Stargirl First Reviews: A Nostalgic, Action-Packed 'Must See' for DC Fans

Critics say DC Universe's newest TV offering is a fun throwback to the Golden Age of comics with heart, adventure, and a star-making turn from Brec Bassinger.

by | May 1, 2020 | Comments

Not to be confused with the Disney+ movie of the same name, DC’s Stargirl series is here to shake up the superhero genre with a big dose of fun.

The TV show, which is inspired by the Geoff Johns–created comic series Stars & S.T.R.I.P.E., tells the tale of the Justice Society of America’s demise and the subsequent rise of a young new hero. That hero is Courtney Whitmore (Brec Bassinger), who goes from innocent yet lively high school teenager to a spry, acrobatic, staff-wielding vigilante-in-training. The series kicks off with Courtney’s family moving from Los Angeles to Blue Valley, Nebraska; her mother Barbara (Amy Smart) and new stepfather, Pat (Luke Wilson) are looking to start a new life in this small town. But it’s not long before Courtney discovers her stepdad is not who he seems. 

After discovering some peculiar items in the basement — and becoming acquainted with the late Starman’s (Joel McHale) Cosmic Staff — the teenager learns Pat was once known as S.T.R.I.P.E., superhero sidekick to the JSA. As you’d expect, Courtney quickly embraces her new role as budding superhero, with Pat’s reluctant guidance, and takes on the mission of upholding justice in the face of old foes, while inspiring the rise of an entirely new generation of heroes. 

Stargirl (DC Universe)

Stargirl is the first series partnership between DC Universe and the CW, and every episode will premiere on the streamer before hitting the network a day later. This all makes sense given the involvement of Arrowverse mastermind, Greg Berlanti; the events that went down in The Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover resulted in the creation of a new Earth-2, which helped spawn this show. And in this realm, the legacy of the Justice Society of America lives on.

It’s worth noting that Johns (Titans, Wonder Woman, Doom Patrol) not only gets a co-creator credit here, but he also writes a number of episodes. Given the personal connection Johns has to the story — the comic was inspired by his sister Courtney who died in the 1996 TWA Flight 800 disaster — we’re surely in for an emotional rollercoaster.

“She’s the first character I ever wrote in comic books and created her in my very first comic book,” Johns told EW. “She was inspired by my late sister, so it means a lot to me personally to have come off the page and onto the screen like this, and to work with the crew and the cast that I did. It was amazing.”

So, how is the new series? Here’s what the critics are saying about Stargirl.


(Photo by © 2020 The CW Network, LLC. All Rights Reserved.)

Newcomer Brec Bassinger is perfect as Stargirl

Bassinger is an inarguable star. She makes the show; it’s a performance where you can track the character’s progression from fish-out-of-water to bonafide hero just from the way Bassinger carries herself. — Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

Brec Bassinger dazzles as our lead, and with the entire show on her shoulders, she proves to be a very capable lead actress. — Ferdosa Abdi, Geeks of Color

…the actress embodies the Courtney Whitmore from the source material more often than not, showing her sweet and fun side away from those irritable family moments. — Kyle Wilson, Lamplight Review


(Photo by Jace Downs/The CW)

Luke Wilson shines as Stargirl’s superhero sidekick stepdad

The real standout, however, is Luke Wilson as the put-upon Pat. While Wilson has worked steadily for over two decades, he’s been somewhat under the radar since his early-2000s heyday. But he shines in Stargirl, perfectly balancing Pat’s roles as awkward new stepfather, exasperated elder, and superhero sidekick, making for a thoroughly appealing character. — Cynthia Vinney, CBR

Wilson, by the way, is an absolute gift to this show. He sells every single line, even the most far fetched ridiculous ones. — Grace Randolph, Beyond the Trailer

The action sequences and special effects are surprisingly strong

If you are or have ever been a fan of the Arrow-verse, then Stargirl will be right up your alley. However, it will be that little bit sweeter thanks to the big budget attached to the show – allowing it to be very visually pleasing in hand with some great action-packed set pieces. Stargirl is a must-watch for any DC Fan. — Alex Page, Discussing Film

The amazing action-packed opening sequence completely blew me away in size and cinematic scope – it might just be the best thing DC has ever done on the small screen. The visual effects are particularly impressive and on par with Swamp Thing, with a number of powers, including the cosmic staff, wonderfully brought to life. — Nicola Austin, We Have a Hulk

So how does Stargirl compare to the likes of Supergirl and The Flash? Budget-wise, the special effects are a slight step up from what Arrowverse fans might be used to. Courtney’s gymnastic skills are put to great effect here as she flips around baddies using her cosmic staff. Props must be given to that extremely impressive prop too, which genuinely feels like a character in its own right thanks to some fun visual quirks. — David Opie, Digital Spy


(Photo by © 2020 The CW Network, LLC. All Rights Reserved.)

It’s a fun, family-friendly throwback to DC’s Golden Age

Time and again when watching DC’s Stargirl — especially the first couple of episodes, out of the five I screened — it very much evoked the Walt Disney films of “old,” namely the ones in which college student Kurt Russell was accidentally bestowed with one power (invisibility) or another (supersmarts), and rightly geeked out. — Matt Webb Mitovich, TV Line

It’s big, epic, and cartoonish in a very fun way. — Alex Cranz, I09

There’s something nostalgic and purely fun about DC’s Stargirl that makes it nearly irresistible. The series has a reverence and love for a simpler time, yet still firmly plants itself in the modern with a similar, but more guarded sense of optimism. — Kyle Wilson, Lamplight Review

Stargirl premieres Monday, May 18, on DC Universe and Tuesday, May 19, at 8 pm ET/PT on the CW.

Thumbnail: Smallz & Raskind/The CW

Stargirl: Season 1 (2019)

Adjusted Score: 91.397%
Critics Consensus: A stellar series perfect for anyone looking for a little hope, Stargirl is delightful fun the whole family can enjoy.
Synopsis: About a high-school student who bands together with the Justice Society of America to fight villains, past and present... [More]

Tag Cloud

VH1 cartoon Drama sitcom crime drama Turner Classic Movies Paramount singing competition dragons natural history USA Network Grammys FOX TLC HBO Go Britbox new zealand TV Land Oscars RT History CW Seed 2019 political drama hist Extras chucky anime Anna Paquin football technology video on demand Sundance Now classics Sundance TV Starz finale golden globe awards Best and Worst adventure Mindy Kaling Crackle GoT Pride Month independent ABC IFC Travel Channel Syfy Sundance dramedy Avengers game show telelvision The Purge science fiction Reality Super Bowl Cartoon Network video Comedy Central TBS documentaries Image Comics revenge Apple Fox Searchlight asian-american Broadway DC Comics Quiz spain Interview nfl mutant godzilla 2015 Baby Yoda Arrowverse Premiere Dates TCA Winter 2020 Musicals Black History Month spy thriller TCA Awards police drama Walt Disney Pictures OWN TCA 2017 Kids & Family supernatural basketball psycho deadpool mission: impossible women 4/20 Cosplay witnail Freeform CNN Lionsgate streaming movies Academy Awards joker monster movies die hard romantic comedy australia Wes Anderson italian transformers Alien Discovery Channel book DGA FX Pet Sematary Summer satire cancelled DC Universe fresh Marvel Television pirates of the caribbean Schedule APB dogs E3 comedies richard e. Grant Nickelodeon television comic king arthur halloween japanese Lucasfilm Spectrum Originals A&E Character Guide Box Office biography spinoff TV renewals Logo DC streaming service 45 24 frames Legendary justice league Star Wars Apple TV Plus Rock TCM Epix Apple TV+ christmas movies dc American Society of Cinematographers target rt archives zero dark thirty Television Academy blaxploitation 007 toy story E! razzies Holiday Chernobyl Film zombie LGBTQ Lifetime Christmas movies Warner Bros. 2018 saw 90s films First Look ratings PBS scorecard spanish Netflix Certified Fresh composers Television Critics Association spanish language Stephen King The Academy ViacomCBS Pop NBC Creative Arts Emmys Podcast Hallmark Christmas movies thriller spider-man name the review Countdown binge stop motion lord of the rings BBC One obituary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Lifetime indie a nightmare on elm street cancelled TV shows TV foreign ABC Family USA YouTube YA Disney streaming service crime Fall TV screen actors guild Christmas kids tv talk Calendar batman emmy awards Black Mirror Tokyo Olympics Pixar golden globes sequel Universal legend book adaptation talk show fast and furious cancelled television Teen black cooking twilight Sneak Peek war screenings vampires comiccon renewed TV shows cults 21st Century Fox 99% Esquire series cats true crime Martial Arts Superheroes directors Biopics TV movies Tumblr Food Network Video Games YouTube Premium theme song rotten movies we love WGN Western MTV Ghostbusters 2020 travel Photos Paramount Plus news werewolf Spike Amazon Prime Video nature Captain marvel National Geographic toronto Disney Plus Awards Tour Hulu adaptation jamie lee curtis ghosts Mary Tyler Moore Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Marvel Studios Awards Polls and Games Tarantino 2017 mockumentary 2016 new star wars movies Comics on TV Country ITV boxoffice El Rey Dark Horse Comics discovery GIFs aliens Acorn TV blockbusters BBC America Election trailers Disney+ Disney Plus hollywood suspense critics Emmy Nominations rom-coms Infographic Writers Guild of America PaleyFest universal monsters The Arrangement Spring TV Rom-Com indiana jones venice Year in Review Women's History Month superman disaster Trailer parents X-Men unscripted TV One Masterpiece 2021 stoner crossover VOD PlayStation 93rd Oscars BAFTA Star Trek AMC Exclusive Video Trivia comics quibi Ovation robots Action Columbia Pictures 71st Emmy Awards 1990s what to watch kong Classic Film Mary Poppins Returns cars VICE Song of Ice and Fire cinemax Hallmark Opinion Musical boxing Mudbound Crunchyroll Rocky halloween tv 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards movies popular SXSW scary movies canceled TV shows social media Fox News Heroines A24 nbcuniversal heist movie Peacock Brie Larson San Diego Comic-Con concert TruTV hispanic OneApp SDCC kaiju remakes Vudu superhero Winter TV documentary ID Fantasy dceu Comic-Con@Home 2021 Binge Guide The Walking Dead comic books HBO archives rotten Cannes Rocketman Nominations Holidays blockbuster TIFF know your critic wonder woman medical drama french psychological thriller Amazon Prime jurassic park hidden camera Shudder strong female leads The Witch worst movies BET Awards GLAAD Watching Series Hear Us Out President crime thriller japan Funimation Animation First Reviews Turner dark Pacific Islander marvel cinematic universe Pop TV Trophy Talk laika Red Carpet WarnerMedia NBA BET worst Adult Swim aapi 72 Emmy Awards MSNBC Bravo HBO Max Family game of thrones historical drama The CW Amazon Studios cops free movies Elton John Valentine's Day animated stand-up comedy Mary poppins docudrama FXX CBS All Access james bond Ellie Kemper adenture Comedy Tubi festival Showtime doctor who ESPN Thanksgiving miniseries LGBT Disney Channel scene in color harry potter RT21 zombies space YouTube Red TNT streaming award winner teaser 20th Century Fox The Walt Disney Company king kong franchise Tomatazos international FX on Hulu TCA Sci-Fi reviews DirecTV new york Shondaland diversity Marvel south america casting serial killer Winners facebook NYCC Set visit reboot latino MCU children's TV Amazon best green book Disney Music prank breaking bad all-time Pirates anthology See It Skip It ABC Signature IFC Films Emmys Endgame politics child's play based on movie cancelled TV series Toys festivals versus Marathons high school Reality Competition elevated horror History live action sports canceled Film Festival Comic Book romance Netflix Christmas movies slashers BBC New York Comic Con Horror SundanceTV Sony Pictures docuseries criterion Superheroe Paramount Network period drama olympics sequels CMT movie Nat Geo Mystery sag awards CBS