Critics Consensus

The Lion King Is a Visual Feast, but Offers Nothing New

Critics say Disney's latest remake is a technical achievement, but it's essentially a rehash of the 1994 animated classic.

by | July 18, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a royal cub (The Lion King, featuring the voices of Donald Glover and Beyoncé Knowles-Carter). What are the critics saying?

The Lion King (2019) 52%

We’ve already gotten two of Disney’s live-action remakes of animated films from their canon — namely Dumbo back in March and Aladdin in May — but this week’s The Lion King was always the most anticipated of the bunch. Director Jon Favreau took on similar material when he helmed 2016’s The Jungle Book, which was both a critical and commercial success, so it made sense to tap him for another talking-animal movie with one less human in it. Multi-hyphenate talent Donald Glover takes on the role of adult Simba, while Beyoncé plays Nala, with Chiwetel Ejiofor as Scar, Billy Eichner as Timon, Seth Rogen as Pumbaa, and returning as the voice of Mufasa, James Earl Jones. Unfortunately, the critics haven’t all been on board for this return trip to the African wilderness. While most are quick to praise the technical craft that has gone into bringing the characters to life, many feel that it’s a double-edged sword, since the photorealistic nature of the animals necessarily limits their expressiveness. In addition, this new version of the story is essentially a shot-for-shot remake of the original that offers precious few new elements, which several critics found disappointing. With all of that in mind, overall reception to the film will largely hinge on whether audiences were hoping to see a new interpretation of the classic story or content to see the same tale retold, but with admittedly mind-blowing visuals. Either way, The Lion King is all but guaranteed to rule the box office this weekend, so Hakuna Matata to that.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

animated Polls and Games 007 WarnerMedia Disney+ Disney Plus cartoon rotten movies we love game of thrones Pop TV Certified Fresh MSNBC Apple TV+ hispanic 2018 TLC Star Wars chucky Discovery Channel 2015 Comics on TV El Rey LGBTQ cancelled television thriller VOD 20th Century Fox green book VH1 Rock miniseries CBS All Access composers Travel Channel Lionsgate romantic comedy travel crime Mary Tyler Moore SXSW Lucasfilm Turner political drama independent Year in Review anthology Apple OWN cults disaster PBS classics Super Bowl dc psychological thriller Turner Classic Movies Apple TV Plus mockumentary spinoff Film directors HBO Max TCA Awards SDCC Heroines comics Tumblr Tomatazos Star Trek 2017 fast and furious Fall TV Pride Month Paramount Network casting finale ITV IFC Stephen King sag awards book witnail Netflix Christmas movies parents Emmy Nominations Endgame what to watch Ovation Box Office GLAAD TCA Winter 2020 ESPN cancelled TV shows CMT screen actors guild historical drama video on demand FX latino Baby Yoda Winter TV Reality Musicals PaleyFest social media Song of Ice and Fire Crackle Dark Horse Comics Marvel quibi Hallmark space Shudder Mystery nature laika Television Academy superhero biography strong female leads toy story Television Critics Association Western Warner Bros. Pop Drama Spike news game show Acorn TV Premiere Dates crossover Country based on movie dceu Oscars Ellie Kemper RT History police drama History screenings Sci-Fi RT21 docudrama crime thriller Quiz talk show Action Reality Competition child's play BBC Lifetime Christmas movies Masterpiece 2016 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt First Reviews President serial killer zombies Sundance TV 4/20 Awards dogs Biopics Columbia Pictures cancelled Countdown Epix Pirates teaser zero dark thirty DGA cops 45 Sony Pictures Paramount Martial Arts television Syfy Superheroe christmas movies Disney streaming service elevated horror festivals universal monsters documentary TruTV Awards Tour video stoner Best and Worst politics National Geographic Avengers canceled TV shows diversity Thanksgiving zombie Teen blockbuster Mary poppins YouTube spanish language Logo FXX 2019 documentaries aliens Election Holidays Nat Geo Photos movies Grammys Netflix Music DC Universe FX on Hulu Disney comiccon Shondaland BBC One Vudu natural history all-time FOX spider-man Christmas golden globes a nightmare on elm street Rom-Com hist DC Comics justice league comedies BBC America reboot stop motion stand-up comedy PlayStation Mudbound transformers Hulu supernatural TV Land Horror TBS war spain Fox News slashers satire Adult Swim APB 72 Emmy Awards Disney Channel YouTube Premium Hear Us Out tv talk Family OneApp Amazon Studios spy thriller joker breaking bad TNT TV Marvel Television WGN The Walking Dead Animation ABC Family dramedy AMC YA revenge YouTube Red sequels indie CW Seed Amazon Spring TV TCM Hallmark Christmas movies psycho comic Pet Sematary films Trivia E! doctor who Classic Film DC streaming service cooking CNN hollywood A24 theme song die hard versus romance VICE award winner 71st Emmy Awards indiana jones Amazon Prime Video GoT See It Skip It mutant Set visit streaming Binge Guide Kids & Family emmy awards Watching Series asian-american USA twilight The Arrangement Universal Britbox Brie Larson true crime Black Mirror dark franchise Arrowverse sports Cartoon Network Starz name the review sequel rotten discovery critics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina movie The Purge Infographic batman technology werewolf crime drama children's TV Trophy Talk Disney Plus halloween criterion Film Festival 2020 E3 best concert adventure Video Games Interview free movies GIFs Cosplay harry potter Musical San Diego Comic-Con Peacock ratings Comedy science fiction Funimation IFC Films Marvel Studios Opinion A&E TCA BET Nominations Comic Book Esquire TCA 2017 Calendar unscripted foreign blaxploitation richard e. Grant vampires jamie lee curtis robots ghosts scary movies Extras Comedy Central Trailer Freeform Fantasy series Academy Awards Character Guide MCU facebook cats NYCC Elton John Mindy Kaling Lifetime Red Carpet obituary LGBT anime Sundance Tubi Rocketman Marathons Schedule Superheroes Winners Sneak Peek Valentine's Day ABC adaptation Spectrum Originals MTV 24 frames nbcuniversal worst BET Awards Pixar canceled cars kids USA Network SundanceTV HBO Go Summer Walt Disney Pictures Tarantino New York Comic Con The Witch singing competition HBO NBC Black History Month boxoffice binge Bravo cancelled TV series The CW Creative Arts Emmys Captain marvel Anna Paquin Nickelodeon Chernobyl sitcom reviews DirecTV cinemax Showtime American Society of Cinematographers 21st Century Fox south america CBS dragons Amazon Prime renewed TV shows TV renewals Mary Poppins Returns Toys Women's History Month First Look Ghostbusters Cannes Holiday TIFF Rocky Emmys Podcast mission: impossible X-Men BAFTA Food Network Sundance Now Writers Guild of America medical drama period drama Crunchyroll