The Zeros

Objection Sustained: Jury Duty Deserves Its Zero Percent Tomatometer

In a career defined by underwhelming comedies fueled by lowbrow humor, this might be the worst.

by | May 8, 2018 | Comments

Behind the Zero

(Photo by TriStar Pictures)

Let’s be brutally honest here. As a rule, film critics are not, and have never been, big fans of the comedian and actor Pauly Shore. When they rattle off lists of their favorite films, Shore’s vehicles seldom make the cut, and it’s rare to meet a film critic who counts Shore among their favorite actors or “Weez the juice!” among their favorite cinematic catchphrases.

Shore’s name goes unspoken at Cannes and Sundance each year, but during the 1990s, he triumphed ironically at the Razzies no less than four times, including a win for Worst New Star of the Decade. That’s an entire decade. Critics tend to view Shore’s mere existence as a personal affront only compounded by his central and confounding presence in a number of theatrically released films from the 1990s.

Most of Shore’s movies have bombed with audiences as well, but some of them have fared worse than others, particularly 1995’s Jury Duty, which scored the infamous Zero here at Rotten Tomatoes. How toxic was Jury Duty‘s critical response? Bio-Dome, which earned a mere 5% higher on the Tomatometer, was practically a critical favorite by comparison, and that movie’s reputation fluctuates between “So bad it’s good” and “So bad it’s excruciatingly, almost unbearably awful.”

Both Jury Duty and Bio-Dome asked audiences to imagine how it would feel to be stuck in an enclosed space for an extended period of time with an even more stupid and annoying version of the real Pauly Shore. Wouldn’t that just be a laugh and a half? It was a proposition audiences found easy to resist, and thanks to the reception of Jury Duty and its ilk, film critics wouldn’t have Shore to kick around for much longer. He was on his way out as a movie star, but he saved some of his most egregious insults for last, and Jury Duty and Bio-Dome are the worst of a very sorry lot.

The Zero

(Photo by TriStar Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

O.J. Simpson’s “Trial of the Century” murder case briefly sparked a flurry of interest in our legal system and ignited a mini-wave of terrible, terrible comedy featuring such totally 1990s aberrations as Jay Leno’s The Dancing Itos, the tragicomic existence of Kato Kaelin, and John Fortenberry‘s 1995 dark comedy Jury Duty, which routinely returns to the sad well of O.J. Simpson murder trial-based comedy over the course of its endless yet montage-filled 88 minutes. It also includes an ending that features Pauly Shore yelling random O.J.-themed nonsense, seemingly out of character.

A singularly irritating Shore stars as Tommy Collins, an aimless loser so pathetic that the prospect of making five dollars a day and staying in a dumpy hotel for jury duty strikes him as a kick-ass open-ended vacation. He’s first introduced stripping as the Cream Machine, whose dairy-themed performance, during which he rubs cottage cheese all over his be-thonged buttocks, sets the art of erotic dance back decades, if not centuries, and acquaints the audience with an unusually loathsome anti-hero in a uniquely unattractive and unappealing light. 

Even if you enjoyed the classic Chris Farley Chippendales sketch, you’ll be particularly insulted and disgusted by this movie’s piss-poor imitation. It turns out Tommy only landed the gig because his Uncle Sal (Andrew Dice Clay) is the manager of the strip club. It’s rare for one family to possess so much raw talent.

Tommy can’t make it as an adult entertainer for reasons that are instantly apparent, but he thinks he’s lucked into a satisfying long-term grift when he discovers that jurors on big, high-profile murder trials, like O.J.’s, can stay in fancy hotels for as long as the jury is still deliberating. With that in mind, he earns a spot on the jury for the trial of accused serial killer Carl Wayne Bishop, who’s seemingly guilty by virtue of his name and the fact that he’s played by crazy-eyed character actor Sean Whalen, who specializes in playing lunatics, most notably as one of It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia‘s viscerally disturbing McPoyle brothers.

For a particularly regrettable Pauly Shore vehicle, Jury Duty wastes an astonishing array of talent. Our boorish anti-hero’s jury includes a slumming Stanley Tucci as a simpering tree-hugger with a dark secret (setting the tone for a career where the answer was always “Yes!”, no matter the role), the great character actor Brian Doyle-Murray (sporting a distractingly pompadour-shaped black toupee), 1980s independent film icon Richard Edson, and Billie Bird in her final film performance, not to mention Shelley Winters as Tommy’s trailer park-dwelling mother, the terrific tough guy character actor Charles Napier as her boyfriend, and Abe Vigoda as a perpetually and justifiably apoplectic judge.

(Photo by TriStar Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

In keeping with the totally 1990s vibe, Shore’s love interest and fellow juror is played by the Wayne’s World series’ Tia Carrere. Carrere is called upon to seem enraged by Shore and eager to wring his throat when, for example, she discovers (long after the audience does) that Tommy has been artificially postponing the outcome of the trial and keeping an extremely pregnant woman from being with her family, all so he can stay in a cushy hotel suite he secured by illegally and unethically promoting a nearby business. This comes incredibly easy to Carrere.

But she is also called upon to be impressed and even turned on by Tommy when he makes his astonishing transformation from entitled creep to unlikely hero, paying homage to Henry Fonda in 12 Angry Men (which the movie has the gall to reference) and taking a lonely stand on behalf of a defendant every one else thinks is guilty. This comes a lot less naturally to Carrere.

Jury Duty takes a deeply pointless and comedy-killing turn for the serious in its third act as our obnoxious, eminently punchable protagonist comes to realize that maybe he shouldn’t be screwing over everyone he meets for the sake of living a slightly less pathetic life on the government’s dime for a couple of months.

The people behind Jury Duty really seemed to have challenged themselves to make Pauly Shore as unappealing a protagonist as possible, which is not something you ever want to do. If you’re making a Pauly Shore vehicle, you have to assume that a lot of your audience is going to hate him going in, just because of who he is as an actor and personality, and work against that instinct.

Unfortunately, Jury Duty does the opposite, doubling down and all but taunting the audience. “Oh, you think you’ve been irritated by Pauly Shore before? You’ve seen nothing! He’s such a garbage monster here that you’re going to want to reach through the screen and murder him yourself!”

It isn’t comedy to faithfully recreate the feeling of being sequestered with Pauly Shore with seemingly no reprieve while he controls things furtively for his own selfish self-interest. It’s torture porn. It’s no wonder audiences reacted to it with a level of dread akin to receiving a jury summons. Thankfully, seeing Jury Duty was a grim chore that everyone except Shore’s old nemeses — the film critics of the world — were able to avoid.

Devil’s Advocate (A.K.A. Did Anyone Like It?)

(Photo by TriStar Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

From IMDb:


Pretty good comedy

frenzalrhomb_255, September 7, 2004

Well if you’re not a Pauly Shore fan, skip this one, but if in facts, you appear to like him, this one might please you. I’m not very picky when it comes to movies, but I’d say this one was not bad at all. Lots funny parts and stuff, maybe you would like to rent it first though, but well worth the money!.

Pauly Shore is of course a like it or not, the way he tries to sound annoying might offend you, but like I said earlier, I don’t really care about it, as long as its funny!

Too bad he stopped making movies!

I give it an 8!

Final Verdict

(Photo by TriStar Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

True, Jury Duty feels like torture, and also like being stuck in purgatory with Pauly Shore, yet it’s nevertheless the least painful movie I’ve seen for this column, although that mostly speaks to the low, low quality of the barely-movies I’ve covered. Maybe it’s just because, at 88 minutes, Jury Duty is over a half hour shorter than The Ridiculous 6, but unlike every other movie I’ve screened for The Zeros, it isn’t completely worthless.

Jury Duty brought me to the brink of mild amusement several times, and nostalgia and the supporting cast alone would seem to raise this bad boy’s score to a two or even a three. That might be pathetic in any other context, but it represents a veritable triumph here at The Zeros, where the movies very much live up to the column’s title.

Nathan Rabin is a freelance writer, columnist, the first head writer of The A.V. Club and the author of four books, most recently Weird Al: The Book (with “Weird Al” Yankovic) and You Don’t Know Me But You Don’t Like Me. Follow Nathan on Twitter: @NathanRabin

Tag Cloud

Amazon Prime Video Brie Larson 24 frames cooking festivals YouTube Red Star Trek MTV cancelled TV shows Pixar BBC The Walking Dead DC Comics binge Oscars Lifetime Christmas movies FX cancelled television TV renewals indie Pirates south america IFC canceled mockumentary Lifetime justice league Valentine's Day Epix TCM book Food Network Music romance Tomatazos OneApp Teen DC Universe A&E Emmys Reality Competition President dramedy Marathons Disney streaming service renewed TV shows children's TV National Geographic ESPN LGBTQ Marvel Grammys Television Academy CMT rotten movies we love TV Election sports slashers Warner Bros. Martial Arts television NYCC X-Men Vudu Anna Paquin MSNBC Rocky ghosts ABC Family natural history Rom-Com batman based on movie Certified Fresh video TruTV Awards Dark Horse Comics robots SundanceTV 2019 Lionsgate Syfy cops VH1 Character Guide History WarnerMedia Writers Guild of America Elton John ratings anthology Tumblr singing competition Spring TV DC streaming service Apple TV Plus FXX werewolf Comics on TV diversity cancelled TV series Marvel Television facebook political drama Comedy Mystery award winner movies doctor who blaxploitation Reality Sundance spinoff nature Rocketman harry potter Disney Plus unscripted Watching Series Spectrum Originals 71st Emmy Awards comics Nat Geo Christmas The Witch Holidays spain Film Festival Heroines Pride Month Video Games crossover true crime strong female leads Disney+ Disney Plus GoT Cosplay golden globes Interview GLAAD Musicals Comic Book A24 richard e. Grant Calendar series AMC Film TBS Peacock Trailer Esquire Sci-Fi Turner Classic Movies Freeform BET First Look versus spy thriller Bravo psychological thriller Black Mirror Pop Sundance TV Superheroes aliens Podcast Masterpiece 45 name the review latino Shudder teaser VICE Year in Review Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Cartoon Network vampires Fox News Apple anime Superheroe Set visit Logo CBS Fall TV Adult Swim period drama Classic Film kids Netflix Quiz The Purge psycho Netflix Christmas movies streaming Marvel Studios breaking bad Song of Ice and Fire 21st Century Fox Photos 20th Century Fox discovery HBO Max Avengers animated San Diego Comic-Con joker Biopics talk show WGN Polls and Games 2020 CW Seed Amazon Prime DirecTV Ghostbusters zombies American Society of Cinematographers Ellie Kemper Sundance Now Nominations GIFs CNN Action Captain marvel 2018 sitcom adaptation OWN Summer First Reviews Rock Shondaland miniseries Drama Opinion E3 Hallmark documentary El Rey Red Carpet The CW Comedy Central Paramount mutant Sneak Peek Mary Poppins Returns YouTube Premium cancelled composers See It Skip It biography crime Tarantino Baby Yoda Hulu PBS Crackle Universal IFC Films historical drama Premiere Dates PaleyFest technology space jamie lee curtis Thanksgiving Disney Box Office elevated horror science fiction Britbox Animation Best and Worst cartoon USA Network Trivia Chernobyl Tubi Musical Trophy Talk toy story TIFF crime thriller RT21 CBS All Access Walt Disney Pictures canceled TV shows witnail what to watch The Arrangement cinemax war Starz HBO Sony Pictures New York Comic Con Pet Sematary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt boxoffice comiccon ABC APB independent Turner Paramount Network medical drama Disney Channel cults Mary poppins free movies MCU dragons casting docudrama Cannes Schedule sag awards green book Family ITV Binge Guide Winter TV travel cats Apple TV+ Super Bowl Horror supernatural Mary Tyler Moore Infographic zero dark thirty SXSW Toys christmas movies spanish language adventure Women's History Month Arrowverse Ovation TCA Hallmark Christmas movies Crunchyroll DGA Amazon transformers TNT Lucasfilm hist RT History spider-man social media YA Emmy Nominations directors Stephen King Creative Arts Emmys Endgame dceu Mindy Kaling hispanic tv talk Academy Awards Awards Tour Fantasy TCA Winter 2020 sequel Extras TCA 2017 quibi foreign stand-up comedy romantic comedy Countdown Mudbound politics Western police drama 2016 Acorn TV zombie blockbuster Nickelodeon NBC screenings cars comic USA Columbia Pictures TLC SDCC Holiday E! Winners FOX theme song finale crime drama thriller serial killer halloween reboot game of thrones Showtime Spike YouTube 2015 Star Wars Kids & Family Discovery Channel dc 2017 screen actors guild TV Land LGBT disaster 007 BBC America Country revenge game show