Five Favorite Films

Melanie Lynskey's Five Favorite Films

by | February 17, 2017 | Comments

(Photo by Tommaso Boddi/Getty Images for IMDb)

This weekend, New Zealand actress Melanie Lynskey stars in XX, a unique horror anthology film comprised of shorts written and directed by exceptionally talented women (Annie Clark, Roxanne Benjamin, Karyn Kusama, and Jovanka Vuckovic, with awesomely weird animated interstitials by Sofia Carrillo). Lynskey’s credits include Heavenly Creatures, Togetherness, Two and a Half Men, Coyote Ugly, and Detroit Rock City, just to name a few, and she took some time to chat with RT about her own favorites. With that in mind, here are Melanie Lynskey’s Five Favorite Films:

Naked (1993) 88%

I guess the first one would be the Mike Leigh movie, Naked. The performances in the movie are so great. David Thewlis — it’s just one of the greatest performances I’ve ever seen. And the movie — they improvised to find a script. They improvised for months and months, and then Mike Leigh writes a script based on the improv, and you can tell that it’s come from such a pure place, because it’s natural for all the actors, but it’s also just the — walking around London, and it’s just incredible. And also, my favorite actress of all time is Katrin Cartlidge, and she’s in that movie. She’s ridiculous in it, she’s so good.

Wet Hot American Summer (2001) 38%

Possibly the next one would be Wet Hot American Summer. It’s probably a movie I’ve seen more than the other one. And it’s funny. The cast is insane. There’s so many great people and they’re all at their absolute funniest. There’s so many moments of absurdity that really get me; they just make me giggle so much. It’s so, so, so funny. I’ve watched it a million times.

I take it you’ve watched the show also?

Yes, and I actually just did a little part on the show, and — oh my God. I said to my fiance when I came home — you know when you see actors being interviewed there in the new Star Wars movie, and they’re like, “I can’t believe I got to be a part of this world that I’ve loved for so long?” And I was like, “This is like me doing Star Wars.”

The Piano (1993) 90%

Would be in the top five. Because I’m from New Zealand, and the movie was very impactful when I saw it. It was so incredible to see a story about the beginnings of my country of New Zealand. Well, not the beginnings, because there were indigenous people there, but when the settlers came, it’s just such an interesting story to see. And also, it was all filmed around where I grew up, and I’ve never seen a movie that was filmed in the part of the world that I grew up in. And Jane Campion is one of my favorite filmmakers.

The Piano Teacher (La Pianiste) (2001) 73%

It’s a very, very intense movie. Isabelle Huppert, I think, is the greatest living actress. She goes on such a crazy journey in this movie. It’s an incredible performance, and it’s just an impeccably made movie. It’s a perfect movie. You haven’t seen it? Oh, you need to watch it. It’s so intense and so disturbing. Nobody does that kind of glowing sense of dread like Michael Haneke, where you just feel it coming and you’re like, “Oh god, oh my god, what’s going to happen?” I think he’s such a master.

I was at a party one time with a friend of mine and I said, “Oh my God, it’s Michael Haneke!” And she was like, “How do you know?” I was really starstruck to see him — like, “How do you know what he looks like?”

Did you talk to him?

I did. I went up and I just said, “You are one of my favorite filmmakers,” and he said, “Thank you, thank you.” He was very nice.

You like disturbing things, I think.

I do like disturbing things. Even Wet Hot American Summer is pretty disturbing.

Selma (2014) 99%

It’s a pretty recent movie but Selma, the Ava DuVernay movie from a couple of years ago. I just can’t remember seeing a movie and it being so clear to me that it was a masterpiece. I mean, I felt similarly about Moonlight this year — I was just like, “Oh, it’s incredible.” But usually movies take a minute to settle with me, and as I was watching Selma I just was like, “This is a masterpiece. This is an incredible movie.” The story is so powerful and the performances are incredible. And it’s made with such clarity and such passion. I think she’s one of the great film makers.


Kerr Lordygan for Rotten Tomatoes: How did you get involved with XX?

Melanie Lynskey: I know Annie [Clark,”The Birthday Party” segment director] a little bit socially, and she sent me an email one day and said, “I’ve written a short film.” I didn’t really know what it was for, but she said, “Do you want to do it?” And I read it and I thought it was so odd and so cool, and I like her so much, so I just said, “Yeah, let’s do it,” and it was really, really fun.

RT: It looked fun. How long did it take you to do that short?

Lynskey: Three days.

RT: And you have to play opposite a corpse, which is probably challenging.

Lynskey: Yeah, but he was a stunt man, so he was very good at carrying some of his own weight so I wasn’t dragging — because it actually would not be possible to drag a body — like, he was dragging it. It wouldn’t be possible, so it was really nice that he was helping me.

RT: But it added to the weird factor.

Lynskey: Yeah, it’s very weird. It’s so weird.

RT: The very ending of “The Birthday Party” is funny. What’s your takeaway of this short, where it came from, and why it’s in XX?

Lynskey: I honestly don’t know where it came from, but to me, the horror in it — because it’s not a traditional horror movie, but it just felt like the pressure that women feel to hold everything together, even in the craziest circumstances. That, to me, felt like where the true horror came from. Because she’s not acting rationally in that situation. Why would you carry on with a birthday party that she just feels such a pressure to get it right? And it’s just so funny to me that she’s trying to do everything perfectly, and she’s going around straightening everything, but she never gets out of her nightgown.

RT: And it is scary. Neighbors are scary, parents are scary, and being a parent is scary.

Lynskey: Yeah, all that stuff is very scary.

RT: And that’s why is so interesting that it’s in a horror anthology; I thought that was really interesting. I’ve never seen something like that before.

Lynskey: Yeah, it was very original. I was really excited when I read it. Also, Annie [also known as singer/songwriter St. Vincent] is such a creative genius, and she has so much play, and her own costumes and style. And there’s so much comedy in her music — and so much drama — and I just feel really proud of her that she was able to translate that into a completely different medium. It also made me have full confidence that she would be able to.

RT: I see elements of music video production in it, but that’s part of why it’s scary. It’s very brightly lit. It’s like every day. That’s what’s so creepy about it.

Lynskey: Yeah, and also at the end of the movie, she was doing an homage to that crazy music video for “Black Hole Sun” which is so terrifying.

RT: What else can we look forward to from you? I know you mentioned Wet Hot American Summer.

Lynskey: Oh yes, that was really fun, but I just have a tiny little part. I have a movie coming out on Netflix on February 24th, that I really love a lot, called I Don’t Feel At Home in This World Anymore.


XX is now open in limited release.

Tag Cloud

vampires Lucasfilm Netflix romantic comedy true crime Mary Tyler Moore Music 2021 aapi Netflix Christmas movies criterion PBS Vudu remakes science fiction Mary poppins Certified Fresh boxing Television Academy new star wars movies NBA 2018 anthology concert Tokyo Olympics discovery breaking bad DC streaming service comics crime drama BET Awards cancelled jamie lee curtis live action french Election spider-man children's TV Year in Review Sony Pictures Cosplay documentaries Set visit 90s Hallmark Christmas movies USA south america TV Land doctor who travel high school 2020 Mindy Kaling Oscars Acorn TV Rocketman venice Television Critics Association Pop 2019 Arrowverse Country italian YouTube Premium hispanic Premiere Dates worst movies comedies OneApp olympics spinoff unscripted 2015 Song of Ice and Fire docudrama blockbusters stand-up comedy Interview boxoffice mockumentary Pet Sematary basketball Sundance OWN know your critic Best and Worst television Mudbound dogs Disney streaming service Writers Guild of America BBC America documentary TCA Awards TCA Winter 2020 TBS The Walt Disney Company joker CBS All Access japan Stephen King reviews Amazon CMT Brie Larson San Diego Comic-Con Mary Poppins Returns heist movie Kids & Family Fox Searchlight Fall TV batman PlayStation disaster GLAAD teaser game show mission: impossible streaming movies saw natural history nfl Watching Series HBO Go Elton John Pirates NYCC FX on Hulu comiccon Exclusive Video screenings singing competition Sci-Fi Hear Us Out Black History Month Marvel Television Comics on TV VOD SXSW Lifetime Christmas movies Dark Horse Comics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pixar Captain marvel toronto Chilling Adventures of Sabrina thriller biography WarnerMedia animated 2016 spanish language Winners Turner spanish Super Bowl VICE Cannes golden globes space The Academy TLC IFC Films die hard GoT Trivia king kong composers The CW Infographic Fantasy Summer YouTube Red BAFTA Marvel sitcom Calendar diversity Disney elevated horror FXX dc VH1 Women's History Month Teen Drama rt archives chucky talk show Cartoon Network docuseries cancelled TV series reboot Christmas franchise new zealand Toys Britbox TCA Adult Swim Musicals Nickelodeon dramedy stop motion fresh MCU Tumblr Paramount Plus MSNBC marvel cinematic universe ratings child's play politics asian-american Creative Arts Emmys best ABC Family Thanksgiving revenge Chernobyl IFC Awards Tour kong casting Martial Arts medical drama Showtime Shondaland ViacomCBS screen actors guild Avengers Holiday spain Lifetime superman Comic Book Rock Amazon Prime Video werewolf Ellie Kemper Apple TV+ zombies Tubi monster movies serial killer Family robots Endgame El Rey trailers Valentine's Day rom-coms Alien Syfy MTV Disney Plus renewed TV shows crime thriller kids Reality cats sports nature FOX kaiju foreign Superheroe book adaptation australia Comedy Amazon Prime TNT Peacock new york Walt Disney Pictures Trophy Talk Pride Month twilight based on movie Nat Geo cancelled television Black Mirror Apple TV Plus Comic-Con@Home 2021 Binge Guide prank Tarantino 1990s adventure justice league 71st Emmy Awards 2017 NBC Discovery Channel razzies crime classics hollywood finale sag awards harry potter TruTV TCM Film Festival Heroines Food Network dragons PaleyFest CW Seed Red Carpet E! Reality Competition RT History Universal hidden camera 007 X-Men Pacific Islander news Animation obituary game of thrones E3 Musical American Society of Cinematographers video on demand FX Columbia Pictures Photos Shudder rotten movie historical drama DC Comics cults legend rotten movies we love Box Office Sundance Now Ghostbusters The Purge Turner Classic Movies Warner Bros. 72 Emmy Awards free movies miniseries YA james bond jurassic park name the review Star Trek A24 crossover scary movies theme song TV movies parents The Witch deadpool worst satire godzilla Crunchyroll Action canceled History cancelled TV shows Paramount TCA 2017 Quiz pirates of the caribbean mutant DirecTV Marathons Lionsgate HBO Mystery Awards social media Amazon Studios BBC golden globe awards Classic Film Fox News Biopics Superheroes Baby Yoda toy story political drama RT21 The Walking Dead Polls and Games Podcast 20th Century Fox strong female leads 4/20 Crackle BET zombie WGN independent archives Spike quibi A&E Hallmark Winter TV The Arrangement GIFs Emmys halloween tv 21st Century Fox Starz ID 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Image Comics TV One a nightmare on elm street Emmy Nominations adaptation Pop TV psycho See It Skip It blockbuster LGBT DGA CNN ABC Freeform war green book Esquire APB Academy Awards USA Network Spring TV 24 frames Film canceled TV shows Rocky CBS police drama Star Wars Sneak Peek telelvision HBO Max New York Comic Con SDCC hist scene in color japanese 45 aliens Western black zero dark thirty Legendary Epix nbcuniversal Marvel Studios AMC dceu 93rd Oscars Trailer Hulu Comedy Central award winner sequel TV superhero Sundance TV technology Extras dark YouTube lord of the rings Disney+ Disney Plus Holidays cartoon BBC One TV renewals 99% international football streaming video cops ESPN tv talk Masterpiece Spectrum Originals Wes Anderson witnail Ovation psychological thriller women Schedule TIFF festival Logo Tomatazos book movies cars sequels Horror halloween fast and furious First Reviews anime what to watch Bravo DC Universe Anna Paquin Grammys Disney Channel emmy awards versus binge Video Games Countdown popular spy thriller First Look indie SundanceTV cinemax slashers Apple ABC Signature blaxploitation romance richard e. Grant cooking comic books critics universal monsters Broadway comic President Paramount Network transformers facebook indiana jones Opinion LGBTQ festivals supernatural films period drama laika all-time ITV Nominations Rom-Com suspense scorecard christmas movies ghosts series adenture Funimation latino stoner target directors National Geographic Travel Channel Character Guide