Rudolph at 50: Timeless or Showing His Age?

Four things that hold up (and one that doesn't).

by | December 9, 2014 | Comments

Quick: name something that first aired on TV in 1964 that you still watch on a regular basis and quote in everyday conversation. More likely than not you answered Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, the classic Rankin-Bass stop-motion animated special that celebrates its milestone birthday this year, complete with a snazzy new 50th anniversary Blu-ray. (There must have been something special in the water in 1964, since it’s also the year when A Charlie Brown Christmas first head-shake-danced its way into our hearts.)

Five decades is a long time for any work of pop culture to remain relevant to an audience, and while the annual network TV airing of Rudolph remains a rare mass-audience touchstone in a 500-channel universe, it’s time to dig in and see just how well this Christmas classic has aged.


The Songs

Not counting the title track, of course — that popular hit dates all the way back to 1949, which was already ten years after the character of Rudolph had been created as a holiday advertisement for the Montgomery Ward department store. (Yes, it’s Rudolph’s dark secret: he was born a corporate shill. Better a song and specials built around him than Ronald McDonald, anyway.) Two of the original compositions for the TV special — “Silver and Gold” and “A Holly Jolly Christmas” — have become standards in their own right, while the others (“Jingle Jingle Jingle,” “There’s Always Tomorrow,” “We’re a Couple of Misfits,” “We Are Santa’s Elves”) are hummable enough that you probably have them in your head just by reading this sentence.

VERDICT: Timeless


The Story

It’s a celebration of non-conformity: Rudolph is shunned by friends and family alike because of his glowing red nose, but when he becomes the only hope for Santa to make it through a particularly treacherous Christmas Eve storm, suddenly everyone loves him. Call it acceptance-by-pragmatism if you will, but often the first step for outsiders and minorities toward assimilation into the majority comes from, you’ll pardon the expression, outshining their former tormentors. Rudolph’s acceptance by the popular kids allows Hermey to put aside toymaking to pursue his dreams of dentistry. Both these characters could easily fit into the smash X-Men franchise, where those ahead of the evolutionary curve slowly and painfully find acceptance in the world.

VERDICT: Timeless


The women

Hoo boy — the men get to go on adventures and achieve personal growth, while Clarisse (Rudolph’s most steadfast supporter) and Rudolph’s mother (denied a first name of her own and known only as “Mrs. Donner”) serve the plot only as hostages. And then there’s Mrs. Claus, who has to glad-hand the elves every time her grumpy, short-tempered husband dismisses their musical efforts.

VERDICT: Dated


The animation

Still gorgeous after all these years, a triumph of meticulous stop-motion craftsmanship from an era where you had to do all that stuff by hand and not with computers. Add to the fact that several of the leading characters are furry (or at least hairy) animals or felt-covered Misfit Toys, and the animators’ feat becomes even more impressive.

VERDICT: Timeless


The quotability

Oh, come on: if you’ve never stage-whispered, “Hermey doesn’t like to make toys!” about someone stepping out of their accepted career path, or lamented “No one wants a Charlie-in-the-Box!” or held your nose and bleated, “She thiggs I’bm gcyoot!” upon finding out that someone you find attractive feels likewise, you’re just not trying. (Super-fans will get into the deep cuts, like impersonating the way Yukon Cornelius licks his pick-ax and sighs, “Nothin’.”)

VERDICT: Timeless


So, OK, yes, the women’s roles are fairly diminished (none of the lady elves gets any substantial dialogue, but they’re presented in a fairly cheesecake-y way — by lady-elf standards, at least), but beyond that, Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer remains as watchable and wonderful as it was when LBJ was in the White House. Have a holly jolly Christmas.


Alonso Duralde is the author of the quintessential holiday film guide Have Yourself a Movie Little Christmas. Follow him on Twitter at @aduralde.

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer returns for its 50th anniversary broadcast Tuesday, Dec. 9 at 9:00 pm on CBS. Read reviews here.


More holiday fun on Rotten Tomatoes:

Tag Cloud

Musical Women's History Month Extras MTV travel sports Mary Tyler Moore dramedy FXX History Song of Ice and Fire police drama Black Mirror Creative Arts Emmys Acorn TV Apple Star Wars streaming Rom-Com space 24 frames adaptation historical drama Valentine's Day Sneak Peek Tomatazos DC Universe BBC America blaxploitation The CW Sci-Fi dceu thriller 2017 Animation The Witch Stephen King TruTV Western CBS All Access El Rey Fantasy cults YouTube Red FOX crime Musicals adventure Trivia Pop Music justice league transformers BET award winner what to watch SXSW aliens Marathons Rocky Amazon Elton John romance psycho NYCC E3 boxoffice ABC Family harry potter psychological thriller Winter TV Calendar Spike Bravo TV Heroines Character Guide biography TCA 2017 Hulu Ovation Super Bowl animated politics Comedy Red Carpet Chernobyl Fox News anime Comics on TV Universal television Superheroes zero dark thirty true crime political drama Certified Fresh Film Festival DC streaming service Countdown President Cartoon Network Disney Channel Trailer Walt Disney Pictures ratings Oscars AMC See It Skip It SundanceTV OWN Writers Guild of America Year in Review CBS Ghostbusters teaser 20th Century Fox 21st Century Fox FX PaleyFest TBS Pride Month MCU Awards Tour unscripted Pixar Showtime DC Comics American Society of Cinematographers Emmys Tarantino TNT RT21 Lucasfilm robots singing competition hist crossover Food Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime thriller elevated horror period drama 2019 2018 spinoff Polls and Games Mudbound ABC Holidays spy thriller Shudder Columbia Pictures serial killer Shondaland DirecTV Cosplay witnail BBC mockumentary jamie lee curtis facebook A&E Adult Swim Pirates X-Men Captain marvel Logo Winners dragons golden globes 2016 talk show Mary poppins binge Premiere Dates Election toy story National Geographic Interview Pet Sematary game show finale Sundance Now Vudu SDCC San Diego Comic-Con zombie disaster cinemax Fall TV Lionsgate Epix CNN comic Quiz Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt natural history LGBTQ RT History war Nominations YouTube Premium comiccon TIFF sitcom GLAAD Paramount Network TLC GIFs Mary Poppins Returns Sony Pictures Grammys USA Network DGA Podcast ITV Masterpiece Syfy Reality Competition Star Trek Anna Paquin IFC Films dc Sundance anthology vampires Martial Arts spider-man Nat Geo diversity Mindy Kaling Esquire TCM Infographic Horror Biopics Amazon Prime Cannes Country Warner Bros. Spring TV New York Comic Con Tumblr Schedule casting mutant MSNBC APB composers First Look Awards TV Land sequel ESPN Spectrum Originals Superheroe cooking Freeform Rock 007 GoT E! supernatural Lifetime festivals Summer Opinion Dark Horse Comics Video Games cats Rocketman richard e. Grant Nickelodeon crime drama zombies Crackle Comedy Central discovery Disney Reality Toys Action Christmas IFC Thanksgiving VICE TCA docudrama Ellie Kemper based on movie The Arrangement Watching Series Photos Box Office cops Britbox Best and Worst VH1 medical drama PBS YA Brie Larson strong female leads Set visit Marvel NBC USA Trophy Talk nature Paramount CW Seed WGN 2015 theme song Netflix green book Comic Book 45 Starz miniseries Kids & Family doctor who Mystery HBO Drama Teen science fiction social media CMT technology