Critics Consensus

The Lion King Is a Visual Feast, but Offers Nothing New

Critics say Disney's latest remake is a technical achievement, but it's essentially a rehash of the 1994 animated classic.

by | July 18, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a royal cub (The Lion King, featuring the voices of Donald Glover and Beyoncé Knowles-Carter). What are the critics saying?

The Lion King (2019) 53%

We’ve already gotten two of Disney’s live-action remakes of animated films from their canon — namely Dumbo back in March and Aladdin in May — but this week’s The Lion King was always the most anticipated of the bunch. Director Jon Favreau took on similar material when he helmed 2016’s The Jungle Book, which was both a critical and commercial success, so it made sense to tap him for another talking-animal movie with one less human in it. Multi-hyphenate talent Donald Glover takes on the role of adult Simba, while Beyoncé plays Nala, with Chiwetel Ejiofor as Scar, Billy Eichner as Timon, Seth Rogen as Pumbaa, and returning as the voice of Mufasa, James Earl Jones. Unfortunately, the critics haven’t all been on board for this return trip to the African wilderness. While most are quick to praise the technical craft that has gone into bringing the characters to life, many feel that it’s a double-edged sword, since the photorealistic nature of the animals necessarily limits their expressiveness. In addition, this new version of the story is essentially a shot-for-shot remake of the original that offers precious few new elements, which several critics found disappointing. With all of that in mind, overall reception to the film will largely hinge on whether audiences were hoping to see a new interpretation of the classic story or content to see the same tale retold, but with admittedly mind-blowing visuals. Either way, The Lion King is all but guaranteed to rule the box office this weekend, so Hakuna Matata to that.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

ESPN Quiz MCU IFC Films medical drama Pirates cults Winter TV Cartoon Network Sundance tv talk Cannes travel BBC Trivia cops Music crime cars Heroines Fall TV thriller finale Crackle A&E HBO Max Apple Writers Guild of America binge adaptation First Reviews Best and Worst Disney Plus Columbia Pictures YouTube Red batman Pet Sematary serial killer talk show nature Nickelodeon SXSW mockumentary robots CBS cinemax Lifetime Calendar Amazon Prime Video spider-man game of thrones BET Superheroes Christmas FOX SundanceTV Certified Fresh Logo transformers Stephen King GoT Musicals free movies television biography History Superheroe American Society of Cinematographers cancelled television Emmy Nominations DirecTV doctor who Valentine's Day Winners teaser GIFs Hulu war Women's History Month TNT south america sitcom Walt Disney Pictures dramedy Anna Paquin San Diego Comic-Con MSNBC richard e. Grant ratings Vudu Pop crime thriller Mudbound USA politics Kids & Family Reality ITV DC streaming service disaster Lionsgate dc Rocketman Emmys USA Network ghosts Set visit CMT Biopics New York Comic Con Pride Month Watching Series Extras TV WarnerMedia game show The Walking Dead Paramount Network Character Guide anthology latino Animation National Geographic spanish language Toys 71st Emmy Awards Family Video Games Food Network Sony Pictures Dark Horse Comics Shondaland YouTube Premium Fox News 20th Century Fox YouTube police drama spinoff Awards cats anime Action zombie theme song Infographic Chernobyl VICE Binge Guide APB Awards Tour golden globes Trailer Captain marvel Comedy Polls and Games natural history Western TCA 2017 PaleyFest crime drama revenge Film Festival YA Spring TV video Brie Larson unscripted Rom-Com Black Mirror cancelled TV series mutant spy thriller Nominations Rocky Comics on TV dragons Masterpiece Disney streaming service Sneak Peek Cosplay DGA Peacock Ellie Kemper Warner Bros. Comedy Central SDCC movies 2017 singing competition animated cooking toy story comic book TBS Bravo Thanksgiving adventure diversity zero dark thirty festivals vampires NYCC Netflix slashers Arrowverse romance boxoffice justice league El Rey The Witch witnail The Arrangement stand-up comedy PBS Disney blaxploitation Television Academy RT History based on movie aliens 2015 foreign E! Opinion Sundance Now Summer 21st Century Fox crossover First Look Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Martial Arts spain harry potter Amazon joker Pixar technology green book The CW Apple TV+ political drama CBS All Access BBC America Drama comiccon IFC Marathons MTV TCA TV Land Oscars TCM 2019 Spectrum Originals kids Esquire ABC Family canceled TV shows Teen Song of Ice and Fire HBO sequel FX Interview 45 Red Carpet Tumblr Reality Competition OWN miniseries GLAAD Elton John TLC Paramount Shudder children's TV Horror See It Skip It facebook VH1 TruTV streaming Country casting Podcast Tomatazos Freeform Marvel AMC psycho Rock Tarantino Creative Arts Emmys Mary Poppins Returns Lucasfilm Holidays Epix elevated horror what to watch LGBTQ Syfy Fantasy Nat Geo LGBT quibi Mindy Kaling Mary Tyler Moore CNN Sci-Fi ABC Film Countdown composers 2016 Star Wars X-Men CW Seed Ovation zombies Adult Swim hispanic E3 Showtime Grammys TIFF 007 series DC Comics Mystery Premiere Dates docudrama social media Amazon Prime award winner Photos WGN hist psychological thriller discovery Britbox FXX Schedule period drama Year in Review sports TV renewals cancelled Universal canceled Acorn TV DC Universe Spike Disney Channel renewed TV shows RT21 supernatural Election halloween Starz Comic Book 24 frames historical drama Ghostbusters strong female leads Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled TV shows Trophy Talk Box Office Mary poppins science fiction true crime space President Musical Super Bowl jamie lee curtis NBC dceu 2018 Star Trek