Space Force First Reviews: Steve Carell and John Malkovich Struggle To Make Netflix's New Workplace Comedy Soar

Critics say the leads shine, and the premise has great potential, but the jokes don't always land and the show doesn't quite know what it wants to be.

by | May 26, 2020 | Comments

Space Force marks the highly-anticipated reunion of The Office alums Greg Daniels and Steve Carell. Carell, who co-created the series with Daniels, plays four-star General Mark R. Naird, who leads the newly-minted sixth branch of the U.S. Armed Services — a concept directly inspired by Donald Trump’s very-real announcement to have American boots back on the moon by 2024. John Malkovich’s Dr. Adrian Mallory is Naird’s unlikely partner, offering unwelcome scientific insight during every step of the mission. According to the first reviews of the series, the timely comedy struggles to connect with audiences and many of the jokes fall flat, but the show’s two leads deliver the goods in bringing their characters to life.

Here’s what critics are saying about Season 1 of Space Force:

Steve Carell and John Malkovich have strong comedic chemistry

But where the show really strikes a chord is in the more heartfelt, charming moments – particularly between Carrell’s regimented veteran Naird and Malkovich’s stubborn head scientist Dr. Adrian Mallory. —Nicola Austin, We Have a Hulk

Carell remains likable and charismatic, even if his gravelly voice as Mark sounds a bit forced, and he and Malkovich (underrated for his comedic abilities) have entertaining chemistry. — Josh Bell, CBR

And the show comes to life most when we get to watch Carell and Malkovich go head-to-head as military determination clashes with scientific limitations. — Nola Ojomu, Metro

Together, Carell and Malkovich forge a charismatic pair that could carry even more episodes than they already do, while Malkovich’s Dr. Mallory could certainly stand for more development on his own. — Ben Travers, IndieWire

Carell and Malkovich make a great comedic duo! — Grace Randolph, Beyond the Trailer

Steve Carell in Space Force

(Photo by Aaron Epstein/Netflix)

Carell does his best to distance himself from Michael Scott

Carell is good playing Naird as a straight-laced military man, who rigidly adheres to his principles even when they make him utterly depressed. After a long day on the job, he’s a good dad, who makes time to help his daughter with her math homework.— Jonathan W. Hickman, The Newnan Times-Herald

Mark Naird isn’t exactly Michael Scott 2.0. He has a wife, Maggie (Lisa Kudrow in a part-time role), a teenage daughter, Erin (Diana Silvers), and is more aggressive and confident than Michael ever was. He’s a plausibly orthodox military man; when Maggie complains that he’s too rigid in his thinking, he insists, “I can be flexible if I’m ordered to be.” But the way Naird stalks through most of the episodes as a defiantly ignorant, periodically bigoted a–hole feels unfortunately very reminiscent of that first Office season when Michael was unbearable. — Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone

Carrell plays General Mark R. Naird like a puffed-up, military-issue Michael Scott — complete with earnest love for his workmates and an inability to recognise the error of his ways until it’s too late. —Brian Lloyd,

Unfortunately, the jokes fail to connect 

But it might be easier to listen to than most of the jokes. Space Force is inexplicably unfunny, a black hole for laughter, with stretches of bombs lasting minutes, not just because the gags rarely work, but because there aren’t that many jokes in the first place. It feels like the first draft of a comedy before the jokes were put in. — Tim Surette, TV Guide

The jokes themselves are also scarce, and when they do show up, they can be painfully all over the place. — Sean Price, The Spool

Daniels and Carell have failed to give their series any discernible point of view, delivering instead an innocuous and startlingly unfunny sitcom about military bureaucracy. — Kristen Baldwin, EW

Put a different way, for Space Force to work, Carell and Daniels — as capable a pair of satirists as we have (see The Office) — would need to come with their humorous focus and targets incredibly well honed. Through the first season, despite fitful highlights, that just isn’t there. — Daniel Fienberg, THR

Here’s a comedy for people either desperate for new Office content, or who still find “covfefe” funny. —Blake Goble, Consequence of Sound

Ben Schwartz in Space Force

(Photo by Aaron Epstein/Netflix)

Political satire or surreal comedy — the show struggles to find its tone

At certain points it feels like biting satire, others complete farce. Sometimes the show is super silly and surreal, and other times it feels like a straight comedy. That inconsistent tone makes it so that you never know what you’re watching or what you’ll get from scene to scene, episode to episode. — Michael Walsh, Nerdist

The series, of course, isn’t going to come without having some contemporary references. On the political side, there are clear-as-day references to Senator Chuck Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Ortez. Though for whatever reason, the Schumer-esque character is a congressman rather than a senator. Instead of AOC, we have AYC (Ginger Gonzaga) aka Angry Young Congresswoman.— Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

Admittedly, the parodies are a little too on-the-nose at times, removing the suspension of reality some might expect while they put on a movie or TV series. Even then, that’s something that speaks volumes to the world we live in, rather than to the quality of the programming itself. — Adam Barnhardt, Comic Book

Its pieces of political satire are both too literal (as when a young liberal congresswoman named “Anabela Ysidro-Campos,” played by Ginger Gonzaga, gives Space Force’s hell in a hearing that evokes an SNL cold open) and too dated (Mark’s annoying communications manager, played by Ben Schwartz, is “Tony Scarapiducci,” or more colloquially, “F— Tony” as in “F—Jerry,” I guess?). — Caroline Framke, Variety

The ensemble cast is spectacular

And their team is ensemble gold: Don Lake as Naird’s overly eager-to-please assistant, Jimmy O. Yang (Silicon Valley) as Mallory’s unflappable No. 2 and Ben Schwartz (Parks and Recreation) as the smarmiest of media managers. […] Maybe the best reason to enlist in Space Force: the posthumous performance of Fred Willard in one of his last TV roles as Naird’s lovingly befuddled dad, a grace note for an earnestly amusing show that isn’t afraid to wear its heart on its star-spangled sleeve. — Matt Roush, TV Insider

Ben Schwartz , whom many will remember for his cheeky Jean-Ralphio in Parks and Recreation, is still a comic relief at all times. — Mikel Zorrilla, Espinof

Oh, and every single time the Armed Forces 4-Star Generals meet, you are sure to be giggling in your seat. It is comprised of greats like Jane Lynch and Patrick Warburton and the dry humor is basically a masterpiece. Trust me. Whenever they showed the room, I knew it was about to be a hilarious scene.

I have to mention others like Tawny Newsome, Fred Willard (RIP), and Jimmy O. Yang. Each of them bring their own elements to the show. You know you have a good show on your hands when the supporting characters make you laugh just as hard as the main characters. In fact, Steve Carell almost plays the straight man in this one — almost. — Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Space Force holds an incredible cast, with the likes of Ben Schwartz (now of Sonic the Hedgehog fame) and Lisa Kudrow, and even the late Fred Willard contributing to its star-studded comedic roster. — Andrew Dex, Starburst

Steve Carell and cast in Space Force

(Photo by Aaron Epstein/Netflix)

With a little finessing, Space Force could blossom into something great

This is one show that is easy to binge-watch and should be renewed for a second season at a minimum, if not longer. Netflix and Carrell have another hit on their hands that is enjoyable and entertaining, especially if they keep Malkovich as part of the cast. —Allison Skornick-Rose, Flick Direct

Still, Space Force comes at a time when audiences could use a bit of laughter and self-care. Mostly, the comedy is harmless and skates by on the charm of its ensemble cast (Don Lake deserves a shout-out for playing assistant Brad). Even if it doesn’t quite achieve the astronomical heights suggested by its wacky premise, there’s enough fuel in the tank to help the inaugural season coast on fumes. —Nate Adams, The Only Critic

Space Force maximizes the absurdity, turning this patently terrible situation into one in which laughter comes as a kind of release valve from a huge, churning sea of frustration.
In other words, the series is rather well-suited to the current moment. —Sonia Saraiya, Vanity Fair

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: An all-star cast and blockbuster-worthy special effects aren't enough to keep Space Force's uneven blend of earnestness and satire from spinning quickly out of comedic orbit.

Tag Cloud

IFC Films Fall TV Pet Sematary Trailer game of thrones debate TNT target romantic comedy foreign VOD blaxploitation TBS crime thriller Rom-Com Elton John USA Superheroe 007 scary movies Rock SXSW 45 series toy story miniseries batman PBS Reality Amazon game show teaser Watching Series Toys Mindy Kaling Brie Larson best live action composers Apple TV Plus 73rd Emmy Awards Food Network HBO Oscars Star Trek video on demand aliens Comedy Central Rocketman cancelled television Dark Horse Comics Winners hidden camera anthology dc space ABC Signature social media BBC indie ABC Family The Purge NBA unscripted Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Neflix VICE The Arrangement Spike book adaptation ID hist Nominations Video Games supernatural Quiz cancelled TV series 24 frames SDCC Comic Book BET Interview nbcuniversal high school Broadway french new star wars movies black LGBT universal monsters scorecard Western cops Vudu Grammys TCA 2017 Peacock justice league cars FX on Hulu Amazon Studios police drama FOX rt archives boxing strong female leads black comedy mission: impossible adenture TV franchise ratings deadpool Kids & Family 71st Emmy Awards serial killer El Rey toronto free movies streaming mockumentary revenge GIFs Podcast TIFF Cartoon Network Awards HBO Max Disney+ Disney Plus christmas movies Epix Best and Worst cinemax football Tubi Star Wars History Super Bowl tv talk razzies Box Office quibi dragons festivals AMC Plus Universal Sundance screen actors guild boxoffice YouTube Red Trivia stand-up comedy canceled TV shows Esquire Academy Awards what to watch directors women vampires Pride Month YA Mudbound video harry potter children's TV japan italian werewolf CBS Funimation See It Skip It TCM GoT talk show Comedy Amazon Prime Video spanish Britbox FXX name the review jamie lee curtis Universal Pictures San Diego Comic-Con doctor who period drama TV One APB fresh new york superhero The Walking Dead Columbia Pictures historical drama GLAAD war docuseries latino Freeform award winner Arrowverse feel good olympics adaptation Binge Guide jurassic park Legendary documentary indiana jones golden globe awards RT21 witnail movies Creative Arts Emmys Travel Channel medical drama sopranos Spectrum Originals chucky comedies crime cancelled Anna Paquin dogs 2015 Ovation Tokyo Olympics Masterpiece Character Guide lord of the rings psycho CNN Alien Pixar live event Tarantino godzilla wonder woman Shondaland The Witch 2021 Action concert Discovery Channel CBS All Access satire RT History Spring TV TV renewals worst movies Paramount Schedule Stephen King X-Men TCA Awards archives festival Music Lionsgate international Cosplay Heroines spy thriller transformers The Walt Disney Company 99% DC Comics A&E Film New York Comic Con vs. Winter TV zero dark thirty Instagram Live First Reviews hollywood spanish language 2018 dramedy Mary Tyler Moore Pirates VH1 posters emmy awards WGN anime hispanic heritage month rotten Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ABC suspense E3 Black History Month worst rt labs comic books disaster Disney streaming service Bravo scene in color japanese docudrama genre marvel cinematic universe die hard NBC Infographic twilight BET Awards movie Turner DGA Starz saw sequel adventure OneApp Red Carpet 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Thanksgiving trailers comics Sci-Fi Countdown YouTube National Geographic canceled streaming movies slashers cancelled TV shows Syfy blockbuster 20th Century Fox Tumblr Writers Guild of America Family Sneak Peek Pop TV natural history australia Trophy Talk legend Photos aapi mob zombie versus Lifetime Christmas movies mutant discovery breaking bad TV Land spain Women's History Month IMDb TV kaiju Fox News TCA Winter 2020 Chernobyl Hear Us Out comic Mary Poppins Returns Drama TV movies President Disney Channel science fiction Pop Year in Review Warner Bros. Awards Tour Comics on TV CMT laika dexter Superheroes American Society of Cinematographers Fantasy fast and furious Animation LGBTQ NYCC obituary 72 Emmy Awards screenings crossover king kong 2020 blockbusters crime drama 90s young adult 2016 YouTube Premium rom-coms Disney Netflix Christmas movies A24 dreamworks slasher Emmy Nominations finale cults halloween tv richard e. Grant OWN Nickelodeon dceu Mary poppins joker TCA Ellie Kemper golden globes Nat Geo superman biopic Marvel green book TruTV Holiday scary Hallmark news Marvel Studios spinoff spider-verse Acorn TV Disney Plus BBC America monster movies travel gangster Paramount Plus cartoon Calendar Tomatazos Cannes comic book movies Black Mirror telelvision critics psychological thriller MSNBC critic resources hispanic singing competition Lifetime new zealand reviews 2019 criterion BAFTA Logo Premiere Dates SundanceTV Apple know your critic romance Crackle true crime Television Critics Association Emmys Adult Swim royal family Apple TV+ action-comedy CW Seed Shudder Set visit kids animated AMC DC Universe USA Network MTV halloween The CW Polls and Games prank Lucasfilm Horror E! dark Christmas TLC Showtime Mystery remakes Reality Competition Musicals comiccon Classic Film technology First Look stoner classics Opinion diversity Extras IFC Martial Arts Country Ghostbusters Television Academy zombies Netflix comic book movie Marvel Television Summer Teen Walt Disney Pictures reboot 21st Century Fox Exclusive Video pirates of the caribbean 93rd Oscars renewed TV shows Musical Fox Searchlight Turner Classic Movies popular parents nfl HBO Go child's play 2017 kong Valentine's Day sports james bond Biopics DC streaming service basketball Comic-Con@Home 2021 binge king arthur rt labs critics edition based on movie Film Festival Sundance Now cats cooking art house Hulu 4/20 political drama Crunchyroll sequels FX Amazon Prime robots BBC One mcc venice PlayStation Rocky all-time book Wes Anderson Baby Yoda ITV PaleyFest elevated horror facebook television Captain marvel Sony Pictures south america nature Marathons ghosts theme song MCU Holidays politics Endgame Sundance TV WarnerMedia documentaries Paramount Network sitcom Image Comics Avengers thriller Pacific Islander ESPN Song of Ice and Fire Certified Fresh films spider-man Hallmark Christmas movies heist movie 1990s biography sag awards Election independent stop motion rotten movies we love ViacomCBS The Academy asian-american DirecTV casting marvel comics a nightmare on elm street