Rudolph at 50: Timeless or Showing His Age?

Four things that hold up (and one that doesn't).

by | December 9, 2014 | Comments

Quick: name something that first aired on TV in 1964 that you still watch on a regular basis and quote in everyday conversation. More likely than not you answered Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, the classic Rankin-Bass stop-motion animated special that celebrates its milestone birthday this year, complete with a snazzy new 50th anniversary Blu-ray. (There must have been something special in the water in 1964, since it’s also the year when A Charlie Brown Christmas first head-shake-danced its way into our hearts.)

Five decades is a long time for any work of pop culture to remain relevant to an audience, and while the annual network TV airing of Rudolph remains a rare mass-audience touchstone in a 500-channel universe, it’s time to dig in and see just how well this Christmas classic has aged.


The Songs

Not counting the title track, of course — that popular hit dates all the way back to 1949, which was already ten years after the character of Rudolph had been created as a holiday advertisement for the Montgomery Ward department store. (Yes, it’s Rudolph’s dark secret: he was born a corporate shill. Better a song and specials built around him than Ronald McDonald, anyway.) Two of the original compositions for the TV special — “Silver and Gold” and “A Holly Jolly Christmas” — have become standards in their own right, while the others (“Jingle Jingle Jingle,” “There’s Always Tomorrow,” “We’re a Couple of Misfits,” “We Are Santa’s Elves”) are hummable enough that you probably have them in your head just by reading this sentence.

VERDICT: Timeless


The Story

It’s a celebration of non-conformity: Rudolph is shunned by friends and family alike because of his glowing red nose, but when he becomes the only hope for Santa to make it through a particularly treacherous Christmas Eve storm, suddenly everyone loves him. Call it acceptance-by-pragmatism if you will, but often the first step for outsiders and minorities toward assimilation into the majority comes from, you’ll pardon the expression, outshining their former tormentors. Rudolph’s acceptance by the popular kids allows Hermey to put aside toymaking to pursue his dreams of dentistry. Both these characters could easily fit into the smash X-Men franchise, where those ahead of the evolutionary curve slowly and painfully find acceptance in the world.

VERDICT: Timeless


The women

Hoo boy — the men get to go on adventures and achieve personal growth, while Clarisse (Rudolph’s most steadfast supporter) and Rudolph’s mother (denied a first name of her own and known only as “Mrs. Donner”) serve the plot only as hostages. And then there’s Mrs. Claus, who has to glad-hand the elves every time her grumpy, short-tempered husband dismisses their musical efforts.

VERDICT: Dated


The animation

Still gorgeous after all these years, a triumph of meticulous stop-motion craftsmanship from an era where you had to do all that stuff by hand and not with computers. Add to the fact that several of the leading characters are furry (or at least hairy) animals or felt-covered Misfit Toys, and the animators’ feat becomes even more impressive.

VERDICT: Timeless


The quotability

Oh, come on: if you’ve never stage-whispered, “Hermey doesn’t like to make toys!” about someone stepping out of their accepted career path, or lamented “No one wants a Charlie-in-the-Box!” or held your nose and bleated, “She thiggs I’bm gcyoot!” upon finding out that someone you find attractive feels likewise, you’re just not trying. (Super-fans will get into the deep cuts, like impersonating the way Yukon Cornelius licks his pick-ax and sighs, “Nothin’.”)

VERDICT: Timeless


So, OK, yes, the women’s roles are fairly diminished (none of the lady elves gets any substantial dialogue, but they’re presented in a fairly cheesecake-y way — by lady-elf standards, at least), but beyond that, Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer remains as watchable and wonderful as it was when LBJ was in the White House. Have a holly jolly Christmas.


Alonso Duralde is the author of the quintessential holiday film guide Have Yourself a Movie Little Christmas. Follow him on Twitter at @aduralde.

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer returns for its 50th anniversary broadcast Tuesday, Dec. 9 at 9:00 pm on CBS. Read reviews here.


More holiday fun on Rotten Tomatoes:

Tag Cloud

transformers Disney streaming service Walt Disney Pictures police drama Song of Ice and Fire Tumblr elevated horror TBS diversity IFC Cosplay 2019 Biopics A&E movies Elton John jamie lee curtis zombies E3 Drama anthology Schedule Brie Larson Shudder cats psycho Heroines 21st Century Fox zombie Valentine's Day zero dark thirty Rock ABC WarnerMedia Warner Bros. Apple Set visit Tomatazos Reality Competition 007 Star Trek tv talk Mudbound Musical Fox News Mary poppins TCA 2017 adventure The Witch Nickelodeon politics Lionsgate Pixar YA Video Games historical drama Character Guide President comiccon FOX social media Pop TV Amazon RT21 BBC America stand-up comedy theme song Sci-Fi robots Awards based on movie natural history green book docudrama TLC Shondaland FX Nominations Fall TV binge Creative Arts Emmys National Geographic TCA 2018 Syfy Crackle Interview DirecTV MSNBC unscripted Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Starz VH1 Ovation Britbox Showtime award winner VICE E! science fiction dragons cars The CW PBS Comic Book Quiz Martial Arts nature Reality golden globes ESPN Sneak Peek revenge discovery Podcast Red Carpet History GLAAD Super Bowl singing competition Fantasy biography HBO what to watch Superheroes Women's History Month Freeform teaser Epix MTV Stephen King Netflix Box Office Nat Geo festivals blaxploitation book 2015 witnail TCM Disney Channel Anna Paquin thriller BET LGBT Holidays Country cops spider-man animated Superheroe CBS All Access Calendar Polls and Games Amazon Prime space Adult Swim First Look strong female leads Star Wars FXX facebook Summer CMT Family children's TV RT History Cartoon Network Ellie Kemper X-Men Paramount Network Black Mirror TV Land CBS AMC American Society of Cinematographers SundanceTV romance serial killer disaster Film Festival dramedy Kids & Family Certified Fresh Mary Tyler Moore Western Trivia USA supernatural Animation Toys mockumentary Trailer Mary Poppins Returns Film 2016 Extras Rocky USA Network SDCC justice league Food Network Emmy Nominations Opinion Election TNT Spike Columbia Pictures crime thriller 2017 Universal CNN Captain marvel cinemax Hulu harry potter medical drama Bravo true crime Thanksgiving Trophy Talk vampires Acorn TV Tarantino Music BBC Writers Guild of America political drama Marvel mutant casting talk show cooking cults sports spy thriller Awards Tour NBC Binge Guide doctor who ratings Christmas Amazon Prime Video Comedy WGN Premiere Dates Oscars crossover war The Arrangement Pirates Disney finale 45 crime drama richard e. Grant Cannes travel Teen Comics on TV Grammys television psychological thriller Rom-Com TIFF GoT crime Rocketman ABC Family Winter TV Action Pet Sematary dceu Countdown ghosts technology Dark Horse Comics MCU Esquire LGBTQ TruTV toy story Marathons composers OWN Spectrum Originals series Masterpiece DC Comics DGA hist Lifetime Pride Month spinoff Sony Pictures Best and Worst aliens Sundance Now Musicals dc CW Seed anime Sundance PaleyFest 20th Century Fox Ghostbusters Photos period drama boxoffice DC streaming service Infographic SXSW IFC Films El Rey APB comic YouTube Red Year in Review See It Skip It GIFs Winners Vudu Mystery Chernobyl streaming 24 frames Mindy Kaling sitcom New York Comic Con adaptation ITV Emmys Comedy Central NYCC kids Spring TV Watching Series DC Universe Lucasfilm HBO Max Paramount YouTube Premium Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sequel game show Horror San Diego Comic-Con miniseries quibi Logo