes mcc Marathons Infographic indiana jones movie Emmys cults comic adventure godzilla GLAAD green book target NBA Apple Watching Series adaptation documentary Black Mirror Winners FX zombies slasher Interview Awards video on demand boxoffice Writers Guild of America TV One Holiday Musical Turner Comedy Central PlayStation Trophy Talk young adult Hallmark WGN YouTube Red remakes mob blaxploitation Super Bowl saw Esquire basketball biopic The Academy suspense cancelled TV series witnail cars renewed TV shows CMT Lifetime cancelled television travel Marvel Studios screen actors guild CW Seed Hear Us Out Endgame king arthur festivals live event trailers superhero Trailer feel good spain RT History Opinion APB New York Comic Con 71st Emmy Awards President rotten X-Men quibi politics Rocketman Schedule true crime Disney streaming service The Arrangement films cancelled TV shows Travel Channel TruTV singing competition best latino social media Quiz Mindy Kaling TBS cartoon ESPN Pop TV comedies spider-verse Best and Worst comic book movie free movies USA crime AMC Plus TV Countdown YouTube worst movies scorecard period drama fast and furious Spike miniseries blockbuster ViacomCBS rom-coms hispanic women Song of Ice and Fire Rocky Classic Film Cartoon Network IFC Films ratings theme song TV renewals international legend Tarantino rotten movies we love spy thriller Lucasfilm stop motion Mudbound screenings Television Academy CNN debate Marvel Television dramedy cooking FXX tv talk toronto PaleyFest satire Walt Disney Pictures australia First Look facebook A24 Mystery Amazon Prime Video Teen boxing christmas movies Extras Winter TV The Witch deadpool Pride Month A&E Stephen King Turner Classic Movies Toys crime thriller sag awards italian VH1 indie strong female leads political drama series casting popular psycho Crackle Tokyo Olympics Comedy 2016 dark IFC new zealand Exclusive Video new star wars movies medical drama french 73rd Emmy Awards National Geographic NBC Pirates TCA 2017 VOD television talk show transformers ABC Adult Swim El Rey Paramount Plus Mary poppins Binge Guide Freeform new york a nightmare on elm street lord of the rings Comics on TV crime drama worst stand-up comedy comic book movies 20th Century Fox comics book adaptation Bravo Calendar batman news TNT Pacific Islander Music monster movies Horror Warner Bros. disaster directors comic books BET Awards Spring TV Elton John Amazon Studios Acorn TV comiccon Film Festival DC Universe fresh Premiere Dates spider-man Lionsgate die hard werewolf canceled TV shows Apple TV+ YA Heroines harry potter supernatural TCM Chernobyl high school Trivia GIFs dogs joker CBS All Access Black History Month Video Games golden globes Holidays 1990s Election Amazon Prime Grammys Universal revenge 2019 reviews Paramount Network scary DGA American Society of Cinematographers doctor who cinemax E3 The Walking Dead movies Sundance Now WarnerMedia hidden camera The CW USA Network 007 hist FOX scene in color dexter Valentine's Day nbcuniversal rt archives Fall TV MCU james bond art house jamie lee curtis game of thrones ghosts Comic Book space Character Guide DC Comics obituary 24 frames dc animated elevated horror Starz BBC America 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Disney Channel pirates of the caribbean blockbusters Apple TV Plus Ellie Kemper ID Captain marvel child's play