Kim Newman on... I Shot Jesse James

RT Obscura 19: Assassinating Jesse James pre-Casey Affleck

by | July 10, 2008 | Comments

RT Obscura with Kim Newman

RT Obscura, the exclusive column by renowned critic Kim Newman, sees the writer plumbing the depths of the RT archive in search of some forgotten gems. In his 19th column, Kim explores an earlier take on the assassination of Jesse James, as Samuel Fuller’s first feature casts John Ireland in a powerful performance as Robert Ford years before Casey Affleck joined the party.

I Shot Jesse James, director-writer Sam Fuller‘s first feature covers much the same ground as The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, albeit inside 81 minutes and with a grafted-on three-way romance which sets up a peculiarly a-historical finish.

Fuller went on record as approving of Ford, deriding Jesse James’ Robin Hood reputation as a sham mask for a murderous hypocrite; however, in his film, Reed Hadley plays the outlaw as an upright Lincoln lookalike, which theoretically makes backshooting Bob (John Ireland) even more of a villain than he’s portrayed in print-the-legend biopics like Jesse James (where John Carradine wields a shaky gun to administer the treacherous shot). It wouldn’t be until Robert Duvall in Philip Kaufman‘s underrated The Great Northfield Minnesota Raid that we’d get a screen depiction of Jesse James as the kind of total bastard Fuller thought he was.

I Shot Jesse James

The opening of I Shot Jesse James is direct, gripping and unusual. It opens in the middle of a bank robbery, panning without benefit of establishing shots from credits that appear as posters on a wall to a close-up of Jesse holding a gun on a sweating clerk (Stanley Price) whose foot is inching closer to an alarm trigger (a very 20th Century-seeming device). The cashier sets off the alarm and shooting starts (if Fuller had really wanted to make Jesse a bad hat, he could have had the outlaw gutshoot the bank official), but the bandits get away — albeit without loot, and with Jesse personally saving a wounded Bob.

Then, we skip months and find Jesse living quietly as ‘Mr Howard’ and planning a return to crime and his wife (Barbara Woodell) nagging about the continued presence of ‘best friend’ Bob in the house. When Bob hears that there’s amnesty and a reward on offer for any of the gang who turns Jesse in, he thinks not of the cash but the freedom to walk down the street unmolested — mostly so he can marry his actress sweetheart Cynthy (Barbara Britton).

I Shot Jesse James

In a scene with a surprising gay undertone, Bob finds Jesse taking a bath and picks up a snazzy gun which Jesse gives him as a present. Jesse says ‘there’s my back’ and asks his friend to scrub it — Fuller shows a POV shot of Jesse’s naked back, with moles where the bullet holes would go. The next time Jesse turns his back on Bob, getting up to straighten a picture, the temptation is too much and Bob draws the gift gun and fires.

Of course, nothing works out as planned — the governor reneges on the reward (claiming it was for capture and conviction, not assassination), and Bob becomes one of the most hated men in the West. Fuller’s best scenes show Bob’s slide from puzzlement to self-hatred as he becomes aware of what he has done. Cynthy’s manager (J. Edward Bromberg) adds him to the bill in a re-enactment of his dark deed but on the first night, with an audience staring hatred at him, he is unable to go through with the charade.

RT Obscura with Kim Newman

In a saloon to steady his nerves, Bob is accosted by a singer (Robin Short) who serenades him with ‘The Ballad of Jesse James’, a song that repeatedly refers to him as ‘the dirty little coward who murdered Mr Howard’. Ireland and Short are superb in this exchange, especially when Bob tells the singer who he is and forces the man to continue the song. As the terrified troubadour goes on, he has a moment of dreadful sympathy for the hard-faced, self-hating man whose misery he is perpetuating.

Directly after these two horrible experiences, Bob is shot at from across the street by a gawky kid (Gene Collins) out to make a reputation as the man who gunned down the man who gunned down Jesse James (only Fuller would have this character plead with Bob to stop shooting back when he runs out of bullets). Most Westerns are about landscape and action, but Fuller delivers one-on-one stand-offs, confrontations and conversations, with shots of angry, agonised or neurotic characters staring directly at the camera: even the love scenes are suspenseful and vaguely disturbing.

I Shot Jesse James

Though Ireland’s complicated, ambiguous performance remains strong, Fuller clutters up the second half of the film with unlikely business. Aside from a sub-plot about Bob’s silver-mining partnership with a whiskery coot (Victor Killian) who could have come from a 1930s kiddie matinee Western, the storyline is sidetracked by Cynthy’s feelings for a rival named John Kelley (top-billed Preston Foster). Kelley winds in and out of the story, an ardent fan of Cynthy’s who gets a job as Marshal. When he cuts in on Bob’s girl, Kelley becomes the proxy instrument of the James Boys’ revenge.

Frank James (Tom Tyler) shows up in town and everyone expects him to gun down Bob, but he actually fells his enemy with gossip — striding into a saloon and telling Bob that Cynthy is seeing another man. This prompts a final shoot-out (Kelley tauntingly presents his back to the advancing killer) which leaves Bob dying in the dust. The real Edward O’Kelley, who shot Bob Ford, was more like that nameless kid out to make a fast rep — and it’s strange that a movie otherwise concerned with setting a record straight rethink him as a conventional hero (the 1953 oater Jack McCall, Desperado did the same for Wild Bill Hickock’s murderer).

I Shot Jesse James

However, even in this relatively less interesting section, Fuller delivers solid character moments — Britton’s best scene comes as she admits she’s put off telling Bob she won’t marry him because she’s terrified of her former lover. In 1949, the idea of psychological depth in a Western was relatively new — even the A-feature Westerns of the 1940s tended to be mythic rather than complex. Ireland, a supporting player in one of the key grown-up Westerns (Red River), usually played straight-out baddies (he plays different characters on the wrong side of Wyatt Earp in My Darling Clementine and The Gunfight at OK Corral) and was an inspired choice for Bob Ford.

Billing or not, this is a whole film about the agonies and yearnings of the sort of characters Ireland always played as taken-for-granted villains who snarl in a few scenes and get shot. By highlighting someone usually played as a minor character, this is almost a Western Rosenkrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, and it’s Fuller and Ireland’s achievement that, decades before Andrew Dominik and Casey Affleck, he made audiences sympathise with the tragic Bob Ford. Ireland’s Bob dies admitting, “I want to tell you something I ain’t never told no one. I’m sorry for what I done to Jess … I loved him.”

Tag Cloud

live action rt labs comic book movie HFPA comic anthology 2020 Netflix GoT boxing Exclusive Video comics halloween tv wonder woman book Starz dexter police drama Sony Pictures miniseries Ovation golden globes obituary Fargo comic book movies Year in Review zombie Winners Rocketman Podcast period drama disaster FX on Hulu dreamworks 73rd Emmy Awards discovery asian-american Sci-Fi 93rd Oscars fresh Alien james bond political drama worst Logo IFC Epix australia french all-time richard e. Grant young adult Shondaland The Witch Legendary parents spinoff harry potter Election docudrama cooking target Sundance Now child's play news Hallmark cars SXSW 2022 cops adventure a nightmare on elm street festival Stephen King Acorn TV HBO Max Sundance OWN Tomatazos ratings werewolf blockbuster Countdown screenings Tubi 1990s 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards historical drama Hallmark Christmas movies TBS Amazon Prime Video spider-verse trophy IMDb TV Disney Plus scary movies First Reviews South by Southwest Film Festival YouTube Red Drama Focus Features women Marvel Studios aliens Action dramedy mockumentary Best and Worst Wes Anderson japan Lifetime Christmas movies children's TV CBS Marathons thriller kids king arthur deadpool 72 Emmy Awards Chernobyl Trivia Comedy Central science fiction DC streaming service Ghostbusters hollywood BAFTA 2017 jurassic park FXX Infographic zero dark thirty See It Skip It marvel cinematic universe medical drama new star wars movies 20th Century Fox Creative Arts Emmys obi wan stoner Holidays rt labs critics edition ID pirates of the caribbean cults sports what to watch MTV TCA 2017 Crunchyroll Comic-Con@Home 2021 Song of Ice and Fire DC Comics Best Actor Animation rotten independent crime thriller Awards crossover Disney Channel Trophy Talk Pop TV Spike summer TV preview 71st Emmy Awards Spectrum Originals dark screen actors guild Trailer Lucasfilm golden globe awards romance Mudbound vs. 4/20 die hard Pride Month Schedule supernatural CBS All Access tv talk free movies Disney streaming service Turner Classic Movies cancelled TV shows Mystery revenge critic resources slashers indiana jones Kids & Family game show OneApp ViacomCBS sequel Universal godzilla Grammys Mary Poppins Returns El Rey new york best SundanceTV Binge Guide Crackle genre jamie lee curtis Toys Hulu Best Director cinemax based on movie Rocky laika feel good IFC Films Adult Swim Freeform franchise japanese Oscars Walt Disney Pictures Mindy Kaling Turner Esquire aapi RT History Tarantino latino witnail broadcast live event 21st Century Fox A24 facebook Horror FOX 90s universal monsters Box Office reboot nbcuniversal Food Network Summer series Film Festival First Look Fox News crime criterion films docuseries Teen 2021 quibi spain PBS TCA game of thrones VOD Academy Awards Peacock Shudder AMC popular book adaptation The Arrangement Pirates vampires Tumblr Interview blockbusters technology SXSW TCA Winter 2020 AMC Plus Pixar Neflix cancelled television Star Wars renewed TV shows Heroines toy story 79th Golden Globes Awards travel BBC America Super Bowl Ellie Kemper The Walking Dead rt archives TCM Superheroe cartoon Best Picture finale LGBTQ Paramount Plus Polls and Games scene in color film series Dark Horse Comics TIFF summer TV Extras Comedy TNT 007 mcc Winter TV theme song dc CW Seed reviews BET Awards Indigenous true crime President TV USA Network mutant debate Women's History Month animated Broadway Martial Arts archives NBA stand-up comedy superhero Calendar crime drama GIFs Red Carpet king kong LGBT Musical Disney+ Disney Plus comic books scene in color series know your critic Certified Fresh breaking bad casting The Walt Disney Company natural history Anna Paquin Pop Amazon Studios 2016 Paramount Funimation Emmys Thanksgiving Television Critics Association hidden camera trailers new zealand anime slasher Fall TV MGM worst movies comiccon classics Spring TV sequels nfl RT21 CNN streaming movies YouTube Premium action-comedy elevated horror Discovery Channel Nickelodeon Fantasy romantic comedy Tags: Comedy binge Vudu remakes dragons diversity Watching Series razzies marvel comics Mary poppins Rom-Com Star Trek video posters sitcom Elton John hispanic canceled TV shows hist Apple TV+ suspense video on demand nature festivals Lionsgate summer preview strong female leads CMT versus ESPN venice Classic Film zombies critics Awards Tour target scene in color BET DGA Tokyo Olympics Music Instagram Live Photos Brie Larson rotten movies we love olympics PaleyFest spy thriller APB social media dceu Quiz Christmas SDCC spanish language VH1 singing competition YouTube name the review Family The Purge basketball green book superman Bravo The CW ABC mission: impossible New York Comic Con football Hollywood Foreign Press Association Set visit VICE transformers legend Black Mirror black comedy hispanic heritage month kong 99% Geeked Week PlayStation international italian A&E USA cats ABC Family TV renewals Showtime space HBO Go politics Superheroes Travel Channel DC Universe Cosplay Rock war Cartoon Network NBC Paramount Network doctor who Western E! sopranos prank WGN Mary Tyler Moore cancelled Sundance TV canceled Image Comics Cannes documentary spider-man telelvision psychological thriller YA royal family talk show BBC Writers Guild of America WarnerMedia Nat Geo toronto scene in color National Geographic emmy awards Britbox indie kaiju scary 2015 Paramount Pictures heist movie Premiere Dates fast and furious Holiday NYCC Syfy television Reality BBC One art house Video Games dogs biography TV One stop motion award winner Amazon joker 2018 TV movies Sony movies Sneak Peek Netflix Christmas movies Valentine's Day Prime Video ABC Signature DirecTV cancelled TV series Masterpiece foreign TCA Awards The Academy spanish Hear Us Out robots satire serial killer 45 gangster sag awards psycho halloween leaderboard 94th Oscars 24 frames Biopics Black History Month south america Chilling Adventures of Sabrina adaptation lord of the rings Amazon Prime FX Marvel Television X-Men GLAAD Pet Sematary chucky boxoffice San Diego Comic-Con Arrowverse teaser History Warner Bros. Fox Searchlight Best Actress Reality Competition Lifetime blaxploitation Nominations biopic Apple 2019 MSNBC TLC Television Academy composers Musicals documentaries monster movies Comics on TV black twilight Character Guide Country Emmy Nominations Captain marvel batman TV Land MCU Pacific Islander HBO concert Universal Pictures ITV directors American Society of Cinematographers scorecard Columbia Pictures Oscar Native movie Opinion Avengers E3 TruTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney adenture Endgame rom-coms streaming Star Wars Celebration Comic Book saw high school unscripted justice league comedies Marvel mob Apple TV Plus Film Baby Yoda interviews streamig christmas movies ghosts