Total Recall

Rank Michael Keaton's 10 Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the American Assassin star.

by | September 13, 2017 | Comments

Over the last few years, Michael Keaton has enjoyed a critical and commercial comeback driven by some excellent and fascinatingly varied work. Of course, for film fans who’ve followed his output since the early ’80s, Keaton’s ability to bring all these characters to life comes as no surprise: from scammers to superheroes and everything in between, he’s built an impressive filmography, and this weekend’s American Assassin gives us the perfect opportunity to take a fond look back. We’ve lined up some of his biggest critical hits, and we’re inviting you to rank your own favorites — it’s time for Total Recall!

1. Spotlight (2015) 97%

(Photo by Open Road Films)

Investigative reporting isn’t typically exciting work, but you’d never know it from watching Spotlight. Director/co-writer Tom McCarthy commanded an imposing ensemble cast for this Best Picture Academy Award winner — including Michael Keaton, Liv Schreiber, Rachel McAdams, Stanley Tucci, and Mark Ruffalo — to tell the sadly fact-based tale of the Boston Globe reporters who fought their way past systemic corruption and indifference to unearth decades of child abuse at the hands of the city’s Catholic priests, all allowed to continue while the church turned a blind eye or actively covered it up. Despite the inherently uncinematic nature of the work, and the fact that most filmgoers knew the end of the story going in, Spotlight proved positively gripping stuff — and a critical and commercial hit that racked up nearly $90 million at the box office on its way to winning Best Picture and Original Screenplay at the Oscars.

Watch Trailer

2. Night Shift (1982) 92%

(Photo by Warner Bros. courtesy of Everett Collection)

Director Ron Howard could have been accused of tempting fate when he elected to direct his Happy Days buddy Henry Winkler in 1982’s Night Shift — a particularly risky move considering that in the movie, Winkler shed his Fonzie cool to play the nebbishy Chuck Lumley, a newly hired morgue attendant who finds himself going against his better judgment to participate in the cockamamie schemes hatched by his fast-talking co-worker Bill Blazejowski (Michael Keaton) and ends up becoming the de facto co-manager of a thoroughly unusual brothel hosted by a free-spirited hooker (Shelley Long). Ralph Malph was nowhere in sight, in other words, but there was plenty of sitting on it going on — and loads of critical praise, including a positive review from Jonathan Rosenbaum of the Chicago Reader, who wrote, “This isn’t as snappily directed or as caustically conceived as the subsequent Risky Business, which has a similar theme, but it’s arguably just as sexy and almost as funny.”

Watch Trailer

3. Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance) (2014) 91%

(Photo by Fox Searchlight Pictures)

Keaton earned a Best Actor Oscar nomination for his work in this technically dazzling Alejandro G. Iñárritu drama, which follows an actor in the midst of a crisis of faith as he makes a last-ditch attempt to salvage his professional dignity by mounting a Raymond Carver stage adaptation. The real-life parallels were interesting — like his character, Keaton was a former big-screen superhero who hadn’t shouldered a feature in some time — but they were far from the most compelling thing about Birdman, which balanced brilliant cinematography against an absorbing narrative brought to life by a talented ensemble of stars. Keaton’s castmates Edward Norton and Emma Stone both joined him on that year’s list of Oscar nominees, but it was his central performance that attracted the most attention; as Rene Rodriguez wrote for the Miami Herald, the film “takes advantage of every facet of Keaton’s talent, from his knack for absurdist comedy to his seemingly effortless ability to tap into graceful profundity without making a big show of it.”

Watch Trailer

4. Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017) 92%

(Photo by Chuck Zlotnick/Sony Pictures Entertainment)

Nearly 20 years after he helped usher in the dawn of our current era of cinematic superheroes, Keaton returned to the comics-inspired fold with Spider-Man: Homecoming, which brought the wall-crawler into a timeshare with the Marvel Cinematic Universe after a pair of Sony-shepherded franchises had run their course. With young Tom Holland thwipping webs and slinging wisecracks as the new Spidey, Keaton got to play bad guy, suiting up as the Vulture — a villain repurposed for the modern age as a blue-collar business owner driven to crime by economic insecurity, with a particular axe to grind against Spider-Man’s pal Tony Stark. Fans had a right to be cynical about the character’s second big-screen reboot, but they — and critics — were almost universally won over by the end result. “This is the Spidey movie we’ve been waiting for,” wrote Newsweek’s Tufayel Ahmed. “It’s also the best Spider-Man movie of the bunch.”

Watch Trailer

5. Much Ado About Nothing (1993) 90%

(Photo by Samuel Goldwyn Films courtesy Everett Collection)

An infectiously fleet-footed comedy about star-crossed lovers and royal deceit, Much Ado About Nothing found director Kenneth Branagh wrangling a typically eclectic roster of stars. On paper, it might have seemed borderline goofy to put Keaton, Keanu Reeves, and Denzel Washington together in a film adaptation of a Shakespeare play, but with Much Ado, Branagh made it work. And while the marquee-friendly cast might have made Shakespeare seem a little sexier to younger filmgoers, Branagh backed up all that glitz with a smart, finely crafted take on the play; as Owen Gleiberman wrote for Entertainment Weekly, the director’s “true achievement” with the movie was that he “found his way to the play’s profound yet populist heart, rediscovering Shakespeare’s vision of romantic fulfillment – celebration with an underlying tug of sadness – for an era that believes itself all too wise to the ways of love.”

Watch Trailer

6. The Paper (1994) 88%

(Photo by Universal courtesy Everett Collection)

Keaton reunited with his Night Shift director Ron Howard for a very different kind of project in 1994: The Paper, an ensemble dramedy about the frantic goings-on behind the scenes during 24 hours in the life of a New York City newspaper. While things have changed drastically for the publishing industry in the years since The Paper’s release, rendering the movie’s backdrop rather quaint, the sharp writing (from brothers David and Stephen Koepp) and rock-solid acting — rounded out by a showy cast that also included Robert Duvall, Glenn Close, Jason Robards, and Marisa Tomei — are timeless. “Howard, after stumbling with Far and Away, is back in form, and perhaps at the top of his game,” enthused Chris Hicks for the Deseret News. “There are times when the sheer size of the film seems enough to throw it off the track, but Howard manages, for the most part, to keep things rolling along in his usual slick, if sometimes obvious fashion.”

Watch Trailer

7. Jackie Brown (1997) 87%

Three years after achieving “young Hollywood genius” status with Pulp Fiction, Quentin Tarantino re-emerged with Jackie Brown, a 154-minute adaptation of the Elmore Leonard novel Rum Punch that served as Tarantino’s homage to ‘70s blaxploitation while resurrecting the career of one of the genre’s biggest stars: Pam Grier. Hitherto known for playing the title role in 1974’s Foxy Brown, Grier returned to the big screen in pretty good company, including Keaton — whose character, ATF agent Ray Nicolette, resurfaced the next year in Out of Sight — Bridget Fonda, Chris Tucker, and Samuel L. Jackson. While it was ultimately a bit of a critical and commercial letdown after the raging success of Pulp Fiction, Jackie still proved a favorite for scribes like Chuck Rudolph of Matinee Magazine, who wrote that it “Achieves the soulful edge lacking from Tarantino’s previous efforts. Forster and Grier’s performances deserve to join the short-list of all-time greats.”

Watch Trailer

8. Mr. Mom (1983) 75%

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

More than 30 years later, Mr. Mom‘s central conceit — that a dad downsized out of his office gig would find himself woefully outmatched as a homemaker — isn’t quite as hilarious as it was in the early ’80s. But it’s still easy to tell why audiences turned out in droves for this hit comedy, which puts Keaton’s Jack Butler through a series of domestic pratfalls when he loses his job and trades places with his wife (Teri Garr) after she returns to the workplace. A film that drew on the manic energy that ran through much of Keaton’s early career while proving he had the chops to handle dramatic roles — and elevate a rather middle-of-the-road screenplay — Mom earned applause from critics like DVDTalk’s Scott Weinberg, who wrote, “Even with Erma Bombeck-style domestic humor like <em>Mr. Mom</em>’s got in spades, Keaton consistently rises above the mawkish material.”

Watch Trailer

9. The Founder (2016) 81%

(Photo by Daniel McFadden/The Weinstein Company)

Keaton’s always excelled at playing hucksters, but some of his most affecting work has a deep melancholic streak that makes it possible for him to believably bring rather unlikable people to life while hanging on to the character’s essential humanity. He was, in other words, the perfect actor to portray McDonald’s mastermind Ray Kroc in The Founder, the 2017 biopic that traced its subject’s meteoric rise from struggling salesman to the (arguably less than benevolent) driving force behind one of the world’s most widely consumed brands. “Without Michael Keaton’s fascinating and slyly ferocious performance as Kroc at its heart, The Founder might still be a biting critique of Kroc in particular and rapacious corporate capitalism in general,” wrote an appreciative Cary Darling for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. “But it wouldn’t be nearly as delicious.”

Watch Trailer

10. Beetlejuice (1988) 85%

One of 1988’s most successful movies, Beetlejuice offers a singularly absurd ghost comedy starring Michael Keaton as the titular “bio-exorcist” that a pair of ghosts (Geena Davis and Alec Baldwin) hire to rid their home of its obnoxious living residents. Bustling with kooky special effects, off-the-wall humor, and Harry Belafonte songs, it racked up almost $75 million in domestic grosses, cementing director Tim Burton’s status as a bankable filmmaker (and laying the groundwork for Burton and Keaton’s Batman in the bargain). More than just a fine early example of Burton’s skewed sensibilities, Beetlejuice remains a thoroughly enjoyable comedy; in the words of eFilmCritic’s Scott Weinberg, it “Coasts by like a rocket, thanks to Keaton’s inspired performance and Burton’s dark-carnival lunacy.”

Watch Trailer

Pages: Prev 1 2

Tag Cloud

Mary Tyler Moore IFC olympics Polls and Games zero dark thirty YouTube Red The Walt Disney Company Country Film video on demand Cosplay binge BET Toys Extras Countdown Nickelodeon Image Comics Elton John Oscars game of thrones space telelvision jurassic park foreign superhero The Witch Epix Tokyo Olympics animated slashers Summer mob batman robots joker VICE comic books popular canceled new zealand Apple Video Games a nightmare on elm street Superheroes critic resources child's play YA independent emmy awards Christmas doctor who Sundance Now Sci-Fi spinoff parents Comic-Con@Home 2021 CW Seed asian-american mockumentary Grammys 73rd Emmy Awards IMDb TV Apple TV Plus Reality sequel japan black comedy debate dogs dark movies Food Network The Academy TBS GIFs IFC Films Esquire hollywood spain japanese football Comic Book HBO rotten movies we love Wes Anderson mission: impossible Horror psycho TCA Awards cancelled TV series australia OneApp E! rt archives Thanksgiving Sneak Peek Baby Yoda 2018 Hallmark TIFF vampires golden globes green book Disney Channel spider-verse suspense Comedy worst movies dreamworks TCM fresh Best and Worst Columbia Pictures DC Universe finale Opinion Hallmark Christmas movies Photos harry potter tv talk Turner Lifetime 93rd Oscars legend BET Awards Mudbound DC streaming service Arrowverse venice TV movies docudrama Ellie Kemper Neflix best Lifetime Christmas movies free movies classics james bond zombies Academy Awards science fiction canceled TV shows Logo FX on Hulu Disney Plus disaster The Purge Quiz NBC blaxploitation Sony Pictures Mystery toronto historical drama saw aliens E3 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards festivals Winners 72 Emmy Awards Creative Arts Emmys Marvel Studios elevated horror CNN Spectrum Originals halloween tv Stephen King Funimation Netflix Christmas movies YouTube Avengers comic book movies Paramount Plus BBC America cinemax USA Network Super Bowl new star wars movies PaleyFest ghosts A24 Holiday name the review Classic Film crime drama scary prank gangster hispanic heritage month SundanceTV quibi stop motion reviews Podcast talk show Song of Ice and Fire sports dexter Spring TV DC Comics Tomatazos HBO Go heist movie Hear Us Out Trailer cancelled Travel Channel RT History Awards Tour Starz police drama universal monsters video Binge Guide Lionsgate romance marvel cinematic universe Emmy Nominations fast and furious wonder woman Broadway hidden camera comic book movie Rom-Com Film Festival werewolf social media travel Ghostbusters docuseries Chilling Adventures of Sabrina action-comedy First Look medical drama Trivia stoner 90s biopic politics 24 frames A&E VOD laika AMC satire Action obituary 1990s Year in Review blockbusters Nat Geo 21st Century Fox biography rotten what to watch worst diversity 007 SDCC dceu Pacific Islander Certified Fresh LGBT Mary poppins anthology CMT Black History Month AMC Plus remakes MSNBC supernatural WGN marvel comics GLAAD indie godzilla discovery Marvel Cartoon Network king kong scene in color monster movies rt labs ratings slasher trailers international documentaries halloween target Alien Paramount crime thriller rom-coms Showtime spy thriller black game show cooking new york YouTube Premium Britbox genre Tarantino USA Election Premiere Dates BBC TV renewals TCA Winter 2020 golden globe awards french crossover nfl critics See It Skip It Character Guide Family Watching Series Amazon Studios History war Kids & Family mcc Awards book adaptation Fantasy San Diego Comic-Con indiana jones award winner El Rey serial killer DirecTV Warner Bros. Instagram Live Sundance TV Walt Disney Pictures NYCC sequels Rocketman hispanic TCA concert Anna Paquin Chernobyl OWN spanish language ID TNT Legendary Rock American Society of Cinematographers singing competition Comedy Central Shondaland National Geographic kong young adult FOX italian Syfy razzies twilight FX adventure Disney+ Disney Plus cartoon streaming movies Peacock 2015 Superheroe Ovation kids Disney aapi Star Trek Box Office comic Teen hist renewed TV shows live action die hard Apple TV+ Tubi Biopics vs. Musicals Music superman cats films strong female leads comedies comics Martial Arts political drama 2017 screen actors guild series Endgame women 45 Black Mirror ITV Fox Searchlight APB Amazon scorecard justice league 2020 4/20 RT21 boxoffice Lucasfilm Heroines Marathons kaiju Crunchyroll zombie VH1 franchise rt labs critics edition royal family TruTV deadpool spider-man Discovery Channel President Trophy Talk SXSW screenings DGA cars Emmys cancelled TV shows spanish PlayStation casting Pop Freeform Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Amazon Prime streaming adenture sitcom basketball Fall TV posters TV scary movies king arthur Adult Swim 20th Century Fox ABC Signature dc Mindy Kaling Women's History Month WarnerMedia revenge technology Red Carpet stand-up comedy art house all-time The CW Captain marvel Shudder Television Critics Association Valentine's Day richard e. Grant Comics on TV festival unscripted Interview TV One Pet Sematary The Arrangement nature ABC Western Spike boxing BAFTA sopranos criterion true crime lord of the rings First Reviews archives Sundance jamie lee curtis documentary facebook transformers Set visit MCU X-Men Calendar cancelled television Vudu sag awards Netflix Musical based on movie blockbuster Infographic versus teaser pirates of the caribbean Star Wars Pride Month Amazon Prime Video Paramount Network ESPN theme song Holidays Brie Larson Fox News miniseries Disney streaming service Marvel Television Pirates news witnail 99% Universal Pictures GoT Bravo dragons Television Academy know your critic CBS All Access Rocky cults television MTV 2019 LGBTQ Tumblr Mary Poppins Returns reboot thriller romantic comedy period drama Pop TV Winter TV children's TV cops Crackle movie PBS breaking bad FXX Reality Competition anime feel good Turner Classic Movies ABC Family toy story Writers Guild of America CBS Hulu HBO Max TV Land book latino natural history TLC TCA 2017 Pixar nbcuniversal adaptation Cannes 2016 71st Emmy Awards Drama south america high school The Walking Dead Acorn TV mutant 2021 comiccon christmas movies Masterpiece Exclusive Video chucky Nominations psychological thriller NBA composers dramedy crime Universal Dark Horse Comics live event Schedule BBC One New York Comic Con Animation ViacomCBS directors