Sundance Reviews: "Chicago 10" Is Unique But Flawed; "The Savages" Is Wrenching And True

by | January 20, 2007 | Comments

Here are some short reviews of "Chicago 10" and "The Savages," both of which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival.

With its bold amalgamation of archival footage and rotoscope animation, "Chicago 10" is certainly unique. And initially, in the wake of the current debate over a "surge" of U.S. forces in Iraq, Brett Morgen’s film feels joltingly timely: it begins with Lyndon Johnston announcing troop escalation in Vietnam. From there, the film tells the story of the Chicago Seven, the group of radicals that included Abbie Hoffman, Jerry Rubin, and Bobby Seale; they were tried on a number of charges, including inciting a riot, in the wake of the violence that surrounded the 1968 Democratic National Convention. The animation is smooth and vibrantly colorful, while the old footage of the Chicago riots is horrifyingly bleak; it’s clear excessive force was used against anti-war protesters, and that the Chicago Seven were railroaded.


"Chicago 10": Talkin’ ’bout a revolution.

But as the movie progresses, something is missing; "Chicago 10" always threatens to make a point or two about the current state of the union, but never quite delivers. Despite being on the right side of history in more than a few ways (not least because the charges against them were ultimately dismissed), the Yippies’ antics (particularly Hoffman’s) can feel pretty anachronistic and childish given the gravity of times. While the filmmakers clearly hoped to light a fire under contemporary audiences, it ultimately feels a bit more like a history lesson, albeit one told with plenty of flair. "Chicago 10" is still an interesting film, but it will have to settle for second place in the "films set during the 1968 Democratic Convention that mix documentary and dramatic styles" sweepstakes behind "Medium Cool."

"Chicago 10" is currently at 80 percent on the Tomatometer; critics have praised the film’s stylistic daring and its depiction of a remarkable moment in history.


Philip Seymour Hoffman and Laura Linney in "The Savages"

People die in the movies all the time. However, not many films show the untidiness of the slow journey into darkness with as much honesty and earned poignancy as "The Savages," Tamara Jenkins‘ assured second feature. Wendy (Laura Linney) and John (Philip Seymour Hoffman) are adult siblings whose estranged father Lenny (Phillip Bosco) is suffering from dementia, and his care has fallen unexpectedly into their hands. Wendy seems on the verge of a crisis already. She’s underemployed and romantically unfulfilled, and her hand-wringing over her father’s care may stem from her own troubles. John isn’t in the best emotional shape either, but he’s more of a realist; he accepts the messiness of the situation and is looking to deal with it as efficiently as possible ("We’re taking better care of the old man than he ever took of us," he says). All of the performances are excellent, but Bosco’s is particularly fine. He doesn’t play the old man with warmth or wisdom, and that’s just right; this man is himself right up to the end. Despite its gloomy subject matter, "The Savages" is surprisingly entertaining, featuring well-drawn characters, some bitter laughs, and an aching humanity throughout.

Tag Cloud

reboot game of thrones festivals TruTV Netflix Awards Tour Apple E! kids USA spanish language cancelled TV shows Superheroe dramedy GLAAD Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Binge Guide Super Bowl Stephen King WarnerMedia NBC The Purge boxoffice discovery MCU Awards Comedy Toys mutant Film Festival toy story The Walking Dead dceu ghosts Amazon Prime Marvel Studios TIFF Box Office biography Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CNN HBO FOX The CW science fiction Sony Pictures revenge independent travel unscripted adventure canceled Sundance Animation TLC romantic comedy Reality doctor who Year in Review sports 71st Emmy Awards cancelled TV series Tubi President Paramount Network X-Men psychological thriller 007 Photos OneApp Crackle movie USA Network DC Comics witnail cops SXSW Interview PBS harry potter Extras Warner Bros. See It Skip It Musicals dogs TV talk show Crunchyroll Arrowverse TV Land Star Wars Spectrum Originals Amazon Studios rotten movies we love Polls and Games movies Adult Swim Tomatazos Chernobyl LGBT Hallmark Christmas movies The Witch what to watch based on movie ABC batman ESPN sequel SundanceTV Turner New York Comic Con documentary technology Disney Spring TV space RT21 Apple TV+ crime Western Columbia Pictures Paramount Marvel Television Freeform Emmys Countdown Baby Yoda BET Disney+ Disney Plus Mindy Kaling robots dc 45 IFC game show A24 period drama Discovery Channel golden globes PaleyFest Dark Horse Comics Bravo YouTube award winner Walt Disney Pictures blockbuster Elton John Mudbound Lifetime Nickelodeon DC Universe animated CW Seed Mary Tyler Moore VICE Lionsgate hispanic canceled TV shows 21st Century Fox Horror NYCC Comics on TV Hulu Action Grammys quibi singing competition YouTube Red streaming Summer Lucasfilm Holiday supernatural crossover anime CMT 2016 Disney Plus Academy Awards richard e. Grant slashers Sneak Peek Nominations jamie lee curtis video YouTube Premium Writers Guild of America E3 Certified Fresh zombie Christmas stand-up comedy directors Trailer Rocky politics ratings comiccon crime drama docudrama LGBTQ Comedy Central DirecTV Showtime Cannes Song of Ice and Fire Biopics Rom-Com thriller Avengers anthology Sundance Now natural history Video Games justice league YA Thanksgiving ITV Music Mary Poppins Returns 2019 romance The Arrangement Reality Competition FXX Apple TV Plus social media vampires Disney Channel aliens Netflix Christmas movies psycho zombies joker TNT werewolf American Society of Cinematographers Rock Fantasy GoT Sundance TV children's TV IFC Films renewed TV shows sitcom screen actors guild Marathons History GIFs true crime Fall TV El Rey mockumentary Shudder Pride Month versus Fox News halloween Schedule Television Academy blaxploitation cats latino composers disaster Podcast cinemax police drama foreign cancelled Valentine's Day Esquire Epix Tarantino OWN elevated horror comic Trivia Emmy Nominations Disney streaming service Pop strong female leads Britbox facebook Brie Larson TBS Winter TV name the review Comic Book teaser Nat Geo finale Drama Amazon DGA 2020 24 frames Set visit historical drama Ellie Kemper spy thriller Food Network Starz free movies TV renewals Kids & Family dragons San Diego Comic-Con Black Mirror 2018 theme song Rocketman BBC Trophy Talk Character Guide Mary poppins Endgame breaking bad HBO Max Pirates MSNBC Mystery Shondaland VH1 cooking Cosplay screenings transformers RT History AMC Calendar Family green book Opinion SDCC Hallmark Superheroes miniseries comics Winners Sci-Fi TCA 2017 Election indie Marvel 2017 Universal Spike Creative Arts Emmys series Ghostbusters Martial Arts TCM TCA Best and Worst book Captain marvel Holidays CBS All Access Turner Classic Movies 20th Century Fox political drama Cartoon Network MTV First Reviews Lifetime Christmas movies National Geographic spinoff Vudu Oscars A&E spider-man zero dark thirty sag awards Ovation casting war diversity APB binge Syfy Infographic Pixar Amazon Prime Video Film Anna Paquin WGN cartoon serial killer Watching Series south america Tumblr crime thriller ABC Family Logo Acorn TV Pet Sematary Heroines cancelled television Star Trek First Look medical drama DC streaming service Masterpiece spain cars TCA Winter 2020 CBS nature Premiere Dates television Country Classic Film adaptation Red Carpet 2015 tv talk FX BBC America cults hist Musical Women's History Month Quiz Peacock Teen christmas movies