News

Star Trek: Picard First Reviews: Patrick Stewart Shines in New Series That Does the Franchise Proud

The Star Trek universe and this beloved lead character have matured in the CBS All Access series. And, like fine wine, the flavor is complex (and perhaps not to every taste).

by | January 23, 2020 | Comments


Bringing back Patrick Stewart to his iconic role as former captain and now retired admiral Jean-Luc Picard was no easy feat, Star Trek: Picard producers Alex Kurtzman, Akiva Goldsman, Michael Chabon, and Heather Kadin told Rotten Tomatoes recently. The classically-trained actor adamantly and very publicly had no interest in rehashing the beloved Star Trek: The Next Generation character.

“It was wildly public that he was not interested in ever coming back ever, ever, ever,” Goldman related. “But we felt that if we went and sat with him, he would come back. And we went and sat with him, and he said, ‘No.'”

But they sent him a 35-page script by Chabon anyway.

“None of which is in the show,” Goldsman revealed.

Series showrunner Chabon added: “None of that. It was a completely different story. But what it shared with what we ended up making was a perspective on the character of Jean-Luc Picard that was serious, and mature, and about a man who is at a later stage of his life, reckoning with his past, and the things that he’s done and things he hasn’t done, and trying to decide what’s next for him. We were just trying to show Patrick: ‘You can trust us. We get it. We get that you don’t want to come back and be on the bridge of the Enterprise and have the crew and all that. You want to do something different. Here’s something different.'”

Evidently, the work of the Chabon — author of Wonder Boys, The Yiddish Policemen’s Union, Moonglow, and Pulitzer Prize-winning The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay — held sway.


Pictured (l-r): Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard; Isa Briones as Dahj of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: Matt Kennedy/CBS

Star Trek newcomers joining Stewart include Isa Briones as the mysterious Dahj, Michelle Hurd as former Starfleet Officer Raffi Musiker, Alison Pill as Dr. Agnes Jurati, Harry Treadaway as Narek, Evan Evagora as Elnor,  and Santiago Cabrera as pilot Chris Rios. Star Trek vets returning: Star Trek: The Next Generation’s Brent Spiner reprises his role as Data, Marina Sirtis returns as Deanna Troi, Jonathan Frakes is William Riker and again steps behind the camera to direct, and Jonathan Del Arco returns as Hugh, while Star Trek: Voyager’s Jeri Ryan appears as Seven of Nine.

Season 1 has just taken flight on CBS All Access and quickly scored a Certified Fresh designation based on reviews. Critics have been given a look at three episodes of the series. Here’s what they’re saying about Star Trek: Picard.


DOES IT HONOR THE FRANCHISE?

STAR TREK: PICARD -- Key Art Photo Cr: James Dimmock/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

So unlike any other Trek property and deeply ensconced in the mythology of Gene Roddenberry’s creation which makes it one of the most distinct Star Trek stories ever to be told on screen. —Alex Maidy, JoBlo’s Movie Emporium

Extending a fiercely loved chapter in the “Star Trek” mythology means a director, practically speaking, cannot win with everyone…These first three episodes have been shrewdly tailored to fit Picard’s elder-statesman status, now that he’s a forcibly retired lion in winter, forced by his conscience and sense of duty to take on an authorized, this-time-it’s-personal mission. —Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune

Despite the cameos and Easter eggs, Picard never feels like nostalgia for its own sake. The creative team… have clearly given a lot of thought to the idea of an elderly Picard. —Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone

Thankfully for “Trek” devotees, casual fans and curious subscribers alike, “Picard” is a delight. —Kelly Lawler, USA Today

Regret is a powerful motivator, and Jean-Luc’s list of regrets is nearly as long as his list of accomplishments, but Picard is more opening salvo than it is a requiem for a starship captain. —Danette Chavez, AV Club

Picard isn’t above moments of nostalgia (one scene in particular is packed with Easter eggs) but it also features a firm commitment to moving the franchise forward not just in time, but in what kind of stories Trek is capable of telling. —Liz Shannon Miller, Paste Magazine

“A bold and exciting addition to the franchise, featuring a compelling central mystery that will undoubtedly keep you gripped each week.” —Nicola Austin, We Have a Hulk


DOES PATRICK STEWART DELIVER?

Pictured: Sir Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: James Dimmock/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

It’s a freight train performance from one of our great Shakespearean actors… There are moments you’re not quite sure if it’s Star Trek you’re watching or a high concept take on King Lear. —Ed Power, Daily Telegraph (UK)

It gives me no joy to say this, but: Stewart gave a more interesting performance in 2019’s Charlie’s Angels. —Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

Stewart is as charming and naturally charismatic as ever, but the general level of the performances around him is significantly higher. —Mike Hale, New York Times

[Stewart] has a unique ability to dial into his roles without completely disappearing, carrying the audience’s earned investment from role to role, whether he’s suffering through an awkward trip to the toilet or sipping tea among the stars. —Ben Travers, indieWire

The cast is marvelous, starting with Stewart, the finest actor ever to wear a Starfleet uniform. His aging and conflicted Picard is an endlessly intriguing revival of the character. He not only keeps you involved but also engaged. —Mark Dawidziak, Cleveland Plain Dealer


READ ALSO: Patrick Stewart and the Star Trek: Picard Crew on Why the World Needs Jean-Luc Now More Than Ever


HOW’S THE PRODUCTION OVERALL?

(Photo by Netflix)

Smart, well-crafted, layered – verging on over-layered. —Verne Gay, Newsday

It’s pretty shallow as a dramatic and thematic construct, but it is recognizably contemporary in its preoccupation with diversity and the mistake of excluding those whose traits and faiths are not fully understood. —John Doyle, Globe and Mail

One hopes that this fits-and-starts opener will give way to smoother storytelling to come, now that twenty years of narrative Band-Aids have been yanked off. —Andrew Todd, Birth.Movies.Death.

For their part, the writing team have found the perfect reason for Picard to get back to saving the galaxy. —Richard Edwards, SFX Magazine

Right now, Star Trek: Picard feels like a cadet pretending to be a captain, and only time will tell whether the series can … transform itself into something more exciting. —Andrew Bloom, The Spool

It takes a while to fully gel, and some fans might start to get impatient, but I’m happy to report that Picard does eventually set up an intriguing mission that’s worthy of its lead character. —Dave Nemetz, TV Line


WHAT ABOUT THE PACING?

Pictured: Sir Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: Matt Kennedy/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

If there’s a problem with this gripping first episode it’s that it has to squeeze a lot of exposition into an hour in ways that sometimes threaten to crowd into space that could be devoted to exploring what the events it recounts mean to Picard. —Keith Phipps, New York Magazine/Vulture

But it moves within three hours to a place that promises as much excitement and movement as there already has been insight into its beaten-down protagonist, a show that suggests it’ll be worth sticking around for. —Daniel D’Addario, Variety

The viewers most likely to get impatient are also those most likely to be so happy simply to have Jean-Luc back on their screen that they’re willing to allow the show some indulgence. —Dan Fienberg, Hollywood Reporter

It’s clear right away though that Picard is also about so much more. It’s a TV series with the narrative mindset of a movie, and a Star Trek story that’s committed to shining a light into dark places that we haven’t explored before. —Adam Rosenberg, Mashable

While I wish it didn’t take three full episodes of heavy exposition to get the fabled Next Generation captain, later admiral, into space, the crew of rogue fellow travelers he assembles over the first few weeks is promising. —Matt Roush, TV Insider


FINAL VERDICT?

Pictured: Sir Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard of the CBS All Access series STAR TREK: PICARD. Photo Cr: Trae Patton/CBS ©2019 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(Photo by Netflix)

Does anyone want a bitter and brutal Star Trek, full of murder-sorrow flashbacks, swoopy-kinetic fights, and all-encompassing paranoia? So much of Trek since 2009 strains to resemble the dumbest version of cool. You always sense the hand of some savvy-pitchman producer trying hard to make everything that was once endearingly nerdy look swole as hell. Picard has flashes of eccentricity, and any science-fiction show with a Miguel de Unamuno shoutout demands a quantum of hope. But for now, this is another disappointing Star Trek. Should we give it a chance? My advice: Disengage. —Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly

Anyone with an ounce of romance in them should feel that thrill. —Robert Lloyd, Los Angeles Times

Against all odds Star Trek: Picard has started strong as both a loving tribute to something we once loved, and an artful exploration of something completely new. —Joshua Tyler, Giant Freakin Robot

One of the most highly anticipated new shows of the year… is simultaneously exciting and calmly beautiful, tantalizing and satisfying. —Diana Keng, TV Fanatic

Picard dares audiences to avoid wallowing in despair or nostalgia, and asks them to take action to build a world that’s even better than anyone could have imagined. —Samantha Nelson, Polygon

Adjusted Score: 90.552%
Critics Consensus: Anchored by the incomparable Patrick Stewart, Picard departs from standard Starfleet protocol with a slower, serialized story, but like all great Star Trek it tackles timely themes with grace and makes for an exciting push further into the final frontier.
Synopsis: At the end of the 24th Century, and 14 years after his retirement from Starfleet, Jean-Luc Picard (Sir Patrick Stewart)... [More]

Tag Cloud

IFC Films 2019 diversity ESPN DirecTV Warner Bros. 2017 MCU classics travel Discovery Channel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt reviews Sundance venice versus cars festival Animation Lifetime scary movies Summer San Diego Comic-Con crime drama reboot true crime Pop Writers Guild of America dramedy TNT video concert CBS All Access Freeform RT History stand-up comedy Grammys Funimation SDCC theme song joker cancelled hollywood Superheroes Tomatazos vampires DC Universe Ghostbusters video on demand 24 frames comics 4/20 Tarantino game show robots 20th Century Fox cults Emmy Nominations Tumblr Pet Sematary criterion CMT twilight critics Country OWN Vudu YouTube Red Walt Disney Pictures stop motion LGBTQ Anna Paquin PaleyFest TV Land romance Interview CNN Baby Yoda New York Comic Con Martial Arts Star Trek Peacock spy thriller IFC MSNBC Elton John revenge Comedy Central 72 Emmy Awards Rocketman remakes canceled batman Hear Us Out composers Heroines disaster renewed TV shows nfl Pop TV Spring TV facebook FX on Hulu zombies crossover Toys The Walking Dead Disney Channel Rocky harry potter anthology AMC stoner historical drama slashers Mary Poppins Returns rotten mutant Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comic Book serial killer golden globes mockumentary movies teaser romantic comedy Marvel Television Winners Nominations award winner TIFF TLC football 2016 GIFs CBS BBC One FXX X-Men blaxploitation zombie TV renewals cops war Family SundanceTV Women's History Month VH1 spain anime screenings Photos scorecard latino TCA Winter 2020 universal monsters Awards Super Bowl YouTube toy story child's play cats political drama obituary A24 Superheroe worst movies documentaries Universal Comedy screen actors guild miniseries YA HBO cinemax Set visit Holiday TCA Awards supernatural DGA A&E PBS FOX Schedule Mudbound singing competition movie WGN President Disney Plus SXSW dceu dark adventure green book spanish language Lionsgate ghosts Amazon Studios 2018 Classic Film Premiere Dates sequel Masterpiece Fox News Oscars cancelled television die hard sitcom Crunchyroll TV dogs mission: impossible unscripted Pirates talk show Extras Cartoon Network quibi BET Awards streaming Brie Larson hist Mystery Netflix Christmas movies NYCC Countdown Cosplay space TCA Fantasy comedies 007 ABC Columbia Pictures politics satire technology Western Film Festival Netflix Travel Channel boxoffice Red Carpet Mary Tyler Moore best Music Infographic Polls and Games Horror Trivia Watching Series Television Critics Association Emmys Amazon Prime Video social media Apple TV+ children's TV Year in Review Mindy Kaling sag awards television The Witch El Rey chucky Paramount dc Nat Geo strong female leads doctor who BAFTA all-time biography Captain marvel blockbuster Disney streaming service science fiction Reality Rock cancelled TV series Disney+ Disney Plus Nickelodeon Certified Fresh Character Guide spinoff nbcuniversal Quiz Valentine's Day Winter TV CW Seed USA YouTube Premium casting Bravo BBC America TCA 2017 71st Emmy Awards Sundance TV christmas movies Musical Trophy Talk Arrowverse cartoon toronto spider-man rotten movies we love Ovation DC Comics PlayStation Adult Swim Marvel Marathons 21st Century Fox FX dragons Creative Arts Emmys Turner Turner Classic Movies justice league ABC Family Binge Guide Television Academy Tubi BBC VICE USA Network jamie lee curtis festivals comiccon emmy awards psycho Sci-Fi Trailer natural history breaking bad Food Network Spectrum Originals Crackle NBC aliens richard e. Grant fast and furious See It Skip It period drama Reality Competition indiana jones Amazon Prime 2020 Kids & Family Dark Horse Comics discovery canceled TV shows 2015 45 Britbox laika Black Mirror sequels Lifetime Christmas movies Thanksgiving Christmas ITV witnail DC streaming service Sneak Peek HBO Go documentary Sony Pictures Spike Best and Worst tv talk OneApp Cannes independent Fall TV Rom-Com game of thrones Musicals cooking worst what to watch Academy Awards Song of Ice and Fire Logo docudrama book Hallmark Christmas movies foreign crime Box Office Disney Esquire Endgame TCM Drama comic psychological thriller crime thriller WarnerMedia Shudder National Geographic Hallmark Comics on TV E! Awards Tour The Arrangement nature Ellie Kemper VOD Apple TV Plus name the review First Reviews TBS APB thriller halloween adaptation BET Acorn TV indie parents Teen Chernobyl American Society of Cinematographers The Purge medical drama zero dark thirty Video Games GLAAD binge LGBT MTV Stephen King superhero Biopics Podcast Pride Month First Look Epix kids Syfy E3 sports werewolf news Shondaland Election Amazon TruTV Film south america animated hispanic Marvel Studios Paramount Network cancelled TV shows directors elevated horror ratings Mary poppins finale The CW RT21 History transformers Hulu Showtime Sundance Now series Opinion Action Pixar GoT Black History Month Star Wars Calendar Starz Lucasfilm Apple based on movie franchise Holidays Avengers asian-american free movies HBO Max a nightmare on elm street films police drama