Scream Queen Showdown: Who Is the Ultimate Final Girl?

It's Sigourney Weaver vs. Jamie Lee Curtis vs. Neve Campbell vs. Sarah Michelle Gellar as we break down Tomatometer, box office, performance, iconic moments, and more.

by | October 31, 2020 | Comments

In our latest episode of Vs. we’re paying tribute to cinema’s greatest scream queens… by making them battle it out to the final reel! (To be fair, something each of them has some practice in.) It’s slasher icon Jamie Lee Curtis against sci-fi icon Sigourney Weaver against ghostface killer Neve Campbell against fisherman’s not-friend Sarah Michelle Gellar as we seek to crown horror’s ultimate portrayer of the “final girl.” How will the battle play out? Well, first we’re trapping them in a mansion with about 30 escaped-from-a-mental-hospital serial killers… Oh wait, no, not that, that would be illegal. We’re actually comparing their box office performance, Audience and Tomatometer Scores, and the quality of their enemies, and adding a bonus round for good measure. Will it be Ripley, Laurie, Buffy, or Sidney who lives to earn that sweet sequel paycheck? Watch along as Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis breaks it down, then have at us in the comments.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

MTV TV renewals BBC America PaleyFest ratings TBS Tarantino dogs Netflix Christmas movies HBO Amazon Prime directors black comedy james bond die hard Oscars superman parents saw Writers Guild of America Disney+ Disney Plus critic resources Fantasy adventure AMC revenge mutant lord of the rings target 24 frames TLC San Diego Comic-Con monster movies Crunchyroll werewolf nfl japanese a nightmare on elm street Heroines Marvel nature true crime psychological thriller Vudu Interview emmy awards Pop TV new zealand prank kong king kong Amazon Studios franchise NBC Hear Us Out Song of Ice and Fire BET Opinion TNT book adaptation genre FOX spain Film Festival Emmy Nominations Biopics Amazon movie finale OneApp Spectrum Originals mob Hulu DC Comics comiccon 99% Amazon Prime Video ID fast and furious Ovation award winner streaming movies Showtime concert Paramount Network 72 Emmy Awards Apple TV+ discovery Cartoon Network criterion TCA 2017 spider-verse Star Wars women christmas movies godzilla Schedule child's play Country vs. Disney foreign anthology Black Mirror 1990s Turner Ghostbusters hispanic dragons blockbusters DirecTV GIFs hispanic heritage month live action TV Land mcc satire 2018 biography Animation Lucasfilm Peacock tv talk WGN Sneak Peek Travel Channel comic books Epix game of thrones Reality talk show razzies IMDb TV Mary Tyler Moore NYCC PlayStation comics crime vampires AMC Plus telelvision Creative Arts Emmys President Reality Competition canceled Tokyo Olympics rt labs critics edition 21st Century Fox medical drama Warner Bros. New York Comic Con Sundance Family E3 Ellie Kemper PBS 73rd Emmy Awards sequel Image Comics Set visit Rom-Com thriller YA golden globes supernatural Starz royal family Spring TV Horror See It Skip It E! sequels Super Bowl news Superheroe blaxploitation Disney Channel aapi Pirates Awards nbcuniversal Christmas A&E ABC Signature facebook new york Exclusive Video Paramount Plus Trophy Talk Lionsgate ViacomCBS south america worst movies 2015 Comic-Con@Home 2021 The Witch science fiction elevated horror Acorn TV Crackle heist movie BBC One DGA cancelled TV series The Purge Nickelodeon transformers composers strong female leads spanish docudrama free movies psycho Western singing competition scorecard superhero natural history indiana jones Pop Tomatazos adaptation classics Classic Film Mary Poppins Returns cancelled TV shows Hallmark Christmas movies cooking suspense Cosplay football TV films breaking bad zombies zombie Brie Larson Polls and Games VH1 Extras 2016 king arthur Masterpiece RT21 cults crime drama spider-man GoT 2020 Marvel Studios gangster DC streaming service Musicals stop motion hollywood 20th Century Fox festivals rom-coms TruTV FXX CW Seed The Academy doctor who deadpool justice league ESPN scary movies Tumblr sopranos First Reviews Avengers Teen LGBT Esquire wonder woman international romance richard e. Grant scene in color Infographic slasher Arrowverse Sundance Now Valentine's Day Martial Arts Superheroes MSNBC CMT technology Nominations Alien miniseries Comedy WarnerMedia rotten movies we love archives renewed TV shows Endgame Black History Month independent ABC binge screenings 4/20 DC Universe Premiere Dates Kids & Family sitcom SundanceTV Quiz action-comedy USA Network blockbuster cartoon spy thriller dreamworks Instagram Live GLAAD docuseries cops Funimation Television Academy diversity travel rt archives video on demand Fall TV Video Games BAFTA rotten Rocketman spinoff obituary toronto X-Men Marvel Television television Apple chucky Trailer VICE Thanksgiving legend MCU Sundance TV Captain marvel debate mission: impossible black adenture Food Network Britbox pirates of the caribbean worst serial killer Mystery Best and Worst comedies casting Pacific Islander posters Rocky reviews TCA Winter 2020 Columbia Pictures documentary The CW Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 90s based on movie TCA Awards Wes Anderson Rock 007 TV movies Emmys aliens Shudder sports dark 71st Emmy Awards halloween tv screen actors guild book 93rd Oscars batman Television Critics Association Awards Tour Year in Review venice romantic comedy unscripted First Look CBS All Access slashers IFC game show Chilling Adventures of Sabrina HBO Go Adult Swim teaser Box Office Drama golden globe awards LGBTQ SDCC RT History Film children's TV latino SXSW Lifetime Christmas movies rt labs Bravo Spike best dc TIFF boxoffice indie CBS Summer Women's History Month Star Trek disaster political drama Broadway Grammys cancelled jamie lee curtis OWN italian marvel comics jurassic park canceled TV shows remakes Chernobyl Pixar American Society of Cinematographers History Holidays YouTube VOD comic book movies hidden camera The Walt Disney Company live event Trivia Binge Guide harry potter cancelled television dramedy comic YouTube Red social media Discovery Channel japan HBO Max politics Photos Dark Horse Comics Fox News Action YouTube Premium Election 2021 USA Legendary Syfy hist Neflix anime Baby Yoda Calendar theme song know your critic cinemax kids Mindy Kaling CNN green book Elton John movies olympics Hallmark ABC Family Fox Searchlight FX historical drama reboot Logo critics stand-up comedy Nat Geo Countdown sag awards video Walt Disney Pictures cats Character Guide Comedy Central scary TCM Podcast Disney streaming service 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards stoner universal monsters Comic Book young adult Sony Pictures ghosts Pride Month Toys name the review asian-american Stephen King Watching Series animated Universal Pictures french war dceu art house kaiju TCA halloween 45 APB BBC Tubi Sci-Fi Marathons Freeform Paramount comic book movie witnail Disney Plus popular versus crossover period drama Pet Sematary dexter Winners cars quibi documentaries FX on Hulu IFC Films ITV police drama A24 Netflix Comics on TV streaming marvel cinematic universe all-time Mudbound Turner Classic Movies 2019 boxing Holiday biopic twilight Cannes space Academy Awards Winter TV feel good series The Arrangement 2017 australia fresh trailers National Geographic The Walking Dead Mary poppins high school what to watch mockumentary festival BET Awards Anna Paquin laika Certified Fresh crime thriller Red Carpet Lifetime robots new star wars movies Musical Music Universal joker El Rey toy story TV One spanish language basketball NBA zero dark thirty Shondaland Apple TV Plus