Five Favorite Films

James Gray's Five Favorite Films

The Ad Astra director expresses his love for Eastwood, Fellini, and pre-Code cinema.

by | September 17, 2019 | Comments

Pablo Cuadra/Getty Images
(Photo by Pablo Cuadra/Getty Images)

James Gray has won the affection of international film critics with New Hollywood throwback offerings like Two Lovers, The Immigrant, and The Lost City of Z, but with Brad Pitt suited up for space in Ad Astra, Gray gets his first major studio project off the ground. Like many of Gray’s films, there is a family story at the heart of his Heart of Darkness-esque space movie, with Tommy Lee Jones playing Pitt’s astronaut father who’s been missing for 20 years but might have just made contact from Neptune. Pitt embarks on a mission not just to find his father, but also to stop the electrical surge from an outpost near the distant planet, which has caused thousands of deaths on Earth.

The film debuted at the Venice Film Festival with high accolades for its thrilling sequences, Pitt’s performance, and the astounding visual effects (which the Fox-Disney merger granted Gray a few more months to fine-tune). Ahead of Ad Astra’s nationwide release — it’s Certified Fresh at 81% on the Tomatometer — Gray told us his Five Favorite Films and spoke about the gestation of his current film. That his choices come from Russian, Austrian, and Italian filmmakers, in addition to Hollywood, should surprise no one familiar with his work as a filmmaker who’s keeping the ’70s maverick spirit alive in modern American cinema.


The Road (La Strada) (1954) 97%

Well, let’s go one, La Strada, which is Federico Fellini’s movie with Anthony Quinn and Giulietta Masina. When was the first time I saw it? Oh, my God, I was in high school. To me, it felt like a fable, and it was beautiful and so moving, and I cry every time I see it. I’m almost crying thinking about it. How both broadly drawn and subtle the characters are, and how much sympathy Fellini has for the people in the movie. Have you ever seen it?

I have. I haven’t seen that one in years, also probably since my first time in high school. Around the same year as La Strada, I really like Nights of Cabiria from Fellini, which I’ve seen multiple times.

Also right up there. I mean, I have to say, I’m very, very pleased that you know both films, because if had to pick, it would be either one or the other, and I kind of can’t stand picking one or the other, but it’s almost like a random choice, which it was either La Strada or Nights of Cabiria. By the way, the middle one that he did — between the two — which is much less famous, called Il Bidone, with Broderick Crawford, is also a really good movie. Much darker than the other two. It’s got a great ending.

It’s almost impossible to imagine a film with more love in it than the ending of Nights of Cabiria — oh, my God. And the ending of La Strada, he does that perfect thing where Anthony Quinn looks up to the heavens. Fellini knew what to do.

I Am Cuba (Soy Cuba) (1995) 100%

Number two would be, let’s say, I Am Cuba. Ever see that movie?

Yes. It’s one of the most beautifully shot movies ever.

Oh God, yes. Cheers. It teaches you that the camera is a weapon that can be deployed brilliantly. What is beautiful about I Am Cuba is that, as showy as it is, it’s not style for no point. It’s an expansive vision of the rot that we brought to Cuba. Whether you agree with its politics or not, it’s not really the issue; it’s really human, and you understand… Well, a poet wrote it. Yevgeny Yevtushenko wrote it. You understand the humanity of the people in it. Whether they are subject to humiliation, or to the humiliation of capitalism, well, that’s almost secondary to their own inner lives. The movie validates their inner lives, and the camera is a weapon in doing so. Beautiful.

I Am a Fugitive From a Chain Gang (1932) 96%

I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang, 1932. This is excellent. It was pre-Code. Ferocious movie. Paul Muni, incredibly intense. It was really the best picture I think Mervyn LeRoy ever did, by far. Maybe the production code got in the way after that. He made another movie called They Won’t Forget, which is supposed to be great, but I don’t love it. I think it’s probably because the production code got in the way and it sort of neutered him a little bit. No spoilers, but the ending of Chain Gang, I couldn’t forget about it for days.

This one I also saw way back when I was in high school. I didn’t even know what the Production Code and pre-Code cinema was then; now I know it and find the distinction fascinating, but for this title, I can’t place what LeRoy did that he wouldn’t have been able to do after Fugitive

I just think it’s so hard-hitting. I don’t know if you remember — I mean, he’s got this scene with this woman who’s blackmailing Muni, and the sexually frank conversations they have, and the toughness, the brutality of the film. I mean, it’s something they really scrubbed cleaner, 1934 onward.

The Scarlet Empress (1934) 88%

Scarlet Empress, with Marlene Dietrich, directed by Josef von Sternberg. That’s also pre-Code, just barely, I think, and it’s the greatest of their collaborations. Morocco is amazing, too, and I love Blue Angel. Morocco has that incredible ending where she can’t resist but follows him off, and you hear the wind sound and all that. Anyway, Scarlet Empress is so singular; there’s nothing like it. It’s almost like a new cinema is being created; he’s creating a new language for cinema. Not just the way that it looks, but the light, the use of light, and the use of production design becomes, almost, a sensory part of the experience and informs her character. It’s all about her character’s sensuality, and he uses all these other elements beyond just herself to sell that. The way the film looks, the way the film feels, and it’s where the style completely informs her identity, which is an amazing idea.

Unforgiven (1992) 96%

One more. Let’s go with Clint Eastwood’s movie Unforgiven. I think that’s a brilliant movie. The acting in it is totally brilliant. I’ve always been a big Gene Hackman fan, but who isn’t? I love Eastwood and Morgan Freeman in it. Richard Harris is hilarious. I think the movie has an unbelievable sense of myth, and a great sense of undoing that myth. I’ve never been in a movie theater where I had that experience where the end of the movie, you have the hero say, “Yeah, I’ve killed women and children. I’m gonna kill you.”

Yeah, it was before the anti-hero truly became chic.

Oh, he kills everybody, and he shoots the man who’s moaning on the ground that presents no threat as he’s walking out. He pumps the guy full of lead, and the audience was applauding when I saw that in theaters. And you get the sense that’s like, “I’m not sure Eastwood was endorsing that behavior.” It kind of says the character goes to hell, and I love the subversiveness of it. He got away with it, because the myth, his myth, is so powerful.

You made your first film, Little Odessa, soon after that?

I did, actually. Maybe six months later, I started working on it. It did have an impact on me; I’m sure it did. I hadn’t thought about it consciously, until now, until you just said it, but I had also seen Lorenzo’s Oil, which I thought was beautiful. George Miller movie. I thought it was just beautiful and very emotional, and I remember both of those films coming out while I was writing my first screenplay. Then, a year after that, there was a Merchant/Ivory movie, Remains of the Day, where I thought Anthony Hopkins’ performance was just incredible. I remember being very excited about this group of films, and they informed a lot of what I’ve being trying to do ever since.

I can see that as a little bit of a trinity within your filmography, when you were cultivating your voice, since there’s parenting in Lorenzo’s Oil, the character violence of Unforgiven, and the prestige sheen of Merchant Ivory.

You’re right. I had never focused on it before, but now that we’re talking about it, that period, I remember seeing some really interesting movies around that time, in the early ’90s, and it was a great time to make independent film after. The Eastwood movie, I mean, I just am aghast at what he accomplished. “I ain’t like that no more.” Just a very powerful idea about what it means to maintain order, and what’s the price of maintaining order. You don’t know how to feel about that sheriff. He’s awful, but he does what he needs to do, and that’s pretty complex. That’s a great screenplay.


Brian Formo for Rotten Tomatoes: Something that’s constant through your work is family expectations and the suffocating weight of that. So I’m wondering, with Ad Astra, did you start with a father-son story in space, or did you want to make a movie in space and have these big set pieces, but then it became more natural to tether it to a father-son relationship?

An excellent question. I wish I could tell you that I came up with the story first, but it’s not how it happened. I was thinking very seriously about a childhood memory that I had. I grew up in New York, and you couldn’t see the stars. The sky had this kind of dull orange at night, because the city was so lit up. I remember there was a blackout that hit the city — this was 1977, in the summer of 1977 — and I remember, as all the lights went out, you could see the stars for the first time.

All of a sudden I had this weird memory back to that feeling — it was, like, 2011 and I thought, “Wouldn’t it be great to make a movie about what is out there?” I talked about it a lot with my friend and co-writer, Ethan (Gross), and I asked, “What it means to be out there, and are there aliens, or are we alone?” Well, there are a lot of movies about aliens, and good aliens and bad aliens. (Steven) Spielberg’s done incredible work about that, but his movies, they play like fables. E.T. is like a fable; Close Encounters, like a fable. Beautiful, beautiful films. (Stanley) Kubrick made a beautiful film, of course (in 2001). The alien is a black slab of granite, whatever it appears to look like. Is that a good alien? A bad alien? What does that mean? You can project anything you want on it. So he beats the trap of false gods, you know?

20th Century Fox
(Photo by 20th Century Fox)

But we thought, “Well, what does it mean if you find that there’s really nothing out there? And if there’s nothing out there, that poses its own set of existential questions.” So it started from that, really, and that was the chain of events. Then I tried to start getting the story as personal as I could, and we wanted to steal from — as pretentious as this sounds — we wanted to steal from The Odyssey, and tell the story, really, from Telemachus’ point of view. His father, Odysseus, goes away for 20 years; he doesn’t know what happened to him. What that would mean, and that sense of abandonment that Telemachus must have…

Now, of course, Homer’s story ends very differently. But that’s where that came from, a kind of mythic idea. Then, of course, you start to personalize it, you start to include things in your own life, and before you know it, you’ve got this tiny little story about a father and a son against the huge canvas, where you’re going out there, it’s the vast infinite. That’s really how it formed.

So, the opening in the film, and I’m not a take-a-notepad-to-the-film person, mostly because High Fidelity scarred me for life…

Oh when his girlfriend clicks her pen throughout the movie to take notes?

Yes!

Ha, what a nice aside.

So I’m not sure if I got the two words correct, but the movie opens with something like, in the near future, there’s hope and fear about humanity’s future. In presenting the future, what is something that you discovered in your research that gives you hope about the future, and what is something that terrifies you?

It’s an easy question to answer. Easy. Hope: the mapping of the human genome, hospital cures for diseases, the specialized treatment of things like different kinds of cancer, that’s fantastic. And fear, I think, is obvious. The fear is climate change and the end of civilization, the civilized world.

If you look at Mars… By the way, the NASA people I’ve worked with on this film, who are great, their hair’s on fire. The f—ing world is ending and, I mean, I understand that it’s a slow burn, but it’s not that slow. In fact, the permafrost is going worse up there than we think, you know? Greenland, large sheets are melting faster than we think, or we thought — now we know. Already parts of New York are uninsurable.

And lots of Los Angeles, for fires.

Yeah. I’m extremely concerned. So, I think progress is a beautiful thing. I think that we’ll be able to do things that we couldn’t imagine in terms of human longevity. Maybe we’ll figure out what it means in the future, to maybe find an answer to not just longevity, but market economics, where five people don’t control all the wealth on the planet. That’s a problem.

If we could solve that, that would be great, but I have hope that we do, because the world moves in cycles, strange cycles. I feel like we’re itching for a new path forward on how to handle some of our problems. But climate change, that’s a tough one. That’s a tough one. There are things like taking CO² and making it into oxygen. Apparently, technologically, there are ways to do it, but it’s ridiculously expensive.  But we’re going to have to do it. I don’t see any other way around it. I hope I’m completely wrong.

20th Century Fox

[Note: Mild spoilers below]

We can get morose for the whole interview, but this movie has a lot of very fun, thrilling sequences.

I hope so.

Like the moon pirates, the underground lake, or even just the opening, falling from space, et cetera. The mayday call for help and where that goes…

All of that was supposed to be thematically relevant, more than narratively relevant. The idea that, basically, unexpected horror is around every turn when you’re that far away from Earth. So we felt that it had thematic unity, if not narrative unity. Anything earthbound, it’s not meant to live out there. It’s not meant to be there. That’s not our friend, it’s different to us. We felt that the mayday response was an important sequence. Do people want to know about that beforehand?

I loved the surprise, so I think, where we’re at for filmgoers is people just want to know that there’s blood, there’s a confrontation, there’s excitement.

Well, there is blood. There is blood.

There are deaths and surprises.

We tried to do that. We wanted to deliver that stuff. The fall from the tower, the lunar-rover sequence, the [mayday] thing, the underground lake, certainly; he climbs up a rocket, he has a zero G fight, he flies through the rings of a planet. I mean, we wanted to deliver some red meat. We absolutely did. By the way, there is no shame in that. Shakespeare was broad and subtle; that’s good stuff. So, we tried, and we tried to do it in our own way, of course, make it weird, unique, strange; in the lunar rover you can only hear what’s inside his helmet. It’s very weird for a chase sequence.

Yeah, you have meat and potatoes, but you also have some asparagus.

Exactly. That’s what we’re trying to do.


Ad Astra is in theaters September 20.

Thumbnail image: (c) Warner Bros.

Tag Cloud

Marvel Television Lifetime Opinion cancelled TV shows Cannes jamie lee curtis all-time Sci-Fi Mystery Epix Disney streaming service Discovery Channel NBC slashers Apple TV+ screen actors guild Syfy Elton John Western Ovation cats Mary poppins christmas movies 20th Century Fox AMC binge Academy Awards Disney Channel comiccon boxoffice scary movies festivals Winter TV stand-up comedy breaking bad Captain marvel children's TV doctor who Rom-Com robots free movies Tomatazos vampires WarnerMedia dragons crime thriller Sundance Showtime facebook LGBTQ zombie discovery sitcom revenge Sundance Now Sundance TV Tarantino Mary Poppins Returns screenings Columbia Pictures Grammys Pop spy thriller 2015 Starz Hallmark blockbuster TruTV crime drama Emmy Nominations CNN latino FOX BBC tv talk witnail cartoon Superheroes Certified Fresh asian-american child's play TLC Cosplay Avengers Horror Tubi Video Games animated Super Bowl Lionsgate zombies New York Comic Con versus Rocketman talk show Anna Paquin Netflix Lifetime Christmas movies south america Amazon Studios Walt Disney Pictures Comic Book ghosts dramedy Fall TV Schedule Family RT History hist Set visit psycho TCM IFC Films VH1 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Hear Us Out TNT Watching Series Warner Bros. Biopics natural history Classic Film X-Men Star Wars HBO spanish language Spike video Endgame Fox News The Walking Dead 4/20 USA Network cooking Film Musical justice league composers Reality Writers Guild of America singing competition Marvel PBS SXSW werewolf RT21 name the review Animation Lucasfilm cancelled TV series game show chucky television dogs YouTube HBO Max anthology TCA 2017 directors Television Academy 2017 FXX GIFs based on movie Fantasy universal monsters Amazon best Drama Infographic streaming Action DirecTV dark Arrowverse Dark Horse Comics stoner CBS 2019 DC streaming service IFC aliens 45 YouTube Red Acorn TV Superheroe ABC Masterpiece adaptation halloween The Arrangement Music Holiday 21st Century Fox TIFF finale miniseries Paramount WGN documentary spider-man spinoff LGBT TV ratings Comedy Central ESPN Pride Month sag awards Pet Sematary joker Film Festival spain President MSNBC MTV Apple TV Plus APB Country Universal social media GLAAD Paramount Network San Diego Comic-Con hispanic cinemax disaster book SundanceTV Vudu diversity crossover psychological thriller A&E Comedy A24 series TCA Winter 2020 The Witch strong female leads Trailer El Rey cults award winner Oscars Rocky 2016 political drama toy story Comics on TV Ghostbusters DC Comics GoT historical drama Polls and Games parents harry potter Disney Plus green book die hard 2018 mockumentary Logo First Look Photos romance rotten movies we love space Pixar BET medical drama Black Mirror franchise Nat Geo Calendar TV renewals Spectrum Originals Sony Pictures Marathons Martial Arts Peacock YouTube Premium Mindy Kaling Creative Arts Emmys Shudder USA Spring TV criterion reboot CMT Mudbound DC Universe biography Summer crime Awards canceled TV shows theme song Shondaland CBS All Access 2020 YA 71st Emmy Awards The CW independent VICE Valentine's Day The Purge Cartoon Network critics Women's History Month science fiction PaleyFest National Geographic CW Seed Hallmark Christmas movies sequel romantic comedy comic Amazon Prime Election First Reviews Bravo nature mission: impossible game of thrones Mary Tyler Moore Quiz Apple Disney+ Disney Plus a nightmare on elm street Nickelodeon Podcast Box Office TV Land politics sports ITV movie mutant Esquire Black History Month Brie Larson MCU unscripted Year in Review Kids & Family ABC Family Character Guide batman Funimation Nominations Travel Channel Countdown travel concert indie quibi Toys Adult Swim Star Trek Chernobyl Britbox comedies See It Skip It transformers Turner Classic Movies thriller true crime Binge Guide Emmys elevated horror Stephen King Pirates Rock Red Carpet Song of Ice and Fire technology Hulu FX on Hulu Crackle E! Tumblr renewed TV shows cancelled 007 FX what to watch OWN cars adventure police drama serial killer dceu Heroines Food Network Best and Worst cops BBC America Awards Tour Turner Trivia E3 casting anime foreign Disney Extras cancelled television Ellie Kemper Freeform comics kids period drama Sneak Peek war Pop TV richard e. Grant movies NYCC SDCC Winners teaser Musicals Holidays Trophy Talk Premiere Dates zero dark thirty Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Marvel Studios Teen canceled Interview 24 frames Amazon Prime Video TBS Thanksgiving golden globes dc OneApp supernatural Netflix Christmas movies American Society of Cinematographers History Reality Competition blaxploitation DGA Christmas Crunchyroll Baby Yoda reviews TCA docudrama