Lovecraft Country First Reviews: Critics Rave About HBO's 'Spellbinding' New Monster Series

In the network's next must-watch series, Misha Green, J.J. Abrams, and Jordan Peele immerse viewers in a version of 1950s Jim Crow America populated by otherworldly monsters and human horrors.

by | August 7, 2020 | Comments

HBO’s Lovecraft Countrybased on Matt Ruff’s 2016 novel of the same name, follows army vet Atticus Freeman (Jonathan Majors) and childhood friend Leti Lewis (Jurnee Smollett) as they travel the tumultuous roads of 1950s Jim Crow America in search of Atticus’ missing father — with the added mystery that his family’s birthright may exist at the end of the line.

Hailing from producing power trio Misha Green (Underground), J.J. Abrams (Lost), and Jordan Peele (Get Out), the series, which premieres to HBO on August 16 at 9 p.m. ET/PT, once again finds the network delving into genre territory to explore the demons of America’s racist past while parading a cavalcade of classic horror and science fiction tropes before the viewer. The result is a show that’s as terrifying and dramatic as it is bloody good fun to watch.

Lovecraft Country is a production-budget upgrade for Green and Smollett who previously both found themselves in strong lead positions with Underground — Green stepped into her first-ever role as showrunner, and Smollett carried the Underground Railroad–inspired WGN series as its star. Their creative reunion is a force to be reckoned with here, further bolstered by an epic effects budget and riveting performances by Smollett and Majors along with their supporting cast: Emmy-winner Courtney B. Vance (The People v. O.J. Simpson: American Crime Story) as Uncle George, Michael Kenneth Williams (The Wire) as Atticus’ father Montrose, Aunjanue Ellis (If Beale Street Could Talk) as Hippolyta Black, Wunmi Mosaku (Luther) as Leti’s estranged sister Ruby, and Abbey Lee Kershaw (Mad Max: Fury Road), and Jordan Patrick Smith (Vikings) as sinister members of the mysterious Braithwhite clan.

Is the new horror series a hit? Season 1 is currently Certified Fresh at 100% on the Tomatometer. Here’s what critics are saying about season 1 of Lovecraft Country:

How Are the Performances?

Jonathan Majors and Jurnee Smollett in Lovecraft Country season 1 keyart

(Photo by HBO)

The real star of the show is Jurnee Smollett’s Letitia Lewis. A Black woman in a main protagonist role, she’s a strong woman, silenced in a world full of men. As she says in the scene with Uncle George, “The name’s not girl, it’s Letitia f**kin’ Lewis.” Her strength and courage save the menfolk again and again. — Nikki Onafuye, Digital Spy

Majors, who broke through with his role in 2018’s The Last Black Man in San Francisco, is mesmerizing as shy yet resilient Atticus. His energy and personality perfectly harmonize with Smollett’s Leti, who’s very brave, passionate, and incredibly fierce. With the actress’ performance of Black Canary in Birds of Prey and Letitia’s portrayal in Lovecraft Country, this is definitely her year – as she rightfully deserves. Both Atticus and Letitia make a powerful, magnetizing duo that fights everything supernatural while battling real-life demons who want to see them fail. — Zofia Wijaszka, Awards Watch

From top to the bottom, Lovecraft Country has an absolutely phenomenal ensemble cast, but special praise has to go to leads Jonathan Majors and Jurnee Smollett…a powerhouse duo who anchor Lovecraft Country in the most masterful of ways, and names such as Michael Kenneth Williams, Wunmi Mosaku, Aunjanue Ellis, and Abbey Lee are all likewise fantastic when given their time in the spotlight. — Andrew Pollard, Starburst

Monsters Abound, but Racism Is the Ultimate Big Bad

Courtney B. Vance, Jonathan Majors and Jurnee Smollett in Lovecraft Country season 1

(Photo by Eli Joshua Ade/HBO)

Lovecraft Country is brilliant just based upon premise and promise alone, and it delivers on this mashup of horror & sci-fi with racism. But despite the monsters that loom large over everything…it’s very true that white supremacy is the biggest terror. —Trey Mangum, Shadow and Act

“Lovecraft Country” wrangles with vicious examples of Black inequality and white cruelty, on the books and off. There are the monsters these characters know — law enforcers who threaten lynching in “sundown” counties, or white Chicagoans resisting Black integration on the north side, for example. There are also monsters they discover along the way, from the Lovecraft dimension. — Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune

“Lovecraft Country” is rooted in traditions of horror, and uses that genre’s tools to argue that, for Black citizens, America is not a problem to be solved but a monster to be outrun. It’s a point well taken, and a case stylishly and often cleverly made. But over the course of this series’ first five episodes, it remains unclear how “Lovecraft Country” will advance itself beyond the shock of monstrosities, both new and familiar. — Daniel D’Addario, Variety

Lovecraft Country as a whole is an unsubtle remixing of Lovecraft’s mythos that brings his widely known, virulent racism to the fore rather than letting it be just a footnote. By blending historical facts like segregation with chthonic fiction, Lovecraft Country immediately sets itself up to be the sort of show (somewhat similar to Watchmen) that ends up teaching certain audience members some ugly truths about the past. — Charles Pulliam-Moore,

How’s the Production Value?

Courtney B. Vance, Jonathan Majors, Jurnee Smollett-Bell in Lovecraft Country

(Photo by Elizabeth Morris/HBO)

Less comicky in its compositions than something like Watchmen, which also brought allegorical fantasy to the African-American experience, Lovecraft Country is either high-octane flashy or pure pragmatism in its visuals. With a joyful amount of viscera and gore, these shocks to the system never failed to leave a Tom Savini-loving grin on my face. — Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine

The series has its share of CGI monsters, from many-limbed creatures to undead spirits, but its most compelling visual scares involve the cold framing of remote manors owned by cult leaders like Samuel Braithwhite (Tony Goldwyn) and his daughter, Christina (Abbey Lee). — Jake Cole, Slant

A credit to the glitzy production design, the city’s historic South Side comes alive as a vibrant summer milieu composed of retro Black-owned storefronts and neighborhood activities: kids playing stickball in the streets, children prancing in the cool spray of a fire hydrant’s water. The costumes also enliven the period, an array of chic threads as colorful as the neighborhood. The frames are dynamic, relying on long tracks and immersive crane shots, and a host of extras: The moments when Tic walks through the city’s streets or navigates the late-night neighborhood blues concert headlined by Ruby are portals into the past, and the generous use of extras give the neighborhood a completely lived-in feel. — Robert Daniels, The Playlist

Do the Heavy Horror and Sci-Fi References Work in Its Favor? 

Jonathan Majors and Jurnee Smollett in Lovecraft Country season 1

(Photo by Elizabeth Morris/HBO)

The show features nods to 1980s adventure movies such as The Goonies, Cronenbergian body horror and classic 1930s monster movies. But while exciting and satisfying to die-hard genre fans, the series runs the risk of fragmenting itself too severely. — Brandon Katz, Observer

Subsequent episodes transition into a ghost story involving metaphors for urban segregation and white flight, and then into a cliffhanger-heavy adventure yarn that examines the colonialist roots of exploration in a way National Treasure or Goonies did not. — Daniel Fienberg, The Hollywood Reporter

In some ways, Lovecraft Country is a victim of its own ambitions. Emptying out a library’s worth of pulp references and using them to spelunk the darkness of postwar American white supremacy just before the dawn of the civil rights era makes for a heady brew. But the ideas don’t always play out successfully. — Chris Barsanti, PopMatters

Music and Media Makes the Period Piece Feel Timely

Jonathan Majors in Lovecraft Country season 1

(Photo by Elizabeth Morris/HBO)

The trip starts with a driving sequence set to James Baldwin’s 1965 words during a debate at Cambridge University about the unattainability of the American dream for Black people. Baldwin’s voice isn’t the only welcome anachronism in Lovecraft Country. The soundtrack is filled with Etta James and Nina Simone songs from the ’60s, but also Rihanna, Frank Ocean and Marilyn Manson. There’s a sequence of Leti at church that incorporates the sound from this 2017 Nike campaign that champions equality for the LGBTQ community. Audio from different eras helps link the present and past. —Patricia Puentes, CNET

“Lovecraft Country” has a sense of timeliness as well. When police arrive at the scene of a disturbance, the Black crowd adopts a “hands up, don’t shoot” posture; taken into custody, Letitia is subjected to the sort of bruising police van ride that led to the death of Freddie Gray in Baltimore in 2015. —Robert Lloyd, Los Angeles Times

Sometimes, the soundtrack is era-specific, but get used to the likes of Cardi B or Frank Ocean or The Jeffersons theme accompanying the action — or, in a bold break from cinematic tradition, for some montages to be accompanied not by songs, but by monologues, such as an excerpt from James Baldwin’s famous 1965 debate about racism with conservative pundit William F. Buckley. —Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone

Even with a soundtrack featuring gospel, jazz, rap, pop, poetry and metal-everything from Shirley Caesar, Etta James, and Marilyn Manson to Cardi B, Gil Scott-Heron, and Leon Bridges, Lovecraft Country manages to holistically comprise feelings of hope, love, despair, and fear into a fascinating story. Though some of the storytelling may baffle viewers unfamiliar with certain folklore (truthfully, I was a bit lost at times), all will be captivated by the multi-layered performances and immersive storytelling. —Candice Frederick, TV Guide

Final Thoughts?

Jonathan Majors and Courtney B. Vance in Lovecraft Country season 1

(Photo by Elizabeth Morris/HBO)

Lovecraft Country won’t be for everyone. It can be slow-moving and the nefarious cultists are generally a bland bunch… Still, there is lots of pulpy fun and some gory moments (the easily-spooked should avoid). —Ed Power, Daily Telegraph (UK)

Lovecraft Country lands in a specific time and place for both, but in a way that feels universal as much as it feels scary. It’s one of the best shows HBO has made in a long, long time. —Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone

Spellbinding. —Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

“Lovecraft Country” is dizzying, poetic, and terrifying. —Robert Daniels, The Playlist

Lovecraft Country season 1 premieres on HBO on Sunday, August 16.

Adjusted Score: 98.207%
Critics Consensus: Anchored by Jurnee Smollett-Bell and Jonathan Majors' heroic performances, Misha Green's Lovecraft Country is a thrilling take on Lovecraftian lore that proves the Elder Gods aren't the only thing that goes bump in the cosmos.
Synopsis: Atticus Black, a young black man, joins his friend and uncle on a road trip in the 1950s to find... [More]

Tag Cloud

archives TIFF VH1 USA Network Certified Fresh transformers SDCC finale telelvision Winners Infographic Best and Worst remakes dc die hard First Reviews Baby Yoda children's TV Drama cults cops cartoon green book true crime nature period drama indiana jones rt archives australia stand-up comedy Esquire zombies marvel cinematic universe adenture cats kong American Society of Cinematographers Ovation CBS Extras black toronto Funimation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Podcast Sony Pictures NYCC what to watch TCA 2017 DGA Oscars LGBTQ travel basketball X-Men Nominations cinemax ratings psychological thriller Netflix Christmas movies Binge Guide Superheroes dragons Acorn TV Western halloween tv italian BAFTA Mindy Kaling National Geographic Tubi independent CBS All Access HBO Max Trivia festival composers ESPN politics Chernobyl Teen docudrama renewed TV shows Year in Review Reality Competition 2021 Red Carpet crossover historical drama Epix TCA Winter 2020 Hallmark Christmas movies franchise screen actors guild Marvel Television Starz MSNBC Emmys comedies APB monster movies WarnerMedia Endgame TV Land Paramount 4/20 Crackle based on movie YouTube Red Awards Tour south america zombie Marvel Studios Writers Guild of America Pop TCM witnail Women's History Month unscripted worst 24 frames Countdown Vudu elevated horror 45 Music animated spider-man christmas movies japan IFC psycho Spring TV PaleyFest Premiere Dates Amazon Prime The Walt Disney Company Horror scene in color asian-american screenings Sci-Fi Captain marvel Spike Christmas Alien DC streaming service Kids & Family San Diego Comic-Con justice league news Video Games Amazon war Star Wars GoT Pirates See It Skip It police drama FXX Comedy cancelled television rotten ABC Signature universal monsters Arrowverse SundanceTV Rocky Apple TV+ disaster VOD Columbia Pictures stoner Masterpiece adaptation venice comics emmy awards Paramount Plus international richard e. Grant Amazon Prime Video President Academy Awards YouTube mission: impossible cancelled TV series History Pacific Islander The Witch Animation rotten movies we love Hallmark popular aapi DC Comics Superheroe MTV new zealand Dark Horse Comics Ellie Kemper razzies spy thriller romantic comedy Food Network Election Crunchyroll HBO Super Bowl spanish language Comics on TV TV One name the review OWN Comic-Con@Home 2021 Sundance TV french Fantasy Biopics Turner The Walking Dead crime drama Shondaland Black Mirror mutant Summer Freeform TNT Pixar book ITV The Arrangement Paramount Network Turner Classic Movies Tokyo Olympics scorecard saw ghosts rom-coms YouTube Premium canceled slashers directors festivals game show reboot kaiju Reality halloween ABC Family prank documentary Polls and Games Heroines satire Fox News Cosplay boxing Sneak Peek Interview Comic Book Toys golden globes series cancelled Star Trek Trophy Talk comiccon Travel Channel ID Pop TV tv talk Britbox Tarantino Sundance Holidays USA Adult Swim Ghostbusters 20th Century Fox streaming movies canceled TV shows talk show First Look know your critic movie PBS teaser Disney streaming service Television Critics Association Hear Us Out dceu Lionsgate king kong Set visit adventure The Purge Warner Bros. GLAAD Musical Emmy Nominations Mary poppins godzilla award winner Rock Box Office CNN Mary Tyler Moore olympics TV classics Nickelodeon NBA boxoffice parents Brie Larson scary movies trailers GIFs 90s golden globe awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina women PlayStation RT History video Cannes child's play TCA Awards game of thrones Amazon Studios NBC singing competition twilight joker hollywood Action Logo El Rey Martial Arts Watching Series dramedy SXSW TruTV Syfy sequel Tomatazos cars miniseries hispanic The CW WGN MCU football nbcuniversal Exclusive Video social media critics werewolf Sundance Now Film Festival revenge latino breaking bad foreign stop motion TBS technology HBO Go fresh Tumblr vampires Photos new york Calendar Family Rocketman Disney Channel Character Guide toy story sag awards Legendary Image Comics Apple streaming facebook kids ViacomCBS Country Film Discovery Channel CW Seed 1990s 007 criterion a nightmare on elm street sports Anna Paquin binge Elton John Grammys BET Awards Marvel robots sitcom Television Academy reviews FX hidden camera jamie lee curtis deadpool Thanksgiving TV renewals romance chucky Bravo worst movies supernatural E3 Lucasfilm space E! obituary diversity BBC One IFC Films aliens Schedule Awards Avengers Pet Sematary A&E Peacock Hulu doctor who indie television serial killer natural history superman all-time Shudder Nat Geo Valentine's Day Apple TV Plus heist movie medical drama TV movies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 21st Century Fox lord of the rings best Universal RT21 71st Emmy Awards concert 2020 Lifetime thriller anthology discovery ABC crime thriller book adaptation AMC spanish Disney+ Disney Plus live action Spectrum Originals Creative Arts Emmys Holiday documentaries blockbusters A24 CMT free movies quibi FOX TLC science fiction suspense Disney pirates of the caribbean theme song dark target 72 Emmy Awards YA new star wars movies DC Universe LGBT fast and furious jurassic park docuseries Pride Month Musicals comic books 2018 Cartoon Network casting FX on Hulu Walt Disney Pictures high school BET TCA spain crime Mystery Song of Ice and Fire anime Comedy Central BBC strong female leads Black History Month versus 2019 New York Comic Con harry potter Fox Searchlight Opinion BBC America comic cancelled TV shows VICE movies superhero Mudbound cooking Classic Film Trailer DirecTV blaxploitation dogs batman films hist Mary Poppins Returns 99% Winter TV The Academy 2015 93rd Oscars Disney Plus Stephen King james bond zero dark thirty mockumentary 2016 Rom-Com Broadway japanese Marathons laika Lifetime Christmas movies nfl Netflix Wes Anderson video on demand Quiz biography Fall TV Showtime sequels OneApp spinoff 2017 political drama blockbuster