News

The Mandalorian First Reviews: Season 2 Premiere Gives Star Wars Fans Plenty of Easter Eggs To Snack On

Between exciting action, a dynamic hero, excellent guest stars, and that adorable — yes, we know, "technically not Baby Yoda" — Muppet, episode "The Marshal" captures everything great about Star Wars and offers fans even more to love.

by | October 30, 2020 | Comments


The Mandalorian comes roaring back with the first episode of season 2. “Chapter 9: The Marshal” serves up loving shots of The Child (“Baby Yoda”), a monster of a challenge for Din Djarin/The Mandalorian (Pedro Pascal), an engaging new character played by Hollywood’s favorite lawman and gunslinger Timothy Olyphant, and plenty of shoot-’em-up action.

Here’s what critics are saying about episode 1 of The Mandalorian season 2:


Is The Child Still Adorable?

The Child -- aka "Baby Yoda" -- in The Mandalorian season 2, episode 1

(Photo by Lucasfilm/Disney+)

“Even with Mando kicking serious ass for most of the episode, the best part of the premiere was, naturally, Baby Yoda.” – Amanda Mullen, Culturess

“This episode of The Mandalorian is pretty much Jaws. It’s Jaws plus Baby Yoda reaction shots. What more could you want?” – Ben Allen, GQ Magazine [UK]

“This week’s adventure is as simple as they come, and, as expected, Baby Yoda’s as cute as ever.” – Jack Shepherd, SFX Magazine

“The Mandalorian has returned to save 2020 with a stellar opening episode helmed by Jon Favreau, a wonderful performance from an unexpected co-star, and plenty of Baby Yoda cuteness.” – Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com


How Does “The Marshal” Hold Up Next to the High Bar Set by Season 1?

The Mandalorian season 2 keyart

(Photo by Lucasfilm/Disney+)

“Hopefully, Favreau and Co. continue to experiment and open up this universe. ‘The Marshal’ celebrates what you love about ‘Star Wars’ and makes you love it more. It provides more understanding of what we’ve seen and who we thought we knew.” – Preston Barta, Fresh Fiction

“[The Mandalorian] proves with one of its best episodes yet that it still has a lot of flair, inspiration, and jetpack fuel to go around.” – Nick Allen, RogerEbert.com

“It’s such a simple premise and it’s been done more times than we can count, but in this age of convoluted storytelling and ‘It’s really a 10-hour movie’ seasons of television, it feels fresh and, in its own way, kind of revolutionary.” – Tom Fitzgerald and Lorenzo Marquez, Tom & Lorenzo

“’The Marshal’ doesn’t feel long. There are probably some spots that could have been tightened up, but on the whole it was very much of a piece with how the show worked so well a year ago.” – Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone

“The first episode, ‘Chapter 9: The Marshal,’ was full of highlights, marking a strong start to the show’s sophomore run.” – Amanda Mullen, Culturess

“You can relax – The Mandalorian Season 2 isn’t about to skimp on the action, and it’s of the same quality as it was in the previous outing.” – Jonathon Wilson, Ready Steady Cut


How Are the New Characters?

Pedro Pascal and Gor Koresh in The Mandalorian season 2, episode 1

(Photo by Lucasfilm/Disney+)

“We don’t need gimmicky cameos by movie characters to tie in with the saga as a whole, and ‘The Marshal’ offers something arguably much richer.” – Richard Trenholm, CNET

“As the episode’s title, ‘The Marshal’, might suggest, a marshal with whom to contend, played winningly by Timothy Olyphant, who has form in the lawman department. Throwing Mando in with someone as laconic and charming as Olyphant even brings something out of the taciturn hero. At one point he comes dangerously close to making what could be considered to be, after much scrutiny, a joke.” – Chris Hewitt, Empire Magazine

“[Olyphant] does a terrific job alongside Pedro Pascal’s formidable bounty hunter and is someone we definitely hope to see more of in this series (or others). The actor in question is one of the most talented working in Hollywood today, though not someone we see anywhere near as often as we should on screen. With The Mandalorian, however, they’re bound to now have a whole new legion of fans. ” – Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com


Good Easter Eggs?

Sand people and Pedro Pascal in The Mandalorian season 2, episode 1

(Photo by Lucasfilm/Disney+)

“Despite my love of all the fun Easter Eggs, we should hope that The Mandalorian doesn’t get too overwhelmed by bringing in wider Star Wars lore and forget what makes it work so well – the simple story of a gruff mercenary and a super-powered alien muppet.” – Huw Fullerton, Radio Times

“Even with so many nods to Star Wars past, The Mandalorian’s not overstuffed.” – Jack Shepherd, SFX Magazine



How Are the Effects in Season 2?

“They also do a very impressive job bringing it to life. Effects on action and sci-fi television series have traditionally lagged behind action and sci-fi movies.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

“While this week’s episode is tipping its hand just a bit too much in its ambitions to be the new, albeit kid-friendly, Game of Thrones, there is something to be said for delivering high-priced spectacle on a weekly basis.” – Barry Hertz, Globe and Mail

“Despite my wishes for what this episode should have been, it is clear that the production values on this series continue to rival anything else on TV right now. It also shows that Jon Favreau truly respects the Star Wars mythology, both canon and non.” – Alex Maidy, JoBlo’s Movie Network

“[Among] its most epic [episodes], partly thanks to an eight-minute sequence that seemed to have been shot with IMAX cameras.” – Akhil Arora, Gadgets360

“The quality of The Mandalorian continues to be on par with the Star Wars movies, and the visuals from start to finish are nothing short of awe-inspiring. ” – Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com


So Is There Anything to Complain About?

Pedro Pascal and Weequay bartender in The Mandalorian season 2, episode 1

(Photo by Lucasfilm/Disney+)

“I just wish it had gone to a new planet, or even dived deeper into the characters.” – Megan Crouse, Den of Geek

“The series isn’t going to succeed until it stops being ‘that Star Wars show’ and starts coming into its own.” – Kelly Lawler, USA Today

Mando’s Season 2 premiere is fun but familiar; creative action and easter eggs help boost an anticlimactic story.” – Laura Prudom, IGN Movies


Final Verdict?

Sand People in The Mandalorian season 2, episode 1

(Photo by Lucasfilm/Disney+)

“If the balance of Season 2 can match the promise of this first episode, it’s still easy to have a good feeling about this.” – Brian Lowry, CNN.com

“Despite a panoply of familiar Mandalorian ingredients… ‘The Marshal’ fails to congeal them into something greater. When it comes to washing Rise of Skywalker’s taste from our mouths, however, The Mandalorian is the perfect Listerine.” – Louis Chilton, Independent (UK)

“The most exciting aspect of the Season 2 premiere, in the long run, comes down to this: The Mandalorian really has made the case for its existence by how it highlights what life is like in the Outer Rim.” – Liz Shannon Miller, Collider

“The action of ‘The Marshal’ and its canon-shaking final shot works better for people who know all the related material (and not just the films, but the books too) but the episode is also entertaining on its own terms, another Western-inspired story of a man who goes to the edge of society to save a village from a violent threat.” – Brian Tallerico, The Playlist


The Mandalorian season 2 episode 1 is now available to stream on Disney+. 

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Comedy Central Fantasy cinemax Holiday festivals Teen Nickelodeon Red Carpet Watching Series werewolf comics fast and furious Sci-Fi spanish Nat Geo TV unscripted travel docudrama sequel ViacomCBS Alien dark Polls and Games Paramount Network golden globe awards Sundance FXX telelvision Disney streaming service jamie lee curtis theme song south america psycho Elton John canceled TV shows police drama Pride Month toy story screenings Chilling Adventures of Sabrina godzilla black Peacock jurassic park space YouTube Red cops Biopics FOX foreign Spectrum Originals Fall TV rotten Amazon Studios SundanceTV Trailer stoner Reality Marvel Studios GoT DC streaming service Winners zombie politics pirates of the caribbean classics political drama TBS cancelled television spanish language fresh war docuseries a nightmare on elm street dceu anime Lionsgate MCU See It Skip It YA Food Network Premiere Dates independent Sony Pictures The Witch Endgame Travel Channel revenge comic sports CNN prank Mary Tyler Moore Election Year in Review Britbox hist Infographic BBC Broadway supernatural boxing green book Amazon Country BAFTA Emmys sag awards talk show 4/20 Turner Classic Movies crime drama VH1 reboot nature transformers series science fiction History The Walking Dead mutant A24 dogs cults 45 Comedy Extras Discovery Channel Pop TV twilight sitcom james bond dramedy President Disney+ Disney Plus laika Superheroes cancelled TV series crime thriller finale American Society of Cinematographers CW Seed Turner Television Critics Association Video Games 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards dragons 99% kids Creative Arts Emmys Star Trek 007 richard e. Grant disaster Rock book adaptation adaptation Calendar Trophy Talk FX on Hulu Horror spinoff Masterpiece Character Guide concert ABC composers teaser Quiz screen actors guild name the review thriller spy thriller versus blaxploitation dc TV renewals Crunchyroll Hallmark Christmas movies Walt Disney Pictures ABC Family New York Comic Con Martial Arts Animation new star wars movies Drama Musicals harry potter Apple TV Plus adventure Freeform golden globes mission: impossible trailers psychological thriller Super Bowl 2019 2021 discovery The Academy Disney Channel ITV italian hispanic Pop Pirates VICE San Diego Comic-Con toronto batman historical drama blockbusters Amazon Prime Video Funimation Classic Film crossover Emmy Nominations christmas movies anthology Oscars NBC Heroines Interview TLC Warner Bros. TCA Winter 2020 TIFF robots E! superhero Starz best women joker justice league nbcuniversal Bravo YouTube binge indie Writers Guild of America Opinion cooking documentary Epix diversity LGBT Logo emmy awards ABC Signature slashers Anna Paquin Esquire romantic comedy Spring TV The Purge USA tv talk Universal venice IFC Films Podcast serial killer Paramount halloween tv Syfy 2020 medical drama Lifetime Christmas movies X-Men book VOD GIFs rt archives all-time Tarantino monster movies 21st Century Fox romance Legendary APB kong japanese Cartoon Network obituary animated parents Awards OneApp Tubi Sneak Peek Hallmark chucky singing competition DirecTV cars Winter TV RT History USA Network The Walt Disney Company football Certified Fresh indiana jones scorecard MSNBC zero dark thirty spider-man Lucasfilm Schedule Best and Worst reviews Set visit ESPN Acorn TV 24 frames Columbia Pictures TCA 2017 king kong Avengers BBC One Shondaland First Reviews OWN Superheroe LGBTQ First Look Apple TV+ Hulu BBC America WGN comic books 2017 The CW quibi razzies stand-up comedy Cannes National Geographic Film free movies 2016 criterion Showtime crime Disney films documentaries halloween E3 ID video on demand cancelled TNT HBO Go archives Black Mirror vampires SXSW Mystery Vudu spain doctor who french Western boxoffice YouTube Premium Television Academy TCA Awards TV One what to watch Spike miniseries video hollywood asian-american Rocketman TV Land directors Comics on TV PaleyFest Rocky Black History Month Holidays Fox News Action Ellie Kemper ratings worst movies game of thrones true crime cartoon comiccon period drama Mudbound Netflix Mary poppins kaiju SDCC cancelled TV shows Paramount Plus NYCC Music Grammys superman children's TV Valentine's Day Toys rotten movies we love Exclusive Video BET Shudder Amazon Prime deadpool Pixar Mary Poppins Returns Marvel Television hidden camera El Rey stop motion Christmas Musical Fox Searchlight Countdown zombies 20th Century Fox 93rd Oscars CBS All Access Tumblr breaking bad 71st Emmy Awards nfl WarnerMedia die hard Film Festival Hear Us Out Box Office aliens Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt casting comedies DC Comics PlayStation Academy Awards Thanksgiving Chernobyl biography Dark Horse Comics technology AMC cats game show HBO Rom-Com The Arrangement rom-coms news child's play Cosplay Stephen King PBS Binge Guide universal monsters FX Crackle australia Trivia Ghostbusters TCA heist movie witnail Women's History Month DC Universe Reality Competition mockumentary Adult Swim Baby Yoda festival Marathons Disney Plus Marvel Netflix Christmas movies Lifetime Song of Ice and Fire CBS Awards Tour ghosts remakes CMT latino Sundance TV Nominations social media movies based on movie BET Awards scary movies satire RT21 DGA Photos Tomatazos Mindy Kaling facebook elevated horror television Family strong female leads Apple 2015 GLAAD movie critics Star Wars MTV IFC TruTV Sundance Now Summer TCM A&E renewed TV shows sequels 2018 Arrowverse blockbuster franchise Brie Larson HBO Max Comic Book Ovation natural history 72 Emmy Awards Captain marvel canceled award winner worst popular streaming Kids & Family Pet Sematary