Marvel Movie Madness! Part 28: Daredevil

A daring proposition.

by | July 12, 2011 | Comments

Enter Marvel Movie Madness, wherein Rotten Tomatoes watches all of the significant Marvel movies ever made. Full Marvel Movie Madness list here. Tune in! We give you our thoughts, and you give us yours.

[rtimage]siteImageId=10244607[/rtimage]

Part 28: Daredevil (2003, 45% @ 211 reviews)

Directed by Mark Steven Johnson, starring Ben Affleck, Colin Farrell, Jennifer Garner, Michael Clarke Duncan

Tim: Why on earth does this movie have such a lousy reputation? The mind boggles. Daredevil is a second-tier movie about a second-tier Marvel character, and so it follows that it lacks the operatic grandeur, emotional complexity, and mind-bending special effects of the Spider-Man and X-Men movies. Therefore, taken on its own modest merits, Daredevil delivers. The backstory is generic as all get-out (kid loses dad to bad guys, gains super skills, resolves to wage a one-man war on crime), but there’s a nice twist here: Daredevil is blind, and his other four senses are extraordinarily heightened. It’s nice to have a hero who turns a physical handicap to his advantage (and the visual effects artists deserve props for depicting Daredevil’s amplified perceptions). It’s also refreshing to have a character who’s a semi-regular churchgoer; even though there are plenty of folks in the Marvel universe who are allegorical Christ figures, I’m glad one of these films makes room for some actual religion when its hero explores (albeit not terribly deeply) the moral weight of his vigilantism.

As a native New Englander, I’ve always had a soft spot for Ben Affleck; he has the look of a classic movie star, but he also exudes an air of vulnerable decency that makes for a sympathetic hero. Michael Clarke Duncan is effectively menacing as the Kingpin, Colin Farrell plays Bullseye with roguish exuberance, Jon Favreau is solid as always as the best friend, and Jennifer Garner is convincing as an action heroine. Garner and Affleck also have pretty excellent chemistry in this movie (maybe they should go on a date or something). And there are some better-than-average musical choices throughout, though they can’t all be winners (N.E.R.D.’s “Lapdance” and House of Pain’s “Top O’ the Mornin’ To Ya,” oui; Evanescence, non). I don’t want to oversell this thing, but for popcorn thrills, you could do far worse than Daredevil. Call me crazy, but I think this one’s due for a critical reappraisal.

[rtimage]siteImageId=10244608[/rtimage]

Ryan: Usually, Tim, when you’re able to concede some words of praise for movies that were widely panned, I’m with you, because I appreciate the fairness of acknowledging silver linings. But to say that the mind boggles when considering Daredevil‘s reputation, and that it might warrant a critical reappraisal… I have to draw the line somewhere. I tried to give this movie the benefit of the doubt, particularly during those early scenes when, as you’ve mentioned, Daredevil’s backstory threatened to suffocate itself with cliches (“My client is not on trial here!”). And for the most part, the first half hour isn’t completely terrible. I’ve come to realize that, personally, I much prefer watching superheroes duke it out with their enemies in well-choreographed hand-to-hand fight sequences, as opposed to battles that rely heavily on special effects. Daredevil’s early raid on that dive bar packed a lot of punch, and aside from a bit of dodgy CGI work, it’s a pretty solid fight scene with nicely orchestrated action.

Unfortunately – and this conflicts with another point Tim has made – Ben Affleck has absolutely no charisma in this movie! Normally I find him to be a decent actor, but he was unbelievably bland here. The chemistry, it can be argued, is there between him and Jennifer Garner because, frankly speaking, she really seemed to be phoning it in as well. Oh, and while we’re on the topic of Dare-Lektra, their playground flirt-battle was the moment the movie’s “benefit of the doubt” expired for me. Come on, that was ridiculous. A blind dude engages you in Hong Kong-style wire-fu on the teeter-totters, and he asks you where you learned how to fight? I think I’d be freaking out right about the time he followed me down the street by smell alone. I’d also like to point out that the two lovebirds met each other a grand total of three times before the climactic battle with Bullseye.

I don’t know, Tim. There were just too many moments that hammered on my sense of logic, and the tone drifted from campy to serious and back again far too easily. The movie is riddled with cliches executed (presumably) without a hint of irony, from the ex-girlfriend breaking up with him on the phone to the slow pan across the roaring fireplace during the love scene, and the actors seem relatively bored throughout. With that in mind, and considering I did enjoy the close-up hand-to-hand fight scenes, I think the 45% Tomatometer is fairly accurate.

[rtimage]siteImageId=10244609[/rtimage]

Jeff: Taken out of context, the idea of a blind lawyer who fights crime with the heightened sense perception he gained after being doused with radioactive chemicals is pretty ridiculous — but if you read the books, particularly during Frank Miller’s outstanding run, you know he’s one of the more realistic, readily identifiable heroes in the Marvel universe.

With a little work, then, Daredevil could have been a pretty killer superhero movie — the character’s history is soaked in noir vibe, gritty urban crime, and one horrible tragedy after another. What did writer/director Mark Steven Johnson give us instead? An inexcusable mess, larded with hambone acting and awful dialogue, not to mention one of the most excruciating sequences in the Marvel filmography, earlier pointed out by Ryan: the Affleck/Garner playground dance.

Like Ryan, I found that scene ridiculous, but I’d already lost hope for the movie by that point. The best action sequences in the world couldn’t paper over this script — and along those lines, while I agree that Ben Affleck didn’t do himself any favors here, there isn’t a lot any actor could have done with lines like “I prowl the rooftops and alleyways at night, watching from the darkness. Forever in darkness. A guardian devil.”


More Marvel Movie Madness:

Tag Cloud

TV video DC Comics VICE sequel Comedy A&E IFC Films cars 45 LGBTQ Tarantino Marvel technology Freeform Black History Month blaxploitation Superheroe Amazon Prime Video space latino directors Amazon Studios stand-up comedy sitcom movie FOX Thanksgiving LGBT Year in Review First Look Universal Tubi Watching Series TruTV emmy awards DirecTV PlayStation festival comiccon Bravo Toys Ghostbusters fast and furious Stephen King TCA 2017 Classic Film Dark Horse Comics war documentaries joker comics Anna Paquin SundanceTV richard e. Grant binge based on movie WGN Cosplay cats Nominations dark jamie lee curtis Biopics video on demand YouTube Quiz a nightmare on elm street Trophy Talk cancelled television Masterpiece casting Fall TV Action transformers Rock GLAAD Oscars DC Universe Rocketman Crackle Nickelodeon political drama See It Skip It cults screen actors guild travel Peacock BET TNT TCA Winter 2020 007 Film Festival Black Mirror MSNBC Holiday Mary poppins obituary Hear Us Out true crime CBS All Access hist Star Trek reboot Discovery Channel Funimation The Walking Dead Marvel Studios spain Apple TV+ docudrama crossover Vudu Winners spanish language Cannes USA children's TV Country Avengers award winner CW Seed Summer news Fantasy rotten movies we love Valentine's Day Ellie Kemper serial killer CMT ITV worst National Geographic Comics on TV anime screenings nature psycho toronto Song of Ice and Fire President free movies Cartoon Network twilight nfl Epix Film Mindy Kaling ratings GIFs dceu spinoff Rom-Com Academy Awards hollywood Countdown E3 CBS The Purge what to watch universal monsters elevated horror scary movies 4/20 Pirates Animation Syfy History thriller Lucasfilm justice league Photos discovery TV renewals TLC Pet Sematary Trailer streaming mission: impossible Calendar NYCC cartoon Kids & Family Sci-Fi worst movies A24 Columbia Pictures Captain marvel adaptation DGA NBC sag awards laika Reality Competition television stop motion classics Disney Plus unscripted YouTube Red Awards Tour Disney+ Disney Plus cops green book scorecard Food Network Ovation Winter TV Shondaland Music movies adventure cooking TCA E! Musical OneApp The Arrangement romance indiana jones Mary Tyler Moore Sundance Now child's play teaser quibi Paramount Network diversity ABC venice zombies Walt Disney Pictures stoner Netflix Character Guide Grammys VH1 Star Wars American Society of Cinematographers OWN Spring TV Opinion series Fox News Certified Fresh FX on Hulu dramedy werewolf foreign YouTube Premium films name the review social media Netflix Christmas movies Tomatazos Lifetime Christmas movies canceled TV shows biography Pixar indie remakes mutant Baby Yoda Travel Channel historical drama miniseries Trivia HBO Max Warner Bros. Lifetime 2015 cancelled TV series Pride Month Crunchyroll tv talk AMC Britbox X-Men slashers blockbuster Television Critics Association versus Binge Guide spider-man hispanic Starz Marathons Superheroes Schedule 2020 SXSW Elton John Infographic sports Spectrum Originals TBS cinemax all-time RT21 Mary Poppins Returns romantic comedy TV Land Amazon Prime BET Awards Adult Swim RT History YA Television Academy The Witch cancelled TV shows Sundance BBC America criterion Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled Turner Classic Movies TCM HBO Go Mystery reviews Disney composers period drama Arrowverse crime drama rotten independent The CW Pop CNN Horror talk show BBC Apple TV Plus natural history TIFF Set visit Sony Pictures die hard GoT Shudder Logo 2016 canceled Creative Arts Emmys El Rey animated Western DC streaming service Mudbound 21st Century Fox batman nbcuniversal Awards Sneak Peek VOD 2019 sequels HBO disaster parents satire MTV asian-american comic Apple Election aliens Comedy Central strong female leads Video Games best Disney Channel ESPN dogs New York Comic Con Spike ghosts Polls and Games 2017 Super Bowl Turner game of thrones boxoffice Amazon Brie Larson MCU Extras medical drama Martial Arts Musicals Holidays harry potter 2018 FXX Podcast SDCC Tumblr comedies politics Heroines crime thriller Showtime doctor who Comic Book franchise Teen mockumentary Hulu Hallmark Christmas movies Acorn TV zero dark thirty ABC Family 71st Emmy Awards 72 Emmy Awards Marvel Television Disney streaming service renewed TV shows PBS witnail TCA Awards breaking bad Best and Worst golden globes Interview Hallmark anthology BBC One supernatural zombie robots festivals San Diego Comic-Con USA Network halloween south america Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt finale chucky revenge Drama Emmys WarnerMedia APB Reality theme song 20th Century Fox concert Paramount spy thriller superhero christmas movies Emmy Nominations Premiere Dates football IFC Nat Geo Lionsgate police drama Box Office critics dc Rocky book Pop TV Women's History Month First Reviews game show Esquire Chernobyl documentary Red Carpet toy story Sundance TV crime Family Endgame 24 frames PaleyFest kids facebook FX dragons Christmas BAFTA science fiction psychological thriller vampires Writers Guild of America singing competition