Comics On TV

Tempers Flare in The Falcon and The Winter Soldier Episode 4

Sam and Karli have a pivotal chat, but brawn prevails over brain in "The Whole World Is Watching."

by | April 9, 2021 | Comments

Winter Soldier/Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan) and Ayo (Florence Kasumba) in Marvel Studios' THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER

(Photo by Julie Vrabelová. ©Marvel Studios 2021. All Rights Reserved.)

One of the great strengths of a Marvel Studios project is the scene where the hero and villain trade their philosophical differences. Sure, not all villains are created equally — not everyone can be Thanos or Baron Zemo (Daniel Brühl) — but even the slightest of bad guys usually has some valid point to make that challenges the hero’s worldview. OK, maybe not Ego (Kurt Russell). His ideas stank.

Spoiler alert: The following reveals details of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier episode 4, “The Whole World Is Watching.” Stop here if you have not watched the episode.

Nevertheless, that strength is once again on display in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier’s fourth episode, “The Whole World Is Watching.” A conversation between Sam (Anthony Mackie) and Karli (Erin Kellyman) was inevitable. But the topics they discuss may be more thrilling than the subsequent fights with John Walker (Wyatt Russell). So let’s dive into the philosophical argument at play and how a key line of dialogue from the past may help us to understand why Karli is still an antagonist after her chat with Sam.

Is Zemo a Baron of the People?

Falcon/Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie), Zemo (Daniel Brühl) and Winter Soldier/Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan) in Marvel Studios' THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER

(Photo by Chuck Zlotnick. ©Marvel Studios 2021. All Rights Reserved.)

But first, let’s discuss Zemo and his seeming standing as a protagonist in this scenario. His argument against the Super Soldier Supremacy is sound. Hell, his argument against the Avengers is sound at this point. Both represent an emerging aristocracy based entirely in might so strong, it can topple a Mad Titan. From the ground, that is a chilling concept; in fact, we’ll give some credit to Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and its illustration of just how frighting it would be to live in a world of super-powered people. The Marvel multiverse, meanwhile, always excels at humanizing these tech billionaires and Super Soldiers. It’s easy to trust Tony Stark (for the most part) and Steve Rogers, because we know their hearts. Without that knowledge, though, they easily become as imposing as Zack Snyder’s Superman or the Batman.

It is the thrust of Zemo’s argument: only Steve was honorable enough to be trusted with the serum (and even then, he still held him accountable for Sokovia). If it were to be produced on a mass scale, then there would be an army of Super Soldier supremacists ready to make the world cower under its flag.

And his notion sounds good except for one thing — Zemo is himself an aristocrat. If history has taught us anything, it’s that you cannot trust the aristocracy. He may continue to champion the people’s causes, and he certainly has an easier time empathizing with the displaced than an Avenger, but his lament for formerly beautiful palaces in Latvia suggests a royal still caught up in his memories of decadence and splendor. So, can we really trust Zemo if he is a baron looking for a barony to run?

One thing in his favor is the way he dealt with the serum. His behavior in this moment reveals a truth about his character; he meant every word about his distrust of Super Soldiers and the Avengers. Where another villain might take the serum and build that supremacy for themselves, Zemo barely hesitated to smash the vials; of course, that seeming altruism may be couched in an aristocrat’s belief that they alone can rule over the people.

Meanwhile, he continues to be a cool tactician. He clearly expected Walker and Ayo (Florence Kasumba) to show up and provide cover for his escape. Despite our healthy skepticism of an aristocrat, the show makes it very hard to hate Zemo.

“Good Becomes Great; Bad Becomes Worse”

John Walker (Wyatt Russell) in Marvel Studios' THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

The night before Steve (Chris Evans) took the Super Soldier Serum in Captain America: The First Avenger, Dr. Erskine (Stanley Tucci) told him a key fact about what it does: it “amplifies everything inside,” so “good becomes great; bad becomes worse.” Steve, having a heart so pure even Mjolnir deemed him worthy of the power of Thor, became the greatest human. Red Skull’s (Hugo Weaving) use the serum unleashed a mad scientist ready to supplant Hitler’s notion of supremacy with his own.

And almost a century after those events, Erskine’s understanding of the serum is once again in play.

Let’s start with Karli. Her aims are honorable; she wants to maintain the world without borders where traditional tribalism is replaced with a broader sense of global community. The serum has made her more effective in that goal. But it also unleashed a darker aspect of her soul. She’s willing to kill, intimidate, and create the supremacy Zemo fears to get what she wants. This is the slippery slope of revolutionaries  — or, at least, the revolutionaries American schools acknowledge in their history classes — the temptation to use might to create a seemingly gentler world. Sadly, it often just means a new aristocracy replacing the old. Noble ideals fall away as revolutionaries find the need to maintain power is nearly impossible to resist. Very few can follow in Cincinnatus’s footsteps (although even his story is fraught with problems), and, at the moment, we doubt Karli will be able to abdicate power under any circumstances. Had Zemo not destroyed the vials, Sam and Bucky (Sebastian Stan) would be dealing with 20 Super Soldiers instead of five.

Winter Soldier/Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan), John Walker (Wyatt Russell) and Lemar Hoskins (Clé Bennett) in Marvel Studios' THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER

(Photo by Julie Vrabelová. ©Marvel Studios 2021. All Rights Reserved.)

We’re back to that number as Walker used the serum to kill one of Karli’s men. But let’s move on to Walker as the serum is clearly doing a number on him. As far as we can tell, he’s not over Afghanistan. That’s totally reasonable as plenty of soldiers in our world also suffer from the stress and memories of their service over there. But we get the impression Walker — and possibly Lemar (Clé Bennett) — never sought out the sort of support group Sam used to run before he became an Avenger. Note the way Walker bristles at Sam’s mention of counseling as a viable option for Karli. Also note Walker’s increasing frustration at waiting for the talking cure.

This only escalates once he takes the serum. Sure, the justification he elicits from Lemar is reasonable. More people could be saved, but John would need to process his PTSD and his inferiority complex in order to use the serum effectively. Sadly, he’s not that kind of soldier, and the serum definitely unleashes a villain. Add to that the psychological stress of seeing Karli murder Lemar, and you get something far more terrible than Zemo or the Flag Smashers. It certainly feels like a sleeping giant has been awakened.

It will be interesting to see how the GRC and the American government deal with the fallout of Walker’s very public actions next week. They’ll likely try to strip him of the Captain America title, but will he be willing to give it up?

Oh, and what did the serum do for Bucky? Free of Hydra conditioning, it made him the best possible partner for Captain America’s true successor — even if both he and Sam deny that partnership.

An Important Conversation About a Fairer World

Karli Morgenthau (Erin Kellyman) in Marvel Studios' THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

In order for Sam to truly becomes Captain America, though, he needs to understand what those words mean in a post-Blip, post-colonial world. Although the program is produced by an American conglomerate known for exporting American culture in ways that can be viewed as imperialistic, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier is doing some soul-searching about stomping on other cultures with the presumed moral authority the U.S. claimed in the wake of World War II. Sam embodies that with both the brilliance and hopeless optimism Karli points out during their key conversation.

As with his offer to get Sharon (Emily VanCamp) a pardon last episode, Sam operates on the notion he can pull off the same sort of feats as Steve. Never mind he is unwelcome in his own country — remember the scene at the bank — or how his presumed authority looks to a person who shuttled around the slums of Europe most of her life.

And yet, Sam and Karli want the same thing: a fairer world.

The problem they face, and the one we face on an hourly basis, is the very concept of fairness. But as Karli eludes to in her eulogy to Donya Madani and expressly says to Sam a few minutes later, a part of the fairness she seeks is the peace and prosperity she found in the years of the Blip. Fairness is an equitable share of resources and an unprecedented freedom of movement. It is also means the chance to build things as communities united in a humanist philosophy instead of the old distinctions of race, country, and religion.

Sam supports these ideals in theory, but as he missed the Blip years, he cannot really understand what it was like. Like Bucky’s limited empathy with Ayo about King T’Chaka’s death, Sam’s understanding of the Blip world falters no matter how many times he tells Karli he gets it. Admittedly, it sounds like a paradise to us, but it comes at an unacceptable cost. And as we now know Karli is willing to commit to the grim calculus, it makes their conversation all the sadder. Then there’s that moment when Sam almost gets through to her before Walker bursts in. Now, the only way forward is blood for Karli and Walker.

Power Broker Watch: Episode 4 Edition

Sharon Carter/Agent 13 (Emily VanCamp) in Marvel Studios' THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

We presume Sam will try to keep the peace, but like Karli, he will be fighting a war on two fronts. For Karli, that second battle will be with the Power Broker, who will be none too thrilled to learn the remaining serum vials are gone. We still don’t know who the Power Broker is, however. Like last week, Sharon is still a possibility. Her free movement through Madripoor, access to satellites, and high-tech command station certainly suggest a level of clout and resources far beyond the picture she gave to Sam last week. It is possible she works for S.H.I.E.L.D. or S.W.O.R.D.; in fact, as The Falcon and the Winter Soldier was meant to stream before WandaVision, Sharon’s shadiness may have been meant to lead into the agency’s first appearance. Or maybe she really did break bad and fund a new Super Soldier program. A showdown between her and Karli would be unexpected.

It is also possible the Power Broker will be the special episode 5 cameo showrunner Malcolm Spellman alluded to in recent days. But after all the digital ink we spilled with WandaVision‘s supposed cameo, we’re unwilling to put a lot of thought into this possibility. If it turns out to be Victor Von Doom or Justin Hammer (Sam Rockwell), we’ll be pleasantly surprised.

The Falcon and the Winter Soldier premieres new episodes on Fridays on Disney+.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

supernatural japanese Western reviews french Lionsgate slashers See It Skip It Emmys reboot The CW cartoon laika Watching Series Mary Tyler Moore know your critic SundanceTV Universal Pictures Sci-Fi singing competition italian Walt Disney Pictures TCA 2017 Rom-Com psychological thriller OneApp rotten movies we love Captain marvel BAFTA History HFPA hist award winner king arthur Trophy Talk Photos mockumentary Pirates 20th Century Fox TV movies cancelled television A24 documentary Classic Film Musical criterion south america Martial Arts RT21 dogs TV Land 1990s Academy Awards FX X-Men Comic-Con@Home 2021 teaser indiana jones 2021 target new star wars movies dragons Extras social media ABC critic resources Pop TV gangster mission: impossible toronto nfl Lifetime Biopics 24 frames Shondaland Comedy Comics on TV DC Comics Teen anime ABC Family toy story mob best a nightmare on elm street romance Winners 2017 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt unscripted NBA Paramount Network The Witch Pop Film Festival 99% zero dark thirty Masterpiece golden globe awards Elton John suspense foreign remakes First Reviews japan concert Women's History Month WGN Year in Review facebook 93rd Oscars Christmas Showtime Schedule breaking bad historical drama Warner Bros. Image Comics MTV finale 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Purge satire travel VOD DirecTV worst Crunchyroll Superheroe TV Toys mutant posters A&E archives Wes Anderson police drama Britbox dc romantic comedy fresh Pet Sematary indie mcc E! casting stand-up comedy Prime Video Sneak Peek book adaptation black 72 Emmy Awards comic book movies jurassic park CMT Opinion genre Ovation Certified Fresh revenge theme song HBO Max Exclusive Video Broadway australia james bond heist movie marvel cinematic universe asian-american royal family canceled National Geographic Disney+ Disney Plus vs. Amazon LGBTQ Superheroes HBO WarnerMedia prank adaptation MSNBC Discovery Channel aapi black comedy YouTube scary The Walking Dead Mindy Kaling leaderboard spanish language Pixar TCA what to watch Tubi natural history screenings cinemax Amazon Prime USA AMC TLC GLAAD women 2015 disaster streaming movies Television Critics Association Election Video Games transformers E3 Food Network space GIFs ESPN nature wonder woman video serial killer Spike renewed TV shows aliens Music Nat Geo Binge Guide pirates of the caribbean Reality spider-verse legend Avengers comedies Box Office Cartoon Network Adult Swim true crime Star Trek psycho Spring TV YouTube Red Star Wars Drama OWN diversity kong ghosts Sony Pictures Amazon Prime Video Emmy Nominations San Diego Comic-Con Acorn TV slasher VICE dark Heroines Shudder Columbia Pictures TCA Awards crime BBC America cults Amazon Studios book dexter Rocky all-time Dark Horse Comics Tomatazos BET Chilling Adventures of Sabrina monster movies kids period drama 73rd Emmy Awards President sequels Podcast Sundance Now Holidays Marvel Television Red Carpet 2018 21st Century Fox Writers Guild of America Country adventure video on demand franchise TV One name the review The Walt Disney Company canceled TV shows vampires Arrowverse Quiz binge composers Esquire superman ratings television joker Trailer science fiction Syfy films Mystery comic Apple TV+ Sundance TV new york marvel comics NBC quibi Oscars spy thriller Neflix international Polls and Games Apple Summer The Arrangement El Rey USA Network dreamworks Hollywood Foreign Press Association YA political drama LGBT festivals TCA Winter 2020 based on movie game show football docuseries 71st Emmy Awards IMDb TV scorecard trailers 2020 zombies latino popular DGA Kids & Family APB parents NYCC TNT series New York Comic Con First Look hollywood 2016 MCU harry potter twilight Disney streaming service hispanic heritage month jamie lee curtis hispanic news feel good Comedy Central Fox Searchlight Travel Channel war scene in color screen actors guild trophy IFC art house Mudbound ID Family Super Bowl witnail deadpool RT History Ghostbusters Hear Us Out superhero independent dceu richard e. Grant politics 007 Awards Fox News Disney Plus talk show rt archives stoner YouTube Premium blockbuster fast and furious critics spain Infographic AMC Plus Netflix Christmas movies Creative Arts Emmys anthology Logo obituary sequel tv talk Endgame PaleyFest Horror die hard Countdown CBS All Access Hallmark Christmas movies ViacomCBS Cannes Pacific Islander Fantasy sports Spectrum Originals new zealand golden globes Sundance basketball cancelled Turner festival Nickelodeon Interview PBS movies halloween tv DC Universe scary movies Song of Ice and Fire Vudu FX on Hulu Action versus Winter TV spanish Disney Animation Comic Book sopranos DC streaming service cancelled TV shows Valentine's Day crime thriller Apple TV Plus chucky cars SXSW Chernobyl Ellie Kemper BBC One Mary Poppins Returns high school directors Best and Worst hidden camera Fargo christmas movies action-comedy 4/20 TruTV debate TIFF adenture cats sag awards godzilla medical drama razzies game of thrones discovery CW Seed Pride Month Tarantino Lucasfilm rom-coms PlayStation HBO Go blockbusters streaming Tags: Comedy Trivia doctor who Epix boxoffice Crackle comiccon Brie Larson Universal spinoff TV renewals Alien halloween Marvel American Society of Cinematographers elevated horror olympics animated batman Mary poppins comic book movie SDCC children's TV comic books thriller nbcuniversal lord of the rings live event Funimation rotten BET Awards Rocketman movie Bravo Tokyo Olympics sitcom universal monsters Starz boxing blaxploitation werewolf miniseries Set visit Hallmark spider-man Baby Yoda cancelled TV series Black History Month live action FXX Reality Competition VH1 rt labs free movies Peacock CNN stop motion king kong biopic green book TBS strong female leads cooking justice league Awards Tour 90s Freeform young adult Premiere Dates Nominations documentaries saw Fall TV crime drama Marathons crossover Tumblr Holiday docudrama technology biography Cosplay ABC Signature Musicals comics Calendar cops Disney Channel Rock Netflix Thanksgiving Paramount Plus Anna Paquin telelvision 79th Golden Globes Awards FOX Instagram Live emmy awards Black Mirror rt labs critics edition kaiju 45 classics Lifetime Christmas movies Legendary GoT BBC The Academy 2019 ITV dramedy Paramount worst movies Character Guide Hulu CBS Turner Classic Movies Stephen King Grammys Film child's play zombie Marvel Studios IFC Films Television Academy robots TCM venice