Critics Consensus

The Lion King Is a Visual Feast, but Offers Nothing New

Critics say Disney's latest remake is a technical achievement, but it's essentially a rehash of the 1994 animated classic.

by | July 18, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a royal cub (The Lion King, featuring the voices of Donald Glover and Beyoncé Knowles-Carter). What are the critics saying?

The Lion King (2019) 53%

We’ve already gotten two of Disney’s live-action remakes of animated films from their canon — namely Dumbo back in March and Aladdin in May — but this week’s The Lion King was always the most anticipated of the bunch. Director Jon Favreau took on similar material when he helmed 2016’s The Jungle Book, which was both a critical and commercial success, so it made sense to tap him for another talking-animal movie with one less human in it. Multi-hyphenate talent Donald Glover takes on the role of adult Simba, while Beyoncé plays Nala, with Chiwetel Ejiofor as Scar, Billy Eichner as Timon, Seth Rogen as Pumbaa, and returning as the voice of Mufasa, James Earl Jones. Unfortunately, the critics haven’t all been on board for this return trip to the African wilderness. While most are quick to praise the technical craft that has gone into bringing the characters to life, many feel that it’s a double-edged sword, since the photorealistic nature of the animals necessarily limits their expressiveness. In addition, this new version of the story is essentially a shot-for-shot remake of the original that offers precious few new elements, which several critics found disappointing. With all of that in mind, overall reception to the film will largely hinge on whether audiences were hoping to see a new interpretation of the classic story or content to see the same tale retold, but with admittedly mind-blowing visuals. Either way, The Lion King is all but guaranteed to rule the box office this weekend, so Hakuna Matata to that.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Tomatazos composers Winners theme song Tumblr RT21 Rocketman mockumentary First Look Elton John Sci-Fi true crime Comics on TV Marathons Film Festival TCA 2017 Disney elevated horror mutant disaster YouTube Red 24 frames Fantasy Sneak Peek Oscars Election TV Land streaming Winter TV Cartoon Network Rom-Com YouTube Premium Quiz dramedy Nickelodeon Amazon Prime Ovation Christmas hist Nominations Adult Swim space Marvel LGBTQ WarnerMedia E! E3 Apple crime drama crime Brie Larson game show Tarantino anthology Pirates series Infographic teaser Biopics CMT Lucasfilm adaptation science fiction Song of Ice and Fire Awards Tour Summer miniseries Trailer Pixar Acorn TV Chernobyl Epix thriller ABC witnail unscripted stand-up comedy Disney streaming service Red Carpet Netflix Trivia cars jamie lee curtis 2017 award winner dc Interview Trophy Talk GIFs AMC what to watch History Mindy Kaling Sundance Now The Witch 2019 movies Drama crime thriller psychological thriller Food Network BBC America National Geographic Anna Paquin Columbia Pictures Paramount Network revenge OWN Pop aliens medical drama BET PBS Mystery binge TCM Country transformers HBO American Society of Cinematographers spy thriller ITV spinoff Video Games kids The CW natural history TNT Cannes Lifetime GLAAD animated Logo singing competition 21st Century Fox YA Walt Disney Pictures historical drama Mary poppins DC Universe Kids & Family TV Schedule romance Rocky X-Men travel Nat Geo spider-man Opinion New York Comic Con Stephen King 20th Century Fox Vudu Heroines TCA Set visit Ghostbusters golden globes Mudbound cults Character Guide Watching Series CBS PaleyFest Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ESPN USA Superheroe nature festivals facebook Musical biography children's TV Reality Competition supernatural Captain marvel Superheroes Writers Guild of America sitcom 2018 Mary Tyler Moore TIFF ratings dceu Sundance television justice league Shudder Podcast Holidays Bravo sports politics CW Seed VH1 Starz El Rey Ellie Kemper docudrama boxoffice 45 DC Comics Polls and Games CNN Premiere Dates comiccon Super Bowl green book Cosplay Horror social media San Diego Comic-Con Hulu Emmys Comedy Central IFC MCU Rock The Arrangement police drama dragons Spring TV blaxploitation richard e. Grant Pride Month NYCC DirecTV robots comic USA Network Calendar toy story Warner Bros. serial killer WGN zombies Film VICE sequel cops Black Mirror Lionsgate Extras diversity SXSW Toys Thanksgiving psycho zombie Comedy Fox News Year in Review vampires Box Office quibi war Spike zero dark thirty finale Binge Guide anime RT History Syfy Fall TV 007 HBO Max 2015 Dark Horse Comics DGA 2016 based on movie Best and Worst strong female leads Emmy Nominations FOX APB TBS MSNBC cooking Countdown SDCC Shondaland Sony Pictures Family A&E Animation Paramount Showtime Star Wars Crackle TruTV Photos BBC Disney Channel talk show Martial Arts crossover discovery adventure DC streaming service Reality Pet Sematary Certified Fresh Valentine's Day Western Star Trek Chilling Adventures of Sabrina political drama MTV technology See It Skip It Freeform Teen Amazon Prime Video tv talk cinemax Comic Book Amazon harry potter Musicals Mary Poppins Returns LGBT FXX Action ABC Family casting TLC Creative Arts Emmys FX Spectrum Originals Women's History Month cats IFC Films doctor who Masterpiece Esquire CBS All Access book SundanceTV NBC Grammys Awards Music period drama Universal President Britbox ghosts GoT