Scream Queen Showdown: Who Is the Ultimate Final Girl?

It's Sigourney Weaver vs. Jamie Lee Curtis vs. Neve Campbell vs. Sarah Michelle Gellar as we break down Tomatometer, box office, performance, iconic moments, and more.

by | October 31, 2020 | Comments

In our latest episode of Vs. we’re paying tribute to cinema’s greatest scream queens… by making them battle it out to the final reel! (To be fair, something each of them has some practice in.) It’s slasher icon Jamie Lee Curtis against sci-fi icon Sigourney Weaver against ghostface killer Neve Campbell against fisherman’s not-friend Sarah Michelle Gellar as we seek to crown horror’s ultimate portrayer of the “final girl.” How will the battle play out? Well, first we’re trapping them in a mansion with about 30 escaped-from-a-mental-hospital serial killers… Oh wait, no, not that, that would be illegal. We’re actually comparing their box office performance, Audience and Tomatometer Scores, and the quality of their enemies, and adding a bonus round for good measure. Will it be Ripley, Laurie, Buffy, or Sidney who lives to earn that sweet sequel paycheck? Watch along as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down, then have at us in the comments.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

cats indiana jones name the review Showtime BBC America Avengers casting Oscars Mary Tyler Moore ITV The Witch Emmy Nominations unscripted President children's TV A24 YouTube Red toronto WGN game of thrones PaleyFest Emmys Discovery Channel transformers Music 2020 period drama Watching Series cancelled hist Turner Certified Fresh Endgame Disney Plus Photos ID YouTube Premium Fox News disaster HBO Go Academy Awards USA Network Mary poppins Spring TV japanese Tumblr Lionsgate NBC TruTV Reality Competition award winner Year in Review doctor who Lifetime aliens Peacock Marvel Universal green book The Arrangement slashers Apple Shudder Superheroes Grammys comiccon sag awards true crime dc 20th Century Fox hollywood GoT TV Musical stoner Musicals ratings Apple TV Plus TCA Awards docudrama CW Seed spain Epix YA Cartoon Network richard e. Grant PBS Vudu Awards Tour BET Awards cars Drama south america Fantasy Black History Month kids animated Pop Comics on TV quibi satire Marathons Food Network Star Trek American Society of Cinematographers PlayStation RT History Teen Quiz cops Trophy Talk Hallmark documentaries reviews adventure remakes IFC Films free movies Pet Sematary 2019 Countdown miniseries BBC One serial killer Nickelodeon jamie lee curtis Mudbound criterion war Infographic directors what to watch The Walking Dead werewolf strong female leads Rock comedies Television Academy spinoff Travel Channel FX TCA 2017 video Sony Pictures TCM Disney streaming service space scary movies Sundance halloween tv rt archives renewed TV shows Film venice Star Wars Tomatazos romantic comedy BAFTA Best and Worst Marvel Studios documentary National Geographic Awards deadpool LGBTQ book travel football binge Bravo 2015 Super Bowl Amazon Studios Walt Disney Pictures canceled TV shows San Diego Comic-Con child's play See It Skip It chucky Anna Paquin supernatural Video Games Logo CBS All Access ghosts laika nfl psychological thriller Classic Film cinemax series latino Kids & Family movies superhero Pride Month Hear Us Out Character Guide cancelled TV shows Tarantino zombie asian-american Masterpiece ABC Family comic dramedy Rocketman Comedy Central MCU sequel Syfy festivals LGBT video on demand justice league cancelled television Action Crunchyroll TV Land First Reviews Schedule Thanksgiving Sundance TV franchise Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sneak Peek IFC Holiday Election Sci-Fi Red Carpet CMT Mystery Television Critics Association vampires spider-man Horror ESPN Amazon Prime Video Turner Classic Movies Paramount movie comic books police drama golden globes concert crime thriller TNT historical drama Amazon Heroines Captain marvel Premiere Dates History mutant diversity black TCA critics james bond Brie Larson MSNBC crime 2018 Film Festival DGA Extras Hallmark Christmas movies HBO Funimation AMC sequels television The Purge OWN Interview revenge best Reality witnail Family Paramount Network VOD Superheroe Cosplay political drama dark crossover archives politics game show cults Britbox worst movies Podcast TBS dogs medical drama cartoon halloween Spike films Holidays joker Trailer Opinion boxoffice Lucasfilm CBS Country FOX mockumentary Lifetime Christmas movies mission: impossible The CW Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Starz nbcuniversal Winter TV SundanceTV BET classics DC Universe Arrowverse spy thriller elevated horror SXSW First Look 2016 australia 24 frames universal monsters Binge Guide 45 die hard zombies DC streaming service Disney New York Comic Con screenings obituary sports Marvel Television hispanic Pirates HBO Max Netflix 71st Emmy Awards all-time Calendar dceu Comedy Freeform GIFs blockbuster Dark Horse Comics OneApp YouTube teaser E! BBC comics Rocky DC Comics scorecard stand-up comedy singing competition Martial Arts zero dark thirty VH1 discovery Set visit nature Women's History Month reboot cancelled TV series theme song Disney Channel parents FXX APB Biopics batman romance sitcom Song of Ice and Fire Toys Fox Searchlight anthology rotten movies we love Warner Bros. Stephen King Elton John blaxploitation foreign technology biography thriller GLAAD natural history indie WarnerMedia spanish language Columbia Pictures Pop TV crime drama SDCC Trivia USA Ghostbusters canceled TLC Adult Swim social media 4/20 robots talk show italian 21st Century Fox based on movie Crackle news VICE streaming A&E Valentine's Day adaptation TV renewals breaking bad Disney+ Disney Plus TCA Winter 2020 Sundance Now Ellie Kemper stop motion independent psycho Nominations Acorn TV Creative Arts Emmys science fiction Shondaland Mary Poppins Returns 007 fast and furious TIFF Christmas Ovation El Rey Rom-Com Amazon Prime emmy awards Pixar Summer NYCC 72 Emmy Awards anime christmas movies Apple TV+ harry potter MTV Cannes toy story Spectrum Originals finale DirecTV twilight Fall TV spanish Comic Book 2017 facebook rotten CNN Esquire a nightmare on elm street Hulu Baby Yoda RT21 Writers Guild of America Box Office Tubi french The Academy Mindy Kaling dragons versus ABC Nat Geo screen actors guild Netflix Christmas movies X-Men E3 festival tv talk composers FX on Hulu Chernobyl Black Mirror Winners Polls and Games Western Animation cooking worst